Loved this restaurant for years. Last week we brought home two Greek salads with chicken on one of them. Was my mother's 81 birthday and her salad as well as my own soaked in water with wilted lettuce. Not alittle bit of water either. So unappetizing and had to throw away. It was late on a Wednesday so just ate the chicken. Don't understand when so much of menu has lettuce why they can't at least use a salad spinner to rid majority of the water? No one wants their salad soaked in water. read more

Warm and welcoming owner and staff with a great selection of Mediterranean dishes. While it doesn't exactly transport me to Greece, the flavors remind me of Astoria, Queens. truly the next best place for American Greek cuisine! It's a cozy spot with just enough seating to enjoy your meal fresh from the kitchen.phenomenal meal. Excellent bakery items to choose from for desert. read more

See all

Delicious Greek food that is worth the wait. I had takeout from here last Friday. The chicken souvlaki dinner plate. I substituted rice for lemon potatoes. The chicken was juicy, flavorful, and tender. The potatoes were equally delicious. I just wish they were cut a little smaller like a wedge instead of potato halves. The dish also came with a delicious and fresh salad, house made vinaigrette dressing, warm pita bread and white sauce. Their portion size is huge, so I was able to get two meals out of this. I would highly recommend calling in your order ahead of time because they get really busy. That was my mistake and I waited 45minutes for my order, but not most people there were picking up phone orders. That is the trick. The next time I'm in the mood for Greek food I will call in an order here. read more

Cusmos Greek American Restaurant - Chicken Souvlaki Plate with lemon potatoes - Greek Near Me - Lindenhurst, New York

Great fresh food. This is our goto Greek spot. It's authentic. Their tzatziki sauce is the best. It's the best on Long Island. The gyro sandwiches are amazing. And they don't chince on the toppings read more

Not much room to sit but the food is very good. Great take out spot. The staff is friendly and the food is always fresh. Prices are reasonable as well. Definitely recommend. read more

Hard to find good Greek food and this is my go-to place. There's a reason they're busy, probably the most consistent place of it's kind. I've had almost everything on the menu and you can't go wrong. Limited seating and call ahead to order, they are a busy place. read more

The best greek takeout in a 5 town radius. I think I pass 3 other greek places in Babylon and lindenhurst on my way here. Friendly staff. The best lamb gyro meat I've ever had. read more

Solid Greek fare in a small strip shopping center in Lindenhurst. Had a large Greek salad with gyro meat and it was very good, with plenty of meat. Dressing had a great flavor, thank you Cusmos, you made the cut ! read more

YES! YES! YES! I had been in the search for greek food for months now, really because I wanted lemon potatoes Cosmos had great reviews so I finally gave it a try. I think the "restaurant" in the name threw me off because its a smaller place and currently only had 1 or 2 tables (probably bc of covid but not much space for many more regardless) small countertop area also. I ordered the souvlaki platter with lemon potatoes and the potatoes were A-MAZ-ING!! I'm not sure if they made a mistake but the "platter" was more of a sandwich because it was wrapped like a burrito in pita - regardless delicious also. I came with a small side salad and additional pita with tzatziki sauce. Would HIGHLY recommend this place. I will definately be ordering more frequently. read more

Cusmos Greek American Restaurant - the front of the restaurant - Greek Near Me - Lindenhurst, New York

I had a delicious cheeseburger for lunch while I was at the laundromat next door . Owner was friendly so I went back for dinner Lamb Souvlaki was delicious, came with rice pilaf and a Greek salad. read more

i love their food, staff, service. it is a great place to get greek food. Nice little place.

At first, I passed by this place with my husband and it popped out to me. Once I saw the place I turned to him and said that I wanted to try it out. That was about 2-3 weeks ago. A week or so ago I told my friend about it and we went to go and eat it. We both LOVED it. The service was great and so was the food. We tried the lamb gyro and we both loved it. The tzatziki sauce was amazing. I've had some that were mediocre and was very disappointed in it, since I think it may be 4 ingredients. If I'm not mistaken. I will definitely come back here again and have more friends and have family come and try the food. I would love to try more of their food. The price was good in my eyes. There was a few tables, but the place isn't that big, which I don't mind at all. There is a public bathroom which is fantastic considering it's size. read more

Best value food around. Me and my family love this place you can get lots of quality food and it is fairly priced also I spoke to the owner and lots of their stuff is home made. Also the man at the front desk is the best always has a smile. read more

My quest for Greek food is over. This is it. South Shore, western Suffolk county, LI champ of Greek food - Cusmos! Just call ahead (trust me!) and order the Chicken Athenia. It's all you need in life. It's perfection. It's also big enough to split between 2. You're not going to eat there. I mean you can, but you won't. Get the food to go. Bring it home, drive down to the beach. And enjoy the best Greek food you can get in a 15/20 mile radius. read more

Greek Salad with Grilled Chicken is Awesome also the Spinach Pie and the Cookies with the White Powder I can't wait to order more from here Great Food!!! read more

AVOID. Ordered the Villager Salad: Half the Cucumbers were bad. Thank goodness the chicken was good. They charge a convenience fee to use their credit card machine!!! LAME!!! The convenience should be coming from THEM without it they will lose a customer. read more

Cusmos Greek American Restaurant - Greek Near Me - Lindenhurst, New York

Way better than that BS, fancy pants l,dry meat havin' soggy fry slinging' place Pita Bowl. Cusmos is a real Greek place. Not some new fangled place for fancy lads who like fancy lettuce and dry meat. It's not some assembly line, ultra Americanized chipotle wanna be. NO SIR! Cusmos has real gyros. Succulent and soft, tender meat. And spinach pie so good make you wanna slap yer momma. (For not makin it as good). I'm going to go there today and get me some excellent, good old fashioned Greek food. read more

Excellent freshly made food, portions were more than plenty, customer services rates 10 stars! You will never ever be dissatisfied! Best kept place . read more

Great food all the time. Reasibly priced alway a wait when you order but ready when they say it will be. Great gyro specials!!!

I had a taste for some lamb chops and I remembered one of our fellow yelpers had recommended this place So I gave it a try and boy was I glad. I ordered the lamb chop plate and it came with 6 chops and lemon potatoes and both were out of this world good. The best I ever tasted. Plus they give you a Greek salad that was good. I also ordered the Greek salad with gyro meat that was great So if you have a taste for Greek food and your in the area give them a try read more

See all

Located in a tiny strip of stores this place is easy to miss. But if you're a local you know Cusmos has been around for many years under a different ownership. Now I don't know who's recipes they're using now but it's obvious new owners have stepped their game up because the food has been amazing the last few times I've been here. They are definitely putting their Greek foot up in their marinade. Because it's so good you don't need the tzatziki sauce but you wanna get some because even THAT has been elevated to another level. The pork souvlaki was perfect! But the killer was the lamb chops! You have a choice of lemon potatoes, rice pilaf or French Fries. I opted for the rice. Delicately flavored it was the perfect accompaniment to the moist well marinaded lamb chops. They even asked how I wanted them cooked. Medium rare please.. And they were! The Greek salad although fresh & crisp I would've liked some fresh dill & a little more feta. But the salad & everything else was well prepared & worth me coming back more often. Sometimes change is good! 8-6-2016 read more

See all

This is one of my favorite Greek places. There's no shortage of good Greek on Long Island, but this place is a hidden gem. Tucked away in an ordinary shopping plaza, the seating area is small but the food is tremendous. The gyros are as authentic as it gets, with pitas so fresh they'll smack ya. They do deliver here but I prefer to pick up in person, since everything is made fresh it can take a little while to get your food but it is worth the wait. read more

I'm a huge Yelp person (reading/trying restaurants based on reviews) but I almost NEVER leave reviews. Grilled calamari. BOMB. And probably the best gyro I've ever eaten in my entire life. Kudos to you Cusmos, read more

Cusmos Greek American Restaurant - Gyro - Greek Near Me - Lindenhurst, New York

See all

The place is great, the food is great, the guys that work there are above par, it's a gem on the south shore that I hope everyone finds out about. Thanks for all the delicious meals!! Eric Hartmann loves it!! read more

We've been on the prowl for decent Greek in the area. Have we found it? Opa! *smashes plate* I really loved my falafel gyro, one of the better ones I've had. Would love to try this with some hummus to moisten it up a bit as I'm not so big on tahini. Hubs and the kiddo got chicken gyros. Big Guy thought it was "okay" but would go back...he says he is more of a fan of he shredded chicken variety. Little guy ate his weight in the chicken and loved it, two toddler thumbs up. Now that the weather is getting cooler I'd come back to try the avgolemono soup..a Greek favorite of mine. Super friendly service was a huge plus. I'll return for sure. read more

Great food, Great taste only thing I would change is how long it takes BUT hey good things don't just happen fast I guess right. 10/10

Some of the best Greek food on Long Island . They make great gyros and the best baklava around

Perfectly prepared Caesar salad with dressing not overwhelming the exceptionally tender chicken I chose to join in! Truly one of the best I've ever had. read more

Uh ohhhh Cusmos...2nd time, no good. Portions have become out of control too small. WHERE'S THE MEAT DEAN? Pitas are gummy, prices are up, grapeleaves are missing. The meat quality has gone waaaaay downhill. Taziki sauce is thin and flavorless. The gyros have shrunk so drastically that it is kind of sad. C'mon man, don't do this. With all the pickup and delivery business, I refuse to believe you aren't making money. We want you to make money but get the noticable quality back to where it was. Everything has gone up, yes, but don't raise prices and decrease quality, maintain standards... read more

The gyros are fantastic. Staff has always been courteous to me when I've come in. It's not really a place to eat in, more for takeout. But everything I've tried from here has been great and fresh. read more

Can be a bit pricey but the food is really good. Love their gyros and salads. Can frequently find coupons in the penny saver :)

Don't let the small take out storefront fool you! This is most likely the best Greek food we have ever had. On about a once a week occurrence we get take out or delivery from Cusmo's. We usually have a chicken gyro plate, grilled calamari, veggie gyro, fallafel, and a few other odds and ends. The only one dish we aren't very fond of is the spanakopita, it seems to not be cheesy and flavorful enough. Otherwise everything else on the menu is excellent, the bill can go pretty high pretty quickly, but the food is worth every penny. The staff is very nice and the delivery guys come pretty darn fast as well. If you are in the area and craving Greek, please give this great place a try! read more

Family meal within a family price , good food . Pay in cash and support your local businesses

The food is good and considered a local Greek favorite. The place itself is small (no bar) so probably best for take-out. If planning to dine-in, expect to wait quite a bit, but I'm okay with that since I know (or at least hope) they are working on the quality of dishes. Dinner salads are fresh. Gyros are super delicious (chicken gyro sandwich is worth it!). Falafels are hand made and delicious. The cooks and staff are good people. read more

Cusmos Greek American Restaurant - Menu. - Greek Near Me - Lindenhurst, New York

Gyros are great! We love to order and either pick up or have it delivered. Better to get sauce on side and put on once you have it. :) Have ordered several times and have not been disappointed once. read more

Might be the best gyro I've ever had. This isn't you're typical gyro that has 2 slices of lamb on it and is 75% lettuce. This thing has at least 6, and the ratio of meat to vegetables to sauce is perfect. A plate is $15.50 and comes with a side of rice, lemon potatoes, or french french fries, and a small Greek salad, (which is more like a medium size) and an extra pita. Not the cheapest but fairly priced for all that you get. Have been here twice in the past few weeks and will continue to come. Highly recommend checking this place out. read more

Cusmos Greek American Restaurant - Lamb gyro - Greek Near Me - Lindenhurst, New York

See all

Very tasty pork souvlaki. And a good avgolemono. Been her before. However 42 minute wait for a soup and sandwich was a bit much. I was told the pork takes some time. Really? I will go back but will keep track of time. Greek garden in Babylon is also very good and they are very timely when you order. read more

You won't be disappointed! Check out this takeout restaurant. Authentic Greek food. Everything is freshly made and cooked to perfection. Chicken and lamb are moist and mouth watering. The portions are very generous. Everything is absolutely delicious. read more

Excellent Greek food! Gyros are amazing ! Great deals and combos! Order early always busy always a wait! But worth it!

This is a great authentic local take out food joint. Delicious gyro, amazing Greek salads with grilled chicken. They have a wall with all kinds of hot sauce bottles to purchase such as "Assosaurous" or" See Dick Burn". Rent a movie and call in an order of Cusmos to pick up and enjoy! Did I mention that they have a very friendly staff?.......Well they do! read more

Cusmos Greek American Restaurant - Cusmo guy - Greek Near Me - Lindenhurst, New York