I love the Greek garden. The food is excellent fresh tender flavorful!! This place is our go to for delicious Mediterranean Greek food. I love the sauces Greek salad & Flavors bon appétit read more

I ordered 2 greek salads and 1 chicken gyro. Honestly the food was super disappointing. Both salads were mostly lettuce with very little toppings... it was a thick bed of wet lettuce and 4 olives, some shredded cheese and overripe cucumbers. Something a 5 year old would make. The gyro was very soggy and the chicken was a little tough on both the gyro and the salad. read more

Soup, gyro, salad.....the BEST IN BABYLON. Service is always perfect. Its nice & quiet. Babylon is filled with alot of loud restaurants. Greek Garden is perfect! read more

Just moved to Babylon but my wife comes here when she's working in the area. They are fantastic! Roseann is so friendly and sweet and the food was great. Roseann said she's been here for 26 years and you can tell how much pride she takes in serving her community. Will be a new go-to spot in town! read more

Very very rude woman - on my lunch break, ordered a gyro - Im someone who works outdoors , it was hot as hell outside- just wanted to eat in a/c before my half hour was over - she basically asked me to leave because school was getting out soon . What does school getting out have to me eating in the restaurant - food I bought - willing to pay if there's table service fee whatever . I mean Im a paying customer . . There was ample are to sit down . I say their very mediocre gyro with added rudeness was terrible - Id say a hard pass...way better places with nice people not this rude awful woman read more

Delicious authentic Greek food! Always good quality food and service. Prices are a little on the expensive side but portion sizes are reasonable depending on what you get. read more

Love this place. It's small and the waitstaff are great. Love the Greek decor too. Bathrooms are clean. We had the saganiki and always perfect. Tomato on top was a bit mushy but tasty. We shared the Moussaka and spinach pie. The Moussaka and a great portion and good flavor. The spinach was gooey cheese and yummy. Pita comes out hot and delicious. Pricing is good and the friends to share it w even better read more

Always fresh and delicious Authentic Greek food very reasonable prices. Only place we go to for Greek read more

I have been coming to the Greek Garden for more than 10 years now. The food is consistently high quality, and the service is ALWAYS WONDERFUL! The Greek Garden has a comfortable atmosphere, with authentic Greek decorations. This was actually my first visit this year. Rosanne still remembers my order-Gyro combo. I think some of the other customers were a little jealous, because they were really staring at me. Haha. And I bet you not many other restaurants you've been to have both cash and charge prices on the menu. This is the ONLY Greek restaurant I visit on Long Island. I recommend the Greek Garden 100%. There is a steady stream of customers present. The food is so fresh. The service is professional, and fast. The restaurant is located just southeast of the High School. Visit today for an excellent dining experience. One last note. Of all the times I have visited the Greek Garden, I have NEVER heard a customer complain because the food was bad or the order was wrong. Thank you, so much, to Rosanne and the team at Greek Garden! read more

Greek Garden - New law in New York, where restaurants that charge you a different price if you pay cash or charge. - Greek Near Me - Babylon, New York

See all

The food is delicious and the service is fantastic! It is a little gem on a side street of Babylon so be sure to keep your eyes focused on finding it. I certainly is worth it. read more

This is an updated review of this establishment: Food is still good, but like another reviewer said, the Greek salad is weak, and the portions are small. Who doesn't put grape leaves in a Greek salad?! Anchovies are 85 cents extra. Really, they need to charge me an extra 85 cents?! Obviously, they nickel & dime you for everything, including soft drink refills, which, by the way, come in a glass a little bigger than a shot glass. Don't go there starving, you'll leave hungry. I'll pass. read more

Very nice owners, good food. I got the falafel and rice and it was very good. The salad was one of the best greek salads I've had. Again the people were so friendly and welcoming, would definitely recommend. read more

This place is excellent especially if you love gyros and Greek desserts. Service was good and informative about the food. Some of the best baklava I ever tasted. Definitely recommend read more

Lousy kind of day for me , but it was so beautiful outside I didn't want to go home, I was at the dog park almost until 7 with my scary German Shepherd Holly both hungry who in the world would let both of us eat ( just maybe some kind restaurants would give me take out & I'll eat on a bench or wherever) we'll walking around my dog tried go in actually just her head this woman comes out & says do you want to eat here I'm like but my dog Roseann & another woman bring out a table with a table cloth & utensils & a chair for me . Omg who does this then the delicious salad & lamb with rice pita bread humus my spirit was lifted that moment. THE GREEK GARDEN is my go place but without my dog . Thank all of you so much for everything. Sincerely Carol read more

See all

OMG, we have been coming to the Greek Garden for many years now and I have to say their food is amazing. Having a neighbor who is from Greece I have had amazing food over the years, well I have to say The food at the Greek Garden is the same authentic food as I have had for the past 48 years . Their Pastitsio is amazing, creamy and full of flavor, their Galaktoboureko is amazing, rich and moist as it should be. Delicious, fresh food. read more

Lovely authentic Greek restaurant right in Babylon town. The owners are lovely, friendly, and make you feel like family. The decor is inviting, the restaurant is clean and with a lot of seating. The service is impeccable. The food is all fresh and delicious. The falafel appetizer is a must. You can tell how fresh and homemade it is, including its dipping sauce. The salmon over Greek salad is to die for.. so fresh and a huge portion! It's enough for two meals really. Any dessert is homemade and so delicious. The last time I came it was rice pudding...so good! read more

I came here quickly for a lunch break and the food was fresh and came quickly. Tasted great and the staff were so friendly and helpful. I loved the cozy feel inside the restaurant too. I wish I lived closer so I can come more often. Thanks again! read more

Still on my quest for quality Greek food. My favorite is far from home- so I've been trying out the local spots. Greek garden was quality. Greek chicken dinner special and chicken souvlaki was very good. Perfectly cooked chicken with veggies, rice, and of course tzatziki sauce! It's not replacing my fav but a very solid substitution! read more

It was ok. Not bad, but certainly not a place I'd want to go back to. The hospitality was wonderful, but the food was subpar. My friend's gyro was kind of bad. The sauce was too bitter. My gyro was ok, but nothing special. read more

Greek salad is weak. Disapponted to say the least. The lunch special was described as dinner salad ( greek) and cup soup. Salad was a side salad with mainly lettuce- 1 small tomato slice, 1 olive and piece of cucumber. The feta was microscopic sprinkle. Still hungry- waste of $15. and gas to get there. read more

Amazing food and service!! Great atmosphere! Highly recommended Owners are delightful read more

Love everything about Greek Garden! Amazing Greek food on a consistent basis. I started taking my daughter here almost 20 years ago and it's still one of my absolute favorite restaurants. The owner treats you like family. Great place, great food, great people! Thank you! read more

This is a Lovely local hidden gem, As soon as I walked in I was greeted by Rosalie the owner, was asked if I wanted the newspaper which was very nice, many items to choose from on the menu everything was delicious and fresh the service was terrific the saganaki was the best I ever had, This is truly old world cooking, they even have a kids menu, The lamb shank with orzo was a special and was delicious , the frappe is like the ones they have in Greece, stop by you won't be disappointed, judging by all the take out orders the Greek Garden is a popular spot in the community, will definitely be back , the dressing on the Greek salad is home made, so are the desserts read more

See all

Excellent food and authentic style great lamb gyros! I can't wait to get the lamb souvlaki, it looks so good.

Visit Date April 4, 2014 Came here with Hubby, my mother-in-law and brother-in-law for dinner. The restaurant itself is weird & whimsical looking. They have a bunch of rooster decorations and some cow related items. The walls are pink. The photos of Greece are nice but a little bit outdated looking. The furniture is nice but also slightly outdated looking. The food was great though! Everything a Greek restaurant should be. Wonderful Taramasala, good hummus, amazing falafel and giant pieces of yummy baklava! I didn't get a chance to sample the spinach pie, maybe next time. Definitely a great Greek place, I loved the Greek coffee as well, but don't drink it unless you can stand your coffee to be strong like a shot of espresso. read more

See all

First time with my husband. We were actually on our way to Argyle and passed Greek Garden and I thought it looked so adorable and was in the mood to try something new / something more with that homey, niche feel. It is just that, it's so cute inside & the people are so sweet. The service was also super fast, and the food was soo delicious!! We have lived in West Islip for so long and never heard about this place before. So happy to have found it. read more

My Husband turned 60 this past Wednesday. We were going to go and have dinner there, but I'm disabled and wasn't feeling well, so we ordered online and he picked the food up. We ordered the stuffed mushrooms for an appetizer, he ordered the gyro platter and I ordered the falafel wrap. The mushrooms were absolutely delicious. His gyro platter was scrumptious and the rice that came with the platter, was so tasty and buttery. I thoroughly enjoyed my wrap and we also ordered the baklava for desert. Yummy! Our Meal was Perfect! Roseann was so pleasant to deal with. We called them after we ate to tell them how happy we were with our dinner, and definitely found our little Greek Gem. Roseann was so happy to hear that our meal was just delicious. ( I'm sure they dont get very many calls telling them that they were pleased with their meal. She was very grateful to hear that comment.) Thank You again, Roseann and staff, for making my Husband's 60th birthday dinner, delicious and unforgettable. We will definitely be ordering again very soon. Rick & Nicole. God Bless. read more

This place is delicious, family-owned, and fast. Old school. Everything is so good and fresh and tastes homemade. Love the avgolemono soup. One of my favorite spots for lunch. read more

Been meaning to try this place for such a long time! So the interior is very clean. Not a huge place but it's really cute and feels oddly really comfortable. It's family owned and you will feel it. The owner greeted us with the biggest smile and allowed us to choose where we wanted to sit. The best way to explain the service is that I felt like I was in their home. It was exactly the sort of vibe my friend and I needed. I felt like I was sitting at a dinner table while my friend's mom (the owner) offered to make me food or grab a drink for me. The service was so very personalized and honestly, I would go back just for that. Forgot what my friend ordered but I had the large Greek salad. There are no onions on the salad which is perfect for me but there were scallions mixed into the salad. Normally I'd switch up my order but i was promised there weren't a ton mixed in and she right. If you like onions, maybe ask for some on top? My friend felt like there was something missing without the onions. The olives aren't pitted, not a deal breaker, but caught me by surprise. The gyro meat was delicious and plentiful though. We also ordered the spanikopita appetizer and I could have eaten it by myself. Tzatziki tasted fresh and was perfect on top of my salad and with the pita bread. I finished off with a Greek coffee which I had never had before? Anyway, it's a little espresso which I was asked if I wanted it sweetened and I said sure. It was a little too sweet for me but that was my mistake, I should have been clear on that. In other words, go check them out. You'll feel like family while you're there and the food hits just the right spot. On top of all that, it's located right in Babylon Village, perfect for a date night and a stroll right after dining. Last thing- bring cash because your card will be charged a fee otherwise. I cannot stress this enough. read more

Gyro is one of my staple meals and I have had one from many different restaurants and diners. I'm happy to report that Greek Garden will remain on my short list of Goto places for Gyro / Greek food. Full disclosure, I know the owners. That does not sway my taste buds, but I can assure you that you are getting authentic Greek cooking. Owners and staff alike will make you feel welcome. The decor has a country feel and while the register up front attends to plenty of take out, the restaurant still feels cozy and welcome. A well made entranceway will protect against cold winter drafts and the heat of the summer. If you are in Babylon and looking for some good food, skip the fancy places and stop in Greek Garden. They are some of the friendliest people in town and it is by far the best Greek food in the area. read more

Went into this with high hopes to be honest and I have to admit I was dissapointed on several levels from price to overall food quality/authenticity My order was 2x gyro sandwich platters (and by platter they mean comes with small Greek salad in the same container as steaming gyro sandwich). 1x chicken gyro. Order of French fries and an extra sauce. This came to 46 DOLLARS! Each meal was 12.95 (high considering it's literally just a sandwich with alittle side salad) and then from there somehow a chicken gyro and side order of fries turned out to be 20 dollars....... The gyros themselves were very small and not what you'd expect from a Greek restaurant. This was more akin to a gyro you would get from a street cart in NYC or the food court at a mall. It wasn't bad but it wasn't exceptional (as a Greek restaurant should be). The yogurt sauce was nearly flavorless. Barely could recognize any sort of dill, lemon or garlic flavor. It might as well of been plain Greek yogurt with a sorry dose of paprika on top. French fries were standard (one step above cafeteria) but honestly I didn't really have high hopes. I can tell 100% every item served to us came from a Greek food distribution warehouse. You can tell the meat and Pita were very generic. That being said my wife enjoyed her chicken gyro as she only eats chicken and whenever she gets a chicken gyro she likes it to be in her words "as fake as possible". Well this chicken hit that out of the ballpark. read more

Walked in on a whim at lunch desiring your typical Greek salad and gyro sandwich. Clean airy place, very good service from the smiling waitress/cashier. Good lunch specials that included a subpar lemon lacking lemon soup that needed more kick and al dente orzo. Where was the pucker? Salad was ok, mixed greens with Italian dressing with some herbs, 2 Greek olives and tomato, and way too light on the feta cheese. I miss Greek salads in Greece where they give you a large square hunk of feta, now that would have been better. Have to say the gyro was spot on, crunchy and juicy off the spit, properly warmed pita bread and delicious tzatziki sauce. Good place for a fast Greek lunch right by train station. read more

See all

Love this place !! Always great food, friendly and accommodating. Spinach Pie, Greek Salad w Chicken are my go to's!!! Owners care about their business. Been told they do a great Sunday morning Breakfast...have to get there for that. read more

I've lived in Babylon for almost 15 years and never tried this place. The food was delicious. The service was great and, who I imagine to be the owners, were friendly and accommodating. My 4 yo said it was the "best burger in town". I had chicken souvlaki pita and the chicken was not over cooked and was very tasty. We will definitely be returning. read more

Excellent take out Greek food! The stuffed tilapia with crab meat is delish, and comes with a nice side salad. I was very happy with my meal and the baklava was delicious too! read more

Went here for lunch with my daughter midweek. We both had the lamb gyro and Greek salad lunch combo. It was overfilled with meat and had a delicious yogurt sauce. The salad was large and tasty. We enjoyed our meal with good service, but I deducted one star for being charged for a second (small) soda. The server never told us we would be charged These days free refills are the norm, so this was disappointing. read more

Greek Garden - Greek Near Me - Babylon, New York

We are new to the area and in search of some Greek food. Yelp guided us to this spot. Upon arrival we were greeted - super friendly owner and employees. Had falafel, gyro, souvlaki and a seafood platter. Everything was delicious with no disappointments. Very nice portions - enough for a second meal which we enjoyed today for lunch. We now have a new Greek place on our list! Thank you! read more

While leaving a local store we decided to stop in for dinner. The food was good and solid, nothing to complain about. It was kind of better than average Greek fare. I love that they make Greek coffee here and the waitress even "read my grinds" after I was done drinking it. Kind of like an old Greek superstition I guess. The bill was average and the waitress was very nice and pleasant. If we were in the area I would definitely go back again. The only down fall is it is more of a take-out restaurant with a few tables and a little on the smallish side. Otherwise it's a good choice. read more

This place has really good Greek food. They're also really nice people. It's important that we support local business like this

Amazing and friendly service - food was very delicious. We ordered mozzarella sticks and spinach pies for appetizers. Dinner was the gyro sandwich combo that had fries and a soda. I had the diet gyro which was gyro meat over salad with a side of pita and yogurt sauce. Nice servings and very reasonable prices. We will be back! read more

See all