Great, friendly neighborhood spot with a parking lot in the back, which is always a plus. I ordered…read morethe beef sticks, and my friend ordered the mixed souvlaki platter. While I personally preferred my dish, both were delicious. The chicken, lamb, and beef were all tender, juicy, and full of flavor. The tzatziki sauce was phenomenal and paired perfectly with the warm pita. The staff were excellent, welcoming, and attentive throughout our visit. Definitely a place I'd come back to. P.S. You have to try their homemade rice pudding :)

The establishment was clean, limited seating and stag very friendly and welcoming,…read more By far one of the better gyros in the area.

We came here on our way to a concert. Originally, we were aiming for the burger joint across the…read morestreet, but after seeing the long line came here instead. The place is unassuming and simple. I ordered the lamb over rice which had a generous serving of lamb. The rice and pees were tasty and the pita bread was a good addition. Service was efficient and friendly. If you're local and looking for a filling meal, this place is a fine option.

Greek delight is absolutely fantastic. The food is so good. My family and I come back here on a…read moreweekly basis because it's just so good. The service is wonderful as well. Highly recommended!

I was disappointed with my recent visit to Athena. The menu is surprisingly limited with no hot…read morevegetables at all. We ordered a mixed appetizer plate and the items were just jumbled together. Everything tasted the same and no one knew what they were eating. The Greek salad was tiny with a too oily dressing. Despite being listed on the menu, there was no moussaka available. My veal souvlaki platter came with a single skewer containing only five or six small, dried out pieces of meat. The sides didn't help much - just some average tasting rice and a few slices of tomato and onion. Our server was perfect pleasant but overall the food quality felt below a diner standard while the prices were noticeably higher. For me there's no return visit.

Unfortunately this place has gone a little south. Food quality, portions and flavor are missing…read more Also, it seemed every take out order had something missing.

Came here a second time and was very pleased. One of my critiques last time was feeling…read moreclaustrophobic due to its smallness but they expanded 4 months ago making dining much more pleasant. A nice dining room, with excellent service and food was good. Lots of vegetarian options or should I say pescatarian options. We had the bronzino , halibut and tuna- all nicely prepared. Parking is in strip mall, can be a little tight. Reservations suggested especially on weekends, it does fill up.

Today I came back to Blue Waters to check out their happy hour in the renovated space. Prices on…read morethe food for happy hour didn't blow me away and they could use some work on the cocktails bjt the service per usual was friendly and we loved what we got to eat.i don't typically opt for wine or sangria but their white sangria is sweet but not too sweet. I really enjoyed it. They have an oyster happy hour. I'm always on the hunt for oyster happy hour. We also got the fried calamari which was nicely lightly breaded paired with a creamy basil sauce and classic red sauce. As well as tuna crudo. We did expect it to be just saw raw tuna but it had a creamy sauce on it. We enjoyed just different than expected. The crostini it came on was delightful. I would come again

I proudly write this review this hometown restaurant. I have been a customer since they opened and…read morethe food is always delicious. Recently I was hosting a dinner party (safely during the pandemic) and I spoke with the owner Spiro to put together the menu. He put together a terrific dinner to cover everyone's food requests (vegetarian, gluten/dairy free etc..). All the food was packaged and labeled perfectly. Spiro was so kind and gave us a plentiful amount + free desserts, pita, hummus and all the sides. I highly recommend Simply Greekalicious for your next catering event or just for takeout dinner. They are simply the best!

Flies, did i say Flies!! Gross the meat had flies on it and they dont care to shut a window or keep…read morethe critters out. The service was slow and the food did i say dirty? Just horrible and dry the meat was, too bad i didnt notice the flies until i sat down and took a big bite, i looked around and got sick, TERRIBLE FOOD

Loved this restaurant for years. Last week we brought home two Greek salads with chicken on one of…read morethem. Was my mother's 81 birthday and her salad as well as my own soaked in water with wilted lettuce. Not alittle bit of water either. So unappetizing and had to throw away. It was late on a Wednesday so just ate the chicken. Don't understand when so much of menu has lettuce why they can't at least use a salad spinner to rid majority of the water? No one wants their salad soaked in water.

Warm and welcoming owner and staff with a great selection of Mediterranean dishes. While it doesn't…read moreexactly transport me to Greece, the flavors remind me of Astoria, Queens. truly the next best place for American Greek cuisine! It's a cozy spot with just enough seating to enjoy your meal fresh from the kitchen.phenomenal meal. Excellent bakery items to choose from for desert.

While driving in Lindenhurst earlier this morning, I happened to pass by this spot and it caught my…read moreeye. I quickly called my husband to see if he wanted to have an early lunch. We don't eat Greek food often, but today we both wanted to try something different. We ordered two Rice Bowls with various toppings, and everything was fresh and flavorful. The Chicken Souvlaki was moist and well- seasoned; the Pita Sauce definitely enhanced our meals. The staff was kind and pleasant to interact with and the space was very clean. We look forward to returning!

I stopped in after working out and needed a healthy meal to end my day with I chose the "Build…read moreyour own bowl" option and picked chicken, spicy feta, cucumber, romaine and some yummy green sauce. Great after workout meal that hit all the points I needed. It's set up like a Greek subway where you start at one end and add as you make your way to the register. Everything tasted good, non greasy, not heavy, not salty. No complaints from me

Great food! Had gyro, melt, salad, fries Very quick delivery…read moreordered direct from store Didn't have a minimum order

Why is it so difficult to order over the phone these days? So often people get things wrong and I…read morespeak very clearly and I try to be very exact. I told the young lady on the phone that I wanted to a combination of a gyro with french fries. I knew there would be potential for confusion so I made sure to tell her that I want a sandwich and french fries. I had my suspicions when they charged me close to $30, and also that she asked me soup or salad. Of course I just got home and her I am sitting there with a plate full of meat and two wrapped up Pita breads. This is not what I wanted. I love this place and their food is great, but why is it so hard to get this right?