3.5 stars. Medium wings were cooked well. Flavorful! Fast service! Totally understand they were very busy but even saying these were "warm" would be pushing it. I'd be willing to try once more in the future! read more

D'Agostino's Pizzeria - Medium wing - Pizza Near Me - Depew, New York

my husband looked up D'Agostino's PIZZERIA as it was close by where we were staying, and when you order the nicest man answered the phone very clear well spoken, very nice and pleasant took our order we had it delivered. We had ease of putting the tip on the card and he was such a nice gentleman that came that brought us our little mini pizza Personal pizza, which was really big to us and then 10 wings. They were cooked like we asked crispy and their sauce on the pizza is delicious and they loaded it down with pepperoni. We thoroughly enjoyed it. Whenever we come to Bufalo, we will do our best to order from D'Agostino's. They have great food and great service.!! read more

Pizza and wings were amazing! Chicken finger sub was delicious (and huge). The chicken finger pizza was awesome! Great option..you should definitely try it!! read more

D'Agostino's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Depew, New York

Love trying new pizza spots. Lucked up to be in the area and stopped in grab some slices to try. The staff was friendly. The pizza is very good! Loved the sauce, little on the sweet side. The crust was cooked to perfection. Was enough cheese and pepperoni to where you would not have to do a double double. Definitely would put this spot into rotation. Will have to add in some wings next time. read more

D'Agostino's Pizzeria - Cheese and pepperoni pizza slices - Pizza Near Me - Depew, New York

Staying the night in Buffalo before flying back to Jacksonville early the next t day and we decide when in Buffalo you gotta great Buffalo Wings right? D'Agostino's was close to the hotel and they of course had wings so that's where we went. I got a 10 piece Garlic Parmesan wings and we also got a Small Pepperoni Pizza. The wings were great. Fried to perfection. Plenty of sauce but the wings were also still very crispy plus no tiny wings here. They also had good Bleu Cheese. The Pepperoni Pizza was for sure on the large size when it comes to a small pizza. I will say the toppings were good but it was thicker than I would have liked and a little too doughy. For sure only able to eat one slice and that was really me pushing myself to get that one down. If you are looking for some good wings this is the place to go to. read more

D'Agostino's Pizzeria - Small Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Depew, New York

See all

Pizza is delicious!! Wings are good too, just a little bigger and more fatty than what we're used to.

We were in Buffalo for one night and my family wanted wings but I was craving a good hoagie so after some Yelp research we decided on D'Agostino. By the time we had arrived at D'Agostino we were starving so we ordered way too much but every single thing we ordered was delicious! My personal favorite thing we ordered was the antipasto sub it was incredible and I will be craving it for a while! I would absolutely recommend this place! There was indoor seating but it was mostly used for waiting on food not so much for truly eating there I don't think. read more

See all

We ordered pizzas, wings, salads to feed a good sized out of town group. Great food! Pizza was great, classic buffalo style, and great wings to introduce some to real buffalo wings! read more

The absolute best pizza in WNY. Their semi-sweet sauce, crispy crust, and mild smokey pepperoni makes my mouth water just thinking about it.

Hidden gem. Located in a strip mall, the pizzeria is decorated with goodfellas and sopranos on the inside. Ordered takeout and the service was very easy. Pizza was delicious and is in between a New York style and Buffalo style crust. The wings were very flavorful and decent sized. Would definitely recommend! read more

D'Agostino's Pizzeria - Small pizza with half pepperoni and half mushroom - Pizza Near Me - Depew, New York

See all

The food was good. Pizza: really liked the pepperonis. Not the greatest slice ever but did not the pepperonis going for them. Wings: really crispy but some were a little too cooked. Skin curled, dried out on a couple of pieces, and easily broken bones (I am the strongest man in the World so that is easy for a person like myself). I would definitely eat here again. Likely pick it over the famous wing places because I think you get more, for less, with less crowd/time. read more

D'Agostino's Pizzeria - Pepperoni pizza and plain wings with ranch - Pizza Near Me - Depew, New York

Great pizza!!!! Must go there for authentic pizza! Loved the sesame crust! My only regret is that the pie was so big I could only eat one piece!! read more

At a first birthday party, chicken fingers were server. As I was eating them, I was thinking how delicious they were. They were crispy and juicy and I was really into them. I asked my friend where she got them from and it was from D'agostino's. Fast forward a week, and I was still thinking about these chicken fingers. A friend was coming over to my house and I had to order these for our meal. I got an order of 10 chicken fingers, plain with hot sauce on the side. It also came with fries and celery. I like that they put in two hot sauce and two bleu cheese. They were delicious and my friend enjoyed the fingers too. I can't wait to share the chicken finger experience with more people. In fact, I might get some more tonight because now after writing this review, I can't stop thinking about them. read more

D'Agostino's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Depew, New York

Really (really) good pizza. and wings. I've had a lot of pizza in Buffalo and these guys are among the best. Service was pretty quick and prices not bad and they had some good coupons, so overall a really good experience. Pretty small place so plan on take-out. read more

Hands down this place has easily become one of my top favs. Ordered from here twice now. I feel like it's a secret hidden gem because it never seems to be chaotic and my orders always made fairly quickly. The service is always so easy & friendly and the food is phenomenal. I've tried their mozz sticks, chicken finger sub & white pizza. I absolutely love this place read more

With moving to Cheektowaga, I've taken it upon myself to find some new pizza shops near my home. On this quest, I found D'Agostino's Pizzeria listed pretty high on Yelp so I knew I had to check them out! On a Saturday, around 5pm, I called and placed an order for pickup. The gentleman on the phone took my order without any issue and told me it'd be about 40 minutes. I arrived at the small shop around 45 minutes later - I didn't realize it was in a plaza with other stores/shops, so there was plenty of parking. I walked right in and was able to pick up my pizza without any issues. All-in-all, I thought the customer service was friendly and fast. I ordered a small (13", six slice) cheese, pepperoni, bacon, green (sweet) pepper, and onion pizza - my "go-to". The pizza was very good! The pie was very generously topped with all of the veggies, meats, and cheese, so I couldn't have asked for more on there. The crust was not the typical Buffalo-style. At D'Agostino's the crust, to me at least, seemed a little thinner but not like a New York City-style, it still had a little "heft" and a nice chew/feel to it. The outer-crust was excellent as it had a satisfying "crunch" without being too burnt/charred. The only knock I had was I wish there was more red sauce - I couldn't really taste it but maybe it was just a little hiccup that night. From what I could tell, the sauce didn't come off like the sweeter Buffalo-style sauce but it wasn't herby/garlic-y either, somewhere in the middle. As for the size of the pizza, it was perfect! I ate the whole thing and didn't feel "stuffed" afterward. Another positive was the price, which was incredibly reasonable especially with all of the toppings I added. I had a great first-time experience with D'Agostino's Pizzeria! The overall service, prices, and the quality (and quantity) of my pizza were great. I wouldn't mark them a favorite of mine, but I'll be back, for sure, to try one (or two) of their specialty pizzas. read more

See all

Pizza was amazing, had terrific flavor. Chicken wing deal was great and were the best chicken wings i've tasted in Buffalo. We got our food almost immediately service was 10/10. Overall it was peaceful and a definite eat again. read more

D'Agostino's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Depew, New York

Pizza super super delicious!! Fresh and really good customer service very good!! One of the best pizza in the area

Excellent pizza and wings. Recently tried their steak and cheese pizza and it was outstanding. A nice amount of steak, onions, hot peppers and cheese. So many places skimp on that steak, not here! read more

Food was good. My issue was that the pricing on their website did not reflect what I was charged. I mentioned this to the staffer when picking up the order, even showing him their website, who said they'll take it up with the manager. But I was not refunded. Plenty of other pizza and wing shops in the area. read more

We ordered two sheet pizzas and 100 wings for our children's birthday party on 11/1. Our party guests enjoyed their pizza and wings. At least two of our guests shared they would order food from this place as well! Pizza was cooked perfectly and the wings were crispy just the way we like them. read more

D'Agostino's Pizzeria - New menu design!! Very nice!! - Pizza Near Me - Depew, New York

Visiting Buffalo and wanted some good pizza and wings. This place DID NOT DISAPPOINT! The wings were good with the blue cheese and the pizza was like no other... the cheese and sauce paired up great! Check this place out! The only complaint I have was that I shared the 2 slice combo and didn't get myself two slices of the pizza! read more

D'Agostino's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Depew, New York

See all

Delish Wings and the fingers are huge!! Wonderful, friendly service and open on Mondays! Which if you live in the Buffalove area you understand how great that is! Destination Yum City!!! read more

The worst!!! Pizza wasn't cooked through, super doughy. Inedible. Chicken fingers were burnt but also soggy. We threw it all away and really regretted making a special trip to check this place out. Disappointed!!! read more

Unassuming and small; but great Za spot! Very decent Buffalo style pizza right here. Good sauce; lots of cheese and crunchy crust. Popped in on a whim for a few quick slices and a coke. Was very satisfied and would definitely try ordering a full pie here in the future. read more

Honestly the best place in the area for pizza . I've lived here for two years and finally found what I've been looking for. Delish!!! One try and I'm hooked. read more

On a recommendation, I made a 30 mins drive to try a different pizza restaurant since our local favorite place closed. Called ahead to confirm that we would be able to order due to a food allergy, they said that we would have no issue. On arrival I asked again just to make sure and it turned out that if I would have served it to my wife she would have been in the hospital for the rest of the day. read more

We ordered a sheet and large pizza (cheese and pepperoni), 70 wings (medium, extra crispy), and a single order of plain chicken fingers (that came with yummy fries!) for a family birthday party. All of the food was tasty and reasonably priced. Thank you for a great experience. read more

Would be great to but we tried two nights. Both nights not a single sole will answer the phone. Called for over thirty mins both nights an hour before closing and no one would pick up. Rang till we got a a digital "please enter your access code". So while I guess both nights they either down want business or the staff walked out well before the closing time. Either way doesn't seem like a great way to run a business. read more

Food was fantastic. I was told that the Italian food in Buffalo was not good but this place puts that rumor to rest. We had the personal pizzas and they are so big you can't eat the whole thing which leaves great leftovers. Also had the garlic bread with cheese and it was the best I have ever had (have leftovers on that too) read more

Pizza and wings were very good. Pepperoni was so delicious!! It was just a lot thicker crust then I was expecting. But really good!!

Ordered a few sheets of pizza from D'agostino's for an event. They delivered on time, the pizza was well received and I thought the price was decent compared to some alternatives I considered. I'd definitely suggest checking the web site -- I was able to find a $3 off coupon that I could use for the order right on the site. Sheet pizzas are around $30 each and 3 of them were more than enough for 30 people (ton of left overs), in the future I would probably only order 2. The veggie specialty pizza was my favorite with the onions and mushrooms; so delicious! The sauce is on the sweeter side and the pizza isn't on the greasy side. The wings were decent (I got the sheet pizza & 50 wings combo), but I thought the sauce was a tad dry and I personally like a more saucier Buffalo chicken wing. If you're looking for a decent slice of Buffalo pie, either for yourself or for a large group, I wouldn't hesitate to order from here again. read more

This is a tiny storefront in the strip mall on Dick Road across from Wegmans. Family owned, they have won some awards over the years, which are posted on the wall. Three tables that could have used a wipe down when I was there. They don't do slices after 4pm. I got a personal pizza as a result. It's a good size for one, you may have a leftover slice or two. The pizza was good. I'd eat it again. Buffalo style with the small pepperoni. Easy parking. read more

The pizza is. So. Freakin'. Good! It is my favorite pizza anywhere. It's good sized and always cooked to perfection. Locally some people like Joey's but I think they are overrated. Joey's pizza has a sweet sauce and the cheese doesn't even stay on the pizza when you eat it. The service is friendly and on time. I highly recommend D'Agostinos. Tip: It isn't very visible from the road. It is in the strip plaza with Walgreen's and Macaroon's. read more

D'Agostino's Pizzeria - Deliciousness - Pizza Near Me - Depew, New York

Found this place by buying an used iPhone from one of the workers there. He went home to pick it up while we waited for him to return. In the mean time, me and the other half was hungry. So we look at the menu and order a few items. I order a sub and some chicken wings and the other half ordered the same thing. The place seems to be mostly take out place with three benches for you to eat in when you don't want to go home or want to enjoy your food fresh. The sub I got was okay, It was a meatball one, the meatball seems like it was pre made and wasn't hand made, home made. I might be wrong though, but thats what it tasted like. The other half got a fried Baloney sub. He said his tasted good. we also ordered some wings and those were very relish. The other half got some medium spicy ones, and I got some there was asian and something else. I forgot, but the sauces were good and complimented my wings very well. I noticed they won a few awards regarding their sauces, but We did not get anything on the menu that used the sauces, but next time for sure I will try it. I will for sure be coming back in the area or if your wanting to try a new Pizza joint, this is the place to try out most def. read more

See all

Because my experience at the restaurant in front of our hotel went sideways after a previously great experience, we ordered from D'S and it was great. I didn't know we could get food from there as it was a bit far but, dang, again, it was great. I'd worked several places just like the in my youth, I know what they can do right and how to get it wrong. We gave them a diverse order and it could have gone sideways but they got it all just right. Good on them. I'd order again in a heartbeat. read more

This place is right around the corner from me. I seriously order from them once a week. The pizza is really good. My favorite is the steak pizza. Have not once so far been disappointed. Their fries are always crispy, chicken wings always cooked to perfection, and always take orders they way you want it. read more

Meh, it's ok. Pizza looked really good. Problem was dry, little sauce and no flavor. The cheese had a strange consistency, not stretchy. Almost like a gritty texture. Wings were ok, they put them in styrofoam containers not cardboard so the condensation makes them soggy. Pizza I would have to pass on again. read more

D'Agostino's Pizzeria - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Depew, New York

Best pizzeria in Cheektowaga! Everything is really good and if you like antipastos, give theirs a shot. It's always loaded with lots of meats and toppings! Super friendly staff and owner too! I always leave them a tip because of their great service. read more

This past Saturday I ordered 4 sheet pizzas and 200 wings for our hard working warehouse crew, and when I arrived at the restaurant at noon the order was hot and ready to go. Sitting with the warehouse guys, we enjoyed some of the best, freshest, most delicious pizza and we've ever had. Great service as well. Thank you to the guys at D'agostino's, we'll be back soon. read more