In a quick rush for lunch so we ordered some food from here. We ordered it online for pick up. I was craving a burger or a sub and decided we had to try a new spot. I ended up getting the best of both worlds with a cheeseburger sub! The sub itself was great! the burger was perfectly cooked and the roll was great. Would have liked maybe a couple options for toppings but all in all was a great sub. I also got a side of fries that were great. Your typical fries you'd get but they still went good with the burger. I also got some breadsticks. I forgot to add cheese to them on the order but my son still loved them and I thought they were pretty good too. Pick up was quick and service was friendly. I will be back to try the pizza since we live down the street now. read more

See all

The pizza here is very good, we did the large pizza and 20 wing special. Pizza was delicious, wings were crispy. What more could you want in a buffalo pizzeria ? Food was out fast, and service was excellent. Inside is nice and clean. Will be back again. read more

The Pizza Heist - Outside area - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, New York

See all

Got the wrong order even after I called to double check I ordered (because I did it online )correct said I was good yet it wasn't super disappointed with the service. read more

First time trying the Heist. Excellent in and out service, Pizza flavor was an "A", the price was right, and they did not disappoint! Highly recommend. read more

The Pizza Heist - First time trying small Pizza from the Heist - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, New York

See all

Super clean interior, friendly cashier at the register. Perfect presentation on the pizza, sauce is on the sweet side and it had the perfect amount of cheese. Pizza logs, well they're pizza logs. Nothing really spectacularly different than most other ones. Wings. Touch on the smaller side, sauce was sparse on the medium and wasn't really "medium" it ate like a dry mild. The garlic parm, I'm sure was buttery, but the paper container drank most of that up. On par with most pizzerias, if you're close it's worth it, but not worth traversing the city like we did. read more

See all

Pizza Heist has decent pizza for great prices. A tomato paste tasting sauce with a good amount of cheese. Two slices are about $5. You can't beat that pricing anywhere in Lancaster! My biggest gripe with PH is that they don't serve slices after 4pm. So don't bother stopping in for a few for dinner because they just don't have them. I get that's their busiest time but the financial benefits of offering slices would be worth it. I've never known a place not to offer them all day. The parking lot is also the absolute worst. The intersection where it is located is one of the busiest 4-way stops in the area and their parking lot consists of 4 parking spots, backing right into the street. It's awful. That alone would keep me from going there. The pricing is the reason I do. read more

The Pizza Heist - Decent slices for great prices! - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, New York

See all

Ordered a large cheese and pepperoni pizza and a mini Royal prior to the Bills game. The pizza looked great, was fresh and hot. I was pleasantly surprised at the amount of ingredients on the "mini sub", it was excellent. I will definitely return!! read more

Pizza was good, I like that the crust isn't paper thin. Could use a sprinkle of oregano on top though. But the cleanliness of the place is questionable. Ceiling fans had cobwebs on them, garbage can was half full yet the place had just opened. read more

The Pizza Heist - Trash can hadn't been emptied yesterday - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, New York

See all

We frequent the Como Lake Bark park and have tried several places in this area and liked Pizza Heist the best. Standard CPMO pizza was a better deal and better tasting. Looking forward to sampling more of the menu. read more

Ordered a small steak pizza. Ingredients and flavoring was good. Crust was hard and a little over done. The price was over $15. Not so sure it was worth the amount. Not horrible but not jumping out of my seat to say it's my favorite. read more

I feel like this is hands down the best pizza in Lancaster. They never miss! We try different places all the time but we keep coming back here. Easily on par with Grassos, perhaps better... read more

Shawn's Pizza Reviews REVIEW # 1 THE PIZZA HEIST Lancaster, NY Score 6.3 The Pizza Heist had the right idea with a thick slice that looks very appealing to a Pizza eater. A prime location on the corner of Como Park Blvd & Aurora St with okay customer service. Unfortunately, the pizza was decent at best. read more

The Pizza Heist - a slice of pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, New York

Today was my first time ordering from Pizza Heist. I ordered online to be picked up at a certain time, a specialty pizza and wings. The order was hot and ready when I got there, exactly as I ordered it. The pizza was fantastic and the wings were huge. And the best thing is, they typically beat other pizza shop prices. A great experienced! read more

The best in the area! I really enjoy the staff and the ownership. The pizza is always cooked right and the wings are definitely one of the largest in the area. read more

Me and my husband get a pizza from here nearly every other week for the last 4 years and have never been disappointed (: I always ask for ours well done and my husband loves the antipasto salad- fair prices as well! read more

I love the dense, oregano heavy, thick sauce. A little sweet. The sauce so rarely sticks out at places. This one does. It reminds me of childhood somehow. Also a slight biscuity crunch of the dough reminds me of Chicago style. It's a local place that tries to stand out. It isn't some fancy brick oven, Neapolitan, New York, New Haven, Coal Fired, Detroit, style this-or-that.... It's consistent stuff every time. Very much in the Buffalo vein. And a good deal. Standard, hot, fresh, good quality pizza from a local joint that you should go to. read more

The Pizza Heist - Yeah I like the black olives; wanna fight about it? - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, New York

Their chicken finger pizza is absolutely the best in town. Lots of chicken, perfect amount of cheese and blue cheese as the base! Delicious.

If this pizza were in college, it would win the Pizza Heisman. But it isn't in college, because Ariana Grande showed it how to graduate. So rather than the Pizza Heisman, you just seriously need to get down to Depew-Lancaster and try the Pizza Heist, man. Just don't show up when the place is being robbed, okay? I mean with a name like this, it gets robbed all the time. And usually at gunpoint. You don't wanna be in that room when those robbererers bring that Bang Bang into the room. And you might get that Pizza all over you. But if you do, they'll let you have it. And you'll be like... wait a minute, can you heat this up (ah ah), wait a minute can you (ahhhhh). Not a fan of that song. But yeah I know Domino's been good to you, you need a Pizza Heist to blow your miiiiiiiiind. What to get: Slices. There are some pretty amazing slices in Western NY, but Pizza Heist is right up there with the very best of them. Not only amazing, juicy, delicious, Imperial-esque slices, but amazing service and prices too. Slices and prices... two reasons to go here. I mean look at the name. And the marquee says "a meal for a steal!" and they are right. Maybe because they market themselves as dirt cheap, people think they are also dirt poor quality. Not at all. It's some of the best pizza around. The first time I went in, they endeared themselves to me by selling me a slice for around $2 which totally rocked my world and was significantly better than most of the other slices I've had. Typical Buffalo pizza but done right... fluffy sexy doughy crush with generous hot melted greasy cheese and yummy tasting not-too-sweet homemade herby tomato sauce and those pepperonis that turn up at the edges and get slightly burned and turn into bubbling cauldrons of heart-stopping grease. Yeah, DON'T eat pizza too often. But when you do, try Pizza Heist. I don't always eat Pizza. But when I do, I Heist it. So the second time I came here it was even better. It was late night (they're open til Midnight, baby) and they were about to close, so they had no slices left. But they had a "burned pizza" from earlier which wasn't that burned and still tasted amazing. They said... you can have these 5 slices if you want... I was like... hmm, okay. How much? Oh, it's free. They're burned and we're closing. Okay then... so I tipped them heavily and took the slices (which they kindly warmed back up for me!) and they were absolutely fantastic. So this place earns top marks on every level, for me. I could not recommend it more highly, and it is easily one of the 10 best slice places in WNY in my none-too-humble opinion. So in the words of AG, they literally let me have it. Not that. I mean the pizza. Neither Pizza Heist nor AG has ever let me have *that*. And I'm okay with that. I don't like salt with my pepper anyway, I prefer pepperonly. Tomato is another day. I thank Jesus crust I am still here to write about pizza. Dough not ever take anything for granted. If you feel down, locate the sauce of your negativity and get it out of your life. Three cheese for great Buffalo Pizza! read more

See all

Their customer service needs work !!! Their veggie pizza is good... Prices are reasonable..Steak hoagies are very good..

We ordered through slice for pick up. We got the BBQ Chicken Finger Pizza and the appetizer sampler. I was so surprised by how delicious the Pizza was! It was ready precisely on time for pick-up, and they took the right amount of caution for COVID-19. They gave us a LOT of blue cheese, which is always deeply appreciated. The pizza was cooked perfectly. We will definitely be ordering from here again! read more

Ordered several subs and wings during a bills away game. They were very busy but got the order done in 30 mins. Subs were exactly as ordered and very tasty. Wings were crispy and just the right amount of sauce. Would definitely recommend and will be back! read more

I was a very good customer of Pizza Heist since the opened several years ago, I ordered from them at least once a week sometimes2 & 3 times a week. Yesterday I called at 3:30 PM to have a pie delivered. I always get delivery from them. They told me they could not deliver because of the Bills game that was at 7:30 PM which was 4 hours later. I asked to speak to the owner told him who I was and thought being a good customer I was would make a difference. He did not care in the least I told him I would order from a new pizzaria just a few blocks down the road and take my future business there. Once again he could care less. Called the new place BOZZY'S the happily took my order and delivered it in a very timely fashion. I opened the box and couldn't help notice how much larger the pie was { seems pizza hiest cut down the size of their pies lately as well as raised their prices} ans how much more pepperoni was on the pie. Overall very satisfied with Bozzy... If your in the area try Bozzy give the new guy a chance I'm sure you will be glad you did.. Pizza Hiest needs to learn how to get appropriate help on big days so they can handle their customers or loose them as they did with me. By the way Bozzy's phone lumber is 716 901 7800 then press 2 for Lancaster location on the corner of Como Park Blvd and Lake Ave read more

The Pizza Heist - a pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, New York

Delivery really sucks. I mean I ordered over an hour ago and still haven't gotten my food, so when I politely called to see what's going on, the guy who answered just said "uhh well our delivery guy is out so im sure he'll be there any minute ." But I called at 6pm and it's not 7:25. And they told me it would be delivered WITHIN the hour. You just don't keep a girl that's on her period , lonely , and starving and in waiting. You just don't do that. It's lethal . read more

I was very pleasantly surprised by my experience with The Pizza Heist. Someone in passing told me "don't sleep on pizza heist!" And they were right! I ordered a large cheese and pep and double order of wings for a Friday night special- which was a great price! The integrity of each slice was good- meaning it holds up well by itself in the hand and through the dipping in bleh cheese without falling apart. The crust and pepperoni were perfectly crisped and the sauce was the perfect amount and slightly sweet. The bleu cheese is homemade and deliciously garlicky which is a huge bonus in my book. My only tip, order the wings crispy. Mine were cooked but not crisped, which may well be because of sitting and steaming in a to go box. This place may well become my favorite local joint! read more

I ordered 4 sheets and 100+ wings for a birthday party and everything was exceptional. Everyone loved the food, it was ready on time and very reasonably priced. I can't wait to go back! read more

My wife convinced me to give The Pizza Heist another shot since they are not that far away. Their standard cheese and pepperoni pizza has greatly improved from when I last had their pizza a few years back. My only suggestion is that they cook the pizza just a little bit longer. It's not only Pizza Heist, but I have noticed a lot of places serving slightly undercooked pizza over the past several years. I don't know if the reason for that is that places are just trying to move product faster. I am reluctant to ask for well done from pizzerias in general because many of the kids that answer phones at some of these places will need to have the concept of "well done" pizza explained for about 10 minutes and still not get it, or they will confuse well done with nearly burnt. But back to Pizza Heist, great job. read more

In a market flooded with an abundance of pizza joints, its hard to decide where you want to eat when you have those oh so dangerous pizza cravings. Next stop, Pizza Heist. Its a smaller business, but it is clean, theres seating that is accommodating for groups of 3-6 and most importantly the service is top notch. PIZZA TIME! Upon opening the white box filled with beautiful slices of heaven, you notice almost immediately that there was time taken to prepare this pizza (I have never had an ugly pie from here). The sauce is evenly placed almost all the way around the pizza with just the right amount of dough at the end, which is a bonus in my books. Pepperoni is average in taste, and the cheese has just the right amount of flavor that is not overpowering nor underrated, its just right. My favorite ingredient to this pizza is the sauce, its hard to explain other that i can only describe it as subtle and sweet with just the right texture that leaves you wanting more and more after each bite! The dough is not thick and it is not thin, it is right in the middle. Again, the ingredients all work in unison to create a great pizza, not one ingredient is overpowering, it simply works. There are many pizza places around this area, and if you are looking for a guaranteed quality pizza for dinner, please do yourself a favor and try this place, I assure you that you will not be disappointed! Truly a "meal for a steal!" read more

The Pizza Heist - 5 Extra hot chicken wings! Great snack. - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, New York

See all

We order from here often! 8 out of 10 times the food is really good!! My only thing is sometimes the pizza is more burnt like & not much cheese, but then the next time it's great! When I order mine with extra cheese it's always much better!! All I all thought it's not bad! Service & waiting time is not bad! Pickup is fast! Friendly service! I would recommend this place read more

My family (and friends) all love this place! The food is always great as are the people! They have amazing pizza, and their wings and subs are also delicious. My husband is a huge steak sub kind of guy, so it's always a treat when he gets one from PH! The owner is always generous and kind, and the staff seem to be loyal and enjoy working for him. Overall this is our Go To place in Lancaster for take out! read more

Pizza heist has grown on me....REALLY. There pizzas have come a long way, very tasty "sweet" sauce. Nice buffalo style pie "thicker crust" the only thing I wish was the pepperoni has some nice char to it. Anyways? If you like thicker pizza and sweet sauce try them out. If you don't skip them or try something else and skip leaving a bad review. read more

See all

Only ordered from here twice, small cheese and pep and 10 wings the first time and second just a large cheese pep...the pizza is good I will admit that it's pretty damn good pizza and the other best part is the price ! by far lowest prices I've seen for a pizza joint but the reason I'm only giving 3 stars is the pizza is too doughy, it defintaly needs to be cooked more that's for sure. Pizza shouldn't taste like sauce on a slice of bread there need to be a little crunch in my opinion, however I will be back because prices are great. Maybe I'll just stick with wings or a sub next time read more

went to order online and they add on a $1.50 convenience charge! what the hell is that for?? cancelled my order and went elsewhere.

By far the best steak hoagie sub anywhere... have to have one whenever I come back to town! If yo like flavor, add the cherry peppers... fantastic!. read more

Absolutely the worst pizza I ever had! For one the pizza did not look like anything in their pictures, second it tasted old, like it was made earlier and reheated . The edges were charred and dried up, usually pizza dough is soft. Not here! read more

Was in the area for business and thought I'd try it out. Pizza was burnt and there were a bunch of small curly hairs in the sauce. Not impressed with the experience. read more

I keep seeing restaurants advertising Fish Fry in my new town. Usually it's only one day of the week and usually Friday. Maybe it's a Catholic thing. Anyways, we wanted some cheap takeout for our stay-at-home New Year's Eve, and the Heist has fish fry all week. Bingo. For $7.99 you get a huge piece of fish or pile of shrimp with fries and cole slaw. The fish comes with bread and tartar sauce, and the shrimp comes with a really addicting herb-loaded macaroni salad and some cocktail sauce. The fries are plain but good and have the peels on. They might be cut fresh in the store, I'm not sure. The place is small and dim but clean, and has a small private parking lot. The menu is huge. If you're with a group and nobody can decide what to eat, there's pizza, fish fry, fried chicken (including wings, pieces, and fingers), hot and cold subs, tacos, and salads. And probably something I forgot already. Some time when I've got more people over I'll go for the pizza and wings. I suspect this place can do no wrong. I am so glad to find a good local fast-food takeout place close to home. Goodbye 2012, and goodbye Toronto and your horrible Pizza Pizza on every corner. I think I like where I landed. EDIT: Hubby found macaroni salad under the bread after all. Also, two litre pop bottles (you sell pop, if nothing else, in litres down here?) are two bucks. This is good because it's big-brand pop. I'm not hooked on big brands, but sadly none of the discount store brands seem to sell a cherry cola. So I'm happy to shell out two bucks for a big-brand if it's cherry cola. Pop companies (or is it soda?) pay attention! read more

Great staff and great food for the price. You really can't beat the amazing specials and always be sure to get a side of homemade blue cheese it's delicious !! read more

I've been here a few times and the last 2 times I ordered food, it was burnt. The pizza I got tonight was burnt and tasted like it had been reheated. I have worked in food service most of my life and the motto has always been: if I won't eat it, don't serve it. read more

We recently ordered tacos at this pizzeria. The chicken was deep-fried but not terrible. Steak taco, was fake steak, processed crap. Tasted awful. The beef taco had too much taco seasoning, couldn't taste the beef just seasoning - not good as well! Overall, these were huge taco raps with very little meat inside. It was a sure tell when I picked up the bag and it felt extremely light in weight. Cost, average to high - $5+ a taco. I will never order tacos from there again. read more

We went their many times and the food was decent and the staff was pleasant. Last few times the chicken wings was undercooked while we order it extra crispy the pizza was good . Give it one more try otherwise try somewhere else . read more