The staff behind the counter are attentive and super friendly. They even give military discount for active and veterans. I'm ver grateful for that. The ambiance is super simple and effective. Clean and bright with good ceiling lighting and some natural light that comes through the large windows. The pizza, wings, subs, and French fries are all delicious and cooked to perfection. I feel their pizza is cooked better than Leo's. The sauce, cheese, and pepperoni are delicious. read more

Muscarella's Pizzeria - Front entrance. - Chicken Wings Near Me - Lancaster, New York

Recently found out they make Detroit Style Pizza and it's the best pizza I have had in WNY since moving here 12 yrs ago.... The crust was cooked to perfection and the sauce was on point ! This is legendary Detroit Style Pizza. Run don't walk and try it. read more

Muscarella's Pizzeria - Detroit Style Cup & Char - Chicken Wings Near Me - Lancaster, New York

We are new to the neighborhood so we are on the hunt for our new pizza spot closeby. We tried out Muscarella's the other night and it was great. We ordered delivery while we were unpacking boxes and it got here so quick! The pizza was really good. They cut it into squares which was good since we had a few people and everyone got a few slices. I think the pizza had a good crust and it was a little crispy but not too much. The cheese was great and the pepperoni were the perfect amount of spice. This spot might be a contender for our new go-to pizza spot at our new house. We will definitely be back to try a couple of the specialty pizzas too. read more

Muscarella's Pizzeria - Chicken Wings Near Me - Lancaster, New York

Pretty decent Pizza. The competition is very stiff and buffalo. Yes I would go back. The service was good the pizza head a medium crust enough sauce cheese and pepperoni. read more

Small little place next door to the express Tops. Pizza is decent, it's not the best nor the worst in the area. If you like burnt (charbroiled) pepperoni, it might be a great place for you. Personally, I hate any of my food burnt. It's nearly $9 for two slices which is insane. I can get two slices for half that price at Pizza Heist down the road. Their cloves subs are pretty packed of meat though so those are with the high pricing. I don't like the hot sauce they use for the chicken finger subs though. Overall it's not a place that I would stop for a quick lunch but I do appreciate that they are on all of the regular delivery apps - UberEATS, GrubHub, etc. read more

Muscarella's Pizzeria - Two slices for $9 - Chicken Wings Near Me - Lancaster, New York

My husband and I did a Lancaster/Depew pizza tasting review on YouTube a few years ago (we were bored and heck, we like pizza). We wish Muscarellas would've been in the area back then because now the review feels incomplete. I rate my pizzerias based on dough texture, cheese taste, sauce,- sweet or bitter, and pepperoni spiciness and style. The dough at Muscarellas has a great chew, good salt ratio, and crunch. The cheese is tasty, sauce has a sweeter vibe, and the pepperoni is cup-style and charred perfectly. I seriously love how the round pizza is cut in a square shape. I love the crust (dipped in pretty much anything), and this maximizes the crust to middle-piece ratio. We will return! read more

Muscarella's Pizzeria - Cheese and pepperoni - Chicken Wings Near Me - Lancaster, New York

The last pizza we ordered was delicious! Good service. The antipasta salad is the best around and very cheap for what you get.

Absolutely delicious pizza! I've come in a few times and have had great help from one of the weekend managers here, I think his name is Lucas. He was very knowledgeable about the whole business and has great recommendations if you're looking to try something for the first time. The front area is a nice spot to eat if you don't mind the noisy kitchen! read more

Our first take out order from the just opened Lancaster location on William and Aurora. We were having guests over so I stopped in and preordered for my husband to pick up on his way home. The staff was very nice and friendly and had it ready right on time at the scheduled pick up. I ordered a colossal pizza and it was 20", so pretty big! It was delicious and cooked just the way I like it! I hate when places under cook them and they are doughy! Next order will be to try their subs! read more

We've lived in the neighborhood for close to 10 years and this is the 4th pizzeria to open in this location between Tim Horton's and Tops Express. I think we may finally have a winner here. We ordered a basic cheese and pepperoni, which I think is the best way to judge a pizzeria you have not tried before. The pizza was ready about 5 minutes after the time they gave me, but that's fine. They use a conveyor belt oven, and I was a bit uneasy with when I saw it. It made me think of Pizza Hut or other chains. But my concerns were unfounded. The pizza was solid Buffalo style. Sauce slightly sweet, thick dough but not too thick, good amount of cheese. Charred pepperoni, but also not full of grease. And importantly, that conveyor belt oven cooked the pizza fully. Nothing saddens me more than underbaked pizza dough. You can eat the whole slice right to the end crust, and the crust is not hard as rock. I like that. The only drawback is that it IS expensive. Yes, I know inflation and all, but compared to Pizza Heist, Ronny's or Bozzy's up the street, the prices are quite high. One additional topping on a large pizza is $4 alone - for a single topping. $3 per topping on a small pizza. For those prices, I would expect something like Bocce Club, but the pizza is not quite in Bocce territory. I will note that they were adequately staffed, which could be one reason for the prices. Despite the high prices, both my wife and I liked the pizza more than the other cheaper options in the area, and it was certainly better than Leo's across the street. We'll be repeat customers. read more

I ordered from them last week and I was very happy with the food. I ordered a half pizza with pepperoni and single order of wings medium. Everything was delicious! read more

The pizza is expensive but good. The service is terrible. They get orders wrong way too often. We stopped going months ago after they messed up 2 of outlet first three orders with them. Nothing complex - routine large pizzas with two toppings. After a few months, we decided to give them another chance. They messed up the order again today. Large pizza - two toppings, pepperoni and bacon. They forgot the pepperoni. We're not the only ones this happens too. We've been in line with others going back for their second attempts at getting an order right. In their defense, they've offered to make it right each time. But I'd prefer to just get what we ordered the first time. There are too many good pizza options in our area. We're done. Never again. Suggest you avoid too. read more

Showed up at 8:55 PM because Google hours said they closed at 10PM. Owner told me they close at 9PM and as I was walking out she asked what I want. I said I don't want to be "that" guy and she asked again. I said a chicken parm sub and she turned around, talked to the employees a minute and said don't worry about it it'll only take us 10 minutes. Felt like a jerk but she reassured me it was no big deal. Incredible service and I threw on a hefty tip for being the end of the night jerk! read more

Wanted to try this new to the area pizza place so I got a couple slices. These slices seem to be very old and over cooked. Based on other photos that have been posted I don't think that they cook their pizza to a well done. Would not recommend. read more

Muscarella's Pizzeria - 2 slices cheese and pepperoni. Not good - Chicken Wings Near Me - Lancaster, New York

I went in after school the other day to get some slices. The lady that took my order was patient and calmly explained to me that a fresh pizza was coming up and that I would have to wait a few minutes. While I was waiting, 2 other families with little kids came in to order food and the environment and customer service was very family friendly. Would definitely recommend to those looking for a bite to eat. read more

We absolutely love Muscarellas pizza and it's become our go-to neighborhood pizza take out! We think it's worth every penny and won't get Buffalo style pizza anywhere else. Takeout is expensive no matter where you go, so don't let it deter you, keep Muscarellas in this location! read more

Outstanding pizza and chicken tenders. Pizza was cooked perfectly! Very friendly staff as well!

Pizza is not as good as this place states. The dough is ok although the cheese is too gory and when you take a bite all the cheese falls off the crust read more

Amazing pizza such a nice family that owns it good prices definitely will be going back a lot! My new fav spot

Pizza was very good but kinda pricey.but will be ordering from there again. Highly recommend.

The pizza was very good and service excellent. Can't wait to try their subs. A few more words. Lol