Came here couple times before when it was Marx Pioneer Inn. It changed owners and brand several…read moreyears ago. We came because I had heard that they had good brisket. And they were right about that. Its essentially a older home that was converted to a restaurant many years ago. Inside there is a large bar, a dining area (mostly tables for 6), and an outside patio area. The place looks a bit in disrepair (the front porch does not give a great impression), and could really use some TLC. Outside in the back is a volleyball court, kids playground, and a bar. Came on a Saturday night, around 7pm. There were a handful of people around the bar, and a couple of small groups of diners. Got seated right away. Server got to us right away, but then the service for the rest of the evening was excruciating slow (and inattentive). We ordered a Sangria and Beer. Apparently the sangria is not on the menu, but they did a good job of making one up. We got served in plastic cups, but saw that others were drinking out of glass (should we have had to ask?). Ordered the Brisket Sandwich and the Pub Burger. Both came out relatively quickly (although they were waiting a while for the server to bring them to us). Both sandwichs were very good. The burger was flavorful, and hot. The sidewinder fries were also hot and well seasoned. The brisket sandwich was excellent. Couple of slabs of moist brisket, with a nice fat cap. The sweet potato fries were ok, but over seasoned. After we got our food, our server was MIA. Never came back to ask how things were, and we had to flag them down to get our check. (they were chatting it up with some other employees near the kitchen). In short, the food was very good. But the atmosphere and the server have a lot to be desired. This one did not make my "got to come back to" list.

Cracking time. What I was expecting from a local WI place. Up from Chicago for the day, but will be…read moreback...oh, & did I mention the brisket? Melt in the mouth

Won't be back! We discovered this place about 6 months ago and loved it. However, after seeing…read moreorders of wings next to me at the bar, prior to ordering, I thought I would order two types of wings and more than disappointed . Mine were so small and out of a dozen, only two drumettes. When I brought it to the bartender's, attention, who I believe is the owner's daughter, she said well they are 50 cent wings and your order is normal with the attitude of what do you expect. Afterwards, I saw a number of wings which by far surpassed my order, again. Recognizing this and giving a fair order of wings would have kept this customer coming back. Besides waited 20 minutes for a drink. We arrived before 5:00 and missed happy hour as a result. That did not upset me as I could see the first bartender was really busy. Last note, there was a bug crawling on my husband's shoulder a couple times which I thought could be a cockroach. I googled it and pretty sure that's what I saw after swatting it off my husband's shoulder and second time stomped on it. I even searched bugs that look like cockroaches and unfortunately none of those matched what I saw. Should have lefts and canceled my order right then and there.

Small local bar. Stopped in for drink and appetizers. Good for bar food. Would've give. It 5 stars…read morebut we really had to do all the work to go order the food, go ask for the bill, wasn't greeted when we walked in or even a smile. But it's a bar so serves it purpose I guess.

A nice spot for drinks, and a solid bloody mary. Not a lot of varied beer options though…read more Unfortunately dogs are allowed inside, which I wouldn't expect in a place with a kitchen. The bartender was very nice though and they had live music on the patio. I didn't eat because of the dog being inside, if it wasn't for that, this place has a lot of potential to be somewhere I'd go on repeat. Unfortunately allergies will prevent that for me.

Staff very welcoming. Great place to watch sporting events, especially packers games…read more Dog friendly, as long as on the leash, and great patio! Drinks are also great, best Bloody Mary I have ever had (make sure to get it spicy) and good espresso martinis. To top it all off, they have a rumpleminze machine iced! GOAT!!

Been here a bunch a times before. Even when it was the AudMar. It's located on the waterfront of…read moreBass Bay, which is part of Big Muskego Lake. During nice weather you can grab a seat outside and look over the water. They even provide pontoon rides during the warmer months (great way to enjoy a drink while you wait for your table). In the last several years they have gone through some significant renovations, especially with the outside seating areas. There is the restaurant on the first floor, and an event space on the second floor. Made 6:30 reservations for Wednesday for 4, and got right in. Had a table by the large windows that look for the patio and lake. Very pretty spot. Got greeted immediately by our server, who did a great job the entire evening. (thanks Laura). Got us water, took our drink order, along with an order for Onion Rings. The onion rings didn't take long, and they were excellent. Crispy with an interesting texture, hot, and served with a side of ranch (could have used more of that). The drinks were good, with the exception of one glass of a beer flight which was super flat, and was happily replaced by the server. For entrees we got: BLT, Blacked Fish Tacos (with extra bacon), Pesto Encrusted Salmon, and Salmon Power Salad. A note about the Pesto "Encrusted" Salmon. It's not really "encrusted", more like a scoop of pesto placed on top of the Salmon, and they finished under a broiler? Good but not what was expected. Didn't take that long for the food to arrive. It was all very good. The tacos were fresh, great flavor and hot. The fries that came with it, were NOT as not as I would like. Both grilled salmon entrees were also very good. The Power Bowl was excellent, with lots of fresh greens and other yummy add ins (goat cheese, blueberries, etc) A very good evening, with the exception of a couple of small hiccups.

Updated: what happened tonight? Service was so negative and snarked Joel M made it awkward and…read moreuncomfortable for ordering food and drinks. Used to love this place but not coming back for quite awhile. Plenty of other lake restaurants around with better staff! Poor man's lobster x 3 people at our table if 7 was way overcooked and dry!

Outstanding food and service as always. Relaxed atmosphere. Good music. Harley is the best.read more

Weather was beautiful, and we wanted to sit outside, so decided last minute on Papa Stache…read more Generally a solid choice. I had the Southern belle chicken sandwich which was delicious (with homemade chips). My friend had cheese curds (I'm not a fan, but she loved them) and bacon wrapped chicken bites. Outdoor area was busy and our waitress (Jodi) was hustling! They have a huge bar with slots, pull tabs, bar dice, pool. Clean, nice place with alot to choose from on the menu

Good food and service. Glad to see them reopened. They have been closed for a while since a recent…read morefire so they're on the food scene again.

The service - inattentive at best. No coffee or water refills offered. Came to our table when we…read morewere 75% done to check on us. Lots of chatty time by the other servers and bussers. Should focus more on customers. The food - Potatoes were cold, soggy and unseasoned. The replacements were crisp and hot but still unseasoned and disappointing. They took about 15 minutes to come out so I was already well done eating. The omelette was very good. We used to eat here alot but you've become very inconsistent in food quality. This was the first time we've had bad service.

Breakfast is served sat and sun mornings. Super reasonable. Food was very good! Coffee was not…read moregreat. (But wasn't really expecting it to be). Very very casual atmosphere. We were the only ones eating and we went at 10am. I don't think people know abt sat breakfast. Can't beat it for the price! Great service too.

This is my Type of Place, the food is good, cheap, and quick. Those ribs and wine were to die for…read more 100% larsen Certified

Finally stopped in on a Monday for the prime rib. This was a very good decision. It looked more…read morelike a small beef roast, I believe 16oz. Large baked potato and a vegetable. All this for $30. sat next to some friendly people and had a delicious meal that would have cost $10-15-20 more at other places.

I have driven past Romeys many times and though the building looked so cute from the outside! I…read morefinally went this past Saturday afternoon. The parking lot situation was strange. It felt like cars just piled in and someone could easily get parked in or hit. Entering the bar, it was very old, small and hot. I'm not sure if they don't have air conditioning or if it just wasn't working, but we could only stay for one drink because it was uncomfortably humid inside. I feel like a window ac unit could work just fine. The bar itself is very small with a large pool table in the middle. A couple guys were trying to play pool and I felt awkward sitting at any of the tables because it felt like I was in their way. The bar seats were full, so I had no other option. There was no music or TVs with sound playing, so it was weirdly quiet for a pretty full small bar. I ordered a Bloody Mary and it was very good! It was made from scratch with horseradish.

I've been coming to Hideaway for years. Always had a great experience; however, the breaded…read moremushrooms were not what they were a few months ago. I ordered the Cajan pasta with the chicken. (paper menu listed as Cajan & website menu has it as Asian style noodles). Seriously, I had to look for the chicken. It was cut in such tiny strips I had to dig through the pasta to find it. This did not remotely taste like a Cajan or Asian dish. it was so bland that a two year child could eat. To spice it up the cook gave me hot sauce. How insulting!!!! I had no choice but to send it back. I have to say the wait staff was amazing. Get rid of the cook!!

We recently had a luncheon there after my mom's funeral and we couldn't have been more impressed…read morewith the quality of food, service and hospitality that was provided. Highly recommend and would book again! Thank you for making the celebration of my mom's life a positive and memorable one.

The staff and customers are awesome! Great place for EVERY…read moreLOCAL!!! And anyone who isn't.

Super fun bar! Great people, amazing food, awesome drinks! Will definitely be returningread more