I wish I could give it 3.5 stars. Went last night with my dad and son. My son had the spaghetti with meat sauce; he said it was okay but, he wouldn't have it again...that being said he ate all of it. My dad and I ordered a large thin crust pepperoni and extra cheese pizza. It looked absolutely delicious but, didn't have much flavor. I'm not sure if it's because it had so much cheese that that drowned out the sauce or if the sauce was under seasoned. Service was good. It's cash or check only. They do have an ATM. read more

DiMaggio's Pizza & Burgers - Spaghetti and Meat Sauce - Pizza Near Me - Coloma, Michigan

Highly recommend this being a stop for anyone looking for some good pizza. The crust was crisp and not too thick. They have an option for thicker or thinner crust. I would recommend going with the regular crust. The toppings were fresh and the sausage was amazing. The pizza sauce had a nice flavor as well. If you like Chicago style pizza, I would recommend stopping at this gem off the beaten path. We got the 18" which ran us $20.99 after taxes. It's a bit pricey but was well worth it. Additionally, the staff was very friendly and on the ball. She was the primary person working up front and handling all the ordering, serving, payments and bar. read more

DiMaggio's Pizza & Burgers - Seating and bar area. - Pizza Near Me - Coloma, Michigan

See all

This place was really cool. Sadly it burnt up and was remodeled in 2019 so it was a clash of tradition with modern interior. This would be a great place to belly up to the bar and enjoy some food. We had the pizza to go. All were great. Wish I would have known they have 3 thicknesses of crust. If you don't ask you'll get the standard but they have a thin and thick. I imagine the thin crust with mushroom is amazing! read more

DiMaggio's Pizza & Burgers - Outside - Pizza Near Me - Coloma, Michigan

See all

Honestly one of the worst pizzas I've ever had ... it's like they tried to reinvent the wheel and cut the pizza into thin strips like cheesy bread... can't hold the pizza right .. like trying to hold a lasagna noodle if it was the crust ... flavorless .. can't remember the last time I put salt on my pizza oh and the place also could use a visit from an exterminator.. bugs all over the inside windows jumping on your table ..And the Ranch Dressing blows read more

While spending the week at Paw Paw Lake we had a taste for a pizza night. After going back and forth on several choices nearby we settled on DiMaggio's (based on others' reviews) and were not disappointed! They have delicious pizza and the staff is welcoming and friendly. We're from Chicago and I absolutely love New York style pizza, so I'm on good authority to say that DiMaggio's pies are top-notch. We were feeding 10 people (4 adults, 2 seniors, 4 kids) so we went with 2 large and 2 small with a side of Garlic Bread w/ cheese. We picked up and brought it back to the house and it was still hot-and-ready to eat. They cut their pizzas into squares, which is fine (triangles are better...), and they do a good job of loading up on the toppings. Not to mention the taste of the sauce... it really makes or breaks a pizza and here it made it. A big thanks to DiMaggio's staff for serving up the good stuff with a smile and also a nod to Yelpers - we wouldn't have found this spot if it weren't for your reviews. If you're vacationing in the area, or you're a local, don't pass this place by, it's great! read more

Pluses: Fast service; easily accessible in the Hagar Park area. Negatives: Salad was shredded lettuce and a pale tomato; pizza crusts were cardboard quality. Conclusion: skip this place if you are craving good pizza. DiMaggios are lucky they have a captive audience in the area. read more

Great pizza and atmosphere. Service was top notch. Would definitely return next time in the area!

Very friendly staff. Service was good. Food was delicious Atmosphere was nice. Special orders were no problem read more

Stopped on Saturday night late. Waitress was pleasant and pizza was very good. Thin crust & plenty of toppings.

DiMaggio's is open again for business and we were thrilled with our experience Saturday evening. Service is old school and reflects the atmosphere. Think Cheers where "everybody knows your name." Prices are reasonable and the food is well worth the drive! Remember: cash or check only, ATM available. read more

See all

DiMaggio's was our "go to" pizza place back in 1976/1977 when we live just a short distance up Blue Star Highway. Since we were in the area last fall we thought it would be interesting to see if it was the same flavorful pizza we had enjoyed many years earlier. DiMaggio's did not disappoint. Not only was the pizza as we remembered, but our youngest granddaughter had the kid's spaghetti with meatball, and absolutely loved it along with a slice of our pie. This weekend we were once again in the area and the granddaughter asked to "go to the place that had the spaghetti and meatball" for dinner. Without hesitation we traveled the short 10 miles north to what has, once again, become our "go to " pizza place when in the area. Another great meal at DiMaggio's. Thank you for bringing back great memories of your pizza, and creating fond memories for our granddaughter. Keep up the great food and service. read more

See all

I would give this place zero stars, but unfortunately I can not. This makes me very upset. They do not let you know over the phone that it is cash or check only. So they charge you $2 to use the atm. Horrible customer service. Customers will harass you if you wear a mask and are not caucasian. Their only mystery in their pizza bag is that it makes their pizza instantly cold. They do not know how to cut a pizza. They wrapped their cheese bread in aluminum foil and all the cheese came off. Pizza isn't very good. Cheese bread isn't good. Save your money and go to Little Ceasars or go to your nearest grocery store and get a Digiorno pizza. Buuuut if you like cold cardboard pizza, this is your place. Thanks everyone for your time Love, Jacob read more

Place is busy. Waited over an hour for a thin pizza. The pizza had zero flavor. It really tasted like nothing. There was no flavor in the crust, sauce, sausage or cheese. The most bizarre thing really. The staff was nice. Worked their tails off and about 100 pizzas were picked up or served while we were there. I wanted to love it. But...flavorless. We did hear that "Josie's in Texas and Marge is in California" so perhaps that makes all the difference and the secrets to the recipes are out west with them. read more

we waited over an hour for a lousy cheese pizza. We asked and were told that's the way it goes. We won't be back.

So disappointed. This is not completely fair to give a rating based on not eating the pizza. I grew up with this pizza and was on my way through town, actually, I made a detour. Their website, yelp and Siri said they were open on Mondays, but they're not. They probably won't see this review, but I hope someone lets them know it's important to keep the modern world updated of hours. read more

DiMaggio's Pizza & Burgers - Closed on Monday May 2023 - Pizza Near Me - Coloma, Michigan

I wish I could put no stars for this place, right when you walked in we were greeted by the most outrageous behavior. she told us she couldn't serve us when there was plenty of space for us to sit at 2 tables, yet she denied. we came to honor our grandmother and mother who passed away, because this was her favorite place to go when she was a child(we are on a girls trip). But the snarky tone and rude manor was unacceptable. We will for sure never step foot near that place again, and we have a bitter taste of this small restaurant in our mouths. read more

I had a large pizza with pepperoni, sausage and mushrooms. The pizza was great. My SIL had the ravioli with meatballs and really enjoyed it. They only take cash and checks. There is an ATM by the bar. The pizza is served with paper plates with raised an eyebrow but worked fine. The drinks were nice and strong. The server was nice and responsive to our needs. Parking is a little tight. read more

DiMaggio's: just a little hole-in-the-wall place with zero atmosphere off in the middle of nowhere (the Coloma, MI outskirts). But it has my vote for Best Pizza Ever. The thick crust pizza has a crust that's a work of art - it would be a delicious meal even if you stripped away the pizza! But combining a delicious fresh pizza with this crust is a memorable combination. It's worth coming back here on vacation just to visit DiMaggio's! read more

Always delicious. A southwest Michigan gem. Pizza is what i come here for . But all the food is great.

This is legitimate Chicago thin crust. But not in Chicago. I feel fortunate to live close by.

Great pizzas and service to take to Hager Beach down the street. I would give it a higher score but Im a well traveled Pizza connoisseur and this pizza is only average to me. I heard its the best in the area so give it a try and have a drink at the bar! read more

Just don't go. How can they screw up cheese pizza and garlic bread, well they do. Not very accommodating either, put you in front of the ATM, and not let people know ahead of time that it's cash only. Save yourself time and money go somewhere else. read more

Stopped in for a quick carry out dinner. Pizza was average, but the meatball appetizer = chef kiss! Wow! Will definitely return for the lasagna (recommended by a local) on our return next weekend! read more

DiMaggio's is fantastic! Their pizza is is a real treat and does not disappoint. It's been the same secret family recipe for years. Enjoy! read more

I'm 54 years old. Waaaayyyy back when I was about 3 or 4 we lived in Lake Michigan Beach (the town doesn't officially exist anymore), just a stones throw from Di Maggio's. I can barely remember mom and dad taking me there for pizza in the mid-1960's. This place has been making pizza for 60 YEARS!!! I haven't been in here since about 1995. Today I was passing by and stopped in for a pie! Nothing much changes at Di Maggio's, that's part of it's charm. It's a hidden gem, off the beaten path, nestled in the sandy dunes and woods of Michigan. The fact that this place has survived since 1957 in this out-of-the-way location means they're doing something right! I ordered a small "special" (sausage, green pepper, onion and mushrooms) and added pepperoni. They had WSBT news on one of the T.V.s (yay, not everybody is a spawts moron!), which was nice since we had a big thunderstorm rolling in from Chicago. The waitresses seemed a little jaded and indifferent. I can UNDERSTAND this if they have been working here a long time- but, I don't LIKE it. I got my pizza and it looked good. I took a couple photos and grabbed the first slice. This is not your ordinary, cookie cutter, McFormula-chain-store-pizza! This is something a little special! At first I thought it might be a little light on the sauce, but it turned out to be fine. I rarely LIKE pizza sausage, but this stuff is pretty good! The pizza has a certain-something flavor that I can't quite nail down (yes, I know the scene from Mystic Pizza) and it really makes this a good pie! The chunks of sausage are almost too big (though cooked all the way through), the veggies were right on the money. The pizza was chewy, cheesy and saucy with that something flavor hitting all the right notes. I need to stop in here more often. Di Maggio's makes a good pizza, but you will pay for it. For my small pizza and a Coke it was over $20.00 without tip. But I would rather pay $20 for a GOOD pizza than $12-$15 for a BAD pie! No plastic- cash or check only. read more

DiMaggio's Pizza & Burgers - Small "special", add pepperoni. This was a GOOD pizza with a certain-something flavor I can't quite determine. - Pizza Near Me - Coloma, Michigan

They redid the place since I've been there last time. Looks great. Good thing they didn't redo the pizza. Still amazing.

We ordered a carry out pizza. We live 15-20 minutes away. My husband got there and saw a sign on the door: Cash or check only. He had to drive all the way home and all the way back and home again. By that time, the pizza was cold and horrible. JUST TELL PEOPLE WHEN ORDERING THAT YOU ONLY TAKE CASH OR CHECK. It's common courtesy. read more

DiMaggio's Pizza is fantastic. I lived in this area all my life & just recently moved to Indianapolis. I have been a customer since my teen years (late 60's) & their Pizza is the BEST! My orders are always ready & hot!Thanks DiMaggio staff!! read more

This place is so perfectly old school that it warms my heart thinking about going here! We make it at least a couple times a year (less now that we don't drive up to east lansing from Chicago a few times a year). The service isn't great which is one of the attractions of the place. The bathrooms are what I expect at this type of "dive" (I call it a dive in the kindest way ever!!) The salad with garlic dressing is one of the nest salads on earth. Garlic bread is like grandmas. Pizzza......don't need to say anything more then...it's the best. And finally, the fact they only take cash ...what more charm could it have. There are still restaurants in a big city like CHICAGO that only take cash. Quite honestly , the people that complain about not taking a credit card or about the hand dryers in the bathroom or the service are not the type of people that should be going here!!! We love you DiMaggios. Keep doing it the way you have been doing it for years!!! read more

We have been going here for about 20 years now and claim it's the best pizza in Southwest Michigan. The wait time for a carrot pizza is usually long but worth it. Always like looking at the bounced checks on pizza boards while we wait to pickup. A family staple for sure! read more

DiMaggio's Pizza & Burgers - Sausage and onion pizza cut Chicago style - Pizza Near Me - Coloma, Michigan

Not worth the two hours to eat there. Food is ok but super long to get drinks and then took forever to get bill.

grew up eating Dimaggios - lived in the area my entire life but no pizza is worth the absolute rudeness that you receive if you come in before 5:00 - I have witness her mistreat customer after customer. From a lady in a wheelchair that she made absolute no attempt to let her family push her out of the way of the door and reprimanded and embarrassed the entire family by yelling at them from behind the bar. This afternoon as soon as we pulled in and I seen her working I knew having a nice dinner was going to be an issue. We ended up walking out - unfortunately for the very last time. There is no reason to bully your customers in the way that she is allowed to do. Not sure if she is related which is why she's allowed to behave that way but more and more people say "well we love the pizza but it's hard to go somewhere you know the staff is rude" that is definitely not the Dimaggios I use to brag about. read more

More problems than solutions. Two of us on Sunday afternoon--didn't want pizza so we ordered spaghetti with sausage and spaghetti with meatballs and two beers. The beer was cold and, although they came out very quickly, so were the spaghetti dishes! We told the server and she had them microwaved and returned one at a time. This time they were hot and quite good, actually. But there was only a small loaf of untoasted Italian bread as the sole side. Of course, the question must be asked--why does the kitchen staff think it was remotely OK to serve the meals way under temp? The bathrooms were almost OK, but the women's had no soap and both had archaic and crappy hand dryers; no towels. When the bill arrived, I tried to hand the server my favorite card and she told me, "we only take cash or checks, but we have an ATM for your convenience." MY CONVENIENCE?!?! It's freaking 2018, my convenience dictates that you accept plastic like every other restaurant in the free world. So let's summarize: cold food, wet hands, having to use cash--I barely had enough, and way higher expectations from a restaurant that's been around for more than a half a century. To the ownership: it is, it always has been, and it will always be about the CUSTOMER'S experience, not your convenience. It's past time to renew that commitment. read more

Delish pizza! Hands down the best pizza in the area. My hubs has been coming here his entire life. Same people and same great quality pizza for 3 decades. Have a family cottage in Coloma and we make it a ritual to have their thin crust pizza on every trip! Our friends who come w/ us always talk about it & look forward to it!! CASH ONLY! FREE Parking lot. Carry out is a great option :) read more

Located in a rather remote area this place is always popping! A delicious mom & pop pizza shop that has many great toppings and perfect for a lake night that doesn't require a grill! The family got a plethora of pizzas. My favorite was the ham with pineapple! I was rather disappointed with the cheesy garlic bread. But the pizza was so good I pretty much forgot about it at the time. read more

Good pizza joint, one of the waitresses at least is nice. The larger waitress with the shorter red hair is a nightmare. She was snotty and rude to me and my boyfriend who were already being helped by the nice waitress with dark hair. We came there on a date and she was hateful not only to us but the other waitress right in front of us. I don't know how she keeps a job but if the owners know what's good for them or their business they'd get rid of that one FAST! What a witch! read more

This is one pizza restaurant that doesn't need reviewing. EVERYONE who has ever been there gives it two big thumbs up and 5 stars!

Good pizza, very busy with the regulars, only 3 beers on tap. Would definitely go back.

Eat pizza ever!!! It's been a staple in our community forever and is still family run with the same homemade food items!!

If I were just rating the pizza by itself it would be an easy 5 stars. This place has the most delicious pizza I've ever had! The salad on the other hand....well, just see attached photo. Worse salad ever and barely deserves a single star. So here we are with an imbalance in food, hence the 3 star rating. Also, it's insane that it's 2018 and they don't take cards- cash only. Anyways, worth the visit for the pizza that's on smash. Other than that, don't expect good service, good sides, or good prices. read more

DiMaggio's Pizza & Burgers - Pizza Near Me - Coloma, Michigan

See all