Twice now I have left orders within their working hours (once at 9pm when they close at 1am), and they have just decided to take my money and my order, and then close early without delivering my food or contacting me to let me know they won't be despite having my phone number. I sit and wait for hours and then call them to look into my food only to get no answer since they've closed. A million hoops to jump through to get a refund, and hours gone when I could've ordered from somewhere that respects their customers. read more

This store is nasty,dirty, and rude. They handle your food with no care in the world and they will leave your food outside on the floor. They customer service is horrible. They are rude and disrespectful. read more

called the local Ithaca number at 11:30pm placed an order and paid by credit card over the phone the woman who took the order said she would give the driver our phone number to contact us when he was on his way. At12:51 am they had shut their phone off so we went to the store and the woman there said that they never had the order and I have to call tomorrow to get a credit back meanwhile they have a pending hold on my card and we have no food! Terrible customer service and experience. read more

Very poor food quality. It was my first time ordering pizza from there and in the pizza I found a piece of plastic. Stay away from this store. read more

I ordered two large pizzas with extra tomato sauce. There was minimal sauce on either pizza. Certainly not "extra" sauce. The crust was very salty. Maybe it's supposed to be "garlic" crust, but it just tastes like salt to me. Domino's used to have great crust, but the greasy, salty crust they have now is unappealing. The biggest problem was with delivery. A full hour from order placement online, to the delivery driver showing up at my house. Both pizzas were lukewarm and far from "fresh out of the oven". Apparently the delivery driver had trouble finding my address, but he never called for directions (I provided my phone number when placing my order). I can't recommend Domino's any more. They used to be a solid choice for pizza delivery, but this was a dismal experience. read more

terrible service terrible food wrong orders of stuff that was nore expensive that we did not want like come on do better you lazy people

I know I know, I'm writing a review for Domino's. After a few late work nights and little food in the fridge, we decided to use them for delivery. I don't think I've had dominos in years, maybe 8. Delivery was pretty quick and the pizza and cheese bread was surprisingly better than we expected. So we ordered again a few weeks later and it was the same: consistent, fairly quick, nice delivery man, and pretty tasty. Don't sleep on Domino's! read more

Tried many pizzas in Ithaca this dominos became Mt goto place for pizza . Great food and service. The staff are always very friendly . Highly recommended read more

I waited 3 hours for a pizza delivery last week, and now I am unable to place an order at all. I have never had such terrible service at a dominos, even in other college towns and busy areas. I'm really not sure why this specific store can't handle any volume of customers. read more

Do not order from this store, we ordered delivery and the pizza arrived ice cold and not well make. We tried calling at least 10 times to the store and they refuse to answer the phone. It is not the first time this has happened. read more

Domino's is Domino's. It's not the best pizza you're ever going to have, but sometimes you just get a craving. The location for this downtown Ithaca Domino's has changed over the last couple years. The plaza itself that it sits in doesn't have great parking and can be difficult to get into and out of when traffic is busy... but you make due. (Sadly, I'm not in their delivery zone... so it's pick-up only.) In the past, I've gotten pizzas that were overly cooked and some of the toppings more burnt, but I had been thinking that seems to have improved recently. Alas, no! Nix that... just got a pizza from there today and my pizza was overcooked, as was my cheesebread. With regards to price, a large pizza is over $20, and honestly? I've gotten better pizzas for less. Also, when I went to pick up my pizza recently? Things seemed to be in a bit of chaos... with employees not being able to find certain items for orders, yelling for things across the room. TL;DR Would be nice if they expanded their delivery zone... because I'm starting to think the overall experience is more pleasant when you don't have to actually GO in to their location. read more

Really disapppinted with the order. Got a large thin crust pizza with no cheese and double philly steak. I have a dairy allergy and this pizza came with white topping on it. My roommate tasted small piece of it and it was cheese. And there was one piece of Spinach. I called them and the guy who picked up the phone did not even apologize but simply said do you want me make it again and you pick it up or do you want store credit? I said I want refund instead. Threw the piazza away . What a customer service. read more

See all

Changed atmosphere, one of the fastest services in town! Used to be 2 hours waiting for my food I've experienced 30min and less!

Every time I try to order from this store there is always something wrong. Says they are open but when you call it's says closed. Try to place a future order on the website, it doesn't let you. When I do get to speak to someone they are incredibly rude. I hate writing reviews like this but like...wth read more

Tried to order delivery to campus. Was quoted that it would take 55-65 minutes. Over 2 hours later I'm still waiting for the pizza and no one will answer the phone at the shop. I would like to cancel my order but cannot get in touch with anyone. This is ridiculous. Do not order from this store. Edit: 8 hours later I still have no pizza and no one will answer at the store. My order no longer shows in the order tracking and my charge to my credit card has been refunded. Seems as though they just canceled my order without notifying me. According to another reviewer from today they went to the store and there was only one employee in the shop. Obviously it is not this lone employees fault, but it is apparent management doesn't give a s*** about their customers and even more so their employees. Ridiculous. If I was the lone employee I'd be done with this establishment and as a customer I am most definitely done with this place. read more

Pizza delivered at 2am? Doesn't get much better than that. The Grub -- * 2 Medium 2-Topping Pizzas (Mushroom & Pepperoni and Pineapple & Bacon) ($5.99 each) Venue Review -- Domino's is tucked away into the corner of a small plaza right before you reach the Commons where the REAL food is. It's nothing special in terms of dining arrangement. Everything feels a little sticky or greasy, but that's exactly what you'd expect at any self-respecting pizza parlor. Food Review -- The price cannot be beat! For $5.99 apiece my friend and I ordered in 2 Medium (12") pizzas to fuel our weary minds. They were SO HOT when we opened up the cardboard boxes that steam came rushing out. It was as if they came right off the pizza belt. The garlic crust is a BIG plus. It might have just been the fact that we were going delusional from all the studying, but my friend and I were very impressed with the pizza. Only problem we had was that the sauce was barely there and the cheese (we asked for the normal amount although there are heavier options) was also almost nonexistent. Service Review -- The times I've dined-in, service has been "eh". Just enough politeness to get your order in and sit down with your food but of course when you get fountain drinks, refills are on your own, buddy. Overall Impression -- If you get hungry on a Friday or Saturday late night, call up Domino's, they'll deliver until 2 AM! Most other nights they're open until 1am. Domino's isn't always my first choice back at home (it falls short of Mountain Mike's, Papa John's, etc.), but with many more great deals like this one maybe I'll be calling them up more often. read more

Domino's Pizza - Pepperoni & Mushroom 12" (Medium) ($5.99) - Pizza Near Me - Ithaca, New York

See all

If you want to wait 2 hours for a cold ass pizza, filled with unhelpful phone calls, and incompetent kids, order from this shithole of a place, the disorderly management is laughable. Update written 3 weeks later: of my last 4 orders - 3 have been messed up, late, and cold. read more

Ordered a pizza online. The guy deliver to me the wrong pizza. After I called, he asked me to call the office and that they would send me the pizza for free. Called the guy at the shop and he said sorry bla bla and the correct pizza never came.. I am startled at how shitty the service and delivery is. Don't recommended ordering online wirh them. read more

I feel ridiculous for trying to write a review for Domino's, but my experience with this place has been frustrating. I've never ordered takeout in Ithaca, but I called this place to order a medium two topping pie for delivery. I was stuck on the phone for ten minutes during this transaction. The man on the other line just couldn't figure out what I was saying, even though there wasn't much background noise on either end. At one point, he said to me, "Shouting will not help me hear you better," which I found irritating because I wasn't actually shouting. It was a bad connection, but thanks, Domino's, for placing the blame on me. When I gave him my credit card number, he said the machine was frozen and it was rejecting my order. When I asked to make sure that all of these failed attempts weren't charging my credit card repeatedly, he said, "It's telling me 'failed attempt,' so how can it be charging your credit card?" So I said I would like to cancel the order altogether. Of course, he called me back five minutes later to say that the order actually did go through and my credit card was charged. To cancel the order now, he added, I'd have to wait three days for the charge to clear from my credit card statement. Apparently, "failed attempt" could very well mean that the order did go through, so I guess he belittled me for no reason after all. read more

In my experiences Domino's usually has good service, but not this one. In three and a half years of ordering from them, the majority of my orders have resulted in a bad experience. They've refused to honor coupons that are still valid, they've delivered the wrong pizza, and they've taken forever to deliver. My worst experience was on a football Sunday. They quoted me 1.5 hours until delivery and I thought that was a long time but I was willing to wait. 2 hours later I called back to check up on where the pizza was and they told me it was next in line to be made. I called again at 3 hours and they didn't even pick up the phone. After repeated calls, I called with a friend's phone to see if they were screening my calls and it turns out they picked up right away in hopes of taking another order. Once they found out who I was they put me on hold and I couldn't reach them after that. The pizza was never delivered. read more

It's mind blowing how bad the service is at Domino's locations across the country. Sure their pizza is decent, but the service is so bad that it makes the whole ordering process dreadful. Save yourself the headache and do not order unless it is the only thing open. read more

Have only had good easy food ordering experiences with these guys. Food is always nice and hot when it's delivered and everyone I've talked to here has been nice. edit: Been a year of ordering from here and they're still always perfect. They never mess up my orders or bring them in late. I don't get the other reviews. edit 2017: Still a great location, nice delivery drivers, perfect orders that are always hot. read more

good, nothing wrong with that. I ordered delivery for chicken wings, and pizza and they dropped to me on time with average great food, great taste. But that was in year 2014 in March and October 2014, though. Lately, I ordered papa john, too. read more

Had to get a refund, it's crazy how incompetent some drivers are. My driver blocked an intersection, used his turn signal incorrectly, and after all that my order was not delivered. Despite him waiting outside for what I assume for me to go out there and pick it up myself? Then finally storms off, in a huff. I guess he's never seen an apartment complex before. I have yet to receive a refund. read more

Worst pizza delivery experience I've ever had! It never came! What are you gonna do if you order pizza for your party or for dinner and it doesn't come? After an hour and a half I called and they said it was already on its way. After three hours, I had to cook eggs and toast for my kids and send them to bed... really, really disappointing. I mean, the least they could've done is give me a courtesy call or something, but nope. Nothing. Never again, dominoes! read more

I absolutely love this Domino's Pizza. I was convinced to give it a try months ago, and have been pizza-happy since. Ordering online is easy, the coupons are decent deals sometimes, and the delivery has always been quick. Once, when the weather was bad, an employee actually called to let me know they would be running late--they called only a minute after the order had been placed! Kindness and courtesy are always appreciated! Picking up in-store has been just as easy and enjoyable. The store itself is always clean and comfortable, and the employees have been nothing but personable and nice, as well as timely and communicative. As for the food? Very good cheap, delivery pizza. Some of the best crust I've had. Their customizability is impressive, and I have always had the pizza hot when delivered. It's delicious and affordable for people on a budget who want to feed guests or even just stay in and get delivery for movie night! 5 Stahs! ***** read more

I ordered chicken at 10 that didn't come until 2. They either don't answer the phone or hang up after you finally wait 20 minutes to get them on the phone. And they will forget to deliver your food. Yet since they are the only place open late at night after dining halls close on campus read more

Ordered thru app. Usually goes fine. Not thistime. Got bread bites instead of the garlic parm wings i ordered. Called store and complained. They said they would deliver asap. It's been over an hour and no wings. Very disappointed. Seriously considering deleting app and never ordering from them again. read more

Its pretty good considering its fast food. I've always had my food delivered within 30 minutes. Their pizzas are best eaten hot but would not recommend otherwise. Pastas are terrible. Love the stuffed cheesy bread with spinach and feta- the one side I would definitely recommend. I usually just order this on the occasional Friday night as its much much better than their Pizza. read more

Sucksssssssss. The hot chicken wings are like pure salt had one and threw out the rest. Go elsewhere!

Domino's is the best. The crust is amazing, and the flavor of each pizza is more heightened and vivid than most other pizzas. The texture of the bread, the cheese and the taste of the sauce all come together to give you everything you want in a classic pizza. I always order takeout so I'm not sure what the inside of the restaurant feels or looks like. read more

Ordered. Waited forever. And when I called them they were surprised that I do not want the order anymore. I expected Pizza but got nothing.

Let's just say I eat a lot of dominos.... This place is great. It's clean, the workers are nice, service is prompt, orders are correct, and the pizza is always made to perfection. read more

Worst service I've ever experienced. Period. Placed an online order via the app at 5:07pm on a SUNDAY night. Called 90 minutes later when my pizza still hadn't arrived to the hotel I was staying at. When the employee I spoke with learned of my situation, she NEVER ONCE APOLOGIZED and said that both they and the driver tried calling to get my hotel room number, which was an absolute lie as I had no missed calls and I was sitting in the lobby waiting for him to arrive. The ignorance, willingness to lie, and attempt to pin the problem on ME is the polar opposite of customer service. I strongly recommend that this store instill a little effort into appropriate customer service training skills, as it is quite evident that none of its employees have any f***'s to give. Promised to refund my credit card. We'll see if that ever happens. read more

Ordered peppers on the pizza. Literally 2 pieces of pizza had peppers on them. Rip off!

By far the most disgusting "wings" I've ever had. Had mango flavor & hot wings right after a workout tonight and despite feeling extremely hungry I refuse to do my body the disrespect of ingesting this poor failure of an excuse they try to pass off as sustenance. The texture was reminiscent of weak rubber with more fatty disgusting gush than meat. I NEVER waste food but I can't call this food so I have no problem throwing it out tonight. Honestly I meant to call papa johns but messed up confusing the two locations.. I'll never make that mistake again. I say all this with no disrespect to the employees at dominos, I'm sure they're all great people and seemed very nice, but on God's name I'll never order food here again. I'd rather be hungry than attempt to drown them in enough blue cheese to force these gross lumps of crappy chicken down. Please learn from my mistake, go to literally anywhere else for wings, I'd burn $20 & kill a chicken to eat it raw before ever doing this again. read more

Ithaca kids save that shmoney! This is the most bullshit service I've had. Listen, when I'm drunk and want a pizza, I do not want to wait 2 hrs for a delivery! It said my pizza was being reviewed for 40 minutes on the dominos app. I had called to see if it was being delivered and they said they were 3 hours behind and hung up! Girl was rude on the line, hung up on me 3 times... read more

Do not order on NFL Sundays. It's obviously a busy day. I ordered a pizza online for pickup and it said about 25min. It's been well over an HR and there's only one worker in site with a line of customers not smiling at all. This place needs new management. I order pizza from them at least 3 times a month. I might have to start going to the Hut! read more

I ate here A LOT back in 2012-2013 and I had a great impression of this Domino's- food and customer service.

Great experience with delivery highly recommend you do it online though as the hold up for on the phone can be quit long on busy nights like Friday or Saturday read more