Tucked away behind (and attached to) The Steerage, this is a little sandwich place they run during…read morethe day. The staff was friendly and helpful - we were kinda lost when we walked into the back room of a restaurant we'd been to before, and they had a self-ordering station set up. The sandwiches themselves were great! Simple, but piled with high quality shaved meat on a tasty sesame sandwich bun (unexpected but it works). I think you're better off getting food to go, as the seating area is very small, but they've done a good job of making it welcoming. The tables aren't on top of each other, there's a TV so you don't feel trapped in a basement, and hey, you can always walk through the curtain and get a drink at the bar!

We popped in for lunch on a Sunday afternoon and we were blown away. At first it's a little…read moredifficult to find, but the entrance is in the back of The Steerage Dining Saloon (you can also enter in the front and walk through to the back). You walk through an alley and it feels kind of like a speakeasy sub spot. You walk into the "basement" and are pleasantly surprised that this is a cute little dining area, not your typical sub spot. You order at the screen in front and subs are brought to your table when they are ready. (Freaky fast! Better than jimmy johns!). We got the Irish baby (corned beef - served cold, which was a delightful surprise. It was not heavy or too fatty like corned beef can be sometimes, it was really just right) and the turkey baby. We liked them both with some giardinara and the oils form the giardinara added. They were a good size, didn't skimp on the meat (I couldn't even finish mine, but my husband literally licked his plate clean). Service was very friendly and helpful. We walked through the restaurant it is connected to and that also looks like a cool spot, we will definitely be back for both places!

Very good and a good theme…read more Very good and a good theme. I highly recommend this restaurant. Best grilled cheese that I have ever found - by far.

Took my bestie here for her birthday lunch in November. It was cute little cafe. Great decor,…read more looks like a ship. Food was very flavourful. Bestie got the turkey sandwich, I got the fish & chips. We both had drinks. They were also well made. Only downside - not handicapped accessible unless there's a hidden elevator. We didn't see one. Definitely still be back.

This place was great. Loved the steak, sides, French Onion soup, and the Key Lime pie might have…read morebeen the best I have ever had. Cool atmosphere and really inexpensive considering the quality of the food. Comfortable atmosphere too. Loved everything about it.

Awesome supper club, we enjoyed our visit. Food and service was great!…read moreWas recommend by our Airbnb host. She nailed it. It was our 11 wedding anniversary. Enjoyed

I really wish I liked their sandwiches…read more.. The service is friendly and quick, even during peak hours. The dining area is welcoming but nothing special. I have gotten sandwiches a few times from this spot, but each time I find the same thing: I don't like their bread. The ciabatta is crackly and hurts my mouth. The focaccia is just so much bread for a sandwich. Often I find my sandwich is just dry and not as flavorful as I'd expect for a spot that seems to be innovative and thoughtful about their rotating sandwiches. Every time, I read the description of the sandwich and think it'll be great, but every time I'm disappointed. It's dry and bland. I'd rather spend my money on food I enjoy, which is a bummer because I'd rather support local businesses, but I'd say save your money for Jimmy John's or Jersey Mikes.... But who knows, maybe I'm just not ordering the right thing.

Yummy sammies - be warned that they can easily feed two. Cute as a button inside and friendly…read moreknowledgeable staff. Nice outdoor seating, too.

I've been a regular of Out & Out for years, even since a friend brought it to my attention. Not…read morebeing a Cedarburg resident it's an extra 20 minutes out of the way if I'm stopping after work or a 40 minute round trip if I'm just heading from home, but I'm happy to make the trip. Their menu consists largely of Mac & Cheese, wraps, paninis and frozen custard. Being a Wisconsinite it really resonates with me. I get the classic "original" mac and cheese every time. It's always consistently good and it's still warm after my 20 minute drive home. They use a less common noodle that is quite large and the portion is generous too. The other menu item I'm always to is the shake of the week. They always have a different one and they're always good. Oh, and I have to mention their salads. Not for me, but my mother likes them as much a salad she gets anywhere else. Another thing I appreciate is the fact they have an app. An app for a local place isn't common in my experience. This makes it easy to order in advance so you can skip the line, skip the phone call and better still earn rewards. Finally, I have to commend a few of the guys who work here. Two gentlemen in particular who both are always pleasant and personable, which alone is commendable, but they've also both been there a few years. They both seem to be managers, but I'm not sure, though I wanted to recognize them. Both are older than the general staff and both are there various weekdays.

Been here a few times now. Mac and cheese is incredible. Ice cream is also really good…read more We got sandwiches/wraps once and they weren't as good as the mac and cheese. Overall though, we'd highly recommend!!

I especially love the chicken salad sandwich and homemade brownies. They've had consistently…read morequality food at this family run business for decades.

A bit hard to find, hidden off the main street, but it's a great little place to get a sandwich…read more Gets pretty busy a lunchtime so be prepared to wait a little to place your order. Sandwiches are made fresh while you wait. Food is really good and the staff is always amazing. They are really friendly and they work their butts off! Menu is primarily subs/sandwiches, soups, chips, some cookies/brownies and maybe 3-4 salads to pick from. Everything I've had been good.

Great little place. We've been coming to PW for many years and I don't know how we've overlooked…read morethis place. Came for brunch. The omelets are amazing. They are huge. They have plenty of ingredients and cheese. The potato side was also amazing. Crispy little cubes of delight. The staff was very friendly. The inside of the cafe is cute. Bonus... a beautiful outdoor patio next to the marina We will definitely be returning again. I am excited to try other menu items.

We've been to Port Washington countless times and never managed to stop here. Today I had one of…read morethe best omelets ever, and will now be a regular customer when in town.

Grabbed takeout for lunch and got the AYO Syd!! sandwich. The cola braised short rib was so…read moreflavorful and tender. As if the sandwich wasn't already enough to feed two people, it comes with Garlic Parm French Fries, which had the perfect level of seasoning to really elevate them. Had I known the portions sized ahead of time, I would've split it with my wife instead of getting one for each of us. Otherwise, I'd love to see a half size option for lunch time.

Over priced for what you get. Ordered the gavone, very thin…read morelayer of dry roast beef. Could barely tell there was any garlic mayo on it- which is one of the reasons I ordered it. Also ordered the clunky luciano. The vodka sauce has no flavor. We ate half of our meals, took the rest home and ended up throwing them out because we had no desire to eat it. And I hate wasting food. Not going back.