Donatos Pizza

Today was my first time visiting Rutherford Café. I met a friend at this café. The interior…read moreincludes a few tables and the counter. There were many options on the menu. I opted to get the Breakfast Sandwich on an Everything Bagel. It was a delicious sandwich. The Everything Bagel was perfectly toasted. The cheese and egg were also delicious, as was the bacon. Price for sandwich was reasonable. This is a great spot for breakfast or lunch. Definitely is worth a visit if you are in the area.

I was excited to try the Rutherford Cafe in Delaware but my sandwich was nothing special compared…read moreto what you could get at other breakfast spots. I came to try a breakfast sandwich and got the Gouda Morning. I really enjoyed the sourdough bread, but felt like I could make the sandwich just the same at home. It was obvious that the ingredients are fresh and the sandwiches are also made fresh, which is what made it taste homemade and simple. I wish they added some sort of creamy sauce to add extra flavor since it tasted too plain for me. The interior is cute and cozy with about 6 tables for people to sit. I think it'd be a great place to sit and study or chat with your friends/family.

Gouda Morning

See all

The Greater Gouda

4.6(21 reviews)

They have an amazing selection of meats and cheese! The staff is very knowledgeable and friendly…read more The shop is small and puts me in the mind of a quaint country market. They have a wonderful selection of cheese knives, boards and fondue pots. When I asked them to help me with a meat and cheese board for my Halloween Wedding they went above and beyond!!! I plan to continue to use them for all of my catering!

I love this place. They have quite a few specialty deli items like cheese and meats. If you're…read moremaking a charcuterie board, you need to go here. The owner is super nice and willing to let you sample the product before you buy. Very nice inside. If you're looking for specialty items, this is the place.

Halloween Wedding Cheese board from Greater Gouda.

Cheese knife

See all

The front entrance of The Greater Gouda cheese shop

Fresh Start Cafe and Bakery

4.5(72 reviews)

Bang for your buck: 9/10 Quality: 10/10…read moreService: 10/10 Ambiance/Location: 10/10 Overall: 10/10

Strolling down downtown Delaware, we were hankering for breakfast and happened across the 'Fresh…read morestart cafe'. I opted for the egg sandwich with sausage - I decided to skip the cheese and requested scrambled eggs but received sunny side up instead. No big deal. The sandwich was nice but not something I would be impatiently waiting to order again. I took a bite of K's Biscuit sandwich with bacon and jalapeno poppers. That was was the standout dish! Now I was really having buyer's remorse. The coffees were pretty good too. I came in for a cafe latte but left with a pistachio cream iced coffee instead -- a sugar bomb but pretty delicious; just don't make it a daily habit!

Club sandwich with biscuit

Entrance

See all

Jersey Mike's Subs

2.8(9 reviews)

1.9 mi

Jersey Mike's - Big Kahuna Edition…read more Listen, I rolled into Jersey Mike's like a hungry hurricane and walked out with a Big Kahuna Cheesesteak so glorious, Zeus himself would've dropped his lightning bolt for a bite. I ordered it extra meat, because regular meat just wasn't emotionally supportive enough that day. And what did they give me? A cheesesteak so loaded, I had to check if I needed a forklift or just really strong napkins. The cheese was melty, the peppers and onions were vibin', and that meat? Tender, plentiful, and seasoned like it had a PhD in Flavor Science. The shop? Spotless -- like a Subway if it actually cared about its life choices. The service? Quick, friendly, and didn't judge me when I looked them dead in the eye and said "extra meat" like it was a spiritual request. I saw the reviews before I came in, and let me just say -- those folks were underselling it. I had to drop some love here, because this Jersey Mike's crew? They understood the assignment. Will I be back? Only if I get hungry again, which--judging by my track record--will be in approximately 3 hours.

Jersey Mikes does it right every time with fresh ingredients. I have never had a bad sub here and…read moreI've been eating here for years. My favorites are the Big Kahuna Chicken Philly, the Tuna Fish, and the Buffalo Chicken. Best of all it is across the street from where I live.

See all

NYC Deli Mart

4.5(8 reviews)

0.2 mi

This is a solid NYC-style deli in the heart of downtown Delaware. The owner is very friendly and a…read moregood conversationalist while he prepares your sandwiches. I tried the pastrami, the chopped cheese, and the philly cheesesteak. The sandwiches are huge (my pictures don't do them justice), and the fillings are generous. The prices are very reasonable for the size of each of these monsters! The location is spacious, and would make a great lunch spot, or a quick dinner stopover.

I most recently tried the Philly Cheesesteak and the chicken bacon ranch club. The chicken bacon…read morewas amazing as usual. The Philly was a let down. It needed more of everything, more meat, more cheese, more onions, more green peppers. The bread to filling ratio was off and I kept getting bites of mostly bread. I also tried their tiramisu cake, wouldn't recommend that either, it was just bland.

Menu with location details

See all

Chelley Belly Soup Sandwich & Sweets

3.7(63 reviews)

0.4 mi

This was is soooo good! Cute little spot downtown Delaware, casual, friendly staff. Great food! Big…read moreportions. I shall return! :)

I love this shop. The food is amazing, the space is very cute, and the staff pleasant. I've been…read moretwice and had the salmon daily special twice. The salmon panini was so good, with fresh dill. It came with chips and a drink (iced tea for me). The salmon salad I had on my second visit was a large portion and so delicious, served with again, fresh dill, and a chunk of ciabetta bread, with poppyseed dressing. The piece of salmon was warm. I chose their Cinnamon Dolce iced latte to drink. Tasty, and made with coconut milk. Highly recommend!

See all

Two Rivers Restaurant

4.5(101 reviews)

9.4 mi

First time here when I came for the Restaurant Week menu. It is in a strip mall at the corner of…read morePowell and Sawmill and is a fairly large space with a patio. I was early enough for happy hour and had a wonderful Cucumber Gimlet. The service was excellent. I ordered the House Chopped Salad, Lake Erie Walleye, and Lemon Blueberry Panna Cotta. The salad tasted really good and fresh. The Walleye too. I liked the fennel salad with cilantro lime rice. I ate half to take some home and not be too full for dessert. The panna cotta was good, mostly because of the topping. It is not something I would order again, being kind of bland, but to no fault of the kitchen. I'm not a custard-y kind of gal, but wanted to try it. I would definitely come back here for another meal.

I've been meaning to go to this restaurant for a while. We went on a Saturday evening and there…read morewere plenty of tables available. The ambiance is low key but nice. Everyone from the hostess to our server was very friendly and nice. They have a full bar and a decent selection of beers. My wife and I decided to share their whipped ricotta appetizer and their French onion burger. The appetizer came with thinly cut crusted baguette. The ricotta cheese was mixed with some strawberry flavor. It wasn't bad but I would have preferred it to be thicker in constituency. The burger and fries came out perfectly cut into half portions for each of us, which was a really nice touch. We had asked for the burger to be cooked medium rare and I think it came out more like a medium well. The patty itself was a bit dry. This may be a one off issue and we hope to return to try some other dishes.

Pork Torta and housemade chips

See all

All-American Cheeseburger and fries

Potbelly Sandwich Shop

3.9(75 reviews)

11.5 mi•Polaris

I wish I could them a 3.5 because it was honestly pretty good for fast casual. My expectations were…read morenot high but I needed a quick meal. I ordered the sandwich/salad combo. I got the chicken club and powerhouse salad for $12, which was enough for 2 small meals. The club was good, with chicken breast, bacon and I pot hot peppers, tomato and lettuce with the spicy bbq sauce, not too much bread - just the right amount. The salad was solid too, tons of toppings. The service was fine for fast casual. The ambiance is as expected for fast casual. I was pleasantly surprised and would go again!

Met up with a friend passing through town, and we decided to hit Potbelly--because nothing says…read more"catching up like adults" quite like soup, sandwiches, and chips that burn slightly on the way down. It's been a minute since I've been here, and honestly, I forgot how good it is. I went all in with the Chicken Pot Pie Soup, Mama's Meatball sandwich with peppers, and a bag of Zapp's Hot Pepper chips--because moderation is for people who don't love flavor. The Chicken Pot Pie Soup? Well, let's just say it leaned more "cream of chicken" than "pot pie." The crusty topping... I'm not sure what sorcery that was, but it had the texture of something between a crouton and a pulverized Ritz cracker that lost its way. Not bad, just... confusing. cracker The Mama's Meatball, though, stole the show. Delicious, saucy, and stacked like it's proud of itself. The peppers gave it just the right kick. And Zapp's chips? Always a chaotic good choice. Overall, great lunch, great company, and a reminder that Potbelly still knows how to make comfort food without overcomplicating it. Would I come back? Absolutely. Just maybe I'll skip the soup--or bring a pie crust of my own next time.

See all

My Little Kitchen

4.9(18 reviews)

This is a great good truck. I was at Zaftig with my two daughters and we had the hot dog, shrimp…read moretacos and beignets. The staff was friendly and very accommodating to my kids. They offered to make the fries with only salt without me asking which was a big help. The seasoned fries are excellent but they are a bit much for my little ones The shrimp tacos were excellent. They were loaded in shrimp and the right amount of sauce. The hot dog was really good. I'm always situated when the dog and bun alone can stand apart. Theirs does and it's a credit to the quality of the dog and the preparation of the bun. The best perfect finish of the meal was the beignets. They were cooked perfectly and were light and airy and topped with powdered sugar. Some may think the powdered sugar was excessive but I thought it was spot on and a huge hit with my kiddos. I'll be back again be t time they are zaftig and if I happen upon them when I'm out and about I'm Definitely ordering beignets on the spot!

My Little Kitchen is a food truck lurking around Delaware. It has a small simple menu. There's…read moretypical stuff like chili dogs and pretzels. It's price isn't that bad. There's a few more healthy options. I found this at Staas. It's usually at a brewery. The places typically don't have their own menu. It's where this food truck comes in. You need something to eat with that beer or liquor. I had the pretzel bites. These are about $5 for a basket full. It's usually somewhere in Delaware. It can also be in Powell. There's good opportunities to catch it at Staas.

See all

Restoration Brew Worx

4.2(181 reviews)

Food and service are always great. Sports bar type environment. If you're wanting to visit with…read morefriends or family, it gets a little noisy on Trivia nights (maybe Tuesdays?). Be sure to check out the pretzel bread.

Late night dinner for me and my husband (9pm) this place is one of the few places open after 9 in…read moreDelaware that's serves food. Pretzel bread made with Ale cheese- heavy on the ale. The bread itself also had an alcohol taste to it- maybe it's the batch as the last time I had it I couldn't taste it but this time I may not pass a breathilizer from it alone I had the RBW Burger and the aioli was tasty. The pickles were unlike any I've had before- like the thing between a pickle and a cucumber. The wait staff were nice! The volume was pretty standard for a bar. Only gave it a four because the food can be inconsistent between visits. (Last time the fries were way too salty and this time they were perfect- also the bread)

Fried pickles, 12 wings (Buffalo, creamy Parmesan)

See all

Comedy

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

20 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Becky E.

0

1

0

6 years ago

Sean this is becky and stan eubank hope everyone is fine at your home. We are ok been picking up some pizzas since the virus but also so glad we can eat in. Just wanted to let you know we were in tonight and you have a wonderful young lady working for you her name is maddie(sp) dont know her last name but she is soooo nice on the phone and in person we were in last week also and she was there she is a good employee and of course it was good to see Luke (he is nice as ever) also the other manager i think hes been there before and came back but hes nice. Got to see tyler last week he was telling us about his little boy. You really are lucky to have some good employees.I know from time to time you have to let some go but you are so nice to work for i hope these stay.Til we see you again keep the family safe and as soon as virus is over BACK TO THE BUFFET!!! read more

Ashley R.

1

6

0

9 years ago

I have been a regular customer at this Donatos location for 2 years now. I love this place. The restaurant is always clean and you cant beat the edge to edge toppings you dont get at other locations. Their thicker crust option is my absolute favorite and i love their cinnamon bread-sometimes its all i order! I also love that every time i come in all of the staff, wither it be a manager, a pizza maker, or a cashier, are very friendly and working hard but are also in a great mood and having a great time. If ever anything is messed up they are concerned about the customers happiness and making it right. Great job guys. read more

Thomas R.

0

3

4

8 years ago

getting very skimpy on the toppings. pay $17 for a large pizza with 4 toppings and barely any pepperonis (maybe 1 per slice if any at all), a mushroom or two scattered about each slice and a few onions. Terrible cut, some slices were cut twice but not all the way through. Was the worst Donatos I've ever had. Donatos is my favorite thin crust pizza but this was terrible. Delaware Donatos needs an overhaul or closed down. Obviously bad management which makes this the worst Donatos I've ever ordered from. Considering the general manager is part owner no wonder the cut food cost like they do. read more

Makayla C.

0

1

0

9 years ago

You know, I'm not much of a pizza person but every time I stop in the employees there make it worth it. No matter how busy they are, they always have a smile on their face and ask you how your day has been. Its a small gesture but I feel it's something that a lot of other place have lost sight in. That the little things in life matter. Even though it's become one of the larger pizza chains, it's nice that it still feels local and close to home. read more

Teyler B.

0

1

0

10 years ago

Stopped in for the first time the other day and the counter girl with pink hair did a wonderful job informing me about the menu and helping me pick out my meal, a little more expensive than other places but worth it. Everything was really good and got done quickly although they were busy. I will be back for another visit soon! read more

Lesa S.

0

3

1

2 years ago

Fantastic pizza; owner is a cheater, that's been banging the KFC Manager... until he invited her to manage his Delaware location. While she works with his children. Such a lovely family. A Huge Christian family as well. Yay Religion!! Cheers to truths and freedom read more

Timothy M.

16

1

0

9 years ago

The Donatos close by me isn't that great any more but stopped in to get a bite to eat while in Delaware. I wish our Whitehall store was like this one I would probably order more food from them thank you read more

Angelica S.

0

1

0

10 years ago

My boyfriend brought me here for a date, Lillian a worker there suggested the place to us. Everything about the experience was great. We are planning another date here next month, 5 stars. read more

Courtney A.

0

1

0

9 years ago

Food has always been great. They have always been super helpful and friendly. Huge shout out to the cashier Ashley. She has help me many times before and I have never left unhappy. read more

Dion M.

0

1

0

10 years ago

I recently ate here and was highly impressed with the food and with the staff. I can not recall her name, but the pink haired counter girl was very nice and very friendly! read more

Ashley S.

0

1

0

10 years ago

Love donatos!! Great Pizza, great service! The counter girl, Lillian is always so helpful and so nice, never had a bad experience with her! HIGHLY RECOMMENDED!! read more

Cierra F.

0

1

0

10 years ago

My friend Lillian works here and brought me in to try it, I thought the food was so delicious. I had wings and pizza they were both very good, I will be back. read more

Larry L.

2

589

6

10 months ago

I be love going to donatos pizza theirs always fresh tastes great food atmosphere is good ambiance is casual services are great their great for a community read more

Noelle Y.

1

6

0

9 years ago

The food is very good and if anything is wrong or messed up they take responsibility and take good care of you! All of the staff here are so friendly. read more

Jason C.

0

2

0

17 years ago

This is by far my favorite pizza in the Delaware area. Although the price is a little high it's still worth the extra few dollars.

Cory U.

0

1

0

9 years ago

Vary friendly servers they always make you feel welcome and if you ask me best pizza in town my number one choice every time

Joanne P.

40

1

0

10 years ago

Thank you Lilli for your great service! Delaware Donatos is tops in food and service !

Linda G.

56

5

0

16 years ago

I agree with the others. This place has the best pizza and the employees are great!

Larry C.

0

2

0

9 years ago

Really nice people and the food is always fresh! Couldn't ask for better.

Cory S.

0

1

0

9 years ago

The food is always hot and the service of the employees is always awesome

Donatos Pizza - pizza - Updated August 2026

People who viewed Donatos Pizza also viewed

Little Caesar's Pizza

3.2

(21 reviews)

Very rude. Young boy with curly hair glasses. We ordered $20 worth of wings and no sauce whatsoever…read moregiven. I kindly asked him if they come with ranch like they usually do at every place that you go to .we have never bought wings anywhere that don't come with sauce. He was very rude about it nope $1.69 each. So we payed $25 for the small tiny wings with 3 ranch sauce.

I don't understand how you print a ticket that has the correct order on it, put it on the box and…read morestill mess up the order. I'm missing both of my sauces. Then the crazy puffs look like they forgot about them at some point and they are dry like no sauce at all just cheese bread and pepperoni. I'm so irritated with this order.

Taranto's Pizzeria

4.0

(196 reviews)

I've been a fan of Taranto's for several years. I first discovered them around 2015 when I was…read moreworking in Lewis Center. I ended up ordering from them at least a couple times a month. At least once a month we would place a group order at my office and everybody loved it. I know that the ownership changed a couple years ago, but it's still the same great pizza and service! I've never eaten at the restaurant but I have gone in there a few times for pick up orders and it's always clean and neat and customers always seem to be happy. The service that I've received over the years whether it's over the phone or in person has always been great!

What a great cozy spot for pizza! Recommended when we staying at a nearby hotel. Pizza was very…read moretasty. Staff friendly and helpful. And the friendly manager / owner stopped by to check on us and our experience after our meal. That was a nice touch. Plan to return next time we're in the area!

Gionino's Pizzeria of Westerville

4.1

(55 reviews)

Trying these dishes for the first time. Meatball Casserole had tons of sauce and cheese. Gioninos…read morebread was perfect pairing. They have so many options that you could eat there every day for a month and not get the same thing. Highly recommend. Staff is fast and friendly.

The service was good, I was greeted at the door when I came in…read more The pizza was actually good. We got the very veggie and it was loaded with veggies. When we went to heat it up the next day it, the crust stuck to the cardboard. I made sure that it was completely cooled before putting it in the fridge, as instructed on the box. So I'm not really sure why it stuck

Eagles Pizza

4.0

(215 reviews)

I cannot speak for the ambiance except for the quick glance into the dining room when I did a pick…read moreup. It seems nice. I got the gluten free taco pizza with extra sour cream and such. It was wonderful! The perfect combination of taco toppings and a nice crust. If you are on the fence of having tacos or pizza for your meal, this is the way to go! The service was ok. I wouldn't call it warm but still ok.

Came in late, staff was nice and probably frustrated we came in at 9. Understand but still did…read moregreat. Atmosphere is unique and has deep meaning. Love that and thank you to the family for the service. The pizza........wow. Just amazing. We have heard for years about their pizza and it's all that and more. Crust is unreal. Huge toppings and very affordable!!! Awesome place!!

Cardinal Pizza

3.9

(156 reviews)

Placed an order for one pizza & said order would be ready in 25 minutes, got there 25 minutes later…read more& was told my order would be ready in 25-30 minutes Very disappointing customer service.

Order was 30 minutes later than promised pick up time. (Got our text saying order was ready)…read moreSat outside and watched our car get bumped by uber driver and an old guy. No real damage, but everyone just drove away! Girls running pick up were confused, overwhelmed, busy answering phones, ignoring guests in front of them, and unwilling to figure out our order. Ok, but. Bottom line roasty had cheese, asked for no cheese. Too bad Guess we'll avoid weekends.

Cottage Inn Pizza

4.1

(95 reviews)

Denny made great suggestions on pizza and it was hot and fast. Also found a coupon to save us some…read moremoney. I would come back again!

Was craving New York Style, foldable crust, pepperoni pizza. Got delivery. Comes in X-Large 16"…read moreonly. Wonderful! Satisfied my craving for quintessential East Coast, pizza. Recommend!

Marco's Pizza

3.0

(20 reviews)

Stopped in and ordered a couple pizzas. The inside was very nice and clean. Bigger than I expected…read morefrom the outside usually quick pizza places are grab and go. Just for next time we might stay and eat. Employees were very friendly and manager helped us with a coupon we asked about. Put our order in and like 15 minutes it was ready to go. We live like 10 miles away and it was still piping hot when we got home. Haven't had Marcos in a while and it really hit the spot. The pizza did not lack for toppings at all. Compared to other quick pizza places this one is top notch! We will be back!! Next time I'll get pictures before we eat all the pizza..Lol.. Thanks for the great service!! See you soon!!

This was for a pickup order, ordered online…read more I've never had Marco's. My son had it when he was at Skate Naked's Skate Camp and dug it - so we ordered some tonight (because his favorite is Papa John's, and I told him that if he wanted pizza tonight, I'd get it from anywhere that wasn't them). First and foremost, it was fast. This is the "closest" location to my house, and I ordered, left, and it was ready when I arrive in ~15 minutes. Now, for the pizza: It's a little "crust heavy." Solid flavor, crispy, crunchy. Crispy pepperoni. Good sauce. I'm liking it. Nice coverage of pepperoni (not "edge to edge" donatos style, but a nice, healthy, crispy amount). I liked it, my son enjoyed it. For the Chicken Caesar Salad: ...I really liked the salad. Shaved parmesan, chunks of chicken? They say "two servings" but you could skip the second dressing they give and consume it solo, and it's maybe a favorite of the chicken caesar salads I've had recently. The brownie: this was a standard "pan brownie" that isn't exactly a "make or break" dessert, just something fast and easy, clearly. I wouldn't say it's the draw (nor, should it be, IMO). I like them. I'm going to keep pushing my son to choose them over Papa John's

Dewey's Pizza - Dublin

4.2

(160 reviews)

I absolutely LOVE Dewey's pizza and salads. I've been coming here since my Dayton days, years ago…read morewhen I first fell in love with Dewey's. This was my first time at the Dublin location and it has an odd layout but the food is characteristically excellent. I love the Porky fig pizza - prosciutto, caramelized onion and fig jam. Yum! I tried half a seasonal special, the Elote corn pizza, and it was great too. You really can't go wrong here. I always start with the candied walnut & grape salad. It's perfection! No notes. Service is fast and friendly. Dewey's rocks!

We had a great meal at Dewey's! My friend called ahead on Friday morning to ask about a reservation…read morefor 10 people for that night and they were able to work us in at 8:30 pm, which was perfect for our timeline. We picked up a few more friends so had to ask if an extra table was possible when we arrived and they made it work - thank you! The big draw was the Tito/taco pizza which I tried for the first time and loved. I think we had 6 or 7 pizzas at our table, and everyone seemed satisfied. I appreciate that they can do 1/2 and 1/2 on any of their pizzas too. I also split the Peppercorn Ranch entree salad with 2 others and it tasted great as well.

Good Fellaz Pizzeria

4.2

(63 reviews)