Was craving New York Style, foldable crust, pepperoni pizza. Got delivery. Comes in X-Large 16" only. Wonderful! Satisfied my craving for quintessential East Coast, pizza. Recommend! read more

My coworker suggested this place for lunch. Normally when I go with pizza for the office I go somewhere a little cheaper, but I checked out the menu and they had a lot of choices, especially for vegetarians! We ordered a vegan supreme pizza (but with normal cheese), a half pepperoni half cheese and a pepperoni,mushroom and olive pizza along with the cheesy garlic bread. Everything tasted great and was a hit with the team. I placed a mobile order and it was ready right on time! read more

Helped my son's family move to Columbus. Busy day unpacking, and i had no idea where there is good pizza since I've never been to Columbus. Thanks to Yelp, we found an amazing pizza place. We ordered delivery so I can't speak about the actual restaurant but I can talk about the pizza. Amazing!!!! Ordered a wide variety since we were feeding the movers as well and all was amazing. Notable pies are: Motor City Meatball, Chicken Mediterranean, and the Ranch Taco. So much better than a National chain. Delivery was super fast and the pizzas were delivered piping hot. Great Pizza! read more

See all

Everyone needs their own nearby go-to pizza joint. I've been on the look out for mine for too long considering there's a several competitors in my area. I realized I've been sleeping on Cottage Inn pizza! Seriously, wake up folks! Let me straight out say that Cottage Inn has the best deals on their website out of all the pizza spots in my area, which I absolutely utilized. I seriously sat down on my computer, pulled up different menus on different tabs, and compared them & did the math to figure this out. Best part is that you don't have to use 1 deal per transaction. I paid $15.99 for 1 large Pepp Pizza with bread-sticks and garlic cream cheese, which was awesome! I also used their $21.99 for 2 Large 2 Topping pizza deal. I customized both pizzas to my liking, so it ended up being $32.99 (about $16.50 per pizza) for both of them but I seriously made these the best pizzas I've had ever! Like reference my pictures and tell me those aren't scrumptious looking! The first one I built with Bacon and Grilled Chicken with a Pesto Drizzle and Garlic Parmesan crust. The second one I made was Hawaiian themed with Bacon, Ham, Black Olives, Pineapple, Red Onions with Everything crust and Tangy Gold drizzle (I had to pay a little bit extra for the additional toppings since deal was supposed to be for only 2 toppings). Both pizzas tasted like a specialty pizza (typically $18.99), except they cost me way less due to the amazing deals! I'm not even at the best part yet; THEY HAVE APPLE-PIE PIZZA. For $7.99, you literally get an apple pizza! The only other place that I know that made dessert pizzas is East of Chicago Pizza in Marysville, so I was really happy to find that Cottage Inn made these too! It's the perfect dessert! read more

See all

came, and they gave us FREE BREADSTICKS cuz we follow them, good experienc, so mango, 67!!

The gluten free crust just keeps getting smaller and smaller. We have chosen CI for years because they carry gluten free. It used to be substantial but now it's basically a personal size cracker with toppings that cost $16. read more

Delicious, tasty pizza. This review is before, during and after Quarantine/COVID-19. If you are looking for great pizza, look no further. We have been on a pizza hunt for a while and tried many local pizza shops and wasn't having much luck finding a great pizza. Our first experience wasn't any good, but they made it right, and now we go here all the time for pizza & breadsticks. Taste: Crust - The regular crust is good, and the thin is even better. It's cracker thin and they cut it into squares, awesome! Sauce - it's quality, well-seasoned, and delicious. Toppings - the toppings are fresh and tasty. They also have seasonings for the crust, be sure to check them out. Our favorite is the Garlic butter Parmesan. Innstix aka bread sticks - nice round sticks, airy, cooked just right, buttery. Innwings- aka chicken wings - they are not that great and would not order them again. We got boneless and they were dry and had too much breading. Salad - they have nice salads with fresh toppings. Very nice! Subs - chicken club - it wasn't that great, I'll pass in the future. Pizza - bbq chicken on regular crust is super delicious. Pepperoni thin crust is awesome. Ham & Pineapple is really good. The all meat pizza thin crust is really good. There are lots more pizzas that we can't wait to try. Online ordering - the website is super easy to use. I just wish they had an app. If you don't want to enter your credit card (website doesn't save so you'll need to enter each time) just click pay later. When you get to the store you can pay with cash or card. The staff is friendly and helpful. I appreciate that they give plates, napkins and Parmesan packs. I would definitely recommend getting a pizza here, it's really good! ** There is a small dining room in the front with a few tables. There are no Highchairs. It's always so hot in there I would rather take the pizza home and eat it. read more

See all

Tried the food truck today pizza was good ... crust a little chewy but all in all good pizza . read more

Cottage Inn Pizza - Food truck - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Local take out pizza joint. Great way to support Small Business Saturday. Make sure to check in on the Yelp app to find a coupon to redeem on your first order. No one was eating in the small dining area. However, they were constantly busy with take out/ delivery orders. We ordered two large thin crust pepperoni pizzas for our OSU vs UM game family party. Great flavor. Free flavored crust options. We tried garlic parmesan. Loved by all. read more

Our first order was the bbq chicken pizza deep dish - very filling and great taste! We also got a chicken bacon ranch sub. I probably wouldn't order the sub again. We recently also got an XL pepperoni pizza with garlic Parmesan crust. Good, solid pizza. Pepperoni is not too spicy. This is better than most chain pizza places. And a pretty good deal at $14 for a pretty big pie! read more

See all

I first had Cottage Inn Pizza at a work function several years ago and continued having the pizza with my family. Ironically this was one of the last indoor dining experiences that we had and we remember it fondly based on how nice the lady was talking to us and making our food, doing extra little things for my youngest child. This is absolutely a solid 4 star pizza place, the pizza is good and prices are reasonable. We tried a double meat Italian sub last weekend and it was one of the best subs that I have had. So if I said it was a 4 star pizza place, why did I give them 5 stars? That comes from their stellar sanitary practices in the Covid world we currently struggle to live through. As we waited for our pizza you could tell that they were taking every precaution possible. While making pizza. gloves were on. Went to take money from a customer, gloves were changed. Went back to make food and another glove change. Too many places do not seem to take this pandemic seriously and we respond by not going back. Cottage Inn is the opposite and we will acknowledge their safety and sanitary practices by spending more of our dining dollars here. Keep up the good work. read more

Cottage Inn is a dime a dozen in Michigan. Having been to Polaris tons of times and even gotten dessert at the Greek next door I never noticed this location. Shame on me, it seems like this and Hilliard are the only in the area and the set up is similar to Hungry Howie's. Only WAY better. For the new everything crust I give 5+ stars for being the best pizza crust ever! I am obsessed with everything bagels, crackers, the more the marrier. It gives so much extra love and flavor to the pizza, it is definetly a fabulous delivery pizza that beats Donatos, Dominos, Pizza Hut, Masseys and so on. Still Papa Johns remains our familys favorite and therefor not quite but close to 5 stars. Its no gourmet but its fast and filling. They have deep dish, hand tossed and thin crust. I got the pricebuster (supreme) deep dish with everything crust and loved it! Loaded with toppings, not auper deep dish, I'd say thick crust and though I usually prefer my pizza round not square, THIS is the way to go. Along with that I had the large salad with italian dressing, also fine at $4.99 The guys got the handtossed, buttered garlic parmesan all meat pizza and it was fine, just not quite as good. In all good take out, its a shame you can't dine in, so we enjoyed it in the park next door. read more

Cottage Inn Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Wow! Decided to try something new outside of our usual Taranto's, and we officially have a new favorite! Incredible pizza, with so much flavor! The seasoning on the garlic Parmesan butter crust and the fresh veggie ingredients really made an awesome pizza. We couldn't stop raving with each bite. Sorry tarantos, there's a new guy in town! read more

Cottage Inn Pizza - Veggie thin crust pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Good, quality food and fast friendly delivery service. The best part is the variety. read more

See all

Great pizza! Friendly staff. Never miss a beat. I get carry out every couple of weeks. Sign up for their emails- they have great deals on days you make an excuse not to have to cook dinner. Carry out beer is an added bonus too. read more

You knocked it out of the park tonight!!! We haven't ordered from you in a while. And now we plan on ordering from you ALL the time. My husband is a huge pizza snob. Picky picky. We got his favorite Thin Crust Pepperoni Pizza- Pie Cut. IT WAS SO GOOD! But we honestly were blown away with the Calzone. It was HUGE!! And so perfectly baked! Our son was really disappointed that I didn't get a jumbo order of wings! I'm not usually a fan of wings. Wow, they were delish! So grateful that you are here to feed us in this "Stay at Home time". Your food and your customer service are both FANTASTIC!!! read more

We eat Cottage Inn on a regular basis. Honestly, one of the most consistent pizza places in the area. Great selection and food! Not to mention incredibly fast! We generally do pickup and the employees are fantastic! I've had to wait before and they threw in a 2 liter. The lady in the kitchen, I think her name is Lauren is always super friendly and knows us when we pickup. Highly recommend! read more

See all

I have always liked cottage inn pizza. It's delicious! I wish I lived closer, I'm tempted to order and drive from Sunbury to get it:) some people complain that it's pricey. Obviously people are paying it or they wouldn't stay in business. Often you get what you pay for and the quality is better. read more

Living in the Polaris area, cottage inn is my go-to for night when I'm too lazy to make dinner and I'm not in the mood for Chinese. I mostly order here for the rewards system and their coupons, but the deep dish pizza here is pretty good. I've also tried the bacon cheeseburger pizza, it's good but it's a bit too much and I can barely finish one piece. I actually enjoy the everything innsticks with the garlic cream cheese and the garlic cheese bread a lot more than I like the pizza. Also, get the apple pizza thing, it's pretty darn good. I usually do pick up, but delivery has been fast for a weekend when I have opted for it. When I go in for pick up everyone is pleasant. I've never had an experience here that made me feel the need to order from a different chain. read more

Was okay; oven roasted wings are just big McNuggets. The Parmesan garlic sauce was tasty but borderline gooey. Pizza was good; got "The Favorite". Won't be going back. read more

We are out-of-towners; & looking for a carry-in pizza at our Motel in Polaris. Couldn't have asked for a tastier pie!!! Also counter staff really nice & accommodating with plates/forks/napkins. I'll make a special point to return when in Columbus again read more

Solid pizza and love the "since 1948" local heritage. The online ordering system could be improved and the coupon system didn't work well as we were charged full price. Also wish one of these pizza companies would delivery out to Lewis Center... its a gold mind when some of these joints decide to start moving north for delivery services! The pizza has great sauce and is not greasy, seems like some of the healthiest pizza around. They added napkins and plates with parmesean which was a nice touch. Thank you! read more

Very good pizza but expensive! Ordered the gluten-free crust and a regular crust. Both were great! Definitely better than Papa Johns next door. Was a little pricey those for two medium pizzas. Would order again but only with a coupon or if they had a promotion. read more

I would give a negative on this company. Pizza was not fully cooked, extra sauce that was paid for was not in the order. Ravioli was cold. Worst ever. I will not be b k read more

Cottage Inn Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

My family and I just moved into the Lewis Center area from Cleveland and with it being a Saturday family game night, I was not cooking. So I used Yelp to find local owned pizza places nearby and I stumbled across Cottage Inn Pizza. I ordered the Family Duo (one gourmet pizza and a pizza with one topping) along with an order of wings. Our pick up time was 6:45, my boyfriend said it was ready as soon as he walked in, the establishment was clean and it was very easy to pick up as we paid online. The pizza was really good. Our gourmet pizza was a deluxe (no mushrooms) and the one topping pizza was with bacon. The vegetables were very fresh on our pizza. The crust was nice and fluffy. The wings were very good. Nicely cooked and still juicy on the inside. I thought it was interesting the sauce we picked came on the side and not tossed in the sauce. Nevertheless, the wings were really good. My daughter was skeptical at first because she wanted pizza from "home/Cleveland". She loved it and said I picked out a very good place. I'm glad we found something local we can support! I'm looking forward to trying something new next time. read more

Cottage Inn Pizza - Deluxe Pizza minus the mushrooms. - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

This is my first time having Cottage Inn Pizza. I just had pepperoni pizza tonight but I highly recommend. Everything from the crust the sauce and the toppings made every bite of this pizza worth it. I personally didn't think the price was that bad especially because how good the pizza was. I will definitely be visiting Cottage Inn Pizza again to try different types of pizza, salads, and subs. I would also like to add in that the staff was very nice. read more

Ehhhh. It smells better than it looks. For the price there is definitely better take out pizza in the area. The crust was almost soggy and the pizza was greasy. read more

One is forced to give a star rating to write a review. Actually, I would give this establishment a 4 or 5. In fact, I've gone out of my way to order a pizza...and drive to my daughter's a mile away for delivery. I understand that there has to be a cut-off for a delivery area. I live about 50 yards from High Street near 161. I could pick up the delivery pizza in the parking lot of the Old Worthington library but have been told "no." In terms of miles from the pizza site, I'm physically closer than about 10% of the delivery area. So, today, I sent my CIP emails to my spam. Bye, CIP, I'll miss you. read more

Great pizza! They accidentally forgot to give us our salad and the gentleman waited for us to come back, we were from out of town. Great pizza place!! read more

Got a large thin crust deluxe this past Friday with some wings and let me tell you that was the first time I've ever had Cottage Inn thin crust pizza but it own't be the last. One of the best cracker-style type pizzas with everything on it that I think i've ever had. We didn't leave a single piece for later, my only regret is I didn't order two of these pizzas! Amazingly good and why I'm changing my rating from 4 stars to 5! read more

Cottage Inn Pizza - Deluxe thin crust, added banana peppers and black olives - OMG so great! 5 star outta 5!! - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

I was staying at a local hotel and wanted a pizza delivered. I chose Cottage Inn because they had some interesting pizza combinations and were very close. Imagine my delight at having the pizza delivered in just 25 minutes! We got a deep dish "Price Buster" pizza and it was fabulous. Lots of good, fresh flavors. My only critique would be the crust...it was a little on the soggy side, which is always a challenge with deep dish. Anyway, I'd definitely recommend trying out this pizza. read more

I'm not a pizza person at all, I tend to not order it unless its a last resort. We had 15 friends over and we had to do something about feeding them. One friend bought a couple name brand pizzas and another friend bought Cottage Inn. We two gigantic Chicken Cordon Bleu pizzas with everuthing crust, and were gone within seconds, and a name brand one that got neglected to see another day. This is handsdown the best pizza I've had in years. The crust was phenomenal and it was super filling. I ate one slice and was good for the rest of the night. After my friend suggesting this, I defintely would buy this again on my own read more

My husband and I were in the mood for pizza and wings and wanted delivery. So, we decided to try somewhere new. We ordered the thin crust garlic parmesan deluxe pizza no sausage add chicken... boneless hot wings and for desert we got the chocolate icing sticks. The pizza was delicious. My husband liked the boneless wings.. I on the other hand did not. They tasted soggy to me. The chocolate sticks we're like the bomb... so delicious! We will most definitely be ordering from here again. read more

Cottage Inn Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Got a large pepperoni and order of bread sticks for my first order. I honestly couldn't tell you a single difference between cottage inns product vs a Little Caesars hot and ready and their breadsticks. Aside from the price of course. Even right down to the bright orange multifold boxes that they use this is more expensive dead ringer for the $5 Pizza up the street. read more

First off, since I've moved into the area I've tried all the nearby pizza joints and this has become my go-to place. They have the BEST sauce, they have an great variety available for toppings, and their delivery is always quick. I really wish I could give them 5 stars, but honestly they're not perfect either. They have a loyalty program that is supposed to be their big selling point. HOWEVER you HAVE to order online to get the loyalty points, and 4 times out of 5 the website is not working. And they won't give you the loyalty points with the phone orders, even if you request it. Additionally, they've forgotten pieces of food that we have ordered on a couple occasions and the pizza has come burnt before (only once though) Again, their pizza is so delicious I would really LOVE to give them 5 stars... but I think they could work on their customer service a bit. read more

I love pizza. I mean it - I really love pizza. I don't know if I ever left the college mindset because I could really eat pizza all the time. Cottage in would be my choice if I was eating pizza all the time. This location is near Polaris, and the hubby and I have gotten both pick up and delivery from here. The delivery time is always reasonable as was the time for pick up. We use the website for online ordering, and it's very straight forward and simple to use.The menu has a lot of different choices, all of which are pretty darn good. We are big fans of the oven roasted wings. They are so tasty. They are still crispy like normal wings, but they have a much more robust flavor because they don't taste of fryer oil. We are big fans of the Parmesan Garlic sauce, though the husband loves the Spicy Garlic. It's tasty, but a little too spicy for me. We have tried quite a few of the gourmet pizzas - our favorites so far being Chicken Artichoke and Motor City Meatball. The other ones we have tried have been awesome - though we were a bit let down by the Aloha Chicken, it didn't hold up to the other pizzas we've gotten. We prefer the round crust, though we got the deep dish one time and it was amazing, but we were only able to eat about a piece each before we were full, so we tend to go for the regular round crust so we can enjoy more pizza in one sitting. The Innstix are tasty, though I prefer the garlic cheese breads (and variations). I'm not a big bread stick person. We've also had a calzone which was delicious, though in my opinion it needed more cheese. Basically everything we have had has been pretty darn spectacular with a few minor let downs (hence the 4 stars). I would definitely recommend it if you are looking for a better pizza than your typical pizza delivery chains. read more

This is our favorite go-to pizza delivery. Their pizza is really good. We enjoy the round crust style for your "traditional" pizza flavors. The supreme is probably my favorite, but I haven't had one I don't like yet. The sticks are really simple and tasty as well. Biggest plus? You can order on the Yelp eat app! Also usually pretty fast delivery. read more

OK time for an update here. This has been my goto place for delivery Zza here in the far northwoods. While my last four orders from this location have been tasty and well portioned every one has been completely undercooked on the bottom. Different type crusts all the same, while well done on the top, baby butt white on the bottom. Last nights Deep Dish bottom was so undercooked in parts it was like eating uncooked canned dough. C'mon pizzamakers, sending out products without doing quality control just doesn't cut it in my book and for my money. Pop, pop, there goes two stars for me. Gonna start the customer service route with the place and will report back my experiences but, for now I will resume my search for the best delivery pizza in the Crosswoods area read more

I ordered some pizza, bread and a sub for a group at the hotel and I sampled each of the three and they were all great. The food was hot and came in a very timely fashion. In this world of delivery pizza, I have to say this place is towards the top for me. I will definitely use them again if I need to order in pizza. read more

First time ordering online with Yelp and they nailed it. Showed to arrive in 45-60 min and was here at my hotel (Double Tree) in 32 min. Pizza was hot. Ordered the pesto pizza w grilled chicken. Delicious. Def recommend and would order again. read more

Cottage Inn Pizza - Had to put this piece back to take a pic......soooo....Yeah... That's how good it was... - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio