Good Fellaz Pizzeria

This is my go-to spot for subs, and honestly, I don't see that changing unless they run out of meat…read moreor oxygen. Jersey Mike's just gets it. My usual rotation: the Big Kahuna Cheesesteak -- beef or chicken, depending on how risky I'm feeling -- and always double meat, double cheese because moderation is for people who don't love flavor explosions. Every bite is molten, melty perfection that makes me forget about the existence of sad, cold sandwiches everywhere else. I order through the app, stroll in like a VIP, and boom -- my sub is waiting for me like it knows I'm coming. The crew here has their system locked down tighter than Fort Knox. It's always busy, but that's just proof of greatness. If there's ever a line, don't worry -- it moves faster than your willpower when you smell that griddle fire up. Verdict: Jersey Mike's isn't just making sandwiches. They're fueling joy -- one Big Kahuna at a time.

I'll start with say it's our local JM. We go to it the most. Im peeved right now because just go…read morehome. Second time in a row they put everything on it except cherry relish which is really the most important thing. When I spend $41 dollars for 2 subs for myself and Son and I specifically told them Cherry Relish and its not on sub. They put on my Son's. Simple instructions. Just a sub I could make without the cherry relish. Ready to take it back.....

See all

Surve

4.4(208 reviews)

0.4 mi

Excellent service with an eclectic but very g9d menu. High quality food the should delight you at…read moreany meal.

This was our first visit to this place. The gentleman who greeted us when we came through the door…read moreexplained the dining concept to us: one side was a self-serve and the other side with the bar was full-service. Since there were a number of couples waiting for the full service side we opted for the former. We ordered and paid at the counter. I ordered the grilled chicken breast with a sweet potato and steamed broccoli while my husband ordered the grilled salmon with sweet potato and opted for a caesar salad in lieu of a second side. The grilled chicken breast was moist and well seasoned but it essentially was naked. It could have used a nice sauce like a bearnaise or some kind of salsa (maybe chutney) to jazz it up. The sweet potato was embarrassingly small. The broccoli was crisp tender but again was bereft of any sauce or just melted butter to make it yummy. My husband's entree was tasty but essentially was pretty bare. His salad was decent though. This restaurant must understand that the eye eats as well as the stomach because when the entrees arrived at our table the plates were rather underwhelming. We also ordered coffees and the gentlemen at the front said he would make a pot of fresh coffee. (He never did). The coffee we were served was old. Apparently, coffee isn't a big draw at this place. The best part was the gluten-free brownie and ice cream at the end. All in all, the place is nice and clean. The food is decent but there is room for improvement. Would we return since we are locals, I don't think so.

Interior

Key lime pie

See all

Bar

Firehouse Tavern

3.5(177 reviews)

0.5 mi

Quaint restaurant on a cute town square! Old buildings have been refurbished and have businesses in…read morethem. Lovely! Firehouse Tavern is small but obviously a local favorite as they were quite busy on a Sunday morning! The food was excellent! My burger was the best Ive had in quite some time! The homemade chips were great! Everyone I was with loved their food! I would definitely recommend this place. Nice variety on menu, excellent service and decor!

Sizzling New York Steak and Chili from heaven, WOW, what a treat! We haven't been there in years…read morebut decided to return just to see if it is still as good as we remembered. We were not disappointed!!! This is not a luxurious place, just a down to earth great place for delicious food in a casual atmosphere.

Eating area

Grilled Steak Dip Sandwich

See all

Ice cold Beer

District 13

3.6(146 reviews)

0.5 mi

WOW! Fantastic food! If you're near by and even slightly hungry, come eat here. We decided to try…read morethis place as we're in town for work and we are glad we did. The restaurant is in an older building, I think a bank, but they've done a good job renovating it to the restaurant. We were the only people in there at 3:30pm on a Monday so the service was good. ** Reaper Pickles are good but not something to try if you can't handle spice**

We stopped into Distract 13 and had the Mexican Street cork, which was plated nicely, but…read moreunfortunately we were not a fan. The flavor wasn't there and the chips were stale. We ordered the fried mozzarella which again was plated very nicely! They had great cheese pool and came out hot. We would have preferred the sauce on the bottom to not have been there since by the time we got to the last mozzarella it was soggy. They are definitely worth a try The mini corn dogs were good and the fresh fries perfectly cooked!! Whisky burger: the glaze was phenomenal, the burger flavorful but the bacon tasted like it was cooked earlier in the day and just warmed up. I would get again minus the bacon. The chicken Philly was filling and flavorful. I enjoyed the chips!!! 3 stars on food, 4 on service, 5 starts on decorations and atmosphere The kids burger with bacon was ok I was told and she didn't like the bacon either but the enjoyed the burgers without The kids Mac and cheese was good and creamy! Our server Wyatt was very nice and periodically checked in on us. Kids

Phili cheese steak

See all

Son of Thurman

4.1(112 reviews)

2.6 mi

Sat at the bar. Definitely a neighborhood joint but welcoming to everyone. Welcoming atmosphere and…read morefriendly bartenders. I ordered the Johnny burger, bacon in the side. Blue cheese and horseradish cheese. So good!!! They won't do medium rare so I went with medium and it was cooked to perfection!!! The cook cooks a mean burger!! Kudos!! I highly recommend Son of Thurman!

Wow! We all loved our food. These burgers are huge...and so good. The onion strings were so good,…read morewe ordered a second basket....but then we were so full from burgers that we couldn't eat all of them. ‍ Make sure you try this place! Also, the staff was super friendly. Note: I eventually had to remove my bun to eat my burger and I still couldn't finish it.

Individual televisions at each booth

Thurman fried pickle chips.

See all

PJ's Family Restaurant

3.1(60 reviews)

0.6 mi

I visited this restaurant one time, which was more than enough. I stopped for lunch. I ordered…read morechicken wings, expecting breaded, fried wings. They came out looking like plain, boiled wings and very unappealing. Also ordered a side, also unappetizing. Sent both back and ordered chili. There was a five dollar difference between my first order and the chili. The server gave me a bill for the meal I sent back and got mad when I pointed it out and politely asked for the correct one. She argued that they were the same. When she returned with the right one, she slapped it down on the table and was very rude. Why would I ever return?

Where Breakfast Pizza Rules and the Morning Rush Tests Your Patience Skills…read more I swung into PJ's Family Restaurant because someone whispered the words breakfast pizza, and honestly, that's all the marketing I need. I ordered it -- and wow. Very good. So good, in fact, that I'm now convinced their regular pizza is probably amazing too. I must return for scientific research. This place was super crowded at 9:00 AM. I'm talking "half the county wanted eggs at the same time" crowded. I grabbed a seat at the bar, which at least gave me front-row seating for the Breakfast Olympics happening. The servers? Absolutely slammed. They were doing laps around the restaurant like they were training for a marathon. Zero blame -- just respect. If you come here during peak hours, bring patience. And maybe a snack. I also grabbed to-go fuel for the tribe: biscuits and gravy, French toast, and bacon -- classic hits across the board. They inhaled everything with the enthusiasm of people who hadn't eaten in 3 days. I'll definitely be back -- but next time I'll arrive earlier, like the seasoned diner ninja I aspire to be. Final Verdict: PJ's serves comfort food worth the wait, breakfast pizza worth a pilgrimage, and morning chaos with a smile.

See all

Big Walnut Grill

2.8(156 reviews)

0.6 mi

Great sports bar (a bit of drive from Westerville) with a diverse and engaging menu. Bar service…read morewas outstanding! Meatloaf special was very good So were the chicken tenders! Parking wasn't ideal But I'll go back!!

I'm going to be blunt. My wife and I love good food. We are foodies. This is not the place for…read morefoodies lol. We went for half off apps got the chicken tenders and loaded potato skins. The tenders even half off were not worth tbh. However the loaded potato skins were. No music while we were there. Service was good tho. Just not going to be coming back unless some insane deal. Also wings were alright...

Huge space, very cool.

Walnut grill house salad w/salmon

See all

Peach cosmo - recommendation from bartender

Grateful Griddle

4.5(11 reviews)

14.1 mi

Love the Burgers!! Had a great experience and good conversation with a few of the workers.read more

As an old Deadhead I knew I would end up here eventually, and today they were close while I was…read morerunning errands. Got there as they were setting up, ordered, and I could tell as soon as the burgers hit the grill- the smell was amazing. Ready in a few minutes because they're smashburgers. Not too thin though- meaty enough in texture and flavor, plus crisped up a bit. Good bun, good toppings. $13 for a double, and yep, that's what a good burger costs nowadays. In a year we will be looking back at that price fondly... Great service. Good menu with a mix of options. A damn good burger.

Frisco Melt @ColumbusFoodDude

See all

Sunbury Grill

4.7(108 reviews)

0.4 mi

The food was delicious! The staff was amazing!…read moreAnd I loved the ambiance! The small cafe was so cute!

What a great little hidden gem. Stopped in for breakfast as we were heading up to Lake Erie and…read morewaited about 20 minutes. Kenny the owner dropped off our food and introduced himself. His wife served us. Love it! Great food too and at a good price. We will definitely be back!!

2 Eggs with Biscuits and Gravy Breakfast

See all

Rye toast

Branch Pizza

4.7(29 reviews)

0.5 mi

Yes sir!!! Ingredients are fresh, staff and owner are awesome! Pizza is on point!! Best pizza in…read moreSunbury!!!

Simply great! More later if I get a chance. Classic small town atmosphere. Ezzo was delicious. Dori…read morewas a wonderful host

See all

I am having separation anxiety and needed some pie

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

12 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Timothy H.

0

10

0

3 years ago

Good take out pizza. We had the traditional crust with pepperoni the good kind that curls up and has a nice spicyness to it. Friendly staff and the place looked well kept and clean. read more

Jake L.

0

5

0

7 years ago

i have traveled across the united states for work and ate pizza in every place i've visited and this is still hands down the best pizza i have ever had read more

Kathe T.

0

6

2

4 years ago

Being from the east coast, can't find better than this in the Columbus area. This is the he only pizza I will eat on this side of town!

Amber F.

2

5

92

8 years ago

First time we tried this place we absolutely loved it..... buffalo chicken pizza... Italian sub....chicken sub... all 5 Stars!!!!

Dave M.

0

1

0

7 months ago

The best in Sunbury. Food is hot and delicious.Good fellaz is my favorite. Try it you will like it. read more

Angela D.

6

34

3846

7 years ago

Delicious- the crust is perfect- the sauce is delicious and the cheese is a 10 ! Must try this pizza

Adam H.

0

13

6

4 years ago

Consistently great food! Prices are pretty good. Also has a great market attached to it!

Saundra H.

0

3

8

3 years ago

There Pizza is Fantastic & Everyone knows what there job is. Sauce is out of this world

Neil R.

0

11

0

9 years ago

Food has always been good and service has been great as well. Would recommend to all.

John W.

0

29

3

11 years ago

Great pizza. Hot and spicy is my favorite. Convenient location.

Hazel A.

0

1

0

9 years ago

I Like your pizza but could cook it a little longer

Mandi G.

144

4

0

11 years ago

Their cheesey bread is awesome!

Good Fellaz Pizzeria - pizza - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Good Fellaz Pizzeria also viewed

George's Pizza

4.1

(30 reviews)

Tried for first time did not like Too spicy for me and…read morecrust very average and too chewy Would not go back

Solid cbus style pizza option where Dublin is sorely lacking. Not that driving 20 minutes is bad,…read morebut sometimes you want to drive 5 minutes. Prices on the website are a relic of simpler times. But hey it would be good to update them? Maybe a 25% premium bc of the area of town vs. equal pizza quality in the 'hood.

Sparano's Pizza

3.8

(93 reviews)

We got take out from here last night for the super bowl. The pizza is delicious! The crust is thin…read morewhich a slightly doughy crust. The sauce is slightly sweet and the cheese is generous. It kind of reminds me of Bridge Street Pizza in Dublin with a slightly thicker crust. We also got garlic cheese bread, macaroni and cheese bites, and mozzarella sticks. The macaroni and cheese bites were good as well as the GCB although a tiny bit cold. However considering we got take out on a snowy Super Bowl Sunday they were pretty good. I think the mozzarella sticks might have either been taken too quick out of the fryer or not at all. Fortunately after putting them in the oven they weren't bad. We will definitely try Sparano's again because the pizza was amazing but will pick a time when things will hopefully be more calm.

Same great food but new location. They have moved to 3947 W.Broad,directly across the street from…read moreDrive Time auto sales. Inside is clean and service is friendly and fast. Try the Heavy Meat pizza,it will put you to sleep!

Susie's Sub Shop

4.3

(69 reviews)

This was a great Italian submarine, I think because of the break they used. The bottom wasn't…read morereally thick which made the sandwich much more tasty. There's not much to eating inside however there is tables. I think the carry out orders must be the obvious way to go.

Keep hearing about this but I'm just not over this way often. Today I was, and this was right on…read morethe way, so duh. Small parking lot, but 10 spaces or so, plenty at lunchtime on a weekday but probably not at peak. No dine-in currently; call ahead, or order there and wait on one of a couple chairs. I got the Big John, an Italian sub with sausage. Came up in about 10 minutes, because I ordered it hot. Very good sub: good bread (Auddino's apparently,) good sausage, good meats, good veggies. And, a good portion at a good price (I got the 8", for $10.) Best in town? I don't know about that. Up in the top 10 or 5, surely, but we have some pretty good ones. But no complaints, for size, taste, or price. A little greasy, which is not a bad thing (for a sub.) I was stuffed. Friendly service, fast for this kind of thing, reasonably priced, and really good food. If I lived closer I'd be back often.

Ange’s pizza

3.6

(9 reviews)

Listen, I'm from Youngstown Ohio, there's levels to this. I was hesitant to try it. Glad i did…read more This place is great, CONSISTENT (which is key these days) , can't beat the price for great crust, QUALITY ingrediants, and pretty fast. I seen a low star for slow delivery LOL people are wild. You will not be disappointed here. I now order it to feed my employees, and they are PICKY - sheesh. - if you order here tell them Brandon sent you from the review, they will probably look at you weird like "WHO" but at least it'll be funny and you'll have great pizza at a great local place. We order pepperoni, pepperoni and banana peppers, chicken, bacon, and ranch, barbecue chicken, and the spicy Italian.

It's connected to the bar right next-door, which makes it very easy as they simply hand it through…read morean interior window. Food was amazing and their pizza is exactly what you want Columbus pizza to be like. Tons of toppings with a great sauce and a great crisp bite. Service was very good as the waitress and bartenders will take your order and put everything through and bring it right to you. And it's a great place to watch games with a great environment.

Brenz Pizza Co. Dublin

3.8

(54 reviews)

Great pizza, great service…read more Located in the shopping center at Avery Square, this restaurant has ample parking outside and a few seats for those who want to dine in. I highly recommend trying the Heritage Honey pizza which is loaded with classic red sauce, cheese, pepperoni, sliced sausage, and creamy ricotta. They finish it off with shaved parmesan, fresh basil, and their signature hot honey drizzle . This pie is absolutely delicious.

Recently tried Brenz Pizza Co. for the first time and it was so good. We did pickup, and everything…read morewas still really fresh and hot when we got home. I especially loved the margherita pizza! Simple but really solid. Definitely see why it's a local favorite in Dublin. We'll for sure be going back.

Ange's Pizza

3.5

(47 reviews)

If only my tummy could talk?!? Not even once over 10 years…read morehas this business disappointed me. Staff, all so kind...pizza will rock your taste buds, price is very reasonable. What can I say, I'm pretty much hooked here. I have consumed their amazing subs and salads. Thank you, Angie's pizza.... Until next time.

My husband and I ordered dinner from here tonight. Disappointed is an understatement. I ordered the…read moreItalian Beef Sub that says it comes in an au jus sauce and provolone cheese. I can tell you the meat is nothing more than unseasoned "steak-um" meat. There was no au jus sauce! I opened the sub to find lettuce and tomato which is nothing even in the description. I HiGHLY DO NOT recommend this place and should have looked at the reviews on other platforms and would not be so upset right now. I am going to share a picture of my disappointment

Pizza Primo

3.9

(50 reviews)

The staff was nice. The pizza is by far one of the worst pizzas I've ever had. I tried Pizza Primo…read morebecause it is next door to my nail salon. You basically taste nothing but dough. There was barely any sauce, any cheese, any pepperonis and literally only had 15 sausage on the whole pizza. Some slices had zero sausage.

Greatttttt pizza! The kind that is hard to put down. 10/10 Everyone and the owner is truly…read morekindhearted. Great place, highly recommend!

D & E-Z-O's Pizza

4.2

(61 reviews)

EVERYTHING!! Love the pizza, it's the BEST!!…read moreWish they would expand out. We live in orient, and drive there all the time, JUST for their pizza. Won't eat pizza any place else.

Our whole work team loves D & E-Z-O's…read more Really nice people. Super-responsive. Delicious pizza. If you're trying to feed a big group, and want to impress people, order THE DESTROYER - it's huge, and it feeds a lot of people. This is one of our "Go To" pizza places.

Johnnies Villa Pizza

4.4

(58 reviews)

Amazing great food Have had it since the eighties and it is…read morestill by far the best. Even some of the same staff from the 90s are there

Villa is a Johnstown staple, no question. It has a fantastic cracker crust that doesn't disappoint…read more It's hard to find one like it. However, accuracy and service are lacking. I've been eating here since I was a small child and I can genuinely think of only a handful times they have actually got our order correct. We're not particularly difficult orderers either. The most complex thing we ask for if a plain Italian sub. But our food is consistently wrong and if you say anything about it the owners are super rude. Our visits are few and far between these days.

Casa Di Pizza

4.0

(89 reviews)