I ordered an Italian sub and it was delicious. I love when they are oven heated/toasted. The pizza looked delicious and the smell in there while waiting for my order was killing me. read more

1/5 Stars - Complete waste of $70. The people leaving good reviews must have zero taste buds. The pizza is totally flavorless, tasting like plain, cheap bread with the lowest-quality ingredients. To make it worse, I paid extra for sauce and didn't even get it. The Stromboli and Bosco sticks sucked, too--completely dry and bland. I love pizza, but I couldn't even finish this. A total $70 waste of money. Never again. read more

Ordered a small pizza and an Italian sub. Both were excellent. The sub was hot , toasted with plenty of lettuce, tomatoes and hot peppers. Love your pizza sauce and the crust just the right amount of crispy read more

Friday evening and not wanting to cook. We ordered pizza, a personal Sicilian and a Stromboli. Everything tasted great. The Sicilian was like a deep dish compared to the regular pizza. The Stromboli was Awesome love the crust with the sauce good combo together. read more

See all

Ordered 2 large pizzas yesterday. Only 1 was ready as the other was given away when I arrived (early) 20 minutes after my phone order to pick up within 25 minutes. We have always been long time, loyal customers & the product. However, something has definitely changed....new owners???? Service was terrible, waited 20 more mins for another pizza to be made to replace the pizza they gave away. No options, offers, nothing! The old pizza that was sitting there for a while along with the replacement of a fresh hot pizza was my only option. Needless to say when we got home the old cold pizza was terrible and not edible. The replacement pizza was clearly not the quality we had come accustomed too. Skimpy ingredients, toppings. Very disappointing & frustrated as I tried talking with them. No offer to Comp., refund my money. Totally lacking customer service & quality product! Lesson learned! I should have just walked away as I had hungry kids waiting in the car for dinner. Should have demanded a refund & gone to Surve for quality, fresh dinner & fabulous customer service! Customer service was non existent & quality of product certainly has gone downhill. Nine people were standing around with nothing to do & were confused, running into each other. Total disorganization as something has definitely changed. We will not be back & I cannot recommend!! Waste of my time & Money!!! read more

If you're looking for local pizza places around or in Sunbury, this is the place to choose. I've tried just about every local place and this is by far my favorite. They only offer carry out with some patio tables outside but I don't mind taking it home. I usually get the same thing every time and it never misses. Which is a pizza with light sauce and pepperoni with half added banana peppers and pineapple. So good!! I recently tried their garlic bread with cheese and the Stromboli and both were very good! Anytime someone brings up pizza for dinner I always have to mention Good Fella'z. read more

Good Fellaz Pizzeria - Light sauce, Pepperoni with half added pineapple and banana peppers - Pizza Near Me - Sunbury, Ohio

Super nice owner, great pizza. I ordered pizza, among other food, for my father's 90th birthday party (Good Fellaz is his favorite,.) I ordered a day ahead, it was ready exactly when I asked for it to be ready. It was delicious!! read more

Decent pizza. The only pizza that doesn't leave bad after taste in my mouth. Feels like It was made with fresh ingredients. They still use wax paper protecting the pizza from touching the cardboard box which is an important matter for my tastebud. read more

Good food...good service. Family running business were friendly and the food hit the spot.

Food was delivered hot and delicious. We did delivery so not sure about service other than our delivery was on time and the gentleman was very nice! Nothing to say about ambiance since we had delivery. I have not been inside this eatablishment. I will def order again read more

This pizza place has changed in the last month or so. New owners, pizza not the same.. disappointing...

bought a large pepperoni pizza on sunday which was a major disappointment. have been going here for years, not sure if new ownership. the pepperoni was old, very little sauce, and toppings stopped at least an inch from the crust. Will no longer be a regular customer read more

This pizza was pretty good. I really like the spicy pepperoni. The sauce was good and the cheese perfect. Only issue we had was the crust. Super thin and super crunchy. Didn't know they don't have thicker crust. If we're in there area we would try this again. read more

See all

I think we just had a bad pizza. It was extremely burnt. I don't mind a crunchy pizza but the cheese was burnt all over the pizza and the crust was rock hard. The sauce was delicious and the amount of cheese was very good. We also ordered Bosco sticks and sauce, that was very good. We will try again, in hopes the next one isn't burnt. read more

Good Fellaz Pizzeria - Cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sunbury, Ohio

Consistent product and more than generous toppings. It's my go to. I pick up and ive never had to wait.

Fantastic pizza. Great chew in crust. Smokey cheese. Perfect sauce. Just moved into sunbury. Glad to find Get you some. read more

Best pizza ever !! I highly recommend Good Fellas!! They are very friendly and affordable!

This use to be one of our favorite pizzas but something changed for the worse a few months ago. It appears they changed everything with their pizza because the last pizza we had was not good and was a totally different pizza than what was their normal great pizza. Either change back or it'll likely soon be a vacant business read more

10/10 crispy crust, flavorful sauce, plenty of toppings, sauce has a hint of sweet to it. Definitely coming back when I shop at Tanger!

Always good pizza and subs. Make sure you go to their web site to download discount coupons as their prices can be slightly high.

I have had a lot of pizza in my lifetime, a lot of good pizza at that. THIS IS GREAT PIZZA!! Incredible!

Best pizza around. I encourage you to try the BBQ chicken pizza as well as the Buffalo chicken. But pep mush onion with extra cheese is still my fav. read more

Great pizza! They load with toppings and have good thin crust. Workers were great and friendly. Would recommend!

I have been all over the united states building power lines in Chicago, California coast to coast, and this is by far the best pizza place I have found small but mighty read more

I really want a solid pizza place so writing the review hoping the owners will see it and make some changes. We used to order from here on a regular basis and stopped 6 months ago. We decided to give it another try and ordered 2 small pizza's on 4/18. Whoever made the dough that day, great job! The pizzas were amazing! They were so good that we ordered 3 pizzas on 4/22 and they were inedible. We ate half of one and are throwing away the rest. It feels like depending on who works that day will determine the quality of the pizza. There is little consistency. read more

Delicious pizza and great wings! We absolutely love the spicy garlic wings and get them every time.

Well - thank GOODNESS we found you as soon as we did. We had lost all faith in good pizza so we decided that dieting was better and we would never eat pizza again. Until we found Good Fella'z Pizzeria. With a few good reviews, we needed to try it! The pizza is amazing! We can't get enough of the Hot and Spicy pizza. It's probably the best pizza we have EVER had. Hot is usually reserved for wings in this town. Spicy is not a concept embraced in this sleepy Midwestern part of the country. So "spicy" is usually greeted by our rolling eyes and loud sighs of disgust. But this one is HOT - and SPICY - and just pure love on the most amazing crust. We also sampled the Italian Sub (get a double) and the Sicilian pizza which is similar to JETs 8 corner pizza, but JETs is not even the same league. We can say it was all good. The pizza crust is crispy and your cardboard is DRY instead of soaked with gobs of grease. The sauce just has a slight twinge of sweet. I am not a sweet sauce fan, so if I like this you don't have to worry about a thing! We've had it so many times now, I think the owners are starting to know us! They even brought us a pizza during an ice storm (we didn't realize it until after the fact) and we drove there during a bad snow just to get the pizza ourselves. There is no place to eat at the establishment, so carry out or delivery is your only option. No matter when you deal with the employees, they are always happy to take your order or deliver or take your payment. It's just a fantastic establishment all around. If you are in the Westerville/Sunbury area, you have to try this. These are some Goodfellaz, with some good pizza! read more

Good Fellaz Pizzeria - Hot and Spicy - looking so SEXY (sorry no onions)! - Pizza Near Me - Sunbury, Ohio

The pizza is amazing. Wings and salad always good too. Service is consistently timely. We order pizza there several times a month for the last 4 years and it has never disappointed us. read more

Good Fella'z honestly never disappoints. It has been my favorite pizza joint for as long as I can remember and for good reason. It might be easy to pass by, but if you take the time to go order, you won't regret it! The pizza crust is the perfect crunch and tastes delicious! The pizza sauce is super savory and pairs great with their crisp pepperonis. The Italian sub is a must-get if you like subs; They put everything on the sub you would want to see on an Italian. Living in Florida with cardboard pizza, I always look forward to coming to Sunbury and stopping by Good Fella'z! Check it out if you haven't already, you won't regret it! read more

Yum! Super good for the area. Haven't had a bad meal yet. Good value for money totally recommend.

Amazing fresh great sauce lots of toppings! Not super doughy. Crust is capable of holding all the juicy goodness. These guys are fast and all about the pie! Love the Italian subs. Loaded and awesome. Great place. Great price read more

Best pizza joint in Sunbury. Consistent, good pizza. Favorite specialty is Hot and Spicy.

Very good old school pizza. We drive out of our way to get it. Happy to be able to find a great pizza joint outside of the 'chain' establishments. Staff is always friendly and orders are always accurate! Highly recommended!! read more

Some of the best pizza in Sunbury. Though, I do have to take off some points because their pizza is rectangle. That is simply disgusting behavior and makes me hurl. #trianglesforlife #rectanglemorelikecrap #cancelrectanglepizza read more

I will say this is the best pizza shop in the area...and I drove over to 23 to try everything between here and there. I think the big winner for me is the pepperoni. I detest sandwich pepperoni on pizza- that belongs on a sandwich, hence the name. This has the nice smaller peps that curl up a bit and crisp in the oven (yes, they do collect some grease, but it's a fatty meat, what do you expect???). Do I crave this pizza, no...does it handle my pizza craving I have for traditional Ohio type pizza- yes. I came from an area where I had some really great shops in short distant walks/drives from my house- Ange's (my #1), Grandad's, Terita's, Pizza House, etc.... so I personally find it hard to live up to these shops that have been around for decades, but this is my go to when I'm at home and want to eat a nice pizza shop pizza. Italian sub is good too. :) read more

Employees were not wearing masks. Pizza was great in the past and I was a long time customer. Happily, they let me cancel my order, but I will no longer eat here as COVID-19 precautions are not taken. read more

Excellent pizza. The only on-site dining is outside, so this is better picked up, but we really enjoyed it. Found it on Yelp and wasn't disappointed. read more

Best pizza hands down. The staff is AWESOME!! I personally don't think employees should throw their sexual preferences in the customers face... read more

Pizza was delicious! We very much enjoyed the pepperoni pizza! It was extra cheesy, which we very much enjoyed. It refrigerated well and it was just as enjoyable cold the next day! The delivery service was prompt and I would absolutely order from here again! read more

My wife loves this pizza, as do I. Its different with the smoked cheese but delicious. last pizza was a tad over done. Need to work on quality control and process a bit. It was a humid day so I dont know if they were trying to adjust the oven. read more