Edit: To answer the owner's comments, we gave some the cake away to a relative, hoping they would…read moreenjoy it more than we did. They ended up not enjoying it, so that's why there's some missing and none of us wanted to eat it anymore! Spoke to Suzi when picking up the cake and explained to her that the cake would not be eaten on the day of, but instead two days later. The cake was for September 1st and that happened to be Labor Day so I had to pick it up earlier! She said, "That's fine," and it can be stored in the fridge for up to a week and in the freezer for up to three months. So, not sure why there's a sense of judgement, cakes should be able to be stored for longer periods of time! And we wanted to order from a bakery specifically, since it was a special occasion. Not sure what your reference to a "squished" cake has to do with it food will accumulate residue in containers overtime! 9/12/25 From seeing professional pictures online of the beautiful cakes on Google Reviews of Suzi Cakes and good reviews on Yelp, I genuinely thought that the red velvet cake I ordered over the phone with Suzi would be amazing. Boy, was I wrong. I had to throw out the cake after 6 days because no one wanted to eat it anymore. We gave some part of the cake away to a relative, so we didn't consume much...not sure if they enjoyed it either. There were 'red' flags that I noticed when placing an order with Suzi. I chose to ignore them because I needed a nicely catered cake for my sister's birthday. Suzi sounded very direct over the phone and sometimes dismissive, so I felt that I needed to truly know and prepare for how I wanted my cake each time I called. I could not go in person to explain or show pictures due to the distance from her business in East Hanover. Suzi gave me the listed price of $90, and I personally thought it was overpriced for a 7-inch, single-tiered cake. I originally did not want to place with Suzi, but I could not find a place around me that would do a red velvet cake legitimately, besides Coco Luxe Cakes in Peapack and Gladstone. Coco Luxe discontinued their red velvet cakes, unfortunately, which is the cake I truly needed, hence why I ordered here. Next, trying to find the suite number and building for this place was a nightmare, another red flag. It's very tight behind some train tracks and very easy to miss. Thank goodness for advanced technology and Google Maps/Street View for helping me navigate. I called Suzi on the phone so she could service me at the front desk to get the cake. I picked up the cake and truly believed that I would make my sister's birthday special, and I planned everything perfectly. I stored the cake in the fridge for 2 days before eating and followed all of Suzi's storage directions. We tried the cake and it was awful. It had a fermented-like taste, and we could not eat it. I saw a similar review on Yelp of someone having Suzi make their cake for their wedding, and their wedding guests could not eat it; it was that bad. I was hoping that would not happen to me, but it did, surely. The icing was hard, dry, and chunky; the cake itself lacked flavor. I got a red velvet cake from ShopRite in July for $16.99, and it tasted way better; just the cake was a little dry. I called Suzi to give her some feedback so she knows. She informed me to come back so she could examine the taste, but at that point, we threw the cake out. $90 truly wasted. Can't really ask for a refund, I guess, because I never came back to her about it, because her location is almost an hour from my house...not sustainable for me. Despite the good reviews, I will never go to Suzi Cakes again. I will stick with another recommendation I got from a relative for Coco Luxe in Peapack if I want a professionally made cake from a bakery. My sister's birthday was ruined, and no one in my family liked the cake. The price for the cake was outrageous, and compared to other local bakeries in the area, the price does not justify the taste. The presentation of the cake is good, but the taste is abysmal. Save yourself, your palate, and your wallet by looking elsewhere!

I stumbled onto Suzi Cakes after having to pivot unexpectedly from a bad experience trying to order…read morefrom a local (new) bakery. Suzi Cakes could not have been nicer or more accommodating with just 2 weeks notice. The communication was so simple, professional, and pleasant. They delivered the cake exactly when they said (in the pouring rain) and even placed the topper and flowers on it before leaving! And then the cake itself...oh my yum! We did Vanilla with Oreo Mousse filling and it was DELICIOUS. The cake was so soft, fluffy, and flavorful. And the filling was awesome! I know I've found my new bakery for future events!!! Thank you Suzi Cakes!

I have been coming here for quite some time and realized that I had not reviewed this excellent…read morebakery. Started coming here to get my Daughter's favorite cake the Philly Fluff cake. Since then I have come here for their excellent breads and pastries. They have a small parking lot and street parking. People are always nice even when it's busy. Great bakery check it out and you'll be glad you did.

First off, I stopped in here on a whim and have never been here before I initially really just…read morewanted some quick cookies and a cappuccino which they do not have cappuccinos, but they have hot coffee and tea. The amount of quality bread that they had was so incredible that I ended up buying a high round plane and pumpernickel. let me tell you the bread and desserts. Here are absolutely delicious. And a fraction of the cost for bread at most places. I will be back because of how amazing and old school this bakery is!

I've tried getting cakes from bakeries closer to where I live but none even come close to Sweet…read moreSisters! Their cakes are absolutely delicious, moist, and not overly sweet. Beth from Sweet Sisters made cakes for two important events that I had. Both cakes were visually stunning and truly works of art. You won't believe how good they taste until you try it! Thank you Sweet Sisters for making the BEST cake I've ever had!!

I contacted Sweet Sisters to see if they could help me create two cakes for my child's first…read morebirthday party. One would be a smash cake and the other for our 30+ guests. Beth, the owner, was so lovely to work with. I show her a picture of what I was looking for, and she helped me come up with the best cake and cream combination. Both cakes turned out exactly how I envisioned it, and the best part is they were both equally delicious. They are on the expensive side because each cake is freshly made and tailor just for you. What she will create for you is something you can't just walk into a bakery to purchase. If you are looking for a cake for a special occasions, Sweet Sisters should be your first stop.

Last minute dessert since mine failed. Excellent cakes, owners very helpful and good people.read more

Came in for too good to go orders, every time they will give me loads of delicious food, and very…read morefriendly people here including the shop owner.

Most creative cupcake towers ever!! Beautiful!! And delicious :) they were so helpful to work with…read moreand made ordering so easy.

Stopped in with our grandson to get a few cookies. The selection was wide and colorful. They're all…read moremade on site and they looked awesome

Came here for the first time after a friend's recommendation. I bought the strawberry shortcake for…read moremyself, a carrot cake for my friend, 2 iced coffee, and 3 blueberry almond croissants. Let's start with the strawberry shortcake. It was so light, fresh, and not too sweet. The Jam on top is clearly made from fresh strawberries. Excellent cake. My friend said the carrot cake was very good. Her family especially loved the frosting. I need to try that next time. The iced coffee was very good. Very strong flavor. The croissants were very good too. I just couldn't taste enough blueberries in them. Service was very friendly! There are tables inside for people to talk, rest, or work. Will definitely come back again!

My family has tried most of the cakes here besides the blackout chocolate cake so we got it for my…read morebirthday! Overall delicious but giving it a 4/5 stars because I wasn't a fan of the chocolate pudding filling. There was just something about it, maybe needed to be sweeter or more chocolatey, less thick/mousse-like. The cake, ganache and crumbles were great. The service day of pick up was excellent and the staff gave me a free cookie for my birthday :) We also got iced vanilla lattes that were AMAZING. They make their own vanilla syrup in house.

A cute cafe in downtown Chatham with lots of street parking. Came here after lunch in the afternoon…read morespecifically for the coffee and desserts, and wow! They have multiple coffee options, and I really appreciated that the coffee actually had a strong, bold coffee flavor. I only wish I could've tried more of their desserts because so many of them looked amazing! Unfortunately, they were already almost sold out by around 3 PM (and this was on a weekday!) so definitely come earlier if you want the full selection! We tried a few desserts and really enjoyed everything. The éclair was a tiny bit on the sweeter side for me, but still good. The pistachio macaron was probably one of my favorites because it had such a strong pistachio flavor, which I love. It was soft with a great texture while still holding its shape perfectly. I also really enjoyed the Black Forest cake - the sponge was soft and moist with plenty of chocolate shavings and wasn't overly heavy. What made the experience even better was the staff. Everyone was so lovely, friendly, and genuinely helpful. They were super proactive with cleaning and helping and made us feel very welcome. I had such a good time here and will definitely be back! Maybe earlier next time so I can try even more of the desserts!

Great hidden gem, qualifying beans and equipment! Service is friendly, good for a solo drink or…read morehang with 1-2 people

I am beyond disappointed and frustrated by the entire process of ordering a cake for my son's 2nd…read morebirthday. I went in person to order him a basketball themed sheet cake. I brought the decorations and even met with Joe Murphy himself. Joe took down my order, sketched the design of the cake, reviewed the colors, and theme personally. The theme of the party was born 2 ball and I asked for a basketball themed sheet cake with orange and green frosting. First the frosting was pastel pink/orange (see photos) and sea foam green. Clearly nothing like the colors discussed - then the drawing he created was supposed to have the ball decorations cascading down the side. As you can see in the photo it looks like my 2 year old son haphazardly placed them with absolutely no care of design whatsoever. On top of the above disgraceful items when I called I was assured I would be contacted to rectify and discuss that they gave my husband at pick up a cake with THE WRONG COLORS, NO DESIGN, AND DOUBLE THE SIZE ORDERED. I was never called back, there was zero respect or apologies. When I called the girl even said "oh the basketball theme cake" - please take a look and let me know, do you see a basketball theme cake or any care taken at all? Disgracefully disrespectfulI

Finally satisfied my chocolate craving!…read more Absolutely love this rich moist chocolate cake!! Introduced to this bakery as a Yelp event- So grateful! It's become my favorite chocolate cake!!

Nothing Bundt YUMMMMMMERS!! Grabbed up some Bundlets for Thanksgiving just to change things up a…read morebit and they were all a huge hit. The Pumpkin Spice, Carrot, Red Velvet, and the Chocolate Chocolate Chip flavors seemed to be everyone's favorites. But for my money it's gotta be Chocolate Chocolate Chip for the win.   Cakes were moist, fluffy, and super flavorful so I'll definitely be hitting this place up again in the future.  Life is Sweet  Dig In!! Come And Get Your Bundt Munch On!!  ;D

My guilty pleasure. The cakes at NBC are just addictive. As someone who is not really big into…read morecake this place consistently has great flavors. My favorite is the confetti cake but you can't go wrong with the white chocolate raspberry or the vanilla. I recently tried the chocolate chocolate chip and chef's kiss for that one as well. I get the buntini and that will actually last me 3 days. I just need a few bites a day to be satisfied. Can't lie those bites are usually first thing in the morning. I would get these cakes for events or to bring to someone's dinner party and they never disappoint. If you haven't tried one you don't know what you are missing