Dowling scoring system Ambiance: 8/10…read moreFood: 9/10 Service: 8/10 Value: 10/10 ---------------------- Total: 35/40

Our go to place for pizza in Marion! Wings are great too. Pizza is thin crust. The dining area is…read moresmall so not good for bigger group of people.

This review is for "Locals on the Lake" upstairs from "The Pizza Stop", same building restaurant…read morebar upstairs, takeout pizza downstairs. I'm telling you, the owner loves his business as the quality has not darkened in years... That is rare. So we ordered one of the new menu items (Chicken Parm, char broiled (bc my wife says I have to be healthy) and the meat lovers pizza with ricotta. AMAZING! We can't go there without ordering fresh pizza bc that is nirvana. The Chicken Parm did not need breading! Crusty and juicy, these people know what they are doing! And they make a lot of sauces there, the one with the Chicken Parm, was a perfect compliment to the HOMEMADE pasta and chicken. Drinks were generous and reasonable. Great service! Ya know what, I shouldn't be sharing this gem... Okay pay no attention!

Best pizza we've had since Lombardi's in NYC. Oven baked BUT it had the smokiness of a coal fired…read moreoven. Service was excellent. Laid back feel of a small American lake town.

Brand new pizza joint in Phelps. I just had a slice of pepperoni for lunch and it was delicious…read more They sport a thin New York style crust. Service ran smoothly for a new place that was pretty busy for lunch. They have indoor and outdoor seating as well as a separate arcade room with several different games.

In town and had to stop by. I am so glad we did. I was in the mood from some good wings and boy…read moredid this place deliver. These wings are life changing.

Was driving through town recently and wanted a quick late afternoon snack…read more This place was exactly what I hoped it would be. The guy working the counter was friendly and welcoming. He still had a few slices left from lunch, so I grabbed one of those. It was excellent New York style thin crust. Perfect for an afternoon snack. Bathroom was clean, parking was easy, food was good, and the pizza chef was a cool dude. There's a few booths for seating indoors and, at least in the summer, two tables outside. I'll gladly stop here next time I'm in town and need a bite.

Great pizza , their "weird" sauce is really good. Always positive and friendly, definitely…read morerecommend trying a slice

My chicken wings in garlic sauce were cooked to perfection, the salad could use more lettuce but it…read morewas flavorful. Service was cool but the appearance inside wasn't so pleasant, they really need to renovate to improve the smell and gain new customers.

Always the best pizza in the area! Staff is extremely friendly, prices are completely fair!read more

The best pizza in the area. They are always friendly and helpful. I order from them whenever I…read morecan.

Day manager h as d as b great attitude went out of there way hyp please and on. S very b hot day…read moremade you comfortable and at. Home.

Great service and the pizza, wings and subs are excellent! My favorite is the chicken wing pizza.read more

Pizza was excellent! Owner was friendly and helpful,…read moreWould definitely recommend! I like that you could order different toppings on each half

Aw man, I wish I could give this place a better review…read more My husband, my five year old, and I came in about 5:45 on a Friday! We were on our way to a soccer game, so we were eating in! There are a few tables, and the dining room was pretty clean. The building looks to be old, but kept in good condition. We ordered a white pizza, an order of breadsticks, and a cold cut sub. The wait wasn't terrible, maybe 20 minutes or so. The staff was friendly, but maybe a little loud and inappropriate in the back. It didn't seem like they knew or cared guests were in the dining room. The owner, came out and greeted almost every take out customer, but didn't say a word to us, sitting in the dining room with our food. The pizza was thin crust, a little messy and greasy, but tasty for a white garlic pizza! The breadsticks were good, as was the marinara dip that came with it. Crispy, fresh. My husband ate half his sub, and we packed the rest up to bring home. When we got home later that night and unrolled his sub to finish it, we realized there was GREEN MOLD on the bottom of it. I'm guessing they don't make the rolls fresh and it was overlooked. We won't return again, which is a shame bc there are not a lot of options in Ontario / Williamson area.

Great thin slice pizza. We have ordered a bunch of times. Second best to all stars pizza in…read moreRochester area.

We were in town for a wedding and decided to order three large pizzas to feed the family. After a…read moresmall tip, this order came out to be $90, which I feel like is a bit steep. This is NY style pizza, perfectly foldable! Love. The Chicken Bacon Ranch was the household favorite and the consensus was that we would absolutely order it again. The Pepperoni and Cheese was a classic if nothing special and I really wanted Eggplant on one of the pizzas so we decided to order that custom. We were surprised to find that pizza so dry! Also, the reason we did not add any other toppings for that vegetable pizza was because every topping cost $3 extra. Who charges $3 for spinach on pizza?! Service was quick; we picked our order up easily just 25 minutes later. From what we saw upon pick up, this restaurant is an excellent vibe; good views of the lake, fun decor, and plenty of space to get together with family and friends. I would absolutely order from here again, but probably their Chicken Bacon Ranch pizza and other food only.

Hot fresh generous size, crust with a nice bite and a good fold . Price a little higher but worth…read moreit . Our family from out of town always wants to go here . It's a nice hidden treasure.

don't like to exaggerate, but the garlic parm wings at Mac's may be the greatest culinary…read moreachievement of the modern era. I went in planning to order pizza like a normal person. Then I made the life-altering decision to get the garlic parm wings. Big mistake. Now every other wing I eat will forever live in their shadow. Crispy, absurdly garlicky, and covered in enough parmesan to make an Italian grandmother proud. I would confidently recommend them to friends, strangers, and anyone walking within a 50-foot radius. 5 stars. Honestly considering writing my congressman about them.

They don't honor the 3 percent discount for cash payment. My mom has had a terrible time with…read moregetting this discount. A Few weeks ago she ordered a blt wrap and waited an absurd amount of time to get it and when she did it was a turkey wrap. The place was not busy so it's kind of ridiculous. The manager on duty was rather short with her as if it was her fault the order took forever and was screwed up. Disappointed as I used like this manager and even if he was having a bad night he should have been more polite. Today nothing of how they have treated their tenants (disbatch brewing). David and Colleen at Disbatch are truly good people and are genuinely supportive of the community. To Steve and Tyler---you are Not as awesome as you think you are......Arrogant people who don't cane about anyone but themselves. I also hope your little tavern crashes and burns. Support disbatch brewing! Genuine people who TRULY care about their community and customers. Go visit DISBATCH BREWING on Main Street in macedon in August. F@ck macs pizza shack. Marks pizza is wayyy better. I'll never waste my money at the shack ever again.