Very cool spot with delicious choices from sandwiches, pizza squares, and desserts including gelato. I think on a weekend getting here before noon will ensure you have all the selection for your picking. I will say I have been here later in the day and it was slim pickings and my entire experience shifted coming much earlier. Everything is delicious depending on what flavors you prefer. Each slice also is ginormous. I think with $60 you can easily feed a hungry family of 5 unless they are 3 extremely hungry teenagers. Prices are reasonable for the fresh thick slices of pieces piled with toppings. The workers are all helpful and quick with your order. Space is small with just 4 stools or so, so going to the nearby park to eat this would be ideal. Pistachio slice is epic and all their vegetarian options are fantastic. read more

Forno Tony - Desserts! - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, New York

This wasn't our first visit. We came last year and loved the Roman pizzas. I was surprised to see a long line to get in and order. Still very busy on a Saturday morning! The line took some time but it was worth the wait. I don't enjoy the ordering process. You have people all around you and things moving fast. I had a hard time hearing what the offerings were with all the excitement around us. We ordered a few slices and ate them on a bench outside. Very good flavor. I can't remember the specific details and flavors, but one was Calabrian and had some heat. Love the decor inside. Decorated all over with soccer merch. Lots to look at. They also sell gelato. read more

See all

Let me tell you something. Forno Tony's is an incredibly special place. It is clear by the line out the door. It is clear by the great folks being the counter. It is clear because of galato. The culture here is amazing. The Rome, Italy in a small is simply speculator. Please go here. Please look around and try one of everything. This is a little bit of Italy in Roch ch cha. read more

Forno Tony - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, New York

This is exactly like my nanas from Naples Italy bread. Its spot on from the flavor of the dough and everything. It was so good to taste her style of pizza she called it for the kids back in the day. The Gelato is out of this world in flavor as well. Biscoff and Ferrero roche we got and it was so powerful in flavor. Presentation was excellent in all. Loved it all. I hope you all can expand into a larger building soon. Prices were great read more

Forno Tony made my sister's birthday genuinely special. This is authentic Roman style pizza, scissor cut and sold by weight, so we tried several slices instead of committing to one pie. Every single one delivered: crisp, airy crust, quality toppings, nothing generic. The gelato and pastries were just as good. Clearly made in house and worth the visit on their own. What really makes this place is the people. You can tell the family running it trained in Rome and does things the traditional way. It feels like stepping into an old school Italian bakery. They went out of their way to make the birthday feel celebrated. I don't live in Rochester anymore, but this place could genuinely make me think about retiring back in ROC. Go early, it fills up fast, and try a few different slices. Highly recommend. read more

See all

Stop booking that trip to Rome and just drive over to Forno Tony for an authentic taste of Roman style pizza and Italian fare! Parking is free and abundant in the lot next to the building. There is a large window which you can see the chefs/bakers at Forno Tony press out fresh pizza doughs. Expect a line but it is worth it! The pastry case is not huge so don't expect a wide array of options, just a handful of pastries that are excellently executed. The pizzas are cut in the Roman style with large scissors and you pay by weight. Seems like they do a lot of different specials and experimentation with toppings. I would suggest getting a simple slice like a tomato/cheese and a more indulgent slice. The simple slice will show you Forno Tony gets the simple things done right. Crispy bottom with a focaccia/soft like interior dough. High quality olive oil and seasoned perfectly with salt to elevate the few but quality ingredients. *I would recommend eating the pizza shortly after purchase or the day it's bought and warm! This is not a pizza that should be reheated the next day or eaten cold!* Did not have a chance to try the Gelato but it is made in house and looked delicious! This shop is open Thursday-Saturday. The team here clearly is putting love into their food and genuinely is baking up some of the best tasting Pizza anywhere! read more

See all

The best Italian food ever. There is nothing equal in Rochester. The pizza and focaccia was so authentic! I could not make up my mind which ones so we brought home more than one each and still raving about all! Then there are the pastries and Gelato take a punto or 2 home with you . Get the Sfogliatelle they are true heaven with a nice cup of espresso ! Tony & Ryan you need to open up on the west and south side everyone needs to experience your fantastic menu ! Auguri read more

Forno Tony - Ryan serving the gelato - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, New York

Gelato....fabulous. Pizza....fabulous, we tried spinach, almost just like I ate when I was growing up, it was lacking sauce on top of the top crust. We tried one with prosciutto and another with veg and ricotta. My only feedback was our server stacked the ricotta ones in the box, literally the only ones that would stick to each other and screw up the topping. Tried the maritozzo which was very underwhelming. read more

Forno Tony - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, New York

Meh. I had high expectations for this place since my Italian neighbor recommended it. Honestly, I didn't think of it much after sampling the gelato and trying the Tiramisu. The dessert was so bad, the lady's fingers were dry and haven't soaked up the coffee liquor at all. I did not like the flavor of any of the gelatos I've tasted either. Won't be back! read more

A little difficult to find, but what a hidden gem in our city! After it taking a few trips around the building to figure out the location, my friend and I stopped in to give Forno Tony's a try. As soon as you walk inside the building the delicious scent of pizza, sauce. and yumminess hits you in the face, and it's wonderful!! We went around noon and it was a Friday afternoon- the place was packed!!! Hit or miss with the friendliness of the staff members- but the ones that were nice made my experience there 1000% better (of course). It was a very busy time so understandable. Pizza was good, desserts were wonderful!! I will be back for more and also to try the gelato! read more

See all

Wow - this place took me back to Italia and to summer days with my grandma. The flavors, texture, seasoning, everything is perfected. We tried a carbonara inspired slice and I would've never thought of making that into a pizza but it works so well. But the piece that really did it for us was the tomato, basil and burrata. I could picture my grandma sitting with me cutting a warm tomato out of the garden and preparing a classic tomato salad for lunch or waking up in Italia to the smell of my aunt cooking at 6am to prepare a massive family lunch later in the day. What you would think of a basic, easy to make slice, has been so perfected. From the fresh tomato, to the creamy burrata, the drip of great olive oil and just enough salt and basil to make all of the flavors pop together. You know a place is great when a "basic" is one of their best products. Pastries were great too but I'll be dreaming when I can make my next visit back to Italia and my family for a while after eating that pizza. read more

Forno Tony - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

Amazing!!! Words can't express my love for Forno Tony. It is to die for. Every single pizza is epic! The Gelato is epic! The family that runs it is so nice. It really is my favorite place in Rochester. read more

Know before you go that they are likely to be busy- use your time in line to see and hear what is available and make your decisions before being asked for your order. They cut/slice the pizza to the size you want and you pay by weight. You can have the slices warmed ( or not) with or without added olive oil ( definitely a yes). Folks are friendly and efficient. read more

Forno Tony - Four slices trimmed to fit the box- $18.88. - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, New York

We tried out several of their types of pizza and thought they were all extremely flavorful. Line was long but it moved fairly quickly.

A Slice of Rome in Rochester If you're planning a trip to Italy, make this your first stop. This pizzeria offers the most authentic Italian pizza I've tasted in the United States--and I split my time between the U.S. and Italy, so that's saying something. My nephew owns a similar-style pizzeria in Rome, and the flavors here instantly transported me back. Every pizza I've tried has been unique and memorable, but the Pizza Bianca con Mortadella stands out as my personal favorite. It's pure nostalgia in every bite. The gelato is equally impressive--smooth, rich, and absolutely true to its Italian roots. And the desserts? As authentic as you'll find outside of Italy. The staff are warm, attentive, and genuinely welcoming. You can feel the pride they take in bringing a real taste of Italy to Rochester. Hats off to the owners for creating something truly special. Ce' solo la Roma. Daje! read more

See all

Sweet pizza Jesus. You do NOT know what you are missing until you visit Forno Tony for unique flavor combos, beautifully thin crust baked to perfection, and the answer to your every pizza craving. Being able to order 1 or several of different pizza slices is such a win!! Gelato and pastries are a nice addition, both fresh and delicious. We ordered so many slices and couldn't wait to try them... bonus that their pizza boxes fit nicely on a car dashboard. Go early for the selection - 10am is NOT too early for this pizza. read more

Forno Tony is a gem! It's fairly new but I think it will become a Rochester staple in no time :) It is located in an unassuming warehouse on university street, next to Black button distillery. While the hours are limited, it makes up for it with its amazing selection of Italian baked goods, pizza, and sandwiches. I opted for a peach and pistachio flavored baked good which a lot of flavor without being overly sweet. The bread was addictive - not dry, very light and fluffy. We also got a breakfast sandwich and pizza bagel type dish. Everything was absolutely delightful. Server was really helpful and patient while we tried to pick out which baked good to indulge in. We learned that the Buffalo Bills had made a stop there recently and a signed jersey hangs on the wall! They also offered gelato which we will definitely take advantage of it some point. I believe they are opening up from 6 to 9 PM in addition to their regular hours but only in the summer time. If you want the non-breakfast style food and want to try their pizza I would come after 11 AM as they do not serve it until then. Regardless the breakfast options alone are to die for. We will be making another stop very soon. read more

See all

Fresh and gourmet pizza. Get there early!! One of a kind place for pizza in Rochester. Has to be the best. Gelato is top tier. read more

Forno Tony - Pizza and gelato - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, New York

Pizza is delicious!! Using flour imported from Rome, with the higher quality ingredients, this pizza has so much flavor and a lighter feeling after eating. When I eat regular pizza, I feel the weight of it afterwards. So many flavors, delicious, and I felt great after. They also have gelato that was creamy and refreshing. Mmm! They've been open for a year and I have a feeling they'll outgrow their current space soon enough! Next door to @blackbuttondistilling on University Ave, you need to check this place out when you're over that way! read more

See all

Amazing pizza and other Italian stuff. Cook gelato flavors. Such nice staff. Once you're through the line, quick to cash out. very Italian. Love. read more

I've been here a few times to pick up some pizza and pastry. At the beginning the wait was a bit much and they have limited hours and that's ok. They make a good product and I believe they also do gelato. Nice place and they staff is pleasant Parking is available in the lot down the way. read more

Literally the best. I went in late in the day and they had ran out of pizza and most if their other food items. When I walked up to the counter the owner made me a special sandwich. I really appreciated it. read more

Amazing real Italian pizzas and pastries! Really small place if business and was not easy to find but so worth going! Just check their hours before you go! read more

Excellent hidden gem with made from scratch Italian treats. Their pizza and pastries are excellent. I will be back to try the gelato. I hope they move again to an even bigger location ad this was kind of packed read more

I came in for a 2 slices of Roman pizza. I came out with 4 slices, 6 pastries, 4 pastries for friends, a whole apricot tart for 8 people, and some gelato. The photos online tell half the story. Once you eat what you got, you'll be back to try the things you didn't get. read more

(Pic) Need I say more? Just go. You think you're going for a sandwich. You're going to leave with so much more, don't fight it. It's OK. You'll thank yourself later. read more

Forno Tony - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, New York

This pizza shop feels like a slice of Rome with exceptional fresh simple pizzas and gelato. Never disappoints in quality and great friendly owner and staff. The shop is fun with soccer memorabilia and smells amazing. read more

Incredible food, such kind people, delicious pastries and pizza! Also had the affogato with the milk flavored gelato. Definitely will be coming back to try more! read more

See all

The pizza is fantastic! Make sure to go early in the weekend because they usually sell out by lunch.

A MUST try if you want true authentic Roman style pizza. There may be a little line to get your pizza but it's 100% worth the wait. They also just started serving gelato as well. I have non celiac gluten sensitivity and I CAN eat this pizza since he has high quality flour not from here. Check out their instagram for more info. There is a huge parking lot to the right of the building. Don't hesitate, go this week! read more

See all

We ordered cookies and tiramisu for Christmas and they were amazing. The whole family loved the tiramisu and kept talking about it. Hopefully we'll be able to order again next year! Looking forward to coming in on regular business hours on the weekends to get more treats. read more

Super food! Great sweets! Awesome gelato! Good service! Friendly staff. Not veru good seating.

We love to pick up both baked goods and pizza at Forno Tony when we get a chance. Service is usually great, even with a line and yes, it could be less expensive but it's worth it! read more

First time going here. Food was amazing. Fresh, light, amazing taste. Loved the smell of fresh pastries bro g baked. Staff were very friendly and helpful. Will be visiting again. More to try! read more

Roman style pizza and baked goods. This is a bustling family run pizzeria and bakery. The bakery opens at 9 am. You can buy pizza sold by weight from a display case starting at 11 am and the pizza has a bunch of delicious toppings. Always over order because the pizza is light and airy and you'll want to keep eating it. Take out only. I've gotten slices to go only to eat several in the parking lot. There's a convenient parking lot, apparently that's important. Open Fridays and Saturdays. read more

Unbelievable place! Unlike any pizza place/bakery you will go to. Highly recommend. But pay attention. The lady at the cash register tried to short-change us. It was not an accident. read more

Awesome. Pizza was great and had a lot of variety in desserts and gelato. Great little spot. Make sure you get there early.

Amazing! Been there twice and each time had a million great things. Their gelato is perfect. I have no idea the Italian names but the almond and olive oil cakes are great - not too sweet but dense and delicious. The pizzas are light and topped with amazingly fresh things - SO many choices! Service is always helpful. read more

We went to Forno Tony's this past weekend and I'll be dreaming of going back to this place as soon as I can! The pizza and crust was absolutely delicious. So many different variations to try. They cut the pizza with these scissors lol but you can get any size you want and try a bunch. They weigh it all at the end and you pay be weight. I will say it was a little pricey, but in the end I would definitely say it was very much worth it. They use ingredients imported from Italy and you can tell it's so good. I tried a few kinds of gelato and had the hardest time deciding all were so creamy and flavorful omg, but my favorite was the Biscoff one. You can get pints of gelato to go as well. The line took a while when we went. (It's a small family business and they are all very friendly.) But if the line is long I would recommend getting some gelato while you wait in line! Do it backwards lol :). The pastries also looked really good but by the time we go there I think a lot had sold out which probably speaks to how good and popular they were. I saw them making some pastries by hand while we were there. We also got a loaf of bread which was super crusty and delicious. 10/10 would definitely go back every time I visit Rochester and recommend everyone to try this place. It's very good. read more

Long lines but good food. More of a place to grab food to go. Most items often sell out within the first few hours they are open.