We ordered the chicken Parmesan dinner and the chicken cutlet sandwich with prosciutto. Everything was fresh and delicious. We will be back! read more

I'm Sicilian, and would die for their chicken cutlets! Food and staff are amazing. Perfect for an authentic experience. Plus, you can bring home extra goodies from their market! read more

This is a great on the go Italian market. I like to stop here after the Sunday Farmers Market and pick up a few essentials like: pasta, olive oil, wine, cheese, and even a treat. . They have hot foods too if you want to eat lunch. My favorite are the meatballs. I grabbed a couple with sauce to make with a bowl of spaghetti. They even have sandwiches, salads, and gelato. read more

Today was the Grand Opening for Eatalia Market, the new Italian Market in Waterside Place in Lakewood Ranch. It's Quaint and Cute and Perfect for It's Location In the Midst of all the Great Shops and Restaurants in This Area. It's Next Door to a Barber Shop and Right Around the Corner You Can Keep Walking to see the restaurants, boutiques, brewery, coffee shop, ice cream and more. Talk about a perfect spot. They also serve up many Italian food options, & have outside tables on the side of their building. Congrats on the new opening! What a great addition! Parking can be a bit hectic, street parking and lot parking amongst the different apartments in the area. The street parking is free, just drive around. Service was very friendly and welcoming! read more

See all

OUTSTANDING Sandwiches! We ordered the Chicken Cutlet on a Kaiser Roll and a Chicken Parm sandwich w/ chips and an Italian Orange drink. These were both absolutely fantastic! The sauce on the parm sandwich was the best we've ever had! There's some beautiful Italian products to purchase in this little store and prepared meals to go as well. Our only complaint was we had to get the sandwiches "to go" since there's just a few barstools inside at a window counter to eat at and some picnic tables outside w/ no umbrellas. It's just too hot to eat outside w/ no umbrella's. We will DEFINITELY be back! read more

Eatalia Market - Italian chips - Wine Bars Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

See all

i enjoyed the sausage and peppers, italian sub (bread was amazing) and the tricolor cake with my son- wish we had photos!! ordered online and made it very convenient to show up and eat outside, but you could also bring food to other areas of waterside and have a picnic! This would be a great place to go with a large group where you can order a variety of items and share as well. read more

We stopped into Italia Market while walking the Lakewood Ranch Farmers Market, and we're glad we did. The space is clean and modern with a large ordering counter, shelves of imported Italian goods (including a nice wine selection), and a small eat-in counter in the back. It didn't feel especially warm or "family-owned," and the staff's expressions were a bit flat. The outdoor seating could've been great had they opened the umbrellas--it was a hot, sunny day. Now the food--incredible. We tried the chicken cutlet sandwich with tomato potato chips, and the chicken Caesar cutlet. The cutlets were perfectly grilled--crispy without being greasy--and the bread was just right: soft yet sturdy enough to hold everything together. I added a bit more Caesar dressing to the sandwich, which made it even better. Half portions were more than enough, and at $12, a solid deal. And yes, the tomato chips are surprisingly delicious. A few ambiance tweaks and this place could be five stars. We'll definitely be back. read more

See all

This relatively new Italian market has wonderful service and excellent food choices. It is a very small market. It's like walking up to a meat market in New York. You order they package and you can either eat it there or take it to go. There are a couple small tables inside as well as an outdoor section with tables for eating outside. The very picky Italian guys with us opted for chicken parm and Italian sausage subs. I was very impressed with the fact that they all liked what they got. We did some wine tasting, and although I don't recall the names; there are a couple of decent choices of red. I ordered a couple of meatballs. They were so tender & delicious. I'm looking forward to going back and trying some other items. read more

I have been a regular of this location since they open, I don't swing by very often, but, I'm always there every month, is the only place in town that I've been able to find REAL guanciale for my carbonara pasta's, this place is great overall food and service are always amazing. If you ever come to this market you should try out their chicken cutlet sandwich :) read more

Was super excited to finally tryout this Market. Ambiance :small "italian" deli Service: Staff took order fast. No interaction ,no explanation of anything. We're not friendly. Didn't have anything in the cheese fridges . Maybe we visited on a delivery day. read more

We were a bit skeptical about going here, because we felt the prices were a bit high for a deli sandwich. However, after reading the reviews, stating how delicious the meats & cheeses are, we decided to try. Couldn't have been happier that we went. Indeed, the sandwiches are mouth-watering, and HUGE. I wish I had a ruler to measure the size of the sandwich. Got the Italian salad with a side chicken cutlet - delicious and moist. HIGHLY recommend this place. Eat at the Waterside Pavillion; light breezes and beautiful view. BYOBeverage, ample free parking. read more

See all

Selection is minimal. Clean space and pleasant staff. Items are on the expensive side. Youthful staff. read more

Stopped in for a sub a few days ago and it was hands down best sub I've had in a long time. I got the chicken cutlet and getting it again today. Amazing price for value. The market and store is so cute and has all authentic Italian items as well as a really cool self serve olive oil stand. I wish I lived in waterside so I could go every day. read more

Delicious . My husband brought home the eggplant sandwich & a chicken sandwich today, they were huge & the pizza was fantastic. We will be back often & share with our neighbors! read more

Stopped in the New Eatalia market in waterside to pick up a few things you just can't get at any market. So glad we did! We were greeted by Jordan and his very friendly staff. We also ordered a couple of Subs to go and 2 side meatballs. Everything was delicious, I had half chicken parm and my wife had half spicy sausage with Broccoli Rabe,both were delicious. The meatball was also delicious. The trick is that the bread is shipped in from the Bronx NY.we will be back! PS.. sorry no pic of the sausage sub, my wife inhaled it..lol read more

See all

I don't usually get excited about food, but the chicken cutlets, bread, meatballs and sausage were phenomenal at Eatalia Market. Not only did I have it for dinner last night, but then had the leftovers for breakfast this morning! It was that delicious. read more

Just got back from summer in Manhattan so I missed the opening of Eatalia Market, today was my first visit. I ordered the chicken cutlet because that's what everyone said was good. Well, I have to say it was amazing. Flavor was truly mouthwatering delicious. Full Hero (NYers don't know what a grinder is) was very large and oh so tasty. I had half for lunch and saved the other half for dinner. What I also liked is I was able to pick up some jarred Caponata and Jarred Bruschetta. Although I would prefer fresh I was happy because the Paolo's brand is quite good. Also picked up some Sopressata and some Regg Parm. I hope they take this concept even further and are able to expand on the Italian specialties. In terms of the staff, perfectly fine to take and prepare an order and then ring it up, but they are not trained on the product suite. I knew more about what they carry than the staff did but maybe over time training will prevail. If they want to attract and keep the New York foodies who know the food have no problem paying their prices, the staff will need to display the same passion for the products that the customers do. In terms of Ambiance, not sure what people would expect from what is predominantly a take out place with some seating. It is what it is, clean, open space, easily accessible. I didn't expect white linens and silverware. LOL. Overall I would highly recommend the place. I will be going back to try more of their offerings and hope they prevail in Lakewood Ranch which has manifested into having a very selective customer base with high expectations. read more

Really good. Had the spicy Italian grinder and Tuscana soup. Both were excellent! I'd recommend it.

Great sandwiches that are big enough for two. Sell some nice Italian products good for Sunday cooking.

A World-Class Dining Experience at Eatalia From the moment I walked into Eatalia at Waterside, I knew I was in for something special. The atmosphere was incredibly welcoming--warm lighting, elegant decor, and a vibe that made it feel like more than just a meal; it was an experience. Jordan greeted me with a genuine smile and asked if it was my first time. It was, and he made me feel right at home. He helped me choose the chicken parm, and wow--what a recommendation! It was absolutely delicious, perfectly cooked, and bursting with flavor. Honestly, I could eat it every day. The entire staff was attentive and clearly passionate about making sure every guest has an amazing experience. It's rare to find a place where the food, service, and ambiance all come together so seamlessly. I can't wait to come back and enjoy another little piece of Eatalia. Highly recommended! read more

Very bad customer service. Menu was not easy to read and we were never greeted. I talked to one of the employees and asked some questions about their menu and they were very snobby and rude. Made me feel uninvited and not welcome. I just left after asking the questions since obviously my presence was not welcome. Would not recommend. read more

They're meatballs and their meatballs Subs and basically everything that they have there I love There was nothing I did not like Even my two year old eat there And loved it read more

We first went to Eatalia Market on July 6th and immediately excited to find the various foods being sold. Although our time was limited by my guests for pre-Dinner cocktails, all of us found your Citterio Sweet Capocollo and Pepperoni and your Columbus Peppered Salame were extremely delicious! We are now looking forward to our next visit to Eatalia Market and to expand our delights for your Italian salamis, sausage, etc. Rick read more

Great food but 25 minutes for a salad is a bit much of a wait time. Could have gotten from any of the restaurants in Waterside.

I am Italian and just moved here from up North. I ordered eggplant parm sandwich and chicken cutlet with prosciutto and provolone. The roll was good, but the rest was horrible. The thin cutlet was dried out, the prosciutto was so small I couldn't taste it, and you could taste nasty oil, not olive oil. The whole sandwich was dry and anemic. The eggplant was just as bad. Couldn't really detect any cheese, nasty seed oil taste and no crispy breading. The sauce was ok. Overall it was terrible. read more

My son and I stopped in to grab dinner and the owner and staff were friendly and absolutely the best to talk to. Loved the food recommendations. We had the chicken parm sub and I simply had the a chicken cutlet sub and both were absolutely delicious. We started with an arancini ball. If you haven't had one; must try. Ended with the pistachio cheesecake. If you haven't been, it's a must try!!! The owner is genuine and has put love into his food! It shows. read more

Way over-priced. Close to $20 for a whole sub. Employees not familiar with authentic Italian sausage called 'Nduja, assumed we were referring to andouille which is not Italian. No chairs, environment was uptight and boujie. Ordered crispy bread on 2 of the subs, both were soft. Paid $7 for beef cutlet that was left out of the order. Subs were good, but could get the same at one of the local NY pizza places for half the price and without the bougieness. read more

The chicken parm and Italian meatballs were so good, they were totally worth straying from our usual lunch spot--this place might just become our new weekly tradition! The service was warm, friendly, and super helpful, which made the whole experience even better. We're already eyeing the meatball sub for next time--it's one of my boyfriend's favorite lunches, and judging by how flavorful and homemade the meatballs tasted, I have no doubt it'll be amazing. You can really tell they're made from a legacy recipe! read more

As soon as you walk in store the smell hits you and it smells fresh and makes you want to order everything off the menu! It was open and pleasing to the eye. There was a small shopping area to look through while you waited for your sandwich. The food was picture perfect and the taste was amazing! The service was friendly and great! I am already looking forward to my next trip! Stop in, you won't regret it!! read more