I was very excited when I got the chance to try this place out with my friends. However, I was quite disappointed as the pasta wasn't what I expected. We paid $26 per person to try three different kinds of pasta (pasta tasting), and to my surprise, all three were mainly cheesy with no meat. This would fit well for those who are vegetarian since it's mainly cheese and one with beets in it. We also ordered bruschetta; it was alright. My other friend ordered a salad and pizza. To our surprise, her meals were bigger and cheaper than what we ordered. As for service, to me it was neither good nor bad. read more

See all

This Eataly is quite small, it has a restaurant section that serves and lunch special and the regular menu. The hot food section is quite extensive and they can heat up your meal on request. Lots of bar seating facing the street, some tables inside by the food area. The goods selection is minimal due to the space, but the basics things are available here. Nice place to stop by in the CF Shops at Don Mills. Lots of parking in the area. read more

Eataly - Don Mills - Grocery Near Me - North York, Ontario

Friend and I went for a brunch and it was our first time trying out Eataly restaurant! They offer both brunch and regular lunch menus which was great. Entire area is aesthetically pleasing, eye catching, and very colourful. Overall the service was good- server was kind and polite. However they were very slow. We had to look for our server to get the bill. Overall, foods were amazing, great atmosphere, neat, clean, and pretty place to explore. read more

See all

Food: 3/5 Service: 4/6 Ambiance: 5/5 This is a really nice looking restaurant. The decor is light woods, red accents, green upholstered banquette seating, and chairs. It's very spacious. There is a store at the front where you can buy soaps from italy, pasta, etc. At the back is the restaurant. My friend took me here for lunch. I ordered the patata fritta (fried potatotes) and spaghetti pomodoro. My friend ordered the frito misto. We both just had water to drink as it was a very hot & humid day. The potatoes were good, if a little salty. The spaghetti was very salty for my taste. My friend liked the frito misto but didn't realize it would be breaded as she's on a keto diet. So she only ate a little of it. We were both full after our food so we didn't order dessert. Service was okay. Our waitress was nice but I found it hard to understand her accent. The manager came by & checked how we liked our meal which was also nice. All in all the service was good. But I didn't really enjoy the food. I would be willing to try a different dish though, to see if it was just the dish I ordered that I didn't like. read more

See all

I visited Eataly Don Mills on a Wednesday night around 6pm without a reservation. There were many open tables but the hostess insisted we could only sit at the bar. We ordered the Tagliere Salumi e Formaggi to start. The board surprisingly came with a lot of meat and only three small pieces of cheese. It also only came with two pieces of bread. For $36, I would not order this again unless it is updated. I recommend the restaurant to add more cheese, including a soft cheese. For our mains, we got the cavatelli on the main menu (the Easter menu cavatelli was unavailable, sadly) and a pizza whose name has escaped me. Both were delicious! The pizza dough was perfectly soft and chewy. The pasta was incredibly flavourful and so unique with the broccoli and sausage combo. All in all, I would recommend visiting to try their pizzas and pastas - just know you're paying a bit more for the Eataly atmosphere. read more

See all

Came here after a quick shopping. Food is OK, you can shop too but I find the items expensive. Service is good. Friendly staff. read more

Eataly - Don Mills - Grocery Near Me - North York, Ontario

See all

First time at the Eataly location at Shops at Don Mills. The grocery store part is actually quite small compared to the Yorkville location, but the restaurant was spacious and nicely decorated. Staff were kind and attentive with their service. The appetizers came out quickly, followed by the pasta. Everything tasted good and met our expectations, but the beef in the pasta was a bit dry. read more

Eataly - Don Mills - Grocery Near Me - North York, Ontario

See all

I was really excited to check out Eataly, but this Don Mills location really fell short of my expectations. It's definitely smaller than the other locations and does not have as many counters as the other ones. It simply has a full restaurant and a quick service pastry and coffee bar on the other side. In between there are minimal pantry items, a small open air fridge section and a singular fridge of fresh pasta pre-portioned. There is also only one singular self service register. Overall, I wasn't too impressed and it's highly unlikely I will be back to this location. read more

Eataly - Don Mills - Grocery Near Me - North York, Ontario

Went a couple weeks ago on a Friday evening with friends and with reservations. The place was nice and I've bought items from their store before but never tried from their restaurant. They had a 2 course menu for about $38, which only included one app (bruschetta) and a pasta (creamy with cheese). Because they didn't have other options we just ordered one set, a pizza, the fresh cheese app with tomatoes and seafood pasta with tomato sauce. Our favourite dish was the seafood pasta, the pasta with just cheese should be eaten hot because once it gets cold it is a bit hard. The pizza was good and crust was soft and bready. I think I had higher expectations of this place but everything seemed okay, nothing that wowed us. Esp with the higher prices and what we got, I don't think I would eat here again. The fresh burrata was good, but doesn't come with any bread or crackers so they ask you if you want to add it on top. Overall, I would say it is good but not exceptional as the prices does not reflect what you can usually get at a good Italian restaurant. read more

See all

Pizza was ok, but nothing special, especially for Toronto. Thing that bugged me most was that I asked for no cheese on pizza (allergy) which they complied, and then offered a dip/sauce instead (server didn't indicate there would be an additional charge). Unfortunately, it wasn't really suitable as a pizza dip (maybe it was mayonnaise?), so I left it behind. Bill came and they'd charged $3 for this TINY sauce. It was already a $26 pizza AND they saved the cheese. Why do these places nickel-and-dime customers like this? So over $100 for 3 pizzas at lunch, including tip ('cause we're not jerks) . Anyway, we won't return. read more

I've been here twice. The ravioli was decent, but it wasn't very filling considering it was a main and the portion wasn't much. I tried the tiramisu which I had high expectations for - taste wise it was one of the better tiramisu's I've had, but wayyyy too much cream. The ratio was off. During another visit, my friend and I tried the sphagetti and we both mentioned it tasted like something we could make at home with minimal effort. Our other friend ordered a pricier pasta which tasted pretty good (I can't remember the name though), but again very small portions. read more

Eataly - Don Mills - Ravioli - Grocery Near Me - North York, Ontario

See all

. booked online using opentables for a party of 8 . the food overall everyone rated super yummy and the waiteress gave a very nice experience . cocktails arent to my personal liking . we booked for a friends birthday and they gave her a tiramisu! very kind . checking in our reservation at 8:15, we had to wait another 5/10mins for our table . the waiter took my order of pizza wrong but handled it very well (some miss communication, she apologized and brought the right one out) . our table came up to $400 . the bread appetizer was also questionable . fun for a first time at this location, maybe not for frequent visits read more

See all

We went at the end of July to Eataly We had reservations for the Taste of Eataly that evening Eataly is part restaurant/part market The restaurant area is extremely spacious with lots of seating The market area is smaller than the location down in Yorkville It offers take out food like pizza, paninis, and dessert items The market itself was offers various food products from Italy Most of the items are highly priced so do expect to pay a price if you are getting a bottle of sauce and pasta or even oil and balsamic vinegar The restaurant is nice The meal was okay My hubby enjoyed his pasta The bruschetta was good My salad was okay....not the best but decent enough Service was a bit slow there which was a bit of a let down I would definitely come again for the market area to try some of their foods Not sure about the restaurant but we will see read more

See all

Visited the new Eataly at Shops at Don Mills for lunch today on Sunday. Not bad, many seats available, but to be sure you can make reservations via OpenTable App/website. The main Eataly market area is small compared to other locations, they have self serve checkout for the market area which was nice. The restaurant I first thought was a small area, but there's two sides of the restaurant. We had a few kids in our party and they ordered from the kids menu which gave a choice of pasta or pizza. The pizza they allowed different shapes such as classic round, shape of a heart or shape of a bunny. Adding extra toppings cost a nominal amount per topping. I ordered the PEI Striploin with arugula and Crispy Potato. The Striploin I asked for medium rare, and it was served exactly like that. The Striploin tasted really good and I enjoyed it very much. The crispy potato was interesting as I've never had a potato in such a style before and was absolutely delicious. read more

See all

I ordered a too good to go order from them and they packed me some stale sandwiched that seemed like it was from the day before and the deli meat tasted rancid read more

We went this evening to Eataly at the Shops on Don Mills It recently opened months ago This spot is known for being a market/restaurant The market sells a wide variety of Italian goods from wines and beers to various pasta and sauces to counters that serve up everything from big sandwiches to a wide array of Italian desserts They had an event this evening called Taste of Eataly They have a $29 two course Prix fix menu that offers an appetizer and either pasta or pizza main I started with the bruschetta It was super yummy....loved the sauce and the burrata underneath which made it quite tasty I had the tonnarelli cacio e Pepe It was really good....a really solid cacio e Pepe pasta dish done good I also bought a focaccia in the store and ate it to go It was a basic focaccia with Mutti tomato sauce on it Super yummy My wife had the insalate Verdi with chicken and enjoyed her meal Her Diet Coke was from Italy and had a bit of chinotto taste to it like a Brio The ambiance is casual mixed with upscale My only knock is that service was slow It took somebody from the bar to come and serve us as the person who was supposed to serve us disappeared Otherwise it was a nice meal and I will definitely go back to try one of those salivating guiges and desserts read more

See all

I swung by with my daughter to grab a slice of pizza for my daughter on a cold wintry afternoon. This was our first time visiting the Don Mills location and I was happy to see that it was well stocked with spreads, pasta sauces, pasta, cheeses, and more. Since we were in a rush, we grabbed a slice (or should i say a square) of Margherita pizza and my daughter absolutely loved it. She is somewhat of a pizza connoisseur and she thoroughly enjoyed that Margherita, devouring the whole slice right down to the fragrant basil leaves. I am looking forward to bringing her back to try out their pasta and maybe next time I'm in a rush for a quick vite in the area, I would like to grab one of their delicious looking sandwiches for the road. read more

This review is for the restaurant. As Eataly recently opened at Shops at Don Mills, some friends and I decided to come by for dinner. We had a reservation and were promptly seated. After placing our orders the waitress asked if we wanted all our food to come at the same time. We requested to have our appetizers come first. Unfortunately the first thing that came was my friend's pizza. We told the server we requested the appetizers first and he seemed confused so we just accepted the pizza. The appetizers showed up afterwards, but the mains took quite a while to come out, especially as my friend already finished their pizza. For appetizers we had the charcuterie board and the fritto misto di mare. The charcuterie was decent, however the seafood in the fritto misto di mare was lacking flavour. Our mains were lacking as well. I got the ravioli and the pasta was still hard. The pizza was soggy. The squid ink pasta was lacking flavour. The lasagna was however decent. We also got tiramisu for dessert which was probably the highlight of the meal. Unfortunately rest of the experience was pretty disappointing. read more

See all

The café and restaurant have nice decor, but I don't think their food is worth the hype, specially the pizza. The service is not good at this location. read more

See all

I came to Eataly Don Mills for the summerlicious menu; the lemon pasta did not disappoint, but the fried artichoke was more fried than artichoke. The saving grace of the latter dish was the dip that came with it. The interior is beautifully done with high ceilings and cute little floral arrangements at each table. It was busy for the summer and was reasonably loud given the number of people dining in. The service was good for the number of people; it was efficient and prompt. I wouldn't go out of my way for this specific location, but I would dine at an Eataly again if I was nearby. read more

Eataly - Don Mills - Grocery Near Me - North York, Ontario

I came here with friends to try the summer set course. We had booked a table ahead of time as we went on a Friday night. From the set course I ordered the deep fried rice balls and a pasta in truffle butter sauce. My friend ordered the lasagna, fried artichokes and burrata pizza. The waiter was super nice and constantly made sure our table was good on a busy Friday night. I love how in the summer they have open windows to let the fresh air in and make it feel like a patio. read more

See all

It was risky going on a Friday night to a new location without a reservation. We said that we would eat at the bar and they took us right away. It was amusing to watch drinks and desserts be prepared behind the bar. Service was good. We ordered: Aperol spritz - solid Tomato foccaccia - maybe a bit oily, but tasty Pizza with ham, olive and artichoke - crust had a nice chew but was very floppy in the middle Halibut - the star of our meal. Excellent. Panna cotta - delicious hazelnut flavour topped with crumbled biscotti Americano - tiny but perfect I would go again to get more halibut. The takeout area had casual seating with pizza squares, dessert and gelato to be had as well as prepackaged snacks. read more

I have been sitting on this review for weeks. I actually went on opening weekend and had such a mediocre experience I felt bad writing about it. I have been to many Eataly around the world and have always thought the quality was high but pricy for what it is. It serves its purpose. I can accept a premium when the service is good and the food as well. Unfortunately this location had terrible service, from the host to the waiter to the kitchen. Reservations were not respected, we all had to wait in line as if we had walked in, meaning 30-45 minutes after your reservation time. The servers had no idea about the food and the table Next to me sent their meal back twice! Their chicken was cold twice! We had a pizza and rapini. I ordered red wine and they brought the wrong bottle. The pizza was mediocre and the rapini were burnt, bitter and completely inedible. I want more higher end restaurants uptown and in the east end, I had every hope for this location to fill that void, but instead I felt put off, like the Don Mills community just did not warrant the quality and service provided in Yorkville. read more

The new location for Eataly opened and I have to say it's a bit underwhelming. A fraction of the size of their downtown location. Offerings wise is much less than what they offer. Overall... not worth the trip honestly. read more

Eataly - Don Mills - Grocery Near Me - North York, Ontario

See all

Took them 45 min to crack 2 eggs and sear one slice of bacon! The pancake was full of butter which gave me headache afterwards! There are a lot of good restaurants in the vicinity for having your brunch with better quality and more reasonable turnaround and not-smelling fresh fish in your background :( read more

I have been to Eataly a few times now, but mainly for dinner. Today I decided to try it for brunch & it was very good. Food & service were both good. Nice restaurant for breakfast, lunch or dinner. read more

See all

The good was extremely mediocre. Eataly is definitely going downhill lately. The pizza and cake were similar to a one star restaurant

Came to the new Eataly in Toronto to check out their summer menu. I've been to a few eatalys around the world now and this has got to be one of the smallest stores. There is a small grocery section next to the prepared foods area. Then it leads to a small restaurant. That's right, there is only one small restaurant in this eataly. It wasn't very impressive compared to their counterparts globally. We ordered two pastas for lunch along with a rustic bread and salad appetizer. All the dishes were made with care and simply let the fresh ingredients shine through. Like most eatalys, this store does a good job on the food. Other than its small size, this location serves excellent food and service was satisfactory. The plus for this location is that there is free parking. Overall, it's a place I can see myself visiting again! read more

Absolutely garbage!! The pasta sauce taste bad and the ground beef they use is dry and the noodles is hard. The steak was rough and the chicken was so dry. The worse is the server has no experience. Did not change our plate from appetizers and napkin was taken away after main meal and no other napkin was provided for desert. Management ask us to leave after 2 hours of seeing. We will NEVER come back again and hope others will see this review!!!! read more

Masih P was our server and he was great. The pasta and the food was good. Dessert was amazing read more

See all

This is what happens when no thought goes into ingredients and the staff is punching a clock. Cannot get over poor service and mundane food. read more

I was looking forward to having an Eataly that is more accessible outside of downtown Toronto. This Eataly is an utter disappointment. It is small, and has no selection. The gelato is located in a small ice cream cart and they do not have cannoli. The person I asked seemed to indicate that they will never have cannoli. Don't waste your time. Wait a year or two and hopefully an Eataly with full selection will open in the Eaton Centre as opposed. read more

Went for lunch with my wife. Started with Bruschetta, it was like rubber. Went onto the Pasta, Tagliatelle Alla Bolognese that came and both my wife's and mine had all the noodles stuck together. For an Italian place you think they would know how to cook pasta. Lunch for two $170, very pricey. I won't be returning. We were told the wait was 15 minutes that turned out to be 30 minutes but could not understand as when we were seated we saw 15 open tables, I think they are just trying to create lines to try to get people in. For a so called Italian restaurant this place is worse than a food court. And the cook is likely a short order guy that is just learning. read more