Highly recommended to us and we weren't disappointed. I LOVE enchiladas and mine was delicious. Loved the sauce. Can't remember what my husband had but he loved it. Very friendly and efficient staff. We will most definitely be going back! read more

El Pueblito Mexican Restaurant - Cheese and onion enchiladas, rice and refried beans. - Mexican Near Me - Greeley, Colorado

Really yummy, food was delicious. My only compliant is I ordered combination fajitas in a to-go order and I only received two tortillas for my entire meal & I couldn't go back because I arrived when they were about to close. read more

I went to El Pueblito on 10th st in Greeley on 4/27/26. The food was excellent! Which is why we go there. However, the service was the worst we have ever received!!!! The young rather thin blond waitress and her female coworker were more concerned about their phones than they were about taking care of their customers! 1. our order was not correct when she brought it. then she thought it was more important to wait on several other customers before she made an effort to take care of the items she forgot. 2. she never came back to check and see if everything was okay and/or if we needed anything else. when she finally did pry herself free from her phone and came back to the table I ask for a refill on my glass of water. After 15 mins. I paid my bill and left. still no water!!! I can't tell you how disappointed I am. I doubt that I will go back! That's really a shame since I go there at least twice a month to eat. there were other customers in the restaurant who received the same kind of service. Perhaps employees in your restaurant shouldn't be allowed to be on their phones while they work, since they can't even offer what would be considered fundamental customer service. Sincerely, David Schott vlab3867@gmail.com read more

First off the food is outstanding as are their Margaritas and fast friendly service in a small nice clean atmosphere. If you haven't been here in quite a while a while, El Pueblito is keeping up with related restaurants, Rubens & Chelos. read more

Took our son and his fiancée there last night. As usual, the food and service was excellent. We have been going for years and have never been disappointed. read more

We were in Greeley for our daughter's volleyball tournament. My daughter surprised us by wanting to try El Pueblito vs the big wrap burrito chain. Reviews looked good and it was on the way back to I 25. Cute place with hand made booths and friendly staff. We were here for lunch, but want to come back for dinner; being it looks fun with lights are strung around the restaurant. Lunch special with lots of options. We had Grilled fajitas with steak, fajitas with chicken, and shredded burrito and a taco. Everything was delicious. Fair prices and good size portions. Warm chips and good salsa came with. Good vibe. read more

This is one of our favorites, but, I think I prefer the Loveland location. Recent visits to the Greeley location have been disappointing. I ordered and received the wrong food today. I went with it because they were busy. I went to use the ladies room and it was out of order. Just not the best visit. read more

Cute little place with great food at a reasonable price. Decor is light and airy and the atmosphere is friendly.

The food was good and the ambiance was really good. The service was a tad slow but nothing too bad. Would likely come again.

Great service! Great food! Seriously, best Mexican dinners. We've been there twice, ordered different meals each time. Both times the meals were fantastic! We plan to come back again and again. read more

Stopped by for a to-go order. "Strongest margaritas in town" was advertised, but definitely not delivered on. The waitress poured in sweet and sour drink mix plus a minuscule amount of tequila to make up the drink. While I sat to wait I noticed behind the bar was cluttered and a waitress arranged a sopapilla with her hands/no gloves. Food was pretty good, but like so much else these days, overpriced. Waitresses were good-natured. read more

El Pueblito Mexican Restaurant - Margarita. - Mexican Near Me - Greeley, Colorado

A hidden gem, for sure. If you are looking for great-tasting Mexican food, El Purblito should be at the top of your list. The service is excellent and attentive. The seating area is a bit small, though so get there early. Their green chili is on point! read more

This is a small restaurant with awesome parking. We have seen it grow with an amazing service and delicious food. Today, I forgot my box containing left over food on the table. This young man who manages the restaurant, brought it out to my car. Thank you. read more

How we managed to live in Greeley and never try this place before now is beyond me. I guess we just didn't look at other places to try once we found a Mexican Restaurant we really liked here. The chips and salsa were good. I got the Special Nachos but had them add mushrooms in place of the meat and my hubby and son each got an order of enfrijoladas and shared a side of refried beans. We all enjoyed our food and the service was good. Nice to have another restaurant to choose from. read more

See all

Ordered the Super Fajitas and the meat portions were very generous. However it came with two flour tortillas and lettuce. I can't eat guacamole, but there was no sour cream, cheese or picot de gallo. Very bland fajitas! Service was mediocre at best. I was never asked about a refill for my beverage and the cheese sauce I ordered to enjoyed with my chips before the meal arrived with the meal. Not sure I'll give them a second chance read more

I came here not knowing what to expect. When my boyfriend and I walked in, the restaurant was filled with people. We were fortunate enough to get a table right away. They served us chips with salsa which was very good. Service was slow, which is the reason for the 4 stars but otherwise everything else was great!!! I ordered the beef nachos and they were very good. My boyfriend ordered the carnitas and he enjoyed them a lot. I will definitely be coming back here. read more

My wife and I had lunch here today. The shredded beef chimichanga was delicious! Good green chili and caso too. The waitress was friendly and attentive. Nice ambiance too! read more

Excellent food! Staff very friendly and helpful. Asked for some hot sauce and he brought me homemade sauce with habanero peppers. So good but so hot. Did not use much. We will be back. Our new favorite in Greeley. read more

My family's favorite Mexican restaurant, possibly favorite Greeley pick. Everyone there is super nice, the food is good, and...that's it? What else do you want? read more

I went there for the first time on a weekday around 3pm and got an excellent beef and bean burrito. There was only one other couple there at the time. Very quiet. Excellent service and food. Excellent chips and salsa. I highly recommend this establishment. read more

Food is delicious with great service. The staff is wonderful and friendly, makes you feel like family. I have yet to order an entrée that I have not thoroughly enjoyed. Lots of hot food, never cold, great taste. I have been there numerous time needless to say it is one of my favorite places to go. Great margs, drinks and red beers!!! read more

It's always delicious and has a great selection of items to choose from! One of our Mexican food favorites, even with out of town restaurants!! read more

Best Mexican food in Greeley! Alhambra with steak and shrimp is the way to go! The family is amazing and everyone working there is super helpful and friendly. read more

This restaurant is nothing short of amazing! Not only was the quality of the food incredible, but the service was off the charts amazing!! They are so accommodating that they actually made a dish that was not on the menu for me and my husband and it was off the charts amazing! We will be coming every time we are in the area! read more

We were looking to try out a new place for dinner and decided on El Pueblito. I had a chicken quesadilla and it was great. The chicken was slow cooked and flavorful and came with generous portions of guacamole and sour cream. He has the combo platter with a guacamole tostada, which is kind of a rare find. We ordered a side of green chile to share/enjoy or chips with and it was great. Our waitress and (I think) the owner helped us and were very friendly. We thought the prices were reasonable and enjoyed the food, so we will definitely be back. read more

Really great. Would be better if they kept nacho chips and taco shells separated and put together when you got it. Everything soggy but delicious. read more

Really good , I got the chipotle burrito And the sauce was so good the waitress almost had to stop me from lapping it up like a dog. The dessert of fried ice cream was also really good. They use honey on the ice cream at its sooo good. read more

Love this little hole in the wall restaurant. The food is always delicious, HOT and drenched in that delicious cheese sauce. Staff is always friendly. Never had a bad experience. Chicken chimichanga with bell peppers is the bomb.com read more

This review is written by a white boy, for white people. But if you are Mexican, then you probably already know about this place. REAL Mexican food is served here. The same as what you would find in Mexico. If you say "hot" here, you will get hot. Very authentic food. Ask about their customersappreciation card. read more

This little family run Mexican Rest. has become my favorite in Greeley. I have had many items from the large menu and all have been good to excellent. The Margs. are great and cheap, as is the guac. The place is a bit small and plainly decorated but the food is an excellent value, large portions and very flavorful. The young family staff members do a great serving guest and keeping drinks and chips refilled. This Resturant also offers text deals a few times per week of specials and features. Just sign up and you get 10% off your first complete ticket. Hard to find better. read more

Not too much to say here. Ordered food from here through 'door dash'. I ordered a combo of a taco, enchilada, and refried beans. On the order, I specifically asked if possible to make the taco with fish instead of chicken or beef and they did which was really nice of them. When the food arrives, my taco is separately wrapped which was fine but then the enchilada...wth? I'm used to actual enchiladas but apparently theirs is literally just a little corn tortilla laid flat and then they put their red sauce and the refried beans mixed together on top of it and call that a enchilada... that was a poor excuse of some sort. I mean what if I didn't want the refried beans mixed with the enchilada sauce? I was more expecting it to be on the side. The flavors of everything was good though so I enjoyed it. I just probably won't be ordering from them again because I don't know what other dishes they sloppily create. They have good horchata at least too. Their guacamole and chips aren't bad either. read more

The food was very good. Cheese sauce was delicious. I would have enjoyed the experience more had the window next to us not have been so dusty. That made me wonder about cleanliness. We had ground beef chimichangas and refried beans topped with cheese sauce and we shared an order sopapillas. read more

This is hands-down the best Mexican restaurant in Greeley. Everything is fresh and healthful, and the family-owned atmosphere is always welcoming. The Chile Colorado is absolutely the best I've had anywhere in the country--deeply flavored and smoky, all the tacos are fantastic, and portions are just right. They use vegetable oil instead of lard. I've never had a bad, or even below-average, meal there. read more

Another awful 'Mexican' place in Greeley (Ft. Collins, and Loveland). I am surprised at how terrible this place is for having actual Mexican owners. The family is friendly, the wait staff is fine, but I am disgusted by everything they plate. Their so-called 'Avocado Salad' was a bed of iceberg lettuce with a dollop of guacamole on top. It was a miserable experience. I have never seen a Mexican family eat here, so that tells you a little something. It is awful. Like Farmer's Inn, but worse, if imaginable. read more

I have to say that I'm quite surprised by the negative reviews in here. I have been to this location as well as the Loveland and Ft. Collins locations and have never been disappointed. The tomatillo sauce is amazing and the food is great! I have a very sensitive stomach and have never gotten sick off the food. This is not amercan-ized food, its authentic and wonderful. I would recommend it to almost everyone. read more

The chips were warm, which is always a nice thing. The salsa is that dark red chili - soupy style which is okay for spicyness but always flows off the chips. For the price, it wasn't all that bad. It's a small little resturant and the staff seems very nice. I did one of those combo platters (burrito, enchalada, etc...). I think to give a better review, I will have to see how a single burrito with the works holds up. read more

I also do not understand all the negative reviews. This is one of the best Mexican restaurants in Greeley. In fact, a number of years ago, they were voted the Best in Greeley. This is one of my go-to lunch places. My wife and I can have lunch, including drinks, for usually well under $20. Most lunches are $6-$8. They have excellent salsa and even better guacamole. They have an excellent lunch-size chicken fajita. I've taken many, many friends here and they all think it is great food for a great price. read more

Yum yum yum! Everything was delicious from the quesadillas to the fajitas to the margaritas. The service was excellent and kept us well taken care of. Reasonably priced, we were be disappointed. read more

The customer service here is amazing, as is the food. Our server brought us some homemade hot sauce which was great. The food and margaritas are always good, I have never been disappointed here. read more

We stopped because we would come here with my dad but I think it's under new management. I disliked everything about the food from the salsa to the carnitas. If I don't puke I think it will give me the shits. read more