I really wanted to love Elmina. I had been wanting to visit ever since I heard that Eric Adjepong (from season 16 of Top Chef) had opened a Ghanaian restaurant in DC. While I liked some thing about my dinner last weekend, ultimately, I left a little underwhelmed.
I had a reservation for one for 7:30 on a Saturday night. When I arrived, I was shown immediately to my table on the main level at the entrance to the restaurant (in front of the bar). I would have preferred to sit facing into the restaurant, but I could tell just looking at the table as I walked up to it that the height of the booth seating and the table did not match up. The booth was too high - or the table too low - and I knew my legs would just be smashed up against the underside of the table if I sat in the booth. So I sat in the chair facing the wall, which wasn't a great seat. The restaurant had cool vibes (I enjoyed the one art piece I could see and the light fixtures hanging overhead), but I couldn't see much of the restaurant.
I decided to go with the tasting menu option since it was my first visit. (FYI They offer a tasting menu for $135 or an a la carte option, and they will bring you both menus when you sit down.) With the tasting experience, you chose one first course, one second course, a third course meant to be shared between two people, and a dessert. Because that third course is shared, I wasn't sure they would let me do the tasting menu option, but they did.
Before the first course I ordered arrived, they brought a little amuse-bouche (that night, it was a raw scallop dish with a coconut broth, crispy quinoa, and a great bright herby sauce). Those couple of bites were amazing, and I got really excited about what was to come. It ended up being one of my favorite bites of the night. I was worried about how much food was coming, so I ordered one of the lighter options for my first course: hamachi crudo (with passion fruit, peri-peri oil, herbs, Serrano, radish, and corn nuts). I also really enjoyed this dish - it was fresh and spicy and had great texture.
For the second course, I got the palm nut shrimp and octopus stew. It was a small portion, which I really appreciate in a tasting menu. But it was easily my least favorite course of the meal. The flavor was great - rich, spiced, and spicy. However, the cook on the proteins was just really off. The shrimp was overcooked, but I usually find that I prefer shrimp cooked much less than others. It was chewy, but that was nothing compared to the octopus, which was one of the rubberiest cooks of octopus I've had in ages. The octopus was served as slices of tentacles, not too thick. But I found the octopus so chewy and rubbery, that I needed to cut them in half in order to be able to eat them. Cutting them was hard to do with a table knife and the steep sided bowl the dish was served in. This dish was a disappointment, because the flavor really was very good. But I just couldn't get past how badly cooked the proteins were.
For my main course, I got the Jollof Duck Pot (smoked jollof rice, tamarind glazed confit duck leg, duck breast, duck eg, shito, and roasted tomato salad. I wasn't crazy about this dish either. It was very smoky but not spicy and not well seasoned other than with smoke. I found the duck leg overcooked and the duck breast was chewy. The roasted tomato salad was cold and under seasoned, although the onion from the roasted tomato salad with a bite of rice was my favorite bite from the dish. The dish just didn't come together for me. My other note about this dish is that they served me a regular sized portion - just too much food.
For dessert, I ordered the Malva Pudding Cake (with sweet pickled apricots and vanilla gelato). It really surprised me, because I typically prefer less sweet desserts. This pudding cake is sweet, but I loved it. The texture and flavor were amazing. (My only note - and I'm aware this is annoying - is that they need to cut up the pickled dried apricots! I get it - it's pretty to serve them whole like that. They aren't pickled long enough to get soft. They are pickled enough that you don't want to eat a whole one! If they had been diced up so I could get a bit of pickled apricot with every bite, it would have been perfect!
The service was good (friendly and helpful). I was charged for a bottle of wine rather than a glass, but it was corrected when I brought it up.
I wanted to love Elmina, because I've been wanting to try and learn more about Ghanaian food, but two of the courses didn't work for me. Maybe it was an off night, because the other reviews are so good?! I'd like to give it another shot to find out, but I wasn't in love after my first visit. read more