Waiting 30 minutes (and counting) for three toasted bagels. I may never know if they are any good. Well, at least I understand the name. read more

These bagels are f-ing better than New York Bagels! Good menu, nice selection of items! They had sesame seed bagels! Three stars because the wait was long! I waited 10 minutes just to get my tea, so I'd recommend ordering online for pick-up if possible. I think the young man who took my order forgot my tea because I had to ask someone else for it while we waited for our breakfast. Lots of people in the kitchen, but they seemed very unorganized. Overall an ok place if you pre-order your food! Service and organization could use improvement. Two breakfast bagels and one tea shouldn't take 20 minutes plus. read more

Best damn bagel I've had in a while The menu has a fun variety and there are plenty of bagel flavors to choose from. Everything is made fresh on the spot, plus canned Gatorade! The perfect start to a day or partying read more

F-ing Bagels - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Islamorada, Florida

See all

Great central location. Great bagels. We did walk into some weird employee situation but happy with our food. We realize it's gotta be tough to get people to work in the keys. read more

See all

On our way to Marathon my family and I wanted a quick breakfast in the Keys. F-ing Bagels was on the way and the food looked good, so we stopped there. I got the heart attack breakfast sandwich (bacon, sausage, ham, egg, and cheese) on a cinnamon sugar bagel and a fruity pebbles bagel with cream cheese. My wife got a cinnamon sugar bagel with cream cheese and both kids got a s'mores bagel without cream cheese. Both the kids and my wife liked their bagels. My wife commented that her cinnamon sugar bagel was less messy than similar bagels elsewhere, which she appreciated. I didn't necessarily love the fruity pebbles bagel because the fruity pebbles didn't stand out like I had hoped, but it was solid. The heart attack breakfast sandwich was great. I thought the cinnamon sugar bagel complimented the meats well and I liked the thick cut bacon. I would definitely get it again if I had the opportunity. read more

See all

Honestly, fire. Drove past it in the morning and stopped randomly. It was a little bit of a wait, but the food was so worth it. read more

F-ing Bagels - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Islamorada, Florida

I'm not a huge bagel person, but I have to say, NOW I AM! I loved their bagels. I ate two full ones immediately - it probably took me 2 minutes. My kids liked the fruity pebbles and the cinnamon bagels. I liked the more plain or savory type, so that was my favorite (but they weren't around long, so I can't remember which ones they were). What a great little business! read more

We stopped by to grab breakfast on our way back to the mainland today. To begin with, the place is cozy and cute,l was greeted when I entered and it wasn't too busy at 830 am. Ragz got the egg and cheese sandwich on a croissant and I got the same thing on a bagel. I also got the hot tea. Both the croissant and the bagel are home made. I really liked the bagel texture - right amount of chew and held its structure well. I did think the bagel was a tad bit saltier than I would have liked. The egg and cheese were freshly made and the cheese actually had flavor. Ragz liked his croissant sandwich. The croissant wasn't as flaky as a commercially made one, but I'd take a home made one any day! It was very tasty in my opinion. I'm docking a star because I paid for my tea and then realized they didn't have a basic English breakfast tea - literally the one version that is universally available. I had to settle for the green tea which was alright. The lady at the counter basically told me she had no idea about the teas and I was on my own, ugh. They had weird hippie teas made out of snakeroot herbs and stuff - not my jam honestly. I will say that the place is over priced - $9 for an egg and cheese sandwich. I guess that the price you pay for being on an island. Am I likely to be back? It wasn't bad, I wouldn't mind being back if I was in the area and starving, but not likely to seek them out. read more

F-ing Bagels - Everything bagel with egg and cheese and croissant with egg and cheese - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Islamorada, Florida

REALLY good bagel shop! The sandwiches are super reminiscent of NY or CT breakfast sandwiches. The only down side was the service was extremely slow. read more

Went in here, had high hopes, but no actual cream cheese. Just spread...meh.. place looked decent, I guess I'll go down to Publix and pick up some cream cheese.... And I guess while I'm there I'll get some bagels.. read more

This small business is quite busy, but it offers delicious bagels. We thoroughly enjoyed them. Everything bagel and jalapeño bagels were delicious. Next time we will try the sandwiches. read more

We came on a very busy morning. There wasn't much room to sit or stand whether you ate or were waiting for your food to go. Bagels were running out too. We noticed that after we ordered and were waiting for our food, they were unfortunately restocking on the bagels we wanted but it was too late for us. I got the bacon, egg, and cheese on everything bagel with a side of cheesy hash brown casserole. I enjoyed my bagel but could pass on the cheesy hash brown casserole. It was just way too cheesy for me. read more

F-ing Bagels - Bacon, egg, and cheese on everything bagel - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Islamorada, Florida

See all

The other bagel spot was closed this was a second choice. We now have two bagel shops to choose from. The service was a little slower but the sandwich was delicious. I will be back. read more

F-ing Bagels - BLT on jalapeño asiago bagel - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Islamorada, Florida

Bagels were absolutely delicious- not as chewy as some NY places, but tender and tasty. We tried plain, sesame and cinnamon raisin all good. Almost $15 for 3 plain bagels seemed high, but hey we are in the keys on vacation... read more

On our way out of the keys, we stumbled upon this small breakfast spot... and could not be more satisfied. From Colton (the 11 year old who took our order, amazing) to the chef prepping food to the bagel being fresh - we couldn't recommend this place more. Parking was easily accessible from the front or side of the building, had adequate tables and chairs, and a good variety of bakery goods and bagels. We got : - cinnamon roll - iced coffee with vanilla syrup and oat milk - bacon egg cheese on croissant - ham egg cheese on bacon cheddar jalapeño bagel Everything was phenomenal and will definitely be recommending this mom&pop shop to friends & will be returning read more

See all

Delicious bagels, muffins, and cinnamon rolls! This family owned business was everything you could want on a Saturday morning and more. Good music while enjoying our breakfast, the service was exceptional. Every person in our party of 6 cleaned their plates! read more

F-ing Bagels - Bagels that melt in your mouth - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Islamorada, Florida

See all

Exceptional bagels and sandwiches with awesome service. Possibly the best breakfast sandwich I've ever had. This is a must have even in the Keys. Recommend sausage egg and cheese bagel and the scookies. The scookies are fantastic- blueberry is our fav. Great job guys! 5 stars read more

They just don't have the systems in place to crank out the food. It was a bunch of kids who were kinda panicking. Our bagels (45 minutes later) were weirdly undercooked and undertoasted, with watery cream cheese. Overall soggy and unappetizing. Not the kids' fault! Management needs to think about how to increase throughput and maintain quality. Then train the team. read more

WOW!!!!! So incredibly good and I am picky about my bagel sandwiches! So many delicious options! The people were so kind and so happy to change anything specific I didn't want on my bagel. They were so quick to bring it out and it was the cutest shop with so much seating!! Highly recommended! read more

F-ing Bagels - Hangover special - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Islamorada, Florida

Bad service, too cold, and food was an overpriced greasy burnt mess. We were the only guests, & the lady propped open the doors behind us without asking us. I told her we'd prefer the doors closed, (because it's 56 degrees outside with 35mph gusts) and she said "i guess" with a bitchy attitude and then she said they don't have any air conditioning in the back so they need it open. The temp gauge on the wall showed 69 degrees. Then My son's bagel was burnt and the hashbrown casserole was an oily mess, not edible. Never going back. read more

Wow this place was incredible, Bagel Sandwiches are incredible. Highly recommended. Reviews were absolutely right about this place. read more

F-ing Bagels - Just Incredible!! - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Islamorada, Florida

Best bagel I've ever eaten! Hot, toasted everything bagel with a smear of cream cheese- incredible. Magnificent. Indulgent. Wow!! read more

See all

Super yum!!!! I got the Rueben with everything Asiago bagel. It was large and heavenly. Hubs got the Cuban and I had a bite. Soooooo delicious. Employees very friendly as well. Super cute place and they have merch too. Even tho it's a 25 minute drive I will be coming back often! read more

F-ing Bagels - Amazing hash brown casserole and Cuban which was super huge and yum - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Islamorada, Florida

See all

Waited almost 1 hour for a bagel sandwich. At least tell your customers how long. Ridiculous. A woman waited 30 minutes for a bagel and cream cheese. read more

We walked down to this locally owned bagel shop. We had several of their very tasty bagels and iced coffees. I'd definitely recommend this shop to anyone passing through the area! I would recommend ordering online in advance to avoid the long line. read more

The only bagel game in town. I enjoyed my garlic bagel and lox. Also ordered were cinnamon raisin and cinnamon sugar butter small place With picnic seats. Owner was friendly and attentive. Everyone liked their food and it was. All made to order. The coffee was excellent. Will come back next im in Islamorada. read more

See all

Bagels were fantastic. Kids especially got a kick out of the fruity pebbles bagel- and the name of the bagel shop. ;) read more

F-ing Bagels - Outside the restaurant - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Islamorada, Florida

Stopped here for breakfast on a Wednesday morning. Unless you want to spend 30+ minutes waiting for 2 bagels, don't waste your time. It's not like they were understaffed either - there were at least 5 people in the back working. The other 4 people waiting said they had been there 30+ min as well. After reading other reviews it evident they don't staff accordingly knowing they consistently have an influx of online orders at the same time. read more

One of the worst experiences I had ever encountered, at a bagel shop. The order process was interesting to say the least. The owner couldn't understand what is a scoop out bagel (simply scoop out the bread from the inner portion of the bagel)...It took more that 30 minutes to get a one single bagel, with egg whites and bacon. When I opened the box the bagel , egg whites and bacon where spread in the container and not an assembled sandwich. Also, I had to go back to get the Chipotle mayo that I ordered, but wasn't added to the bagel. Will NEVER go back. We are from NJ and can say NY/NJ bagels are BY FAR better and this was a waste of time and money, during our vacation in Islamorada. read more

Had to wait 15 minutes for a toasted bagel, while the place was empty. Bagel was decent, but not worth the wait. Won't be back again. read more

F-ing Bagels - Store Area - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Islamorada, Florida

Don't question, just go. They are out of this world! Expensive but worth it. Blindfold in New Yorker and he will swear he's eating a bagel in Brooklyn. read more

Place is very cute. Family run and everyone was so nice. The bagels were so good. Huge bagels and fluffy with super light and creamy cream cheese. The bacon egg and cheese was super good too with thick bacon and a good amount of stuff in it. The iced coffee was half milk, and although some people's preference, was not good in our opinion (couldn't taste the coffee at all). Would return for the bagels if I lived here! read more

We are from NY and this was by far the best bagel I have ever had. When you walk into the place it is super cute and very clean. The showcase was full of all different types of bagels along with other pastries and giant cinnamon rolls. They had a chalkboard sign with all the bagel flavors along with sandwiches, drinks and other sides. The girl at the counter was very friendly and for our two bagels and two drinks it was very quick. I got the bacon cheddar bagel, toasted with butter and it was phenomenal. It was light and toasted to perfection!! It is not your typical, dense bagel that you eat and feel super bloated from. This was more like a good sourdough or Italian bread. The top and center had crispy bacon pieces and warm cheddar cheese. It was the perfect breakfast and a quick ride on our bikes from the resort we were staying at. I wish I would have taken a picture for this review- I will remember for the next time because we most definitely will return. read more

Bagels are delicious but rather pricey at $5 each, just the bagel. Older lady working the counter needs to find her smile.

The bagels in the case looked good. I was looking for coffee as the Starbucks couldn't make any do to their machine being down. My 2 cups of coffee were very thin and might as well have been folgers. read more

We stopped in and got a couple of bagels for breakfast. We ordered a s'mores bagel with cream cheese and a cinnamon raisin bagel. Both bagels were really softer than we are used to but were pretty good. Could've used more cream cheese on the bagel. Got a large OJ that was just over $5, which is a little ridiculous. This place is more of a 3.5, but I'm going with the 4 because I didn't notice a tip jar, and it's not a table service business, so it shouldn't have one. read more

See all

Great service, incredible coffee and all sorts of bagel and sandwich options. Local place with local folks doing a phenomenal job. If you're in Islamorada, this is where you should start your day! read more

Food 10/10 ( pecan pastry, iced coffee, sausage egg n cheese on a jalapeño bacon cheddar bagel) Service 10/10 (shout out Victoria at the front, sweet heart!) Ambiance 10/10 ( whole in the wall vibes ) read more

As a local, I try to support small business in the spirit of entrepreneurship, but this was not good. We were on our way down to Key West and we stopped in for a quick grab and go. Waited on line for about 5 mins before giving our order to then be told it would take at least 20 mins. We opted for simple cream cheese bagels, untoasted to save time. I guess spreading the cream cheese would've taken too much time, because we ended up doing it ourselves in the shop (took 2 minutes). Bagels were undercooked with flat, bald bottoms. Cost $14 with a small Natalie juice and me doing the labor, so not sure what I paid for here. It didn't seem busy enough to justify such a long wait and I feel this was a deterrent to clear the line or accept whatever they threw at you. Please do better next time (not for me, I won't be going back). read more

F-ing Bagels - Bald ass bagel - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Islamorada, Florida

One of the best bagels you can find in Florida! This cute little family owned Buisness makes some great food and is always my go to stop when I'm in the keys! Everyone who works there is super friendly and will help start your day in a great mood. They always have a new special so there is always something new to try. Definitely stop in if visiting or a local. You will not be disappointed. read more

See all