Ice cream is decent. Service is iffy, but I will say they seem understaffed for a nighttime rush.

We went here two days in a row because they were so friendly and the ice cream was delicious. They told us they make everything on site and don't use artificial food dyes, which was a huge bonus and made it an easy choice for ice cream. The kids all loved it and between the seven people in our group we tried at least half the flavors & none disappointed. read more

Conch Custard in Marathon is exactly what a local frozen custard shop should be, and something South Florida doesn't have nearly enough of. Everything is made in-house, and the custard is the real deal. This isn't the stabilized, heat-resistant soft serve you can walk around with for 20 minutes. This is old-school custard; dense, eggy, and already melting before you've taken your third bite. It forces you to stop, stand there, and actually eat it. As it should. The texture tells you everything. They're running proper equipment and not cutting corners. The swirl holds just long enough, then starts to collapse under its own weight, especially once you start loading it with toppings. [[HIGHLIGHT]]The shop itself leans hard into Keys vacation energy; bright colors, clean, a little over the top. Not trying to be minimalist or trendy. Just unapologetically cheerful.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] [[HIGHLIGHT]]And then there's the logo. Let's just say: ice cream piled into an open conch shell is... a choice. One that feels like it's perpetually one comment away from becoming a full-blown Facebook debate. Once you see it, you can't unsee it[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]]. For the record, no, there is no conch-flavored custard. I asked. Probably for the best. Bottom line: this is a focused, well-executed shop doing one thing right. Real custard, made properly, in a place that knows exactly what it is, even if the logo raises a few eyebrows along the way. read more

See all

you have to stop here! The custard is incredible, and my family loved the water ice. They let us try as many things as we wanted and all of it was so good....we will be back tomorrow!! read more

Conch Custard - Vanilla kids custard with sprinkles - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Marathon, Florida

Very friendly service and delicious coconut ice cream! They also have Italian ice that is yummy. We always come back here when we are on vacation! read more

Conch Custard - Coconut ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Marathon, Florida

See all

From the moment we walked in, we were greeted with happy smiles. [[HIGHLIGHT]]The nicest Service, spotless clean store.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] The Ice cream was delicious, ices excellent and the Best Custard I've ever had! Don't miss out. Winner. read more

Great ice cream. Had chocolate peanut butter. Great service. The prices were very reasonable.

This is a must visit if in or passing thru marathon key. We both had the Italian ice and vanilla custards large $7.49 each. The gentleman behind the counter quickly whipped up our order, one with ornage Italian ice and one with raspberry. They really hit the spot very light and fresh tasting. Will definitely be back again. Great spot for that after dinner treat. FYI they also have many home made ice cream flavors, including key lime pie. Will have to Tru on our next visit. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Very clean inside, and they kept slinging the orders out fast.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

See all

One of the best ice cream places in marathon the ice cream is great and the workers are super friendly i definitely recommend coming read more

Conch Custard - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Marathon, Florida

Great ice cream shop, tons of flavors and options. Accommodated my daughter's allergy by getting a new scoop and scooping out of a fresh bin from the back. When we went in late on a Sunday night there was a long line. Only two workers, and we were in and out in no time! Owners were great and so nice! Highly recommend. read more

Best Cusard I have had in years and a family owned business on our last visit the owner gave us some samples to take home ginger bread it was yummy. The gelato is my favorite they layer it in I alway get a pint to take home. read more

[[HIGHLIGHT]]The place is amazing.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Ice cream great. Staff so helpful. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Very clean.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Parking easy. Happy to have a wonderful place close to home. We love our local shops. read more

Great service from some really nice young women that work there. Ice cream is amazing and of the best quality. Hard to choose flavors because they all looked delicious. I had the key lime and coconut. Absolutely delicious! The soft serve is yummy too. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Nice clean cheerful inside but we sat outside to enjoy the evening.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] If we're ever back, this place is on the list for another visit! read more

This is the best ice cream and custard in the keys! You can't go wrong here anytime of day

Excellent soft serve, coconut ice cream was AMAZING. On the sweeter side but delicious coconut flavor. Butter pecan was not my favorite. It was overly sweet and had a slight artificial flavor, in my opinion. The vanilla soft serve was excellent served with rainbow sprinkles. Great place overall and worth a trip! read more

Great spot for a sweet treat. My wife and I came here about four times over our ten day stay in Marathon. The lemon poppyseed ice cream was so good. Staff was always friendly which I feel can be hard to find with high school age kids. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Shop was very clean as well.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

Conch Custard - Lemon poppyseed ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Marathon, Florida

This visit to the keys we went to conch custard several times and I still can't say enough good things about this place. The staff are the friendliest, most welcoming staff I have ever seen - they are definitely doing something right! The ice cream and the Italian ice are delish, this time we really loved the snickers and the pb cup. Most of the time when you get a candy bar ice cream, it's a plain vanilla or chocolate with pieces of the candy bar in it. Both the snickers and Reese's cup embodied the flavor of each throughout the ice cream. This is hands down one of our favorite spots in the keys + the staff keeps us coming back multiple times when we visit! read more

Great little local ice cream shop. Went to a different place and noticed how all their ice creams were artificially flavored and colored (pistachio was bright neon green) so it was great to come here where the ice cream is actually natural and delicious. Got a regular sized in a cup with key lime ice cream and pistachio and both were good but key lime was phenomenal. Creamy and smooth yet still tart and tangy yet also sweet, it was the perfect balance of flavors. It was great and the price was decent, I hope they don't raise their prices. Seems like a nice family owned business. The girl who served us was very friendly and also cute. The older woman at the cash register was also very friendly. If I lived nearby, I would come here all the time. Next time I'm driving through the keys, I will be sure to stop here for the key lime ice cream. read more

Conch Custard - Key lime ice cream and pistachio under - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Marathon, Florida

An amazing find in the Keys that's open late! Despite the long line, the kids working behind the counter were hustling with a smile, and we barely waited 5 min. Homemade ice cream, Italian ice and custard, you couldn't go wrong with any of them. The flavors were great, especially for the ices. Really fresh and flavorful that didn't taste artificial. The consistency of the ice was great too, not slushy like some chain establishments. Marking this place as a favorite and we'll definitely be back. Please don't change anything! read more

See all

Yummy!! So good and fresh. Service was excellent-offered tastings so we could decide. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Fun cutie decor and clean.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] So many choices too- our part of 6 all found something special. read more

My orange Italian ice and soft vanilla custard creation from Conch Custard was so refreshing and delicious on a hot day. The guys behind the counter were so polite and helpful. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Cute little shop with ice cream type tables and chairs.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] You need to try it!!! read more

Conch Custard - Orange Italian ice and vanilla custard creation from Conch Custard - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Marathon, Florida

Better than Savannah's... the service was so friendly! The flavors and selection are vast! The coconut ice cream is delicious! They have soft serve, hard scoop and Italian ice. The location is easy to access off route 1 with good parking. [[HIGHLIGHT]]The inside has a few places to sit but ambiance is bright and welcoming![[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Overall will be back! read more

The ice cream is delicious, [[HIGHLIGHT]]the place is super clean[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]],, and the staff is always friendly. We recently moved to the Keys, and we are making it a tradition to have ice cream after dinner at least twice a month. read more

Conch Custard - Fourth of July table gnome at the Conch Custard. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Marathon, Florida

See all

Came here with the family while on vacation. The staff was SUPER friendly, explaining everything, and not rushing anyone to order. I tried the homemade hard peanut butter cup and cookie dough. Both excellent. My kids loved the soft serve and my wife had an orange sherbet which she liked. Prices were very reasonable and portions were huge (smallest size was 12 oz, which is about 2x the ice cream I normally eat). read more

Conch Custard - Service counter - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Marathon, Florida

Where do I began? This place is amazing. They have a variety of flavors and all of their ice cream is made in house. The ladies that work there are super friendly and always have a smile on their faces. Everything is clean, there is a bathroom onsite, and plenty of seating inside and outside. Italian ice and soft service is also available aside from the hand scooped ice cream. My go to flavors are coconut, pistachio, and reeses. Chef's kiss! I can't wait to see what the seasonal flavors are on my next visit! read more

Conch Custard - a cup of ice cream and a pumpkin on a table - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Marathon, Florida

See all

[[HIGHLIGHT]]Quaint shop, warm and courteous staff and great homemade frozen custard and gelato.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] My wife had the lemon gelato with vanilla custard and my daughter had the pineapple gelato with vanilla custard. I was being a good boy and only had a taste of both. They were both great tasting and later I wish I had indulged. Highly recommend this shop. Oh they also have their own homemade ice cream. You will be happy you stopped in. read more

Conch Custard - Pineapple gelato and vanilla custard - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Marathon, Florida

Great homemade delicious ice cream. Pints are underrated and really worthwhile. Also underrated is the gelati (the froyo + icy is a yum combo - but hard to pick over the ice cream). Terrific friendly customer service (they will gladly give samples unlike other keys establishments) and [[HIGHLIGHT]]its always a nice clean happy store.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Happy to be a regular repeat customer. read more

I was in town visiting and my family were regulars at another place but I wanted to try Conch Custard. On Yelp, Conch Custard had better reviews so I got them to bend... Well what an excellent surprise for all of us. [[HIGHLIGHT]]For one then this place is really nice and clean.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Also the service we received was excellent... both girls were extremely courteous and pleasant. We all ended up opting for the homemade ice cream... the flavors we chose were key lime pie, salted caramel and vanilla. All three of us were really impressed with the quality, texture, flavor and portions of our 12oz cups. They have many other offerings including waffle cones, which are my favorite and looking forward to many more visits... Give them a try, you definitely won't be disappointed! read more

Great custard, good friendly service and [[HIGHLIGHT]]ahop ia bright, clean, comfortable and inviting[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]].

Fabulous! Not only smooth creamy Tanika and chocolate custard, but also wonderful flavors of ice creams and Italian ices. Favorites were swirl custard, delicious refreshing key lime , salted caramel, and cookies and cream and heath bar ice cream . Our vegan friend had a red rasp Italian ice. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Everyone was pleased and we also enjoyed a bathroom break[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]]-- [[HIGHLIGHT]]Huge thumbs up! Cute spot, great service with plenty of sampling[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]]-- read more

This is a MUST have in Marathon! We come here almost every night when we are in Marathon Key. They don't just have ice cream, they also have water ice and gelati which are my favorites. They can also make you milkshakes with the ice cream flavors. You won't be disappointed! read more

Conch Custard - Orange water ice with gelati! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Marathon, Florida

This is a fantastic custard/ice cream shop! They make their own custard on site and it's delicious. They also have Italian ice that can be combined with soft serve ice cream for a gelati, and they're also wonderful. The staff was very friendly and gave us samples so we could hone in on a favorite. It was also very clean and orderly. read more

[[HIGHLIGHT]]Awesome place with good food and vibes![[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] The Italian ice with soft serve is to die for.

Ok, the other reviews are not hype. My wife and I tried this place out after hearing from a friend....and yeah, it's legit. Ice cream is made in the back and they have a good variety of flavors...good ones like cookies n cream, butterfinger, etc and gelato. A must try and worth the trip. read more

The BEST ice cream we got on our baby moon. I made my husband pull over during our drive from Key West to Islamorada and tried to make him drive us 45 minutes back the next day. A must stop in the keys!!! read more

Fantastic spot for custard! We dropped in after driving past a few times, and the staff was so friendly. They have a wide variety of homemade selections, and it was so hard to choose. I tried a few options before deciding to go with the Lemon Poppyseed custard. It was FANTASTIC! And tasted just like a fresh lemon poppyseed muffin. I was shocked how similar the flavor was. It was delightful. Prices were also very reasonable, and parking was available right in front. read more

Conch Custard - Lemon poppyseed custard - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Marathon, Florida

Ice cream was good it's better then sweet Savanah's if your a local totally recommend this place

Delicious home made ice cream with a [[HIGHLIGHT]]very clean and friendly environment[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]]. The owner's daughter was cordial and engaging and provided a great face for her family's business. read more

Great little ice cream and Italian ice shop. Clean with really friendly staff. Flavors were all excellent. I loved the pistachio and also really though the lemon poppy seed flavor was unique and delicious. What a great little shop. 10/10 for a cool sweet treat. read more

Conch Custard - a display of confetti cones - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Marathon, Florida

See all

Great service from the staff, lots of combinations (we had key lime/coconut, heath/soft serve chocolate, coconut/pineaple italian ice and Reese's/butterfinger combos). Highly recommend!! read more