Manager is soo nice, they didn't have an item from Uber eats order and they called me right away to let me know and fixed it up. Great customer service, so friendly. The food is also 10/10. read more

This pizza is okay. Service is great, it's maybe the best choice in the area. I like an everything pizza with anchovies which isn't possible here. Thin crust with two standard ingredients is an okay and consistent choice. Accurate wait times. read more

I called in a pick-up order in the morning and it was hot and ready right on time later that day as I asked. The woman who took my order was very efficient too- we'll done on her part. I have had Falbo's pizza many times and loved every bite. But something is changed now. The crust seems a different blah taste and the sausage on the pizza was hard to find. Paying $20 for a pizza should assure that the single ingredient i ordered is more than a just a small bit of sausage or two on each slice. We were disappointed and hope it was a bad day, not the norm now. I would also like to mention to the management that the side area, wide open to customers who come in, looks dirty and filled with stuff. It does not look clean and made me wonder if that dirt carried into the kitchen area. I really hope things get better because I have loved this food in the past. It will be a shame if this current quality is what we can expect from now on. read more

Good food, good price. Staff are sometimes not so engaging, but generally friendly. Pizza by the slice at noon time isn't always hot, but quality is there. read more

Pizza was not done. The crust was not baked all the way through and that made it doughy. So much for the new oweners!

This is a solid pizzeria in the heart of Hartland, one of a few of a local chain. My work and I ordered from here for a staff in-service day, and the service provided by the restaurant, both during the ordering process and the delivery itself, was great. We had a large order, as we were feeding 16 people, and the staff member who took the order over the phone was very patient and attentive, answering any questions I had quickly and allowing several substitutions/alterations to occur. The guy who delivered it a few days later to us at work was super helpful--instead of just handing the order to us at the door and scramming, he took time to carry all of the food and drinks inside and helped us set it up around a large table. He made sure we had everything we needed before he left, and he left a warming bag with us to keep some of the smaller food in before we busted into the boxes (we returned it later, and there wasn't a certain time by when we had to get it back, which was nice). The food itself was pretty good--the pizzas were a little greasy, and the cheese bread a little overcooked, but otherwise it was excellent food. We got orders of cheese curds, garlic bread, cheese bread, pizzas, sandwiches, and a salad, and all of the food was fresh and/or hot, with nothing seeming like it had been cooked far in advance and then left under a heat lamp until the order was ran over to us. I personally ordered a chicken parmesan sandwich, and it was excellent--the chicken tenders in the sandwich were crispy and warm, the marinara sauce not too sweet, and the cheese perfectly melted. Based on the ease of ordering and the great delivery service, combined with the really good taste of the food, we plan on using these guys again at my work for catering purposes, and I wouldn't mind getting an order here myself someday when I'm around town, especially one of their many specialty sandwiches, which all have pretty phenomenal names IMO. read more

Falbo's has been our go-to pizza place, providing a really good pizza time after time. Last visit (June 21st) we were quite disappointed. As always I ordered a large thin, crispy crust - which means you need to bake it a little longer, right? Well, only two pieces were done right, while the remaining part of the pizza was under cooked and limp. Maybe next time they can spin the pizza around in the oven so all sides get properly baked. I had to finish it off by putting in our oven at home. I also ordered sliced tomatoes. What I got was 9 partial tomato slices, sliced so thin they barely covered the pizza nor made a difference taste-wise. What a waste. And the dough was a nice amoeba shape...all for over $30!! This place can do better and they have in the past. read more

Falbo Bros Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Hartland, Wisconsin

This is the worst pizza I've ever tasted as of 2023, and the service wasn't much better. Ambiance is comprised of a manager that openly demeans and denigrates his employees in front of customers. If I could provide a zero or negative rating, I would .... read more

At first I was hesitant to go back after I heard about new ownership but I can absolutely say the pizza has done nothing but get better. I got a stuffed meat eaters pizza and it was perfect, everything from the crust to the topping. Hands down the best pizza I have ever had. I was also pleased to hear that with the new ownership the price will be going DOWN!!! I have never heard that before, especially in today's day and age. I am also very excited about the new app of the months that they just started doing, I can't wait to try the arancini balls that are coming in July. This is easily the best pizza and maybe one of the best restaurants I have ever been to. Definitely recommend. read more

Stuffed bbq chicken pizza is legit!! Excellent flavor...perfect! Order it and then head downstairs to Melms microbrewery for a beer. Falbo will bring it to you! read more

Falbo Bros Pizzeria - Stuffed BBQ Chicken Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hartland, Wisconsin

Falbo Brothers was one of our go to places for after bar food eats when I lived in Madison. It's been many years since I've had their pizza, but was excited to see there was one close by our new house. I called for a carry out order. Every employee we encountered from the girl on the phone that took our order to picking up the order were very friendly and appreciative of our business. The pizza had a nice thin crispy crust. My only complaint was it had a little bit too much sauce. The Greek salad was good and all the ingredients were fresh and crisp. Great variety of pizzas, sandwiches and salads to choose from. read more

Falbo Bros Pizzeria - Da Works Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hartland, Wisconsin

While I would not put Falbo Brothers in the pantheon of Chicago-style pizza restaurants (Uno's, Lou Malnatti's, Gino's, etc.), it is still very good. We have ordered the deep dish and the stuffed, and the stuffed is much closer to the real Chicago-style experience. It's definitely worth a try. read more

Worst pizza my husband ever had. They wouldn't take the coupons that were just sent out in mail. They were belligerent and it was cold.

Very good pizza with friendly staff... We took it to go due to Covid... forward to a return visit! read more

Falbo Bros Pizzeria - a pizza box - Pizza Near Me - Hartland, Wisconsin

Since moving to the area, we've been looking for some legit pizza. I don't know that Falbo's will be our go-to, but it is good, close, and offers a good variety for the whole fam. My husband and I went to the Hartland location, which offers take-out, delivery, and a really cute dine-in option. There are just a couple of tables in a space about the size of a small bedroom. There is also a small hot sauce bar with napkins and extra seasonings and coolers with a selection of beverages. The dining area was really everything I needed it to be, despite its very utilitarian appearance. We started our meal with salads while we waited for the pizza. I got the Greek and Kyle ordered Caesar. Both were freshly made, generously portioned, and iceburg free. The Greek salad could have been made more authentic with kalamata olives instead of black ones, but I've never met an olive I didn't like. I ordered a thin crust pizza with sausage, mushrooms, onions, olives, spinach, and artichoke hearts. I also swapped the cheese blend for just parmesean. My dearest went for deep dish with pepperoni, sausage, bacon, mushrooms, onions, and olives. The 20 minutes wait time for the thicker crust gave us time to enjoy our greens and enjoy some Dang diet root beer. Kudos to Falbos for featuring locally-based sodas. The pizzas came out piping hot and timed together. My thin crust was perfectly crisp and generously topped. It was delicious, but was missing something: simple seasonings. Salt, pepper, and garlic go a long way in enhancing the flavor of pretty much everything and this pie needed a healthy pinch of each. A little oregano wouldn't have hurt either. My husband's pizza was surprisingly crisp for deep dish, but not necessarily in a bad way. It wasn't the stereotypical wad of warm dough that thicker crusts tends to be. The crust was, however, a bit dry. A brush of olive oil would remedy the situation for sure. Topping wise, Kyle's pie was a smorgasbord of meat and gooey cheese. It also needed a bit of seasoning and less smokiness on the bacon, but a worthy effort overall. The great service we received was definitely an asset to our dining experience. The young staff members were funny, helpful, knowledgeable, and unendingly patient while we figured out how to purchase our meal with Google Pay. Falbo's was definitely not among the top 10 pizzas I've ever eaten, but it was decent, local fare served with a smile. read more

Really disappointed on the meatball sub. 2 small meatballs cut in half to fill an 8 inch sub. For $8 is ridiculous. Won't order this again. Falbos you better step your game up or your going to loose more customers. read more

Falbo Bros Pizzeria - Meatball sub. - Pizza Near Me - Hartland, Wisconsin

We only had the thin crust pizza and the cheese bread, but I was really surprised at how great both things tasted. The thin crust pizza was some of the best I have had in the area, cracker thin with an appropriate amount of toppings, and the cheese bread was very,very tasty. I will be returning soon. read more

I had shied away from this place a bit because of bias against chain places (even though this is fairly small and regional), but I sure learned my lesson. The stuffed pizza is great. If you like deep dish and that avenue of pizza style, you won't be disappointed. read more

Many times their pizzas are over cooked and dry. Some times burned as well. Buyer beware.

Great little spot right next to Melm's brewing Company. Pizzas are absolutely delicious and the fun, energetic and focused staff has the food always turning out delicious! Highly recommend! read more

Comfort food doesn't get much more satisfying than wings and pizza, and Falbo Bros do it pretty well. I've ordered take-out here about 5 times, and the quality has been impressively consistent. Well worth the ~15 minute drive from Oconomowoc. Notable wing flavors: sweet thai chili, spicy garlic, and teriyaki. Their pizza is your best bet within a ~25 mile radius--nothing particularly special about it, but decent enough that you'll be ordering again and again. Update: Wouldn't order the wings again. They used to be great. I'm not sure what happened. read more

Falbo Bros Pizzeria - 'Za - Pizza Near Me - Hartland, Wisconsin

Turkey sub was sub par and over priced. No meat on the sandwich and terrible bread. The pizza was average (thin crust) and not very well cooked. read more

Our first time eating here, we were super happy with our food - I ordered the Garlic Chicken Ranch deep dish and my husband ordered a Falzone - both delicious and piping hot. Deep dish takes about 20-25 minutes - you might want to order online if you don't want to wait - it was fine with us since we had no time constraints. Staff was friendly and courteous, we will definitely be back and/or order to go. read more

We order often. Always speedy delivery and accurate with our order. I have to admit, I don't find their "regular" pizzas to be my favorite (sausage, pepperoni, etc) but their specialty pizzas are our fav of all places in Lake Country! Their Gyro pizza is my favorite of all time - I crave it! And others in the family love the BBQ chicken pizza. read more

Worst customer service ever - manager said that they were busy and I don't know how to run a business - DO NOT Order from this place ever for a sub par pizza - awful read more

Falbo Bros Pizzeria - We waited 1 hour and 20 min for this nasty looking $20 pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Hartland, Wisconsin

Very close to home, so we order from here a lot. The staff knows me byname and they always make us feel welcome when we come in to pick up our pizza. The Tony Falboni salad is an amazing addition to any pie you take out. I really enjoy their lunch special of a $2 dollar slice. It's a quick in and out for lunch and so delicious! read more

Waited around 1 hour and 40 minutes for this disgusting pizza. Supposedly a "half bbq, half buffalo chicken" pizza. You cannot see a clear distinction at all. It's just a gross blend of the two flavors with a foul amount of cheese piled on top. It is not even remotely circular and I'm still shocked how the crust can be so uneven. It shows zero effort went into making this pizza. I called several times while it was being delivered late and an incompetent person kept answering the phone and couldn't answer a single question without the manager's help. My total order was one medium pizza and some cheese curds. It was for an address less than 10 minutes away and yet it took over 1.5 hours to get it delivered. Never ordering here again. Disgusting food. Manager was nice though. That's the one positive. read more

Falbo Bros Pizzeria - Medium half BBQ Chicken Pizza, half Buffalo Chicken Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hartland, Wisconsin

Great tasting pizza. Carry out only. Friendly staff. A little pricey but well worth it. Convenient location.

They deliver to Spence Rd!! Thin crust pizza was delish.

I've ordered pizza from here twice now and both times I have been impressed. I'm fairly particular about my pizza joints and consider pizza as my favorite, go-to comfort food. My kids first had their pizza at a friend's house and insisted we try it. I would have to agree with them that the pizza is very good. My kids prefer the thick crust (I'm more of a think crust guy), so both times we have gotten the thick crust. Very impressed with the crust as it seems with most thick crust pizza you end up with a doughy, inedible piece of crust after eating a slice. But I polished off the crust every time and enjoyed it. The toppings are plentiful (fresh mushrooms, not canned!!) and I find their prices to be very reasonable. Definitely recommend for pizza in the Hartland area. read more

I have been a chef for 30 plus years and all I can say is flavor, quality, and a reasonable price for really great tasting pizza, subs, salads, and appetizers. We dined in and were really happy with the service and friendly staff. read more

First time was great the second delivery was late and delivered to wrong home! They tried to make it right and gave it to us free but was still late and delivered wrong! read more

Love this pizza! It's like the New York pizza I have always loved. Tastes great and no nonsense. Doesn't require lots of toppings to make it palatable. Excellent sauce and crust. Not too much cheese. Just good, quality pizza. read more

We just moved to the area and this is become on our favorites! Highly recommend the taco pizza as well. Food is always hot and fresh, for pizza you can't go wrong. read more

Best deep dish to date I'll be back eat your pizza while having a brew at melms better than other deep dishes we had nice place to socialize too read more

"Authentic Italian pizza" Their Pizza has great flavor and a nice crust sometimes I wish they could get a little crispier but otherwise it's great. read more

Awesome pizza definitely a great Yelp find. Amazing food and great staff. Three different crusts, we had the thin. It was done perfectly, nice and crisp. Only drawback about the place is it is very small, so you may not be able to eat in. We were lucky enough to. read more

Wow! This is the best pizza I've had in Waukesha county! I ordered 'The Zeus', Greek inspired pizza with big chunks of feta mixed with mozzarella, spinach, red onions and black olives--comes with a side of pepperoncinis and Greek dressing. OMG, so freakin' delicious! Ordered thin crust pepperoni and cheese for the kids and they scarfed it up in minutes! The staff was helpful and friendly. This place is a hidden gem. I'm holding one star in reserve for the next time we go there. read more

We love their pizza. Their timing is horrible. Every time we order carry out, which is at least once every two weeks, they never have our order ready when they say. Sometimes they haven't even put the order in when we get there! read more

Have placed many carry out orders from Falbo's and have always had a wonderful experience. We ordered delivery for the first time and they were extremely friendly and timely! read more