Their chicken wings are slimmest, not crispy, disgusting wings we've ever eaten. We spent $50 and threw over half of them away cause we couldn't even eat them. We usually clean the entire bone to give you relativity. Repulsive. And the RANCH?! It couldn't be a nastier thick buttermilk ranch, like that's the best you can do? Seriously disappointing. We will not be back. Save yourself and your money. read more

This place has one of the best burgers! I had a single with bacon and it was amazing! The staff is friendly and helpful with choices even though I always get the same thing! I am allergic to cheese so that stops me from trying their many choices but my boyfriend has and he loves them all! read more

I usually love coming here it's one of my favorites. however tonight I got home and realized my order was wrong. i tried calling the store 5 times to try to get ahold of a manager as I live in wellington. And nobody picked up the phone once. I understand getting busy or not hearing the phone. But this was just outrageous. read more

Really good burger but the fries were amazing. Service was quick and friendly. Again, did I mention the fries were SO GOOD?

I still think this is one of the better places in Fort Collins. Had a fat stickler plus the cheese fries. Bring an empty stomach the person working there was very friendly. The food is fresh. It was terrific. read more

Fat Shack - Cheese fries - Sandwiches Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

See all

The food was ice cold and missing ingredients we paid for. They would not remake or refund our orderto make it right. We are never going to fat shack again. read more

THE Fat Shack. Late night drunchies have never tasted better. Fat Shack seems to have something for everyone in any state of mind except sober. My only problem is the late night service, but then again, it is late night service for drunk students. I recommend the Fat Shack. read more

Other fat shacks are great, this one took an hour to provide me food for the 2nd time. lol. (Not even busy, typical rude and slow service) Driving to the other location is definitely faster. 11:00pm June 10th - read more

Business is open and offering take out and delivery (via grub Hub, Uber Eats, etc. Visited for the first time. Burgers and fries were quite yummy, though I'm sure even tastier if we had been able to eat immediately while it was hot. Definitely have to go back and try their signature sandwiches -- look to be some crazy combinations to explore!! read more

Fat Shack - Yummy! - Sandwiches Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

The ambiance was really cause we could hear that bish in the background. I rlly like it here it's cool. Service was lovely great people here rlly Amazon people we really like the people here I'm just saying how much I love the people lemme tell you. Food was aight ranch was weird ‍‍‍‍ read more

This location has absolutely nuked their menu and it's now a total rip off. If you compare this location to others, you'll see that the FOCO menu is now smaller, and they charge ~$15 for a 9 inch sandwich (no options on sizes, also got rid of around 6 sandwich options). At any other location, you'll see that you can pay around $15 for a LARGE 12inch sandwich, or a medium 9inch for less. They also don't have ANY bone-in wings anymore, so forget about that sunday wings deal. Total rip-off to pay upwards of $30 for a 9 inch sandwich and a side. There's plenty of other places to grab a sando without destroying the wallet. Definitely not a fault of the employees, but clearly the owner/management made a really stupid choice in making the menu smaller and more expensive when there's 4 other places to get a sandwich just a stone's throw away. read more

ave it another shot 3 months later, still sucks ass! I made a pickup order and of course my order was wrong! It was obviously due to how difficult it is to remember no burger sauce and no pickles. After having driven all the way home and seeing my order was wrong I called, and they offered to correct it but only once I was in store. I don't want to drive all the way back to that hell hole to sit inside and wait on a burger that should've been correct the first time and I shouldn't have to. If I call and my order is wrong you should immediately start to make me a new burger. after all this is entirely the fault of undertrained and careless employees. read more

After a night out with friends we wanted some fries, mozzarella sticks and a burger to top off the night. Little did we know that would mean waiting nearly 45 extra minutes when we were the first people to walk into the restaurant!! No one was ahead of us! But clearly to-go orders took priority and even those people waited a good 20 mins. After reading through reviews, it's clear this place needs to take some notes from Chic Fil A on efficiency. I felt bad for the cashier taking all the fire for slow service. The food was alright, average at best but definitely not worth 45 minutes. I recommend taking your dollar elsewhere. read more

I came to the loveland location on Thursday the 15th and this has been the best experience I have had.(shout out to Matt) He seemed to be the only one working at the time he took excellent care of us got our food out in under 15 min even with other orders on the screen,and taking phone orders. Oh and his charisma and personality is out of this world kept us laughing the whole time. If I could give him 20 stars I would read more

This place has the potential to be really good, but I just ordered online and my food was absolutely disgusting. I showed up ten min after I got a message saying my order was ready and when I got there they said they were still waiting on the side of fried pickles. I waited another ten minutes and finally got my food. After getting home five minutes after that, I opened the two sandwiches I ordered and they were soggy asf. Not a single thing was crispy, the fries and onion rings on it were mush, everything was just mush. The side of fried pickles were the only fresh thing I received and they were good but the rest of my order was inedible. I essentially paid $32 for fried pickles. This could have been really good if the sandwiches were fresh, but they were wet and soggy and inedible. I won't be going back. read more

I have never eaten food so disgustingly delicious. While eating I was throwing up the food cause it was the fastest path from the plate to my mouth. But let's back it up, when i first entered the restaurant i got the most horrendous whiff of pleasure, followed by a joyess greeting from the counter. Twas my first time at this establishment and was given the walk through with care and thought although i didn't buy the big kahuna recommendation i enjoyed my food none the less. Hazzah read more

Fat Shack - a hamburger and french fries - Sandwiches Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

The shack is the place! Delicious food and they are open late, most importantly the service is wonderful. (My favorite being Reed) Absolutely love the environment, great music all the time! Highly recommend. read more

I have left a review before about the chicken being awful and the owner was nice enough to give me a refund and a gift card to give them another shot which I did at the time and it was great, I ordered again tonight and am so let down yet again, the chicken is not chicken fingers they are nuggets, not to mention I was given way over cooked chicken! I pay my hard earned money to order through door dash which adds up and I am given this.. very unhappy with my order and doubt I will be ordering anytime soon read more

Fat Shack - "Chicken fingers" - Sandwiches Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

See all

My partner is vegetarian and got a sandwich with chicken tenders so she called back, got a refund and had it re-sent and when it got here it was a really crappy made one with just bread, cold fries and soggy mozzarella sticks. Nothing even close to the veggie sandwich that she ordered. Felt like a sarcastic "screw you" for reordering. Terrible quality. read more

Fat Shack - Crap made sandwich. - Sandwiches Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

This is probably the best place to go after a good night of partying. This is one of the only places that stays open till 4 am. And the food is quality, fried sandwiches. It doesn't get much better than this. I would recommend getting the Fat Gorbies. It will change your life. read more

Fat Shack - Sandwiches Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

Cashiers were rude to me when I walked in and asked me if they could help me with something. Ordered food in store at 1:30 in the morning and it took over 30 minutes. read more

A-OK sums this place up perfectly. I didn't have high expectations for quality food after the bars closed so Fat Shack didn't disappoint. The fries I had were delicious. The service wasn't great, we were the only customers inside but 3 people were working on like 15 to go order so it was understandable. read more

Got a gross surprise in my sandwich): somthing that looks like hair or string took a video of me pulling them out of my sandwich, they also forgot my fries and had no one upfront to answer- I will not be eating here again read more

Fat Shack - That black string was inside my sandwich - Sandwiches Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

We were extremely excited to try out the food here because the menu is fun & different. We walked in and we're immediately screamed at by a homeless man laying with all of his items including his dog in the middle of the restaurant with the furniture arranged to his comfort. We walked up to the counter and made eye contact with staff maybe three times before they took our order. We weren't greeted; which whatever we all have off days. We sat down, food came quick but was tossed and slid across the table. The girl was extremely rude. We were really disappointed in the atmosphere, vibes, customer service and overall experience. The chicken used was old, because it was cold to the touch. We will try again in the future and hope to support a local owner. read more

I'm a lover of sandwiches and these are amazing. So many combinations of SUBS. You can get em with chicken, with cheese, with beef or just put it all on one and test your luck. I tried and it was too much for me to tackle but still one of the best I've ever had read more

Fat Shack - Philly steak, fries, onion rings, chicken strips, mozzarella sticks & jalapeño poppers - Sandwiches Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

I ordered cheese fries and the chicken tenders with fries. the cheese fries were mediocre-- just american cheese melted on fries rather than the usual nacho cheese on fries that other establishments do. it was pretty gross but the fries itself were ok. the order took like half an hour, so honestly if you're thinking about coming here at 1am, just go back to sleep. the owner contacted me and gave me a gift card and i was able to try it again. i got the chicken tender basket and it was awesome! thanks a ton for being awesome! read more

Great food, fast service, friendly and attentive staff. Great pub atmosphere.

Just finished my late night dinner from Fat Shack about 2 hours ago, my first time trying this popular FC late night carb paradise, even though I'm a lifelong local. The Philly Cheesesteak was absolutely awesome, I'd order it again in a heartbeat. I didn't have high expectations for the sandwich at all, so it was a great surprise! If I was only rating tonight on the sandwich and the ordering/delivery process it would have been 5 across the board!! From ordering to the knock on my door was barely 20 minutes and I live in Warren Shores! AMAZING! Unfortunately, the main reason I ordered from here, and likely the only reason I would think of ordering from here in the future, is because they are known for their deep fried delights, and in that respect I was sadly disappointed. I very rarely indulge in anything deep fried so I was super excited to sink my teeth into the Deep Fried Rice Krispy Treats! I struggled to decide between the Rice Krispy treats & the Deep Fried Cheesecake Bites, I don't know if I made the wrong choice or if it was just an off night for Snap, Krackle & Pop, but they were definitely not the stuff that Deep Fried Dreams are made of They were chewy, hard to even bite into and very flavorless except for the taste of grease. Not. Super. Yummy. I know what you're thinking, "Well, dumba$$, when you let your dessert sit around half an hour while eating your Philly, what do you expect to happen?!" Nope, not this girl, not at 2:30 am after moving all day long, you better believe I ate dessert first!! Well, I tried dessert first, it just wasn't worth the calories, I closed the bag back up and moved on to the Philly. To my surprise it was piping hot, fresh, made exactly the way I requested and absolutely amazing. I feel bad that I'm not leaving a higher rating but I'm just so disappointed. I was really excited about the prospect of such deliciousness and I feel like the issue needs to be addressed, I can't imagine that I'm the first to have dealt with this issue... One thought I have, if anyone actually reads these reviews or is interested in making a difference... The Rice Krispy Treats were in a bag that appeared to be designed especially for the deep fried delicacies, and they may have been fine if they had been in that sack alone. However, for the trip over they traveled in a plastic bag along with the Philly, both of them all tied up tight in there, even taped closed (I realize that this may be for safety/security/ insurance that all items are delivered, etc. therefore not really much of an option), allowing all the steam to build up between them, creating tons of sweaty condensation. Therefore I think that more than anything the treats were just soggy from the steam and it completely ruined what would have otherwise been an incredible experience... Obviously it's not terribly practical to transport each of the items in separate bags, however it's possible that bagging orders in paper bags might alleviate the condensation and soggy mess of deep fried foods. More sustainable as well and they could be stapled closed with the ticket attached. Just a thought, not trying to harsh anyone's vibe read more

Pretty much find puke out front and in the parking garage daily. Trash everywhere. Drunk stoner clientele. Back door ALWAYS open (cmon in bugs! See pics) and vaping inside the business common. I just waited 40 minutes and not even close to having food prepared. How is this place even in business? Pathetic. Eat at your own risk! read more

It appears to be run by college kids who don't care about customers. Had their backs to the customers waiting and too busy messing around to come take care of the customers. I was impressed with the precautions being taken as they were all wearing gloves until I noticed the cook pulling his cell phone out, doing something with it and then going back to cooking with the same gloves on. I think you missed the point! read more

This is the one of the only Fatshacks I have eaten at, so I don't really have much grounds for comparison. I will say that usually does take a while (20 min ish) but I think that's consistent with most locations preparing elaborate 3000 calorie sandwiches. The "vibe" as some might refer to it is rather relaxed, and makes you feel comfortable while waiting for your food. Not too shabby, nothing spectacular either. read more

I normally really love Fat Shack. I've ordered from them a bunch of times. But, last night I ordered 5 sandwiches, only one of them had a special request (no marinara, sub ranch). The Fat Donkey Lips Sandwich has nacho cheese on it instead of buffalo sauce and blue cheese. The Fat Shack sandwich was basically only a philly with like five french fries and like one jalapeño popper. And mine, the Fat Bronco with no marinara, sub ranch ended up having marinara which I can't eat. So, I couldn't even eat my sandwich. I ordered through GrubHub so I don't know if something happened with that. But I really don't think it was. I got a refund for the sandwich I couldn't eat which was good. But, I was disappointed. I've never had this problem before and I've ordered online and in person so many times from Fat Shack. read more

So it's been over a year and I tried this place again. I even called and asked them to cook it extra well done for me. When I received my order, I made sure to check it before I took a bite just in case. The inside was pink again. I called and asked the guy why?! All he said was "ma'am I cooked it a extra 3 minutes" I hate this place! read more

Fat Shack - Raw hamburger - Sandwiches Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

I'm not much of a sandwich guy but I am a big fan of burgers, that being said their burgers are pretty good. But not for $7.40 they're not, Red Robin is just down the street and for $7.20 you can actually get a large CheeseBurger with all the fixings! read more

Shits aight a bit ass on occasion but overall 3/5 sometimes you just gotta treat yo self splash some cash !!!!

FOOD: If you like meat and cheese you'll probably be pretty happy with the food, also the deep fried Oreos are amazing. DELIVERY: I've ordered delivery a fair amount over the past year. They have always been faster than the time quoted and not once have I received cold food. SERVICE: On the phone they are always pleasant and the drivers are polite. Why 5 stars? You know exactly what you're getting, is it going to be fine dining... Hell no. It's a filling, meaty, cheesy, hangover curing/preventing miracle of a meal. read more

Like to say the least this place is fantastic buttttt if I ever have to use grub hub again imma kms... We ordered at 12 and at 2 o'clock they cancel after habinng a driver enroute the whole time.. Like we know they closed at 1 tonight so at least call us grub hub. Again nothing on fatshack they are amazing but FUCK grub hub!!! :D haha seriously love fat shack tho! Try them chicken tendies with sweet bbw and buffalo and you might just get all wet down south! read more

I placed an order using Order Up at about 9:30 last night. Around 11, exhausted and ready for bed, I called to check the status of my order. The young man who answered apologized profusely for the delay and said my order would arrive soon and they would comp it. I thanked him and about 5 minutes later the food arrived. Around 11:30 someone started banging on my front door! The driver for The Fat Shack was back and she told me I needed to give the food back to her because I was being refunded! I was completely shocked. I told her I already started eating the food and I didn't appreciate her banging on my door at this hour because I have children. She told me she still needed the food back. I told her to leave and closed the door on her. I called The Fat Shack and spoke to a guy (not sure if it was the same guy from earlier) who told me I wouldn't receive a refund since I kept the food. I didn't request a refund in the first place, it was offered to me! Even if I gave the food back, it's not like they could resell it. It really felt like they were trying to "stick it to me" for taking the refund. I could hear the guy talking to his manager for answers to questions I was asking and he finally asked if I would like to speak to the manager and I said yes. The manager instantly became unavailable. This was by far the rudest customer service experience I have ever had in my entire life. And I work in the service industry! The food isn't anything to rave about, typical bar food. It used to be fast and hot but now it takes forever and the staff doesn't care about the customers. I will not be ordering from them ever again. read more

When you come here to eat, you know what you're getting into. The place is called Fat Shack - what else do you think you are going to eat? Vegan, Vegetarian, Gluten-free, Diet-friendly - if any of those words describe your eating habits, just stop reading now. The Fat Shack is probably the perfect place for anyone drunk, hungover, high, or looking to kill themselves by a self-imposed heart attack. The Fat Shack was originally started by Tom Armenti in New Jersey, home of the famed MTV show Jersey Shore. I cannot express how fitting that is. The place that brings us "juice head guidos", The Situation, GTL, and DTF - brings us sandwiches loaded with chicken fingers, french fries, onion rings, mozzarella sticks, and whatever else you can throw in a deep frier. This is the guiltiest of all guilty pleasures. The Fort Collins location opened August 23, 2011 on the corner of College and Laurel where Gohan Time used to be (R.I.P. Gohan Time). The spot near CSU with students who like to party, fist pump, and plain just don't give a damn about what they eat is a match made in fatty heaven. I walked into Fat Shack at 5:30pm, clearly too early for the usual late-night clientele, took one look at the menu overhead and let out a "Ooooohhhhhhh. Wooooooowwwwww." "Yeah, we get that a lot here. Just take your time," replied the guy at the counter. Shockingly, they have "normal people" sandwiches here - a list of grilled options like Buffalo Ranch Wrap, Philly Cheese Steak, and Chicken Parmesan. And?? They do have "FIT sandwiches" that appeal to the health conscious crowd like the Fit Caesar. But what the hell are you doing there if you're going to eat a regular boring sandwich? This is the place to pull a Paula Dean and pretend this food isn't going to slowly kill you. I unwrapped my tasty calorie catastrophe that looked unexpectedly small, and took the first bite. Not too shabby! It's the sauce that makes the sandwich, so I'd recommend asking for extra if you decide to brave the fat. There's so much junk jammed in there, that you only really taste the cholesterol without a liberal drowning of sauce. I kept eating through the first half of my sandwich, and then my chest started to tighten. This is not an exaggeration - my body was revolting. I joked about congestive heart failure, but that probably wasn't too far off. "Oh my god, I'm eating a Gout Sandwich," I exhaled. I took a deep breath and powered through. I started on the second half of the one 8 inch sandwich which had begun to congeal and decided that there is no way in HELL I'd be able to eat three of these. They would need to provide me with Wilfford Brimley's direct number for personal delivery of "dia-beetus" testing supplies at the bottom of my receipt. After some painful winces and deep breaths, we finished our meals, successfully making it out of there alive. I thought that they should probably give out Baby Aspirin as breath mints on your way out. Or maybe a fried cocktail of Aspirin, antacids, and heart burn medications. All in all - would I go back? You bet - if I'm drunk, high, or looking to slowly kill myself through heart disease. Best case scenario, I've been out fist pumping in Old Town until four in the morning and they deliver it right to the smoosh room. read more

Ordered sandwiches and mozz sticks for delivery: Mozz sticks were rubbery, stale, and cold. :-/ Sandwich bread was chewy and tough, fries in the sandwiches were also stale and cold. Not sure where the disconnect was, hopefully if one chooses to dine in the food will be much better. read more