Dude this place is PHAT, ok for real though best wood fired we've had. Maybe some personality from those working the register but great food otherwise. read more

Like others below. First time at the sumner location as Puyallup FZ had a long wait on a Friday evening. Fat Zack's is a upgraded Mod pizza. Love the Puyallup one. This one doesn't have the awesome FZ Sandwiches which is why I had to take a star off. Much quieter location as really nothing nearby. Plenty of seats inside, small parking lot. Employees seems nice but busy with online orders. Convenient drive thru. Place is clean. Looking forward to the FZ's opening in South Hill closer to us. read more

Fat Zach's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sumner, Washington

See all

Small pizzas for the price. It reminds me of pizza by the slice quality. Fast, friendly service and convenient location.

This was my second visit to Fat Zach's and first to the Sumner location. I went to the Sumner location on a Friday evening because wait time for Puyallup was over 90 minutes (woah). A few highs and lows: HIGHS -I loved the Sumner location's drive thru, it was quick and my food was ready immediately when I arrived. -The female employee I placed my order with was very friendly, but window staff was average. -I was relieved that the wait was 15 min at dinner time on a Friday night (maybe there's good reason for that -- keep reading). -Modified order was made correctly which seems like a rarity these days LOWS -I ordered the large antipasto salad which is the same thing I previously had at the Puyallup location -I LOVED the salad at Puyallup, but I honestly couldn't eat half of my meal because the quality was so low. A lot of slimy lettuce and also MASSIVE-sized brown lettuce that had not even been chopped. The toppings were great luckily but what a shame when you pay so much for a salad and can't even eat half, gross. -My fiance had the hot-style bone-in wings and was really disappointed. They are absolutely overpriced for the poor quality. Swimming in a container of sauce and the drums had no bite and were extremely mushy. He said the flats were "okay." Definitely a sub-par experience here and I was really disappointed after hyping up Fat Zach's to my fiance. If we go back, I will never order salad again (shame for a GF vegetarian) and he won't be ordering wings, but I would honestly wait the 90 minutes to go to the Puyallup location where staff were super friendly and food was very high quality. read more

We are visiting from buffalo NY and very happy to see they use Franks hot sauce! Pizzas were amazing! We had the poly pig and mama Rita! Love the decor! The employees were very friendly and food was quick! 100% recommended! read more

Spent over $100 worth of pizza and wings from here for the first time and was extremely disappointed.. everything was black on the bottom and tasted like the oven needed to be cleaned. I know this is "wood fired" pizza, but this is beyond that. Dessert pieces were burnt as well. Wings were... slimy? Disappointed, don't plan on ordering from here again. read more

See all

I keep giving this place another try and am disappointed once again. Undercooked in center and burned on one side. Not very busy in there so feeling like it will be a while before I give this place another shot. Two pizzas both undercooked one charred on the side, now I'm eating what's like raw dough. Plenty of other pizza places around to choose from so I doubt I'll be back here anytime soon. Too bad, nice investment in a real pizza oven and it goes to waste on undercooked pizzas, every time I've had this pizza. Farelli;s Wicked Pie, Trackside, Cascadia, I'll drive the extra for those places to get better pizza. read more

I believe my pictures speak for themselves. First time trying this place. We door dashed it and they were closed when it got here so I couldn't get ahold if anyone at the restaurant. Too expensive to be worth trying again. Also the desert that's supposed to have "butter" was dripping in some foul oil. All around disappointment. read more

See all

My husband and I liked the pizza, but my kiddo (and her cousins) weren't that big of a fan. It's a little too much for their young taste buds! Haha but we like the options. We like pickle pizza.. yum! read more

This review is for Fat Zach's food truck/catering. Great service, prompt, professional, and engaging crew. Hired them for a neighborhood block party and everyone LOVED the pizza- kids and old people. Nice selection and fast turnaround. They even provided a GF crust option which was nice. Fair price and this crew earned their tip read more

Ordered on door dash. Asked for extra cheese and got almost no cheese. Salad was missing from our order. Pizza was cold (which the restaurant can't totally control, but it looked like it had been sitting a while). Pissed I paid all the fees for cold, cheese less pizza and no salad. read more

Fat Zach's Pizza - My sad, cold version. - Pizza Near Me - Sumner, Washington

See all

Super good! Never been here before and would come back. Nice to have a pizza place that sells personal pizza. thank you!! read more

See all

I saw the dill pickle pizza last summer and have been wanting to try it. I finally went and oh my, so good! I will be back! The mobile order with drive thru pickup was convenient. Their wings were really good too! Good job, Fat Zach's!!! read more

Fat Zach's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sumner, Washington

Their pizza is amazing idk what else to say just good pizza best I've had in a very long time

Very good from the New South Hill store Ordered at 5:30 by phone for take out and it was ready like they said. Great pizza and customer service.. read more

I observed the construction of the establishment in Sumner WA as I lived close by. Every now and then I would see the owner as he kept up with the progress. When the business did open I was blessed with a taste of the food, I was extremely satisfied and as time went by I was able to try several different items on the menu, All to which I am so grateful for each time the owner would give me food. A pizza, a salad, drinks, desserts, a sandwich here, a burrito there and as I stated, the owner GAVE me food. You see, I had a heart attack a short time before that and lost my job, soon, I found myself homeless and let me tell you of an angel I entertained (unaware) and how I was blessed by the owner of Fat Zach's and will NEVER forget the mercy and compassion shown to me! Eternally grateful, Dacoda Bodéwadmi read more

Yummy pizza. I would prefer a little longer in the over but still very good. The BIG Dill pizza is AMAZING. I love it when a restaurant takes a classic idea (pizza) and add some out of the box thinking to create a really unique masterpiece. read more

After a disappointing first visit I decided to give it a second chance because my son wanted to check it out. We were the only customers in the restaurant but had to stand at the counter waiting to place our order because the two employees were discussing staffing issues. They were right next to us so they knew that we were there but chose to make us wait to place our order. Very unprofessional. Both the pizza and breadsticks were burned so I had to go back to the counter and request that they remake them. They did remake the order without any issue and it was much better the second time. Before we left a staff member brought out dessert as an apology for the burnt food. The pizza was decent but certainly not worth the poor customer service. We will not be going back. read more

Absolutely love this little pizza place for the environment and delicious food. The staff is beyond friendly and accommodating. I appreciate the coloring station they have set up for kids and the candy pizzas they give them. The food always comes out delicious and fast. Love the serving boards when you dine in and the fun box when you take it to go. The customer service is what really makes it for us and that's why we will always be loyal customers. read more

I ordered gluten free pizza, not because I want too, because I have celiacs and I have to. Now I'll be sick for the next three days because they didn't listen to my very detailed allergy...ate two bites before I realized. Don't worry, they made a replacement (free of charge), burnt has heck, still couldn't eat after everyone else had their amazing pizza. If you say I can trust your business, and I can't, I won't be back. Allergies (celiacs disease) are dangerous to mess up. Seriously, I will get violently ill, disappointed after they said they could make it safe and change gloves, but I still got the regular crust read more

Fat Zach's Pizza - Glad it was free of charge after the first allergy mess up. Inedible, even for gluten free. - Pizza Near Me - Sumner, Washington

Needed to find some food on our way back from dozer day and fat Zach fit the bill. The pies were ready super quick and kept my toddler occupied on the 45 min drive back to Seattle. Will eat here again next time I'm in the area. read more

My brother-in-law who lives in Tacoma said that he heard about this great pizza place in Sumner, so we drove kind of out-of-the-way to try it out for the first time. I love pickles and I saw this crazy pizza with pickles on it and decided I would give it a shot. When I say that this pizza was the best pizza I've ever had I'm not exaggerating. I was taken aback at how much I loved the quality and complexity and the uniqueness of this pizza called the NBD. Wow wow wow! Every pizza from now on will be measured by this pizza. I wish I didn't live 700 miles away in California or I'd be a regular. I'll figure out a way to sneak 2-3 trips over to Fat Zack's every time I come and visit. read more

We are, however, disappointed their lunch specials specials begin at noon when then when our lunch break begins at 11 o'clock. They didn't seem willing to fudge on it at all. read more

I'm really surprised no one mentions the difficulty you encounter when you try to call the restaurant (Sumner) to place an order. Every time I have tried to call them I get an automated message from Verizon that the call cannot be completed. You have to hit redial many times in order for the call to go through. You'd think they could afford a multi line phone system especially if they can afford to open another restaurant. They have lost my business for this reason alone which is too bad because I do like their pizza. At least when calling other pizza establishments my call goes through and if they're busy they ask me to hold and then take my order. read more

New, Hot, Fresh!! Wood fired pizza in Sumner?? Yes Please!! This spot just opened and it was D-lish!! Prices were good for a 10 inch pie, fresh from the apple wood oven. This ain't your machine made corporate cardboard. All ingredients seemed homemade and service was fast and friendly. ( Wood fired pies cook in under two minutes... that's fast!!!) No beers in the menu yet but coming soon. Grateful to have this in our neighborhood. read more

Fat Zach's Pizza - And you box transforms into a bib!?! - Pizza Near Me - Sumner, Washington

I came to WA for business and this was the closest place near my hotel that was in walking distance so I decide to give it a try. I was impressed bye this spot the prices are very reasonable and the pie was actually pretty bomb. Furthermore, the restaurant was spotless and all the employees that helped me were very polite. read more

I made my order online and was given an approximate time of 40 minutes until I could make the pickup. About 10 minutes later I received a text that my order would be ready by 6:20 pm which was 10 minutes earlier than expected. When I showed up my order wasn't even started. So they put together 2 nice pizzas and put them in the oven and worked them around and got them done really fast. Well when I got back to my hotel both pizzas had really soggy crusts. We love wood fired pizzas because of the crispy crust and smoky flavor. I wished they had spent the time properly cooking the pizzas in the wood fired oven. The taste was there but the sogginess was a bummer. read more

This wonderful place and it's Staff have earned it to be our go-to when feeding our crew at work. The pies are just amazing. We have never had a bad experience here and recommend anyone check this place out. You will not be disappointed! Every trip here is looked forward to be the entire crew. Thank you for loving what you do, it's easy to see! read more

Friendly crew and I liked the pizza. Pretty nice place. They all had masks on (if you're worried about covid), I was the only one in there so no info on seating. But back to the pizza, pretty delicious and you can get your own packets of pepper and cheese. Took maybe 10 minutes from order to ready, so they're pretty quick. Thanks y'all. read more

We ordered Fat Zach's through Uber Eats on a whim, and although we had a great experience with the staff, the food was not quite what we expected. The side salad was very small for the price, but fine. But when our pizzas arrived, one was in tact but the other left much to be desired. The sauce had apparently soaked through the crust to the point that it was soggy and wet all throughout (the top of the pizza was essentially a puddle when it arrived). The solid toppings slid off of the pizza in transit, and it was really not a pleasant eating experience. When we called the restaurant to let them know, they were very gracious and understanding and added our name to a list for a free pizza should we decide to eat there again which was appreciated. They knew exactly which pizza we had ordered and said that because of the extra sauce on their version of a Margherita pizza it can cause the sogginess etc. which was not necessarily reassuring but that was offset by the kindness and prompt customer service that we encountered. All in all, we can't speak too much in favor of the food, but the staff are exactly what we would hope to see in any setting and we are extremely appreciative of that. read more

Fat Zach's Pizza - The solid parts of the sauce and cheese had all but slid off of the pizza leaving a wet, soggy, tomato crust. - Pizza Near Me - Sumner, Washington

AVOID AT ALL COSTS! Service, or lack thereof was condescending and disrespectful to older people. I am a senior citizen myself and was there with my 90 year old parents. We never got our order completed as the counter guy tried to play the heavy with us ordering one beer (which was for my 90 year old father). Obviously, the counter person was uninformed on state law, and expressly stated that he couldn't serve a beer unless I showed ID because it was state law. After I asked, are you kidding, he told me no ID no beer, that is the law for everybody. I told him you are mistaken, you must not serve to those underage, but he was adamant. I was willing to avoid a situation, so I flipped open my wallet and showed him my ID (remember I am 65). He said that is not good enough and while he smirked and laughed at me, he told me to take it out of the wallet as it may be fake, and you don't look like you're 21 anyway. Now, I'm a reasonable person, if he had politely said it was company policy to ID everybody, sorry sir, or something like that, we probably wouldn't have had a scene. But when he tried to play mister police man with me that was enough. So, I told my ageing parents, who have mobility issues, that we're leaving, and we did. We went to Farrelli's and had a wonderful lunch, served by a respectful server, and we even got beer without being hassled by someone wanting to play the heavy. The disrespect, smirky attitude, and lack of respect was something I've never experienced before. We will never be back, EVER! Common courtesy towards the older generation goes a long way and it was lacking here. read more

OMG one of the best Pizza joints I have ever been to. There toppings always have a fresh taste to them, staff is always amazing and funny. Please put one in Auburn gas is killing us...LOL read more

This place is awesome. I love all the different options you have. Whenever I eat pizza, this is the place I try to go to.

Pizza is always fresh and amazing! The garlic cheese bread is also really good. I highly recommend eating here!

Love the pickle pizza if you haven't every person that I have had try it loves it. White sauce and pickles what could be bad about that.

We had this ordered one night. Two smalls one pepperoni and one Canadian bacon and pineapple. Both were awesome. I didnt realize even where they are located bc the pizza was still hot. We're in Federal Way. Excellent pizza and local. Check them out!! Fast, hot delivery. read more

I had high expectations for this spot after reading many of the reviews here. This area is located in an industrial park setting of Sumner literally just off Highway 167. It is far removed from the charm and coolness of the "Downtown" Main Street of Sumner. Still, with limited dining options despite two large hotels nearby, this pizza shop is in a prime location that is starting to grow very rapidly. I have no doubt it will become successful and profitable given the heavy traffic that passes by non-stop especially after this COVID-19 pandemic passes. Onto my experience...They have an online order system in place but that's only for delivery using GrubHub or DoorDash (I am a fan of neither). So if you want to order and pick-up, you must call in to place your order and use their drive thru to pick it up. Annoying, as your wait in the drive thru line can be long. While waiting in the drive thru line, stopped and in park I was answering a quick text. Surprisingly, I got a lecture from the "Window Witch." Was it me not wearing a face diaper? No. I was texting and driving according to her and breaking the law and she frowned on that. Wonderful! What a way to treat a first time customer. (Especially, since I'm staying at the Holiday Inn Express-Extended Stay for the next month until my new home is built) Onto the important stuff. The food. I ordered the 18 Wheeler Pizza that so many people here have raved about. I also ordered a Caeser Salad. The pizza was O.K. Not bad. Very average. Nothing memorable. Their "Caeser" salad was pitiful and came with two plastic ramekins of Ranch dressing and two small generic packages of very small croutons. Their Caeser Salad was awful. I felt bad eating the slightly brown and tired pieces of iceburg lettuce (I put them out of their misery with my own actual bottle of Caeser salad dressing and parm cheese...and my own black pepper). I've had better salads from a gas station. All that said, I really feel bad for this place. They will one day figure it out. As for me, they lost quit a bit of potential business as I will be residing in a hotel across the street for the next month (at least). I haven't decided which is worse.....the food or the employee's attitude. Either way, I won't be returning. read more

Awesome chicken wings and I like the fact that you can order your pizza the way you want it at no additional cost. Oh and they have beer as well! read more

Very good pizza. Breadsticks are especially delicious. Great service and atmosphere. Right next to the truck stop I parked at.

The pizza is terrific, the staff are very friendly, it's a wonderful value for money, and the wait has never been long. Been there many times and I've never had anything short of a great experience. Thanks Fat Zach! read more