Fathom Restaurant

I just had the worst meal I've had in a long time tonight. I went to Colter's because it was a…read moresteakhouse and I wanted a steak. So I ordered an old-fashioned for a cocktail and it came in a water glass with ice filled to the top, I had to take the ice out of the glass in order to drink it. It was not good. Then I ordered the T-bone steak with the baked potato and the only side veggie available, which was steamed vegetables. The steak was $30. When our plates arrived at the table we could see the steaks were pretty pathetic, really thin, and mine was definitely not a Tbone. I had ordered mine, medium rare and it was well done but more than that, it was so gristly I couldn't even eat it. The baked potato was good, but the vegetables were so full of garlic and so soft and mushy yuck. I would never refer this restaurant to someone who wanted a good steak dinner. I felt bad for our waiter because not only was he the only waiter there, he was the cashier and was also checking people into the hotel .

The new executive chef has really transformed this steakhouse. Went in on a Friday night to give…read morethe new chef a look see. Initial order took a bit of time, but after that OK. Had to get the prime rib special, not disappointed. My meal flew out of the kitchen before I could get half way through the salad. And I like my food HOT and this was much appreciated. Portions were unreal. I think the prime rib was on the menu at 14oz, but I'm pretty sure mine was 16-18oz. Veggie side was huge as was the baker and enough to feed two people. Good people and Outstanding Cuisine.

Salad bar, with a soup of the day

See all

Definitely not a T-bone steak and full of gristle, yuck

Salt River Grill

3.8(45 reviews)

0.6 mi

The food here is phenomenal. Has been from the beginning, when they were in a smaller location…read more Julio (the owner & chef) knows his craft, and nails it time and time again. This particular visit, we got there before 5:00pm, so my husband wasn't able to get what he wanted (Chicken Fried Steak isn't served until after 5:00), but that did not dissuade us. We had the Hot Wings appetizer (6 piece) to start. They were delicious and come with either ranch or bleu cheese. We picked ranch and it was perfection. The wings were crispy and the Buffalo sauce brought the perfect heat. I had the Baja Chicken Breast Salad. Mmm mmm mmm! The balance of salad to chicken to dressing (which comes in a small bowl on the side, so you can dress to your liking) brought a whole new level of YUM. Can't go wrong with avocado and crispy tortilla strips! Husband had the Bacon Cheeseburger, and while it was not the CFS he had hoped for, it was good (a bit dry) and the beer-battered French fries made it even better. If you're looking for some top notch food in a tiny town: look no further! You found it!

One of our favorite places in town. We visited Afton for a month and we came here on our first day…read moreand on our way out. For lunch, the burgers and fries were great. Everything is fresh and there is always a table ready for you. For breakfast, I got a breakfast burrito and my partner got a chicken fried steak. Both were really good, I definitely recommend.

BBQ Burger

Side Salad

See all

Salt River Grill

Diamond Heart Cattlemen’s Steakhouse

5.0(1 review)

New to the valley, but what I had was good. I had a vegetarian salad. The dressing was good. The…read moresteak was also pretty good. It wasn't super busy and the waitress was very attentive. Overall good service.

Rocky Mountain Seafood

4.4(80 reviews)

•$$

I have driven by this place for years and never noticed it. We finally stopped in for fish and…read morechips and it was great! The Mac cheese bites were also delis! The ambiance is clean, and nautical - we feel like we were on the coast. We will be stopping by on our trips more often -

They overcharged us and when asked about it they were really rude. Told them never-ending and was…read moretold on the way out to not come back. Horrible business. Food wasn't that good Three little pieces of halibut for over 25 dollars.

Diners in the shop

Coconut Shrimp Basket

See all

Super good crab cakes, coleslaw and fries

Star Valley Roadhouse

3.8(13 reviews)

0.6 mi

Food was really good, my wife said the Baja Chicken Salad may be the best salad she has ever had,…read morethe chicken on the salad was fantastic

Overdone steak. Service appeared as though they didn't want us there. Food was bland. Everything…read moreoverpriced.

Chicken Caesar salad

14oz steak cooked perfectly every time. Baja Chicken Salad soooooo good.. the staff and food are always great

See all

Valleon Cafe

3.2(12 reviews)

I don't know why the star rating is low on this amazing historic café. We had exceptional waiter…read moreservice, incredible food, and custom made coffee. We will absolutely be back! If you do come eat, make sure you check out the historic bar in the hotel. It's a gem.

Stopped for breakfast and what a nice surprise. Friendly small town atmosphere and nice service…read more Big portions ,good food and hot coffee- all at a small town price. What else do you need? Give it a try.

Country decorations!

Menu!

See all

Can't get more Wyoming than this!

The Wok Teriyaki Grill

5.0(2 reviews)

0.8 mi

•$$

Our favorite food truck for Asian food. We always get their teriyaki chicken bowl. We get ours with…read moremedium spice, the kids like theirs in the original. A good sized meal with veggies, a big pile of white rice, and lots of juicy chicken (or steak) with a side of teriyaki sauce. So tasty! We look for their truck whenever they're open and serving the valley.

Owned and operated by the cutest family around! This food truck makes an occasional stop in Star…read moreValley once or twice a week and post their times on Facebook. Catch them while they are open and enjoy fresh, made to order teriyaki style meat with hot veges and rice. Chicken or steak are the meat choices topped off with a portion of teriyaki sauce for the customers enjoyment.

Nothin like birthday lunch at the fair!

See all

Chicken teriyaki!

The Rolling Omelet

4.7(15 reviews)

0.2 mi

My friends and I stopped here for breakfast otw to the Tetons and it was delicious! The service was…read moregreat. Food was so yummy. Would definitely eat there again! I got a CrossFit burrito and french toast, and would recommend trying those out.

A really cool and novel breakfast/lunch spot that creatively uses their space on an old school bus…read more Friendly owners, good food. I thought the breakfast burrito was great except it was a little heavy on the potatoes and could have been balanced better with more eggs and less potato. Also their red salsa that was supposed to be the hot one needs a lot more heat, it almost wasn't there at all, but perhaps it's just par for the area. But the real shining star dish from here is the quesabirrias with complimentary consomé, but I think they call it cheesy beef tacos or something like that. Breakfast is only served until 10am, but they do the breakfast burritos until closing at 2pm. Dont skip this great spot!

Self portrait painting of the restaurant

Bacon breakfast burrito

See all

Quesabirrias plate

Agave

4.3(76 reviews)

0.0 mi

•$$

One of the best Mexican restaurants we ate in traveling around the country. Didn't take long to…read morebring our tortilla soup and fajita. Both were very delicious. We enjoyed it a lot. Not sure if we'll be back in this area but I recommend it to anyone. Locals or nomads alike.

Yummy! This place has excellent Mexican food... especially for being located in Star Valley…read moreWyoming! You will be met with a friendly staff and comfortable seating. The menu is ample and includes favorites like enchiladas, burritos, and fajitas. If you're passing through Afton and need a place to grub, give Agave a try!

New menu prices

Prawn fajitas

See all

Subway

2.3(15 reviews)

0.9 mi

Bruh I ordered a sandwich not a slop fest. Over sauced asf. The paper wrap was pretty much soaked…read morein marinara sauce.

Worst subway I've ever been to. Stale bread, frozen meat, it's hardly edible. Girls working sat…read moredown at tables in between customers. Maybe go in the back and make fresh bread!

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

2 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Cynthia R.

0

2

0

4 years ago

yummy food!! We had the butter chicken and curry and it was so good!!! The menu is very diverse and there is something for everyone! I HIGHLY recommend Fathom! The staff is extremely welcoming and so friendly! Can't wait to go back read more

Thea C.

0

4

2

3 years ago

The best restaurant in a small town! Servers are so friendly and the chef will make you whatever is your request. Awesome people Primerib and butter chicken curry is the best food here! read more

Fathom Restaurant - indpak - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Fathom Restaurant also viewed

Leyon’s Kitchen

4.0

(10 reviews)

Given the location, the food at Leyon's is surprisingly good. The place is very clean, even the…read morerestrooms, and is comfortable and well-lit. There were absolutely no vegan offerings on the menu, and the waitress was not willing to make substitutions (e.g., swap the chicken with tofu) that most other Chinese restaurants will do, but we were able to get a couple of dishes meat-free by having them leave out some ingredients. The portions are fairly large and the ingredients fresh, though the fried rice was somewhat bland. Service was very friendly and reasonably quick.

Driving through to Jackson Hole and stopped at this place! They have a lot of locals and to go…read moreorders. They don't have lemon for your water (maybe that's a southern thing). The services is t that great. The food was hot! Egg rolls were flavorful- wish they served with hot mustard. The order took a while to get. We ordered wonton which had lots of noodles, Mushrooms, carrots and chicken. Nice flavor. The fried rice was good. The restaurant could use some improvements on the decor inside, looks like a nursery with toys. All n all, passing thru we got hot tasty meal. Like. I said, lots of Togo orders!

Star Valley Roadhouse

3.8

(13 reviews)

Food was really good, my wife said the Baja Chicken Salad may be the best salad she has ever had,…read morethe chicken on the salad was fantastic

Overdone steak. Service appeared as though they didn't want us there. Food was bland. Everything…read moreoverpriced.

225 BBQ

3.9

(58 reviews)

The menu is amazing and that's only the start. Their special sauces are delicious, they have…read moreamazing staff, and the little gift shop is so fun. They're an amazing local gem.

Wasn't anything special. Wife had the special which was a burger with blueberries and Brie I think…read more She wasn't blown away or anything but said it was okay. Her hush puppies seemed to be cooked to almost a rock. I had the two meat platter of dry brisket and ribs that had almost no meat and it was both the small end rib of a rack. We got fried mushrooms as an appetizer and those were the best part of the meal if that says anything. Wasn't impressed. It's edible. Daughter liked the smoked make and cheese. Guy waiting tables was super nice and fast.

Horseshoe Inn

4.7

(39 reviews)

We stopped here on our way back to Salt Lake City from the parks and it was a smart move! We found…read morethis place looking for anywhere that had breakfast burritos and they were delicious. We got the sausage one and the veggie one, both really good. We also got the half order of biscuits and gravy, bacon and 2 eggs. I would say the bacon is some of the best I have ever had. The wait staff was friendly and the place was a cozy old school diner type. The only thing is the bathrooms are small, but clean.

My family and I have eaten here a lot over the years. We also grabbed lunch here a lot as a company…read moreand they always do great. I ordered a couple burritos this morning for breakfast. They were enormous spot on. It was $30 bucks. 11.99 with one meat, but I got sausage and bacon so I guess that was the extra four dollars each burrito. Got to our shop and took a bite. There wasn't anything to speak of but potatoes,"not cooked" no cheese to be found and a little bit of bacon and sausage strewn with overcooked eggs. I only took the first picture belcause I thought it would be great. It was huge! through the rest away.

Cedar Creek Grill

4.5

(24 reviews)

The food was okay, but what really got me was seeing all food prepared with bare hands, not a glove…read morein sight. Do they not understand food safety practices, because ready to eat can not be handled by bare hands.

Closed. Website still acts like it is there. Drove around looking for it. Not a trace.read more

JACZ Drive-In

4.4

(36 reviews)