First time visiting Fatty's -- shrimp & grits, apple crisp on french toast, and fried egg with potatoes on a waffle -- all we're outstanding! Can't wait to go back. read more

We must have hit this place on a bad day. We waited over an hour for our food and it was mediocre at best. They brought out one dish at a time to our party of eight and the last three people ended up taking their food to go. Awful! read more

We stopped for ice cream...wonderful selection & customer service. I really liked that I could have shaved ice while my kids had ice cream! We will see you next year! read more

Jeff Dawson, a local who's family goes back to the late 1600's has created a family style eating place with amazing food. The shrimp and grits is the best I've ever had. Fried shrimp, homemade desserts The wall murals and signs are worth going in to see. Handmade milk shakes, Hershey's ice cream, should be on food network!! read more

Go for the fish of the day. The mahi mahi was very tasty, but the mac 'n cheese burger was nothing special. Service is attentive, though the food took a little long (we're New Yorkers though). read more

Fattys Eatery - The dining area - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Buxton, North Carolina

The food was good, but the service was very slow..enough to notice. Staff was friendly though! Great place to stop for breakfast, but if you're in a rush I would definitely get take-out versus sitting down to eat. We got the waffles and French toast, but I wish I got the shrimp and grits after reading the other reviews! read more

Though turned away by the name, we ventured in 2 yrs ago and what a prize this is! Open 7a to 3p, a great breakfast, or lunch spot. The shrimp and grits is to die for my wife says, and my omelette was more like a philly wrapped in egg. Great biscuits, fair prices. Don't be scared of the homey exterior or the name...they should call it great food cheap! Still very good today...one of our go to's read more

Crab cake sandwiches so tasty. Mac and cheese excellent too, good service. Funny signs and sayings decorating the walls. Would come back.

We ate at Fatty's for an early lunch after visiting the Shipwreck Museum down the way. The food was delicious and the service was very good. Try the mac and cheese burger with the french fries (which were much more than just vectors for taste like your average fry). We also had the crab cake sandwich with onion petals which did not disappoint! All in all, we'd gladly recommend and/or return to Fatty's! read more

Loved this place! It's nothing fancy, but it's yummy, cheap and adorable. We had breakfast here while camping in the dunes. I had a wonderful mimosa with fresh berries. I don't remember what it was called but we had a breakfast option with eggs etc over a waffle. It was yummy. I'd definitely go back! read more

Great local place. The food is great and the chef puts a little love into every dish. The onion "rings" are a must try and don't forget to try the dip that comes with them. I say this because they taste so good without dipping that you may miss out on some pretty tasty dip. The grilled fish & chips was mahi and it was to die for. I look forward to returning for more delights. read more

Excellent food!! But why three stars? Went there for breakfast and while the food was killer, it took about 30 minutes for a bagel with cheese and an omelet. Luckily, we weren't in much of a rush. The next morning we were leaving town and I wanted to get another bagel for the road. Knowing the wait was long I called ahead. Got there about 25 minutes later, went to the counter, and they hadn't even put it in yet. Then told me it would take about 15 minutes, no apology, just blaming other employees for not putting the order in so I left without food. If you aren't in a rush, go here the food is great. However, this is not a place to go for a quick in and out. *neither day was the place over crowded or overly busy. read more

Great breakfast. Sat on covered patio on a rainy day. Was nice. Good service and coffee.

This is a very casual place which is perfect for the beach. Cute atmosphere. Lots of things to look at for toddlers. Order at the counter and they bring it to you. Service is not very friendly. You get a good portion size. We ordered breakfast, lunch and ice cream. All was average. It is convenient so we would go again for that reason. read more

Fattys Eatery - Toddler entertained while we wait for our food. - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Buxton, North Carolina

See all

Delicious! Everyone in our family enjoyed the food they had. I had the signature burger (bacon, mac & cheese, fried egg, hash browns, & BBQ sauce on a burger) and it was phenomenal. My son also especially liked the mac & cheese dog. Great service, excellent ice cream flavor selection too. Definitely a repeater! read more

This was the best meal we've had on our trip. The shrimp and grits were amazing. It was so flavorful and fresh and it was cooked perfectly. My husband got the family breakfast platter and that was super tasty too. I love how passionate the people who work there are about the menu and the food! We would go back to try other things if our stay was longer. I'll be thinking about those shrimp and grits for a long time to come! read more

Great stop for lunch! Great food, friendly service and reasonable prices. Plus, ice cream! Shrimp burger, skinny fries, mac and cheese, and flats were all a big hit. read more

Excellent food and service! The chicken and waffles were delicious. Love the decor as I'm a video game and comic book nerd. Definitely will make this a must stop every year. read more

First time here. Extremely friendly staff. Stopped for breakfast. Food was outstanding. Highly recommend.

Is not open on a Tuesday morning at almost 9 AM. Very disappointed not to get to try after great reviews. Should update business hours online or be courteous enough to have a sign apologizing. read more

This place is amazing ! Food is so good !!! My kids loved the Mickey Mouse waffles ! Can't wait to eat here again our next visit.

From the reviews on Yelp and the local paper this place seemed like a MUST GO! Well my family and I say the opposite of that. We had gone for breakfast and it was not even close to being good. I had ordered and they came back and told my family member that there was only one biscuit left and they gave her a croissant that was cold and tough to get through. The biscuit was cold and the bacon looked like leather. The eggs were an off yellow color and I didn't even eat more than one bite. The food seemed pre cooked and warmed up. Service was friendly, but I would NOT recommend for food at all. read more

Do yourself a favor and have the chicken and waffles! Absolutely phenomenal! The place is small but clean with fun decor. Staff was very friendly and service was quick and efficient! They've got shrimp and grits on the menu... that'll be what I try next time! read more

5 of us ate breakfast here this morning. The food, once we got it, was very good. It took about 20 minutes to get breakfast sandwiches. Get the heated cinnamon roll!! There was a lot of confusion in the kitchen even though there were only 2 other tables with customers. Not sure how they manage when it's busy. The staff was apologetic and friendly. read more

Didn't get a chance to actually eat, we came in with a party of 16 and I guess the young girl working the register didn't like the idea of seating and feeding so many people. She was about as rude as she could have been without making jokes about our mom. We decided that with a welcoming party like that we didn't want to meet the rest of the staff. read more

The shrimp and grits was AMAZING!! My mom bragged about it and I thought she was hyping it up...until I tried it. She gets it without the sausage and I get it with the sausage - both ways are delicious. This is a must go for breakfast. read more

Great find. Very fresh food, very friendly staff, and fun surroundings. It almost has that 'tourist trap' view from the road, but it's anything but. We had shrimp po boy and mushroom Swiss burger. read more

Great family place to eat. Have been here twice and everything was good, cooked fresh, and hot! Staff I super friendly and helpful.

We walked across the street to Fatty's for a late breakfast from our hotel in Buxton. It was just after the cut off time for breakfast but the staff agreed to fix us breakfast anyway if we so desired. That was nice. I liked the atmosphere with all the interesting posters and the eclectic background music. Unfortunately we did not enjoy the food. My veggie burger and my friends eggs were over cooked. The home fries were deep fried. I can't understand why some restaurants want to ruin home fries by cooking them that way. I suppose it's a faster way to cook then. The food was just low quality and overpriced. It seems that no matter where you eat on Hatteras Island the food is generally overpriced and mediocre. read more

We make a point to get ice cream at Fatty's every summer. Hershey's ice cream is always good. This summer, though, their hours have been irritatingly inconsistent, to the point that I've lowered my review to 3 star. We checked their posted hours before going to get ice cream the first night of our trip this year and it was advertised open till 10. We got there at 915 and the doors were locked. The nice kids behind the register still let us in since we could pay cash, and said the store closed at 9. That was annoying but we figured they just haven't changed their online ads. However we decided to go get breakfast today at the sister restaurant Fatty's Eats, supposedly open 7-3, and at 9am they were closed. We probably won't be attempting to give them business anymore. read more

What a great spot for a quick breakfast before hitting the beach! Service was speedy and friendly. I had the Apple Crisp French Toast and loved it. No syrup needed when it's topped with caramel. My one complaint was that the crisp wasn't very crispy. My fiancé had a breakfast sandwich on a bagel and home fries. He didn't leave a crumb! I've been coming to the outer banks for years and am glad I gave this place a shot. We'll definitely be back! read more

We are breakfast here and were less than impressed. The pancakes were doughy - undercooked and the rest of the food was just ok.

Wonderful service. Outstanding food quality. Love their french toast with fresh berries and whipped cream.

Good food average service waitress need to be more professional they are way too casual. Cold coffe. The whole place needs a deep clean all over just averaage dinner read more

5 stars for breakfast!! Simple menu with limited but excellent options. Got a bagel breakfast sandwich and it was HUGE. Candyland waffle and Mickey pancake were a great treat for the kids. Don't be fooled by the COFFEE sign out front. It's one option of black coffee. No espresso or specialty coffee. Very friendly staff of all ages - I think Santa works here. read more

Great location right off the highway before the lighthouse. Stopped here in the off season for a quick lunch. You have to order before you sit down where there are hundreds of funny pictures on the wall. I ordered the BBQ sandwich with slaw and it was outstanding. It's not cooked on the spot but thats probably bc it is real slow cooked BBQ pulled pork. The bark had great flavor. My only complaints are that it didnt have a vinegar sauce and the store was quite warm with lots of pesty flies all around. The employee said that the ac would be turned on next week which is probably why the doors were open and the flies were plentiful. Ive also heard rave reviews about their doughnuts but they werent available when I went, only weekends and tourist season. read more

The food was great, service was friendly, and best of all, we paid a reasonable price! Highly recommend for a quick breakfast!

I've stayed right across the street for the past few years so I'm surprised I haven't tried their breakfast until now. It was awesome! I ordered the biscuits and gravy but they were out of biscuits. The woman at the register recommended I try it over croissants instead. I went with her recommendation and it was delicious. The homefries were delightfully crisp on the outside and soft on the inside, as they should be! I definitely recommend this place for breakfast if you want a laid back beach feel :) read more

This place should have 5 stars. Everything here is perfect. Best breakfast sandwich I have ever had. The cook is a genius.

OMG, this place is amazing. The food was fresh and tasty. They have a great selection of beers on tap and the prices are very reasonable.