I visit this place pretty often. LOL! I enjoy it. I don't ever eat a whole pizza & don't like a lot of red sauce & definitely prefer white over it. I always get the 2 slices for $5 (drink included; comes to about $6.50). I have tried other things & will list below. Service is always great & always answers the phone. I have sat in & waited.. normal pizza place; pizza decor.. booths & tables with limited high bar stool seat outside. *ALL RECOMMENDATIONS ARE NOT PICTURED* 16" Mother Klucker: 10/10 LOVE IT; always my recommendation Slices I pictured: 9/10 my go to LOVE IT Cheese Sticks: 10/10 cheesy AF & garlic just put it in the perfect place Sweet Tea: 10/10 never misses Items I often see ordered: -Garlic Kinks -Hot Klucker -Wings Only didn't do 5 stars because I don't eat enough of the items to give it 5; in my opinion. read more

Fatty's Pizza - pepperoni & sausage - Pizza Near Me - Macon, Georgia

See all

I was always told when I tried Fatty's for the first time to go downtown because the food and customer service were so much better. Well, I rarely go downtown, so today was the day to try it. The customer service was great (at the non-downtown location). I got the 2 slice $5 pizza special that comes with a drink. I love the thickness of the crust and the pull of the cheese is insane. It was freshly baked and hot out of the oven. I don't mind waiting for hot food. It tastes pretty darn good. I love white pizza, so I know that I would definitely return to try the one with the spinach and mushrooms. Sorry, I can't recall the name. read more

Fatty's Pizza - Double Slice of Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Macon, Georgia

I finally understand the hype--this pizza is OH MY GOD, SO GOOD. I just brought it back to my hotel room, and I'm literally devouring it like a savage. No shame. The crust, the cheese, the sauce--everything is on point. I was just in town for the night from Atlanta, and now I'm seriously considering grabbing another one before I drive back in the morning. It's that good. If you're in Macon and looking for pizza, this is the spot. And if you're from Atlanta like me and just passing through--whether for a basketball game or whatever--you have to stop here. I'll be back. Probably in the morning. #BigBackProblems read more

The salad was the best ever. Spinach was fresh cheese was delicious even without dressing.

Was not impressed in the least. My husband and I have been waiting to come here for awhile. With the rain coming in, we figured this would be perfect to take back home since we live an hour away. When we walked in, tiles on the floor were broken, it was dimly lit, thick with smoke from the pizza oven, torn chairs, rap music playing loudly and unfriendly staff. I ordered two slices of pepperoni and pineapple, got out to the truck and found they were burnt. I mean, cheese-is-brown/orange-burnt. The sauce was extremely sweet. After one bite, I couldn't eat anymore. read more

We have been coming here a while. Usually the pizza is great. This time it was hard to say that. The pie was very doughy, overly soft, overly floppy, overloaded with cheese which sounds good yet it over powered the dough that didn't seem cooked at a high enough temperature or long enough. I couldn't really tell if the sauce was there even though I could see it at times. Very thin crust which is awesome, yet so chewy and soft was hard to tell if it was cooked long enough. Hopefully the oven will add a little heat and fix this issue. read more

Please practice proper food safety as it comes to hair in the workplace. Otherwise, I enjoyed the pizza; just a little grossed out read more

Fatty's Pizza - Hair in pizza. :( we ate half the pizza before I got to the slice with hair. - Pizza Near Me - Macon, Georgia

Ordered a personal supreme via DoorDash. Very good! Not too much sauce or cheese. The crust wasn't soggy. The gentleman who answered the phone was pleasant. Hope to visit in person soon.. read more

The service was very good and friendly. The chef let me create my own interesting pizza and said they might make it a special. The ambiance of the place had good energy and chill music and I'll definitely be back! But back to the pizza, the breading was soft and chewy but not too much and it was delicious. read more

Fatty's Pizza - a slice of pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Macon, Georgia

While the pizza is delicious (we ordered 6 different kinds) the management and communication between shifts needs much work. We phoned in a large order (for 25 people) the night before, called to confirm 2 hours before pick up and when we arrived 5 min before pickup no one had a clue about our order. Our attempts to talk with the general manager sadly has fallen on deaf ears. We also noticed staff behind the line not wearing gloves. The only employee wearing gloves was the cashier however he kept on answering the phone and taking money and went right back to handling food. For this reason we can not recommend read more

Ordered the is after my son was born. Never seen my wife attack a pizza like that. It's probably good even if you haven't just been through that. read more

Two stars is a stretch. First time trying this place. Cheese bread sticks are not bread sticks. Just burnt pizza crust. Barely any sauce on pizza and just taste bland. Lady who took my phone order acted like she didn't have time to listen to me. Have me some price I couldn't catch and hung up. She was nice, just apparently doesn't take any time to listen. Will not go back again. read more

If you are going for great pizza then come to Fatty's. The people are nice and they make great pizza. I look forward to my next chance to come here. read more

Of course the pizza is delicious, the cheesy bread is awesome, but I cannot say enough about the people!! I have ordered twice from here. Two big orders to be delivered to Atrium Hospital. Both times they have been OVER THE TOP ACCOMMODATING!!! Most recently I dealt with Ryle (I'm not sure if I'm spelling his name right), he was SOOOOOO hospitable!!! Thinking of every detail I would need to host a Lunch & Learn for one of the departments. He went out of his way to make sure we were taken care of!! Again, the pizza is fantastic, you won't be disappointed!! I highly recommend Fatty's!!!! read more

Great pizza. Why the three star rating? The staff was playing hip hop with the most uncensored filthy lyrics I have ever heard! I'd prefer my 11 year old son not hear about "popping p***y", the n-word, or other related profanity while getting pizza. read more

best pizza in Macon hands down. always quick friendly service.

The pizza wasn't bad, but the crust was NOT cooked. The private online are not correct. A side salad (4 pieces of lettuce, A LOT of mozzarella, and 2 pieces of tomatoes) was $7, online it was $3. The small self sized pizzas online said $10-12 when they are $16-17. The wings are definitely overpriced with little to no flavor or sauce on them. We spent $50 on 2 self sized pizzas, 6 wings and 4 pieces of lettuce. We just moved to Georgia from NC and wanted to try local businesses, yet have regret as we paid way more than we wanted to or needed to, and the pizza crust not being cooked made it doughy and unable to eat. Very upset, we should have just gone to a chain restaurant instead read more

The food is always good however the wait time way over 20 mins because they forgot half of my order. Needs more organization.

Good pizza good service by the slice or a whole pie it's well worth the wait order ahead and pay for quicker service

Ordered online through Chow (requires by the restaurant's webpage). Arrived at the store 40 minutes later. Total chaos. Woman in line in front of me has the wrong order. After multiple employees open just about every prepared order to figure out what is in the box, they realize that some of her items were never prepared. Got to the counter and was informed that they were so busy that they haven't bothered with any of the online orders. Went to mellow mushroom. read more

The best local pizza joint macon has to offer i love fattys. I normally always get the cheese pizza. Try they desserts as well

Stopping in Macon on spring break and we thought we would try some local pizza. I ordered the pizza online and the email said it would be ready about 45 minutes later. I ran to the local grocery store and arrived about 5 minutes early. 30 minutes later I had to stand at the counter to ask once again about the pizza. It was getting close to 8:30pm and I had kids at the hotel that needed to eat and go to sleep. The pizza was nothing to talk about and the Garlic Knots were burnt. Pizza Hut would have satisfied me more, for less $$ and on time! read more

Been coming here for lunch and thought is was good pizza. But the service has tanked. Waited 30 minutes for 2 slices of pizza. It was in the warmer the whole time the girl tried to tell me they just put it in there. It was soggy. You could tell it had been in there a while. They have rap music cranked up. Very unenjoyable. Won't be back. read more

I almost didn't order because of the reviews but the front desk at our hotel said it was so good. Well it did not disappoint. It was delicious. We ordered pepperoni pizza, a supreme and cheese breadsticks. Everything was hot and tasted great. I called and placed the order, the lady taking my order was extremely nice. We had no issues at all. I am glad we decided to get it delivered. read more

I called five times in a row to place a carry out order. I was hung up on, and put on hold several times. I finally placed my order online and waited 30 minutes to pick it up. When I arrived at the restaurant they did not have my order, claiming "maybe you ordered it from the wrong location" - which did not. Eventually my order "mysteriously" came through their ordering system (after 30min). If a restaurant can't staff their establishment sufficiently to take orders, they need to close their doors. They Upgraded us to larger pizzas due to the mixup, which was a nice gesture. read more

I went to Fattys last night about 625 to pick up a hawaiian pizza I had called in on phone.The girl that took my order said I was screaming in the phone was my first clue.I asked if all the cooks and help wore masks cause Im 69 and have a heart condition.She assured they all wore masks. So when I went in the cook, caucasian man with dark hair was not wearing a mask and another black emplyee was back in prep area with no mask on either.He walked all way up to counter and took a mask out of his pocket and put in on.I stayed back 10 ft with my mask on.So I asked why they didnt have them on and that the Girl had assured me they all wore them and he said They werent required .So I asked for a manager and he said there wasnt one.And he laughed at me when I said why did she tell me all personel wore masks. So I told him I didnt want it but my husband had charged it on his card.So I reached and got it far back as I could.Box was almost cold and I had been early per the girls instruction. He gave me the owners name and number but It couldnt be read.Dont go there. You are taking your life in your own hands. Sharon Raines S read more