Found this great pizza shop after leaving the local KOA and doing some exploring downtown Forsyth. This is a great pizza joint with a very welcoming staff, the sidewalk seating was nearly filled so we grabbed a corner booth inside next to the large windows facing the street. We were immediately greeted by Ella who provided outstanding service during our visit she was very attentive and continued to check in on us ensuring our drinks were always filled. We order a 14" pepperoni, italian sausage with extra cheese and cooked crispy, the crust was amazing and all the toppings were of good quality and plentiful. This seemed to be a very popular restaurant on Friday afternoon with a great takeout business. They are definitely dog friendly at the outdoor seating area and there were plenty pups enjoying the afternoon with their owners. This is pizza I'd return for if back in the area we had a great experience... read more

See all

Wow! If you're in the area and craving amazing pizza, you absolutely have to check this place out. I stumbled upon it in my search and I'm so glad I did! This isn't your average pizza joint; with their delicious stone-baked crusts, it truly feels like pizza made to order, giving you a wonderful, personal experience. And you can order by slice! My favorite was the white pizza with cauli-flour crust - delicious! We got there just in time, beating the Friday rush, because about 20 minutes after we sat down, the place was bustling with both to-go orders and new diners. It might look small from the front, but don't be fooled - there's seating outside and a good amount in the back. The layout is a little quirky (you pass the server's drink station on the way to the back and restrooms), but it adds to the charm. I also appreciated that the manager walked around, checking in with everyone - a really nice touch! The food is delicious - so much so that I even took a pizza to go for later! Next time, I'm definitely going to try one of their specials (I didn't see them written at the counter until after I ordered!) and one of their signature alcohol slushies. I'll be back! read more

See all

Pizza was greasy. I also ordered the meatball appetizer which was good. I'd order that again.

Great food and wonderful people to serve you lunch or dinner. Their pizza is definitely the best in Forsyth, Ga. They inside and patio dining always makes a trip to Jonah's very enjoyable. read more

See all

The restaurant it's self and the service were great. If you are looking for a chill spot with good local vibes it's a great place. Everything food and drink was pretty average overall. We ordered the jalapeño popper sticks and it was just essentially a half pizza but with better crust than the actual pizza. The Florentine was okay but very soggy and had to be eaten with a fork and knife as all the toppings would have slid off. Ingredients were all basic, nothing really stood out as special. Jarred Jalepenos, hidden valley ranch dressing, etc. read more

Jonah's on Johnston - Pizza Florentine - Pizza Near Me - Forsyth, Georgia

Riding thru town from Macon to Jefferson and found this pizza place and it was delicious! Service was great! Highly recommend.

Me and my family were traveling through and decided to get pizza here. Workers were very friendly and super helpful, but the pizza is just average pizza. It was too greasy as well. Cool spot though, but felt like a chain pizza would've sufficed and been cheaper. read more

It takes a lot to screw up a pizza in my opinion...this place hits the spot. Crust is crispy/chewy and the toppings were all fresh. Everything was good and we all enjoyed our meals. Some items could have used a little more salt, but others were well seasoned. Service was attentive and nice. The place was clean and orderly...tables and their tops need some TLC-I know a random thing but our three tables were all different heights and made for awkward plate setting....and the finish is in pretty bad shape. We'd come back again. read more

See all

We had a wonderful meal here while passing by on our way north. We had a Greek Salad and an Islam Sandwich. The salads were tasty, but on the small side, but the sandwich was amazing. It alone is worth the stop. While we didn't try it, the pizzas all looked delicious. The atmosphere was very nice and the service was awesome. Definitely would go back. read more

If you look at the pictures of interior and exterior, you get the vibe. Cozy pizza joint in a cozy historical square. Great selection of food and beverage, large portions, nice, attentive service. Beware and use common sense if you are on a low sodium diet. It was definitely a cheat day for me, but enjoyed it! We'll be back! read more

See all

"Unbelievable... I've lived up north, and honestly, this might be some of the best pizza I've ever had. Absolutely incredible."

There's not many pizza pl here unless u get Pizza Hut and papa John's chain restaurant. Anyhow the pizza looks good we gave it a try. I order the special white pizza and Forsyth pizza, my husband love the white pizza and Forsyth pizza was good the only thing is it has so many topping on the dough that it got soggy. Next time I will try something else with less topping. Overall it's good. read more

Driving past the town, looking for a place to grab a quick bite that was not fast food. The service was excellent. All the girls working were friendly and attentive. Food arrived quickly and was delicious. Especially our Greek salad made with love from our sweet waitress. We have saved the location so we can stop back by anytime we are passing through. read more

I stumbled across Jonah's while I was in town for a work trip. A quick Yelp search revealed that Jonah's was one of the highest rated restaurants in Forsyth so off I went. I ordered a medium Hawaiian (yes I like pineapple on my pizza) over the phone and picked it up 15 minutes later. The restaurant has a nice vibe and seems charming and casual. The pizza looked great and quite honestly was baked almost perfectly. However, the pie did not taste as bold as it looked. I really wished the sauce -and overall pizza- had a bit more flavor. Overall the pizza was made well but unfortunately a little bland. It felt forgettable and 'ok'. It was not bad by any means but it was not impressive either. They probably have great pizzas on the menu so feel free to give them a try. If I was ever in town again I may try my luck with something different. read more

Jonah's on Johnston - Pizza Near Me - Forsyth, Georgia

Great tasting pizza and excellent friendly service. Outdoor seating available and enjoyable. read more

I came here while in town for work. I seen all the great reviews and a Forsyth Police Officer also recommended this place. I was seated right away when coming in. The hostess advised that I can sit anywhere I wanted to. There actually is a ton of room towards the back with several booths. I am so glad that I went to the back from. This place is a lot bigger than it looks from the outside. I already viewed the menu online prior to coming so I already knew what I wanted. I ordered the meat calzone with the additional toppings: onion, banana peppers, and mushrooms. The additional toppings were $1.00 each which brought the total to be around $13.00. The calzone was around $9.95 without the toppings. The calzone was huge but I was actually able to finish it as it did not contain as many toppings like I would wanted it to. The service was great and friendly. I highly recommend this place if your in town and craving pizza/calzones. There isn't many places to eat around Forsyth but this place definitely hits the spot. read more

See all

We ordered the Ultimo - and it was great! Service was friendly and efficient, food was excellent, restaurant was clean

Pizza was horrible. The pizza had a crap ton of grease and just overall tasted bad. The staff was okay but it took a long time for the food to arrive. read more

We found this place on Yelp and boy were the reviews right on target. The service was great and the food was delicious. Very cool atmosphere!! My husband got the Sangria slushy and said it was the best he's ever had!!! Such a great hometown place. Will definitely go back when we are in town. read more

Great pizza! Great service! Excellent location, convenient parking. Pleasant atmosphere. Nice that there is a family owned establishment that has the owners on site every day. I'm already excited about a return visit to try some other appetizing entrees. read more

Laid back (aka Southern) vibe in the front half of an old, former blacksmith shop (or so we were informed.) Eclectic decor runs the gamut from painted-on-peeling plaster walls (meh) to bushel basket lamp shades (cool). Somewhat limited seating in front and along side the big wood oven work zone. More in back. Our young server was friendly and congenial - and relatively new, so she had to ask other staff about questions we had regarding the menu. No problem; her charming smile and demeanor made up for the pauses in service. Water was served promptly but we had to wait a bit (since our server was under age) for our ice-cold beers in frosted mugs (ummm good). Again, we were not ignored and repeatedly were offered apologies. My suggestion.... relax and enjoy your time here. Pizzas are individually hand made - you can watch through the window into the "prep & work zone." Thick crust with appropriately thicker, chewy edge (yum yum). Great choice of fresh toppings and cheese! Go for it!!! Meatballs for our youngest grandson came in a screeching-hot-out-of the furnace cast iron skillet. Do-do-do be careful! Balls were a bit dry and highly seasoned with Italian herbs, spices and tongue-tingling pepper. Garlic bread - chewy and a nice accompaniment. Prices - very reasonable. Owner and staff - very welcoming and helpful. Only regret: we were just passing through and live much too far away for return anytime soon. :-( Last bite - check out the Anvil burger if you're ever lucky enough to visit. Oh my! read more

Popped in on our way back to Jacksonville & what a gem!! Weekly specials of the 2-slice combo were just the right portion size! Outdoor seating, friendly staff - and it was kinda perfect that the gentleman playing Live Music was playing Zac Brown Band! read more

Jonah's on Johnston - Jonah's on Johnston: Live Music on a Sunday - Pizza Near Me - Forsyth, Georgia

See all

First I'd like to say that the calzones are huge!!! They have pizza by the slice or a whole pie! We always feel welcomed by the staff, the service is great! It's a small town pizza joint with great pizza and a small town vibe! read more

Excellent food! We had a calzone and a meat, lovers pizza . Crust was excellent. Food came out quick. We ate outside, very Plesent! read more

Very good place to eat Staff is awesome Good place to relax after work Food is on point read more

Waitress made us feel rushed and Uncomfortable to continue to eat Eliza Kept pushing us to hurry up . No one was waiting for our table . We just wanted a nice dinner . Our brownie was so dry it needed to be tossed . Little Debbie brownies are better . Please be patient with your customers read more

The customer service is great! Everyone is always excited to see you and the food is great.

So having just moved from the Atlanta area I was doubtful that we would find a good pizza place in Forsyth. Well, we didn't, we found a fantastic place! Antico is one of our favorites and Jonah's can hold their own with them! The pizza is excellent, the pretzels are phenomenal and Jonah's edges them out with service and those great wine slushies! My move from the big city to a small town got better when I discovered Jonah's! read more

Good pizza, great friendly staff! If you are in Forsyth it can be a good option.

Confused by the reviews. We stopped here and tried their pepperoni pizza and margherita pizza. I asked the waitress if they made their pizza with fresh basil and she assured me they did. The pizzas were both very small for the price. The pepperoni was more cheese and lacked actual meat while the margherita was missing any fresh basil and had giant chunks of Roma tomato. Instead when I asked another server she brought me back a little container of dried basil. When we checked out, I noticed the "cooks" behind the counter appeared dirty and were not using gloves when preparing the food. I would not recommend this place. Overpriced and definitely not as advertised. read more

We have eaten here several times and the pizza is fabulous. The atmosphere, service and food are great!!

Absolutely delicious homemade everything! Fresh baked bread, desserts straight out of the oven, and homemade tuna salad. The bread and desserts were to die for, so rich and delicious. The people are very kind also, and made every effort to greet us and were accommodating to all of my dad's picky needs. Absolutely recommend this place! Ps. Tip from the owner: Baking is done on Thursdays... and it sells fast! Soooo delish! read more

The best sit down pizza in Forsyth by far. ..................................................................................................................,,. read more

We went for lunch thinking we would just have pizza but the Italian beef sandwiches caught our eye so we both had them. I chose pasta salad as a side and my Honey had chips. The beef was flavorful but very dry. Every other time I've had it the sandwich was so juicy you needed a knife and fork to eat it but not here. Like I said it was really good but I was disappointed in it's dryness. The bread it came on was delicious! The pasta salad was just awful. It tasted like it had been frozen and for way to long. I couldn't eat it and sent it back. We ordered a pizza to go to take home for dinner. The pizza was very good even reheated. I recommend the restaurant but ask for juice if you get the Italian beef. Next time we are in Forsyth we will eat there again! Clean restaurant, friendly and attentive staff and cute decor! read more

Jonah's on Johnston - Came for pizza. Ended up ordering Italian beef sandwiches. - Pizza Near Me - Forsyth, Georgia

The owners really want you to enjoy your meal. They put a lot of love & pride in each pie. Gluten free options available.in each pizza.

Great food and great service ! We had a party of 28 and our servers were amazing! Our food was fast, delicious and more than we could ask for! We will absolutely visit every time we are in Forsyth! read more

Very good, was ready when requested and very polite service. Have been there twice and both times had great service and good food

Ignore my previous 2 reviews . It took a little while but Jonah's got their act together. Family run business, super friendly and attentive, awesome Facebook ads and most importantly excellent food. read more

Two words- WINE SLUSHIES!!! So good!! Never tried cauliflower crust pizza and it was amazing. Went back at a later date with my son and it was still good but unfortunately way more greasy than the first time I went. Have been back since and it was just as good as the first time so not sure what happen the second go round. Everyone has an off day so I wouldn't necessarily count that against them, overall the place is really great. Their help is kind of young so if you don't already know what you like to drink, don't expect recommendations as most of them are under age. Which is not a bad thing in my opinion, they just couldn't recommend which slushie was best (sangria!!) great place would definitely recommend. read more

Amazing pizza! The crust was phenomenal. Cute little setting and a locally owned business.