My favorite pizza on the NW side. Hands down! The undercarriage is perfect, not soggy or floppy. It's not cheap but you can tell they use quality ingredients and the cooks know what they're doing. I would be remiss not to mention the house made rigatoni! I've only had it with vodka sauce, which is too delicious for me to risk venturing out to others. Front of house staff are welcoming and the ambiance is great as well. read more

We recently stopped by Fentonelli's and had a really good experience overall. I liked the counter service style and the vibe of the dining room. We started with the ABG salad that surprised me because I'm usually not a big fan of Gorgonzola, but the combination of green apple, pecan brittle, and cheese worked really well together and made for a great balance of flavors. For the pizza, we ordered the mushroom pizza and added pepperoni. The sauce was excellent I believe was some sort of a garlic/oil white sauce the mushroom portion was generous which I absolutely love, and the crust was exactly what I look for crunchy on the outside while still soft and slightly sweet inside. My only minor complaint with the toppings is that the $4 pepperoni add on felt a bit light, we only had a 2 or 3 slices per piece. The reason I'm giving 4 stars instead of 5 is that our pizza was just slightly overcooked. The bottom was charred all the way around; wasn't burnt to the point of sending it back, but definitely left in the oven a minute or two longer than it needed to be. It wasn't busy when we visited, and it seemed like the employee rotating pizzas was a little more focused on chatting with FOH coworkers than keeping an eye on the oven. I've worked in pizza restaurants for nearly a decade, so I may be a bit more particular than most customers. Realistically, if our pizza had come out even a minute earlier, it would have been a 10/10 meal. That said, I enjoyed my visit and will definitely be back. The quality is there, and I'm looking forward to trying more of the menu in the future. read more

Fentonelli's Pizzeria and Bar - Pizza Near Me - Tucson, Arizona

See all

We saw a stellar IG review and were so hoping for a solid OV pizza experience. First mistake, we ordered just before 6pm on Friday - the entire parking lot was completely full - no exaggeration - with no pick up spots in front of or near Fentonellis. Had to park illegally in front of the Credit Union to pick up my pizza. We ordered online (you actually have no choice if you want to pick it up) where you're not able to customize/do half, so it was cheese with added meatball (a +$5 up charge) - total bill with tax, 29.71 By the time I got the pizza to bring home, (wait in the restaurant for pick up depended on a waiter and there were three of us - in between which he was serving tables their drinks) the bottom of the box was soggy and the pizza was cold. Even before we heated in a hot oven, it was overdone, really salty and no meatballs- see the photo - instead there was a tiny bit (less than 2 oz) of hot sausage on an overdone pizza. Not anything close to decent or what we ordered. Don't kid yourself, this is not NY pizza by a long shot. The search continues. read more

See all

Absolute Gem! We stumbled into Fentonelli's not certain what to expect, and I'm so glad we did. Old-school Italian menu but a modern restaurant feel. The service was fantastic. All of the food came out very quickly, despite them being busy on a Friday night. Most of the food was great, and the simple cheese pizza may have been the highlight! read more

Fentonelli's Pizzeria and Bar - Wings - Pizza Near Me - Tucson, Arizona

See all

The mushroom & truffle pizza was heavenly! My cocktail was just okay, next time I'll just get soda or a beer. Although you order at the counter, they still serve you at the table and check in on you-will be going back! read more

Fentonelli's Pizzeria and Bar - Roasted Mushroom Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tucson, Arizona

Best pizza I've had in Tucson so far. Highly recommend if you are a fan of a crispy, thin NY-style pizza

This was our first time here, and we will 100% be back! The staff were so friendly and accommodating to dietary restrictions. The atmosphere was relaxed and comfortable, with direct views into the kitchen for an added entertainment factor. The ABG salad was fresh and delicious with a great crunch factor from the brittle. The pizza totally hit the spot! I love thin crusts similar to those of a Neapolitan style pizza, and this was reminiscent of that. We look forward to trying dessert next time! read more

Fentonelli's Pizzeria and Bar - Half and half sausage and veggie pizzas - Pizza Near Me - Tucson, Arizona

See all

I didn't know they were associated with Reilly's pizza. Not a bad thing as both make excellent pizza/food. The counter person was super helpful and helped me double check what we paid for. The place is clean and spacious. We were getting to go pizza so we are next door at one of the best beer bars in the country, Tap & Bottle. Great spot to check out. read more

Fentonelli's Pizzeria and Bar - Pizza Near Me - Tucson, Arizona

One of the nice Pizza Spaghetti bar in town, they offer Gluten Free!!! I've ordering Vodka spaghetti meat balls and a sliced pepperoni pizza!! Tasty and strong flavours spaghetti... so delicious!! Services were provided To Go and Table services... quick and efficient... environment is quiet authentic Italian style and contemporary dining room!! read more

See all

Popped in here on a Sunday afternoon around 3:30 PM. Wasn't too many customers. We were greeted immediately upon entering. You order at the counter, then seat yourself. We got the Margarita pizza (add cheese at pepperoni) and Rigatoni pasta with Alfredo sauce and chicken. The pizza was good, I'd come back for it. I wasn't a fan of the pasta, the noodles were rubbery. They Had a nice playlist going, smooth R&B read more

See all

Been eyeballing Fentonelli's until now, and I finally at least tried it for carry-out pizza. I gotta tell you, I'm pretty particular about my pizza. And born and raised in The Bronx. And I absolutely loved Fentoneli's pizza! First of all, the online ordering experience was a breeze, the pizza ws hot and ready on time, and I even received a text notification that it was ready. And the woman working the counter was pleasant and welcoming. Secondly, the pizza itself (Neapolitan-Brooklyn hybrid meatball in my case), exceeded my expectations! Crust? Nailed it - crispy AND chewy, charred on the bottom but just enough. AND it had a few dough bubbles on top! Texture? Pretty much exactly what I look for. Sauce to cheese ratio is also very good. Cheese itself is quality mozzarella. Tasted delicious. And for added bonus, conveniently located. Instantly became the new go-to pizza place with the first bite. Will absolutely return! read more

Fast and casual pizza joint, counter ordering, with quick and attentive service.Went there on a busy Thursday evening and was impressed by how quick they were turning out food orders. Pizza only comes in one size (16inches) - more than enough for 2 people with leftovers. The spicy chicken wings were spicy for real and yummy. Their food seems to be on the milder garlic scale as the cheesy garlic bread was cheesy but lean on the garlic flavor... same with the marinara and on the pizza. Mind you this is not a bad thing depending where you fall on a garlic scale. I personally an heavy handed when it comes to garlic. I enjoyed watching them hand toss the pizza dough as it is an art! Decent drink selection available. Indoor and outdoor seating available. Parking can be a bit challenging but a little walk is definitely needed after a good meal. Will return for sure to check out their other menu items. read more

See all

The food was good. The vibes were good. Service was good. Definitely would come here again! read more

Fentonelli's Pizzeria and Bar - Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tucson, Arizona

I'm really trying to find a good pizza place, this one had decent ratings. I called but it says to order either online or in person, no more call-in orders. The website is easy to use, but it wouldn't let me customize an order. I wanted the meats one ($30) but I didn't want meatballs, it wouldn't allow me to remove the option, only to add more. I got a pepperoni instead ($27) each additional topping is $3, so I just stuck with the pepperoni. I also ordered a ranch cup ($1). No drinks available. I'm not sure what ranch they use, but it didn't taste like any ranch I've had before. Not in a good way. I thought maybe it was blue cheese? And the tiny cup it came in, was enough for maybe 2 slices. I ate all but 1 slice, I didn't want to waste food. I wasn't really a fan of the dough or the pizza in general. Not really what I was looking for, but everyone is different. read more

Fentonelli's Pizzeria and Bar - Classic pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Tucson, Arizona

I gave this place another try since I saw they have $5 lunch slices. I personally don't mind the fast casual way of dining, order and pay at the counter, get a number and go take a seat. I ordered half of the ABG salad which is one of my favorite salads anywhere (they also have it at Reilly). I also got a slice of pepperoni. They brought my salad and a minute later, my pizza, so the pizza gets cold while eating the salad. The food was awesome but for $5 the slice was small. 1 slice isn't enough for a meal. Service was very friendly and even though there isn't actual table service, there is someone going around doing server duties. This is a decent choice for a light lunch. read more

Fentonelli's Pizzeria and Bar - Lunch slice - Pizza Near Me - Tucson, Arizona

See all

Love it here! The vodka pasta is my absolute favorite. The bread and butter is to die for!!! read more

See all

The pasta is really, really good! We love the rigatoni with vodka sauce. We liked the previous concept of being served; instead of the current ordering at the front. The worst thing that they did was replace real napkins with cheap diner napkins. We must go through about 30 or so when we're there. At Uptown Burger last evening, it was nice having a quality paper napkin....only needed one each. read more

tony pepperoni pizza is the best pizza i have ever had!!!!! The homey made it explode in your mouth!!! The salads were amaziiiiiiingggggggg as well!!! read more

Salad was delicious as well as the meatballs. I was craving meatballs and these ones satisfied my craving. Not pictured is pizza that we ordered which was so delicious we ate it all. Got some wine. Our server was very attentive and friendly. This place is modern-esque. I like the wooden booth tables they have and the cute lil pillows that are on the sides. Overall cool place! I'd come back and try some different options read more

Fentonelli's Pizzeria and Bar - Salad - Pizza Near Me - Tucson, Arizona

See all

Amazing Pizza! Fentonelli's was on my date night list and finally got to try it. The food was great and service was friendly. I wouldn't really classify as a romantic date night spot though. Nothing fancy for sure and menu is basic. We loved our hand tossed brick oven pizza and brew and look forward to returning with buddies! read more

Fentonelli's Pizzeria and Bar - Pepperoni, mushroom and onion pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tucson, Arizona

Our first time here last night. The pizza is fantastic. Best crispy crust I have ever had. The service was so friendly and spot on. Great place for date night or to bring your family. Will definitely be going back. read more

This is the most over rated and over priced pizza place in Arizona. I lived in New York City for 20 years and this pizza is 25% more than practically every pizza parlor in New York City and the quality is a 3 compared to 9-10 for virtually any place in New York. I've also eaten at all of the top places in Phoenix and Benet is at least 15% higher than all of the places in Phoenix and the Quality Inn Phoenix is an 8. TOTAL RIPOFF. They should be out of business. One block away is Whole Foods and your peaches is much better and much less expensive. Also, you can go a mile and a half east to AJ's, and their pizza is much bigger,better quality and less money. read more

Fentonelli's has been on our take out rotation recently and it's been pretty good. We'e enjoyed the cheese pizza, vegetarian (we love the kalamata olives on it!), and the mushroom truffle pizza. Online ordering is easy and the pizza is usually ready on time. The pizzas are quite large as well. Two will easily feed 4 hungry adults. The mozzarella sticks with marinara are good, but on the oily side. The pizzas dough is on the crispy and thinner side but not too thin, which I like. The ingredients are good quality and the tomato sauce is good. The menu has something for all tastes. read more

See all

Delicious pizza! We got takeout on a weekday night and it was quick, but we had to order online and go in person to place it. Nice space and patio with good beer next door at Tap & Bottle. Our pepperoni pizza had a generous amount of toppings and was delicious. read more

Fentonelli's Pizzeria and Bar - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tucson, Arizona

We've been to Fentonelli's a couple of times now, and we're fans of their appetizers and pizza! We've gotten the brussel sprouts, the meatballs and garlic bread, and the bread -- a super pillowy loaf that comes out steaming hot with olive oil and butter (*chef's kiss*). This most recent visit, I got my standard pizza order: pepperoni and mushroom. Theirs boasts a very solid covering of cheese and toppings -- no skimping here! I really like the lighter sauce and heavier cheese, and this hit the mark for me! I also really loved the mushrooms, which were cut thick and so retained a lot of flavor and moisture. My partner got the marinara pizza, to which he added pepperoni and meatballs. He liked it a lot, and said the toppings had great seasoning. We've found the service to be friendly, and enjoy the laid-back atmosphere. The pizza is on the more expensive side, for sure, but it's better than the chains by a long shot. read more

Fentonelli's Pizzeria and Bar - House-made bread with whipped butter and olive oil - Pizza Near Me - Tucson, Arizona

See all

Sat at the bar, Antoine is awesome. Great recommendation on food selection especially the brussel sprouts definitely a must. Pizza wise we ordered pepperoni and pickeled fresno chili, soooo good. Chill ambience and will definitely make a return trip read more

Fentonelli's Pizzeria and Bar - Pepperoni and pickled fresno chilis - Pizza Near Me - Tucson, Arizona

See all

Always amazing service when we sit at the bar. Meat Pizza and Caesar salad are great! Love that you can order and take to tap and bottle. The wings don't disappoint either. read more

My first time here and yes, I gave it a five star rating for a lot of reasons. Since it was our first time, we asked our server what he would recommend and we listened. And he was on point with everything! So glad we listened to him. Reason why we came? We were looking for a good pizza crust...call me crazy I love good pizza crust. And this place have the best! And I fell in love with their Rigatoni with Vodka Sauce! It is the best one I've tried so far. And their bread is so good. It was love at first bite! The place is not that big, so I recommend to make a reservation. Highly recommend this place. read more

See all

Fentonelli's is amazing. To start we ordered the Chopped salad and the Caesar salad. Both were delicious and very fresh. We also ordered the vodka pasta with meatballs. Also very delicious and tasty. Additionally, we ordered a Margarita pizza and a pepperoni pizza. The crust is amazing. I think I found my favorite pizza place in town. Then we ordered the chicken wings. We could not resist. The wings were very tasty and crispy. Awesome wings. Lastly, the cashier recommended the brussels sprouts. Very interesting definitely worth a try.. the food came out quickly and the service was excellent. I highly recommend this place. The ambiance is Very inviting and informal. read more

See all

Absolutely delicious! Such a warm inviting vibe inside as well. Definitely some of the best vodka pasta and pizza I've had! Highly recommend! read more

Fentonelli's Pizzeria and Bar - Vodka Pasta Rigatoni - Pizza Near Me - Tucson, Arizona

See all

Arrived about 2pm on a Thursday with just less than a 1/2 full dining area & 1 person at the bar. I ordered a pepperoni pizza to go which was only offered in one size 16" which is bigger than needed for 1 person. I enjoyed a Dragoon IPA on draught & engaged with the staff while I waited on my pizza. Ambiance was simple & clean with some fake plant's up high, nothing too fancy. Pizza was well cooked & I enjoyed it as well as my experience, but nothing stood out as above & beyond which was ok for me. I'll likely return to try other items on the menu & dine in. read more

Best pizza in Tucson! We have eaten in and take away. Most recently we did take away on a Friday night, we ordered online and had a small wait when we went in to pick up. The staff are friendly and welcoming. Not a huge restaurant and can't speak to wait times, but it seemed to be busy! We love their truffle fries and have ordered their mozzarella sticks our last couple of trips. We ordered their mushroom pizza this time and added sausage. We have also tried the white pizza -- again adding a protein -- and have always been pleased with the pizza. We can't wait to try them all! read more

Fentonelli's Pizzeria and Bar - Mozzarella sticks - 4 come with an order - Pizza Near Me - Tucson, Arizona

See all

Stop by for lunch on our way back to Phoenix. The place was pretty dead but the atmosphere was nice. The art work is cool and the service was nice. Our food came out fast and hot. The pizza was good and a decent size for 3 people. The bread and butter were good as well. I'd recommend for a quick bit and good food. read more

Fentonelli's Pizzeria and Bar - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tucson, Arizona

See all

Great pizza for all thin crust pizza lovers. Hand tossed dough. Service is outstanding and the atmosphere is friendly and welcoming. Save room for deserts made on site as well. read more

Fentonelli's Pizzeria and Bar - Fresh made canolli - Pizza Near Me - Tucson, Arizona

Their pizza was great, not store flavored. Pasta was very good. But their house wine on tap reminded me of how we would get it in Rome.

Very pleased with my spaghetti, vodka sauce and meatballs I had and the service. This is a great date night place or just a special night with friends. What the heck, just go anytime! So good! read more

See all

Visiting Tucson, don't ask me why, I'm a Sun Devil, but stopped in here to grab some lunch and glad we did. The meatball plate is empty in the picture because they were so good that my fork would not let me stop eating them. They come with garlic bread that was delicious. My ride or die wife had a chopped salad that she absolutely loved. Homemade Italian dressing that she said was some of the best she had tried. The slice of pizza looks awesome and is awesome. The crust was crisp and chewy, just perfect. A definite come back when in Tucson. read more

Fentonelli's Pizzeria and Bar - Great pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tucson, Arizona

Fentinelli's is a Must-Try! Pizza is amazing. Fentinelli's pizza is next-level. Even Jacob , the guy working the dough deserves a shoutout. The crust? Extra thin, crispy, and absolutely delicious. And don't even get me started on the pasta sensational. Every bite is packed with flavor and cooked to perfection. Five stars across the board. I can't say enough good things about this place. White cheese pizza to die for .Highly recommend. Love it! read more

See all

The pizza is ok. It's soggy like a Neapolitan, has a bit of crunch on the outer crust but the rest flops. The toppings are very salty. The worst - I paid $25 for rigatoni with chicken parm and got pasta with 4 pieces of 1/2 inch grilled chicken pieces. What a rip off!!!! read more

We went for restaurant week, which included 2 starters, 1 pizza, and 1 dessert to share for 2 for $45. The quality of food was delicious! We ordered the brussel sprouts (MUST HAVE) and mozzarella sticks. We got the Tyler's pie and although it was good, it was a little simple. We would try a different pizza next time. We got zeppole for dessert and they were delicious! Overall quantity was plenty for 2 and we even had leftover pizza for home. Could be a little pricey outside of restaurant week, but quality of food is good. Would definitely return. read more