Another bang up find! This place is the real deal. Get there early and HUNGRY! All the staff were…read morecool and friendly. The decor was simple and not over the top "oceany" as some tourist traps. I saw they were inland which I like. I try to avoid the neon wharf spots and I was so happy. I sat at the bar, which was full of welcoming locals and a tired traveling clown (me). The gravelly-voiced owner of I thing third generation paused a few times between sending out trays of steaming crab. He was a perfect blend of warm-hearted welcoming and hard-bitten tyrant. I went for the all you can eat feast at $69 (prices always subject to change) which comes with fries, hush puppies and coleslaw. I was assured the sizes were running large and it wasn't just a line. I was happy with the mediums. All I can say is they do crab RIGHT here. Fresh steamed ONCE so the meat is incredibly moist and succulent. And they just kept coming in trays of four. I ended up having a dozen which made it a deal at $69 compared at the price of a dozen à la carte. But who cares?!? They are blue crabs steaming and fresh and it was a feast. Side dish commentary: the fries are excellent. None of this cardboard tasting shoestrings. They were thick cut with skin on! The hush puppies classically tasty and the Cole slaw was not over dressed. Bonus!!! I can't wait to go back and try the she-crab soup and the bread pudding (highly recommend by my neighbor at the bar who is a local restaurateur).

Went for the steamed blue crab. They did not disappoint. Was able to order 1/2 dozen (all I needed…read moreas a single eater), added a side of corn on the cob. Crab was cooked and seasoned perfectly. Would repeat and bring my crowd.

We went to Seaside Fish House on New Year's Eve for a casual dinner, and we had a great experience…read more We were seated right away, and the staff gave us a heads-up early on that the food might take slightly longer because they were so busy. I always appreciate when a business gives me insight like this. We promptly received our drinks and were informed of the specials, which all sounded delicious. We put in our order, and we barely noticed a delay in our food coming out. (But nonetheless we appreciated the heads-up!) I had the short ribs, and they were incredible. They were falling off of my fork because they were so tender! The mashed potatoes served with them were also great. The rest of our party ordered seafood, and everyone in the group raved about how good their dishes were. My only regret was that none of us saved room for dessert! Something that also truly stuck out to me: one of the managers noticed my grandma was cold and adjusted the temperature in the room in which we were seated. I know this isn't standard practice at restaurants, but I can't say enough how much it meant to us that the staff paid so much attention to us. Seaside Fish House is DEFINITELY on my permanent list of favorite places in Delaware now.

We love the food and ambiance at the Seaside Fish House. The food is delicious, staff is so…read morefriendly and the ambiance is delightful. Whether you are in the mood to watch a football game (Go Birds!), enjoy a relaxing dinner with friends, or sit at the bar and enjoy a drink, this is the spot. The only downside is waiting through the summer and fall for the Seaside Fish House to open again (all their staff work at the outdoor Paradise locations that are open in summer). Give this place a try if you're here in the fall and winter -- you won't regret it!

Lovely clean airy dining spot on the main road next to brewery…read more Excellent service despite being busier than usual most of the time. Delicious calamari, wings and fresh raw oysters for appetizer! Love the Fat Crab Cakes, savor every bite. Good selection of drafts to go with the meal. One of the better choices in Rehoboth. Highly recommend!!

My family loves going to this restaurant! They have some of the best, if not the best, oysters and…read moreseafood in the area! They have a good selection of different oysters and are really fresh! They are knowledge about the flavors of each oyster type and have been on point every time! They have one of my favorite mignonettes made there that pair well with the oysters! The menu has rotating new items occasionally which helps change up the menu and choices available. The fish dishes are really flavorful, moist and cooked well! The crab dip was good, but underwhelming. They have delicious wine and cocktail here. The staff are always extremely friendly and accommodating. Food service is quick and on time. They have a big inside facility with a lot of seating. They have outdoor seating available during the warmer weathers and occasionally have live music and a fire pit. We will continue to back when we're in the area and definitely recommend trying this delicious food establishment!

This place is pretty cool. The big crab out front is a pretty cool feature. My little one loved it…read more The service was great as well. A rotation of 2 servers so we always had what we needed. We were in from out of town so the powdered sugar on the hush puppies were a little weird, but still pretty good. Very crispy and flavorful. Sweet, but good. The baby back ribs tasted fine, but there was barely any bbq sauce. After putting extra sauce on it, it was fine. The potato was not very good. The first one was partially black, but the immediately came with a replacement. But they were a little dry. The crab cakes were flavorful and pretty large and meaty. Not a lot of stuffing like filler. One is fried and one is broiled. Not much different between the two. Tasted great. Fries were really crispy. The admiral plate wasn't too bad. The shrimp was like cocktail shrimp and could use more seasoning. The fish was a tad overdone but the tartar sauce saved it. The tarter was probably the best I've had. Scallops. Same thing. A little overdone and needed more seasoning. The crab cake was great though. Might try this again.

Went here this past weekend as part of a crab feast/ casino trip . Upon arrival, the establishment…read morefrom outside appears to be big. Once inside the restaurant, the tables are long and very close together. Not too many table are just 4-tops of which means you'll be seated with others most likely . It was a tight squeeze to get up from the tables due to them being so close . They dump all the crabs and corn on your table which leaves lil space to actually eat them. There are three bathroom stalls for a really big restaurant of which causes a long line every time you need to use the bathroom. Now the crabs themselves were a mix of small & mediums but they were really juicy and had a good taste. The servers were pretty cool although they seemed overwhelmed with the large groups of people. Overall the crabs, corn, clam strips, and fried chicken thighs and shrimp were good. I would come back again just not on a trip so I can get a better chance if not being seated with people don't know .

Lovely experience!…read more We wanted some midday oysters and Matts Fish Camp was just the place! We stopped in and sat at the bar for some Oysters and drinks and I couldn't rave more about our experience. The oysters were delectable, the ambiance was wonderful and the staff couldn't have been friendlier and more attentive. I truly have zero complaints about our experience and will without a doubt be back next time I am in town!

The establishment was what was expected when on inside. I wish it was a little warmer, so we could…read morehave had dinner with dog outside instead of carry-out. The staff seemed truly friendly which is nice on vacation since a lot of places these days people are just rude, They made me feel welcome which is nice. The food was decent. We enjoyed the lobster roll and enjoyed the fish sandwich with hopes that it was truly fresh and not a Captain Sully's Summer Vacation Event. We gave a 4 not a 5 since prices were high and always get disappointed paying these prices when we can make the same thing at home. Although, we discussed that it would be nice to come back and enjoy a drink with a meal.

The crusted tuna and the pot roast were delicious. Our…read morewaiter John and the chef worked with us to avoid certain food allergies and offered slight modifications to the menu that met everyone's needs. The smallish dining area offers privacy and the quietness to carry on conversations. We still look forward to going there after many years.

This should be a DDD spot. Would never guess this place rocks. Been here several times and the food…read moreis always delicious. Clean, good atmosphere, always crowded. Props to a well run gem in Bethany...there aren't many

Captain Mac's is our go to place for crabs. They are consistently the best in the…read moreBethany/Fenwick/OC area. Call at 11AM (when they open) to reserve so you get the largest available. We had Large yesterday and they were heavy, juicy, perfectly cooked and seasoned. Add some fries, Oysters on the half shell, Corn on the cob and eat on the deck overlooking the bay...you can't beat it!

I love softshell crabs and this place has the best!!! They were perfectly cooked and melted in my…read moremouth!! It was an order at the counter and very clean place to eat. The staff was very helpful and I enjoyed talking with them. I wanted something beachy and this was the perfect place to go!! The view was amazing and Faith was a true sweetheart!! We will be back and I will bring my friends