I had dinner here on a Saturday night after exploring the village all day. Some of the local workers in Blue Mountain recommended trying it if we were looking for something casual. The atmosphere itself is pretty laid back and chill. The inner child in me thought the firehall theme was pretty cool. Service was okay. The actual food itself however, was not that great. I ended up getting a prosciutto pizza and wasn't really happy with the overall taste. Way too salty and oily. To be fair, that's what pizza is I guess. Yeah, I know. This review couldn't be more bland, but I guess that's the best way I could describe my overall experience there. Just okay. read more

Online ordering was super easy to follow. Our food was ready quick and was delicious. Staff at the pick up window were also very friendly.

Ok pizza though not outstanding. Better Pizza if you head over to Pie Wood Fired Pizza Joint. (Our go to place from now on) We had two pizza's, one was nicely done the other could have used a few more minutes in the oven. Can't imagine what the quality would be like if it was busy! read more

So impressed with the table wait time and information system through YELP! We put our name down for our group of 6, were told it would be ready at 7:15 (1 hour plus waiting time)--no biggie, we all enjoyed a cocktail and stayed tuned inn to the YELP APP. at 7:00 we were #3 in line, we headed over to The Firehall and as we rounded the corner -- ding ding -- Your table is ready! Excellent service received and excellent dinner too!! read more

We stayed at the Blue Mountain Resort for Labour Day Weekend. First time staying here. We had been told the Firehall was the place to have a good meal. My wife and I walked in with high expectation. Ordered a vege pizza. One of the worst pizzas I have ever had. We were told to expect a nice thin crispy crust. What we got was something that tasted like it was pulled out of the freezer. Thrown on the oven and that's that. The service was great. But i think they may have dropped the ball after the fire. We ended up dinning at Tholos the other nights. Much better value and good food. read more

Tastes like Frozen Delissios. I have nothing to add but yelp says my review is too short.

Pizza was comparable to McCain pizza and poutine was made with shredded mozzarella so overall disappointing and overpriced

Love the place, great pizza ! Wait time was 40 minutes tho. Too long imo but maybe due to covid restrictions

I wouldn't come again. There was a used lemon wedge on my seat when I first sat down. The hostess could care less to seat you. The waitress was nice. Very jack astors vibe inside but a lot more kids. Much more prefer other places to eat in the village or westin. Over priced for average pizza read more

Firehall Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Blue Mountains, Ontario

The menu has a nice selection of salads, burgers, pizzas, etc. The portions are good too. Overall I did like the food here. I just didn't love my experience there as they really jam them in there, and if it's a busy time at the hill then expect to wait a while for a table. It's also quite loud. And the staff at times seemed a little stressed out. Usually I just care if the food is good, but the ambience of the place definitely distracts a little... If you are looking for a relaxing time away from the city you probably won't find it here. If you have kids, there are lots of family friendly options on the menu. And you could save a few bucks by splitting some pizzas for sure. Though there definitely isn't room for kids to be running around... which might be a plus. read more

If Boston Pizza was a hit or miss, I'd say this is like BP on a hit night.The pizza was good and the atmosphere is friendly. I'd say it deserves 3.5 stars, but since I can only give 3 or 4, because of the great and super fast service, I give it 4. read more

Firehall Pizza - Sexy Texy Mexy - Pizza Near Me - Blue Mountains, Ontario

Good atmosphere in the heart of the Village. Good variation of pizzas and pastas - a consistent staple of good eats that you can count on whenever visiting Blue Mountains. it's pretty busy on weekends and I also see a lot of take out orders come in. read more

See all

Get spot! Quick and friendly service. Pizza was better then I expected. Fresh ingredients, wood fired thin crust. Everyone cleaned their plates! Would return! read more

Firehall Pizza - The Mystic - Pizza Near Me - Blue Mountains, Ontario

Not sure what the negative reviews are talking about, we were nothing but pleased by both and food and service at this restaurant. We loved the wait list feature that allowed us to explore the village without worrying about needing to wait for an hour for a restaurant. Once inside we ordered pizza, pasta and a sandwich, all were really delicious and wonderfully cooked. If we visit blue mountain again we will definitely stop in for a bite! read more

What we had: - Arancini - French Onion Soup - Hot Wings - Meathead Pizza - Spaghetti and Meatballs The arancini and the pizza was alright, the pasta and the soup was bad, and the wings were awesome! The guy serving us bumped this from a two-star to a three-star... Super nice guy! read more

I quite enjoyed the food here. The ingredients were incredibly fresh, including the mushrooms on top of the pizza. The risotto ball appetizer was really tasty! Order it - you won't be disappointed! The only qualm I have with this place is the slower than acceptable service. We had to go in to find out waitress to ask for refills and the bill. This is not the place to come if you're in a pinch for time. read more

See all

I thought this place had really awesome Italian food :) The pizza with pulled-pork on it was amazing & the pasta with the sausage was delicious as well. It honestly really hits the spot after a morning of hardcore skiing & snowboarding. And the ambiance is really nice as well :) I enjoyed the fire hall decorations. read more

Ok, so I will start off by saying this might not be a completely fair review as we are from the Buffalo, NY region and are surrounded by awesome places for pizza and wings. The pizza - was OK at best, and judging by the other reviews, it might have been an off night? We got the margherita which was just sauce & cheese, however it tasted doughy and undercooked and mostly a Neapolitan style . The wings - tasted like the one and only time I had them delivered from Dominos lol. They are microwaved/baked and _not_ deep fried. Very chewy and the blue cheese is a watery dressing, nothing like real buffalo wings. I've seen a lot of decent reviews for this place, we might give it another shot sometime and try something different. read more

Our experience wasn't so great. You can tell by the rating. The fire department uniforms were a nice touch. There is limited space to wait for a table. It was very crowded. My food was ok, but not eventful. I ordered a salad to go without onions. Guess what was on my salad. Yes, onions! I didn't discover it until I was on my way back to Indiana. Otherwise I would have taken it back. The service was crappy and I wouldn't recommend this restaurant while staying in the village. read more

Go to spot in the village! Decently priced and freshly made! They are always ready for walk in, and they will text you when your table is ready! You must try the sweet potato fries- they are perfectly seasoned and crispy! read more

Nice service and place, but the pizza wasn't anything special. The nachos also seemed like they just threw some cheese over a bag of nachos and threw them in the microwave. read more

See all

Ordered a Hawaiian pizza and it turned out "just okay". For the price the were charging, I was expecting better. Next time I'm staying at blue mountain and craving pizza, I would probably order takeout elsewhere read more

New year's day, we walked in for dinner with 2 young children and although they were really really busy, there was seating available for us in one minute! Our server was obviously experience and he was quick and very pleasant with us. The food only took about 15 minutes to arrive after we ordered, considering they were so busy, and it was soooo good!! We ordered a pizza and a penne a la vodka... The tastiest!! And.. We got to watch the hockey game! I would go Every single time we are in the village, at least once. I learned they also do take out orders! To take back to your room.. Good to know! Overall, a good experience! Decent prices for great food and compared to other village restaurants. read more

Great food plus great service! I had the bacon cheeseburger pizza which is a firehouse favourite and I could see why! My wife had the burger and fries. Burger was really tasty (although it was on the pink side) and the fries were crispy and spicy. Definitely recommend this place! read more

This place had pretty good food. I went here last night with a friend and the restaurant looks very neat and trendy. I ordered spaghetti and meatballs while my friend ordered bbq chicken pizza. The spaghetti was delicious and the portions were quite decent. It was nice that there was garlic bread to go along with it. The pizza was big enough that there were leftovers. I ate some this morning and it tasted so good! There were a couple of waitresses who were chatting around not doing any work, however the waitress that served my table did a good job. Like all the places at Blue Mountain, the food was a bit on the pricy side, but it was one of the better places overall. read more

See all

Food tasted stale, wait time long - especially for drinks (15 minutes for water? when waitress was available) Pizza crust was stale while bottom was wet and food seemed like it had been out all day. Overall, would not return, not good value for money. read more

Great service. The food was not bad. Found the burger to be very salty. The service was a nice touch and cool ambiance.

This place has a nice patio for the summer. I had a pizza with pulled pork, BBQ sauce, pineapple, and green onions. I also tried their dairy free cheese which was the first time I have actually enjoyed the simulated cheese. The pizza sauce was good, and the crust was not too dry or undercooked. They were also generous with the toppings. It's not as good as Italian pizza but definitely worth visiting if you are at blue mountain. read more

Recently ordered pizzas for take out. The entire ordering and pick up experience was perfect and I was really impressed with the efficiency. However, I was disappointed in the food itself. Not sure if it was an off night, but the pizza was one of the worst I've ever had. I was really surprised by how poorly made and low quality it was considering how well known this restaurant is and the price point. read more

Being Celiac, I did a lot of research to make sure that I can safely eat something while in Blue Mountain. I'm sad to report that Firehall Pizza made me super sick... their menu states that they can't guarantee cross contamination on their GF menu. Plus, they use a ridiculous amount of melted cheese on everything. I basically made it 10k down the road to the first gas station before I became violently ill. Consider asking for the smallest amount of cheese possible or replace with Daiya. read more

I've been here a few times. I love it here!! The food is great. Had Nachos and a few beers. Great!!

Pizza and pasta are both very good. The environment was upbeat and friendly even during a Saturday evening rush. The service was outstanding. Would definitely recommend. read more

Order something simple. Sexytexymexy pizza was so spicy and full of mayo. But the place was so crowded so i guess something should have been good there. read more

Firehall Pizza - Sexytexymexy pizza - Pizza Near Me - Blue Mountains, Ontario

See all

The pizza was like a B/B- but their beer selection was a D. Service was good. The prices are rather standard for the area.

Disappointing to say the least. We had to order online for pick up as it was raining so no patio service during Covid. The signage for pick was terrible...stating go to the side of the building, needless to say we were soaked by the time we got to the right side. Our food was ready, but the text came in 10 min after we picked it up to say our order was ready. It was already cold when we hit back to our suite. It wasn't tasty, it was like that slapped some canned sauce on the pasta and the pizza was not appealing. On top of that with a $80 order, they added a $13 online order fee! What's that all about? #firhallpizzafail read more

The food was really good, lots of choices other than pizza, however,​ it took some time to get our main food so make sure you order an appetizer​ if you are starving! read more

The food was excellent! We had the Penne Pasta with Vodka Sauce and the Tuscana Pizza, both were very delicious. We will be back for more!

Went here for dinner - service was speedy and the pizza was delicious. Only downside was the price of a beer - $10 for a pint!!!

Not a bad joint to eat standard fare, there are more interesting restaurants to be found however.

Had amazing food especially the suicidal wings, sweet potato fries, nachos and the meat head pizza & drinks. Our server was excellent and the food was good. First time visiting Blue Mountain village. One of the busiest restaurants in the village. Absolutely loved the look of the place. I would love to go back & have the suicidal wings. I would rate this place as a 4.5/5 read more