I haven't had this since I was a kid, and decided to give it a try again since my colleague is a huge fan. The location is exactly like any other Five Guys location, clean and efficient. The burgers are very customizable, and the prices are fair. I've always appreciated the free peanuts and still do. I recalled the fries being memorable, so I decided to give them another go. You can definitely taste the starchiness of the potatoes. I love that you can adjust the salt level, so I said no salt. They also don't salt their burgers. The food wasn't oily or salty, like the feeling I get with something like Shake Shack's burgers. These burgers are simple when you don't want anything special. They have a homemade feeling to it. This was definitely not as good as I remembered. Sometimes, a good memory is best left undisturbed. read more

See all

Great burgers made fresh when you order. Just know regular burger comes with 2 patties and a junior is single patty. And if you have peanut allergy, stay away. Free peanuts everyone eats and not sure how well tables are cleaned from patron to patron. So if you have contact allergy, steer clear. Also the fries are made in peanut oil. They make a damn good burger. Juicy & delicious. Only knock..cheeseburgers. Cheese isn't melted enough. You can see they add at last second and don't keep on grill long enough to melt it. Still, tastes awesome but I don't want to see fresh corners on my slice of American. I went with bacon cheeseburger. Bacon is crispy, not greasy and plenty of it to go around. Fixins are free: lettuce tomato grilled onions condiments jalapeños and more. Build your own burger. Sooooo good. Been to many locations of Five Guys. This one is on point with others. Happened to be in area today. read more

Five Guys - Cheese not melted well on cheeseburgers Still delicious - Fast Food Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

One of the best fast food burgers you could get!! Only competition is shake shack except shake shack doesn't have fresh jalapeños read more

Five Guys - Bacon Cheeseburger and fries - Fast Food Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

The burger was good, but nothing crazy. The service was fine, and not many people where here at 2:15 on a Wednesday. Food got to us quick and smell was fine. My milkshake was a little bit to much liquid, overall it was pretty good. read more

See all

Not only was the food good but the employees came up to me & offered me a mr.beast chocolate bar read more

Five Guys - Fast Food Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

My first time in this Five Guys and the place is very clean and the people that work there are very friendly and helpful I had the cheeseburger with bacon and onion which was good and their French fries which I think are the best from a fast food chain they were excellent and I also had a strawberry shake that was also very good. So if you're looking for a burger and a nice Shake and all the peanuts you can eat give this place a try read more

See all

I've had five guys once before which was pretty good, but my evening visit to get food to go here was rather disappointing. Mixed up my specific requests for my order, which wasn't the end of the world for what I wanted but felt like the burger patties really just lacked in any flavor whatsoever. Found a random mushroom in my patty. Only had like one bacon in my bacon cheese burger. Many things I could overlook but to have the burger itself just be so lack luster really just tainted this place in my head. I'm obligated to give one star but the only one star for the free peanuts always read more

Five Guys - Bacon Cheeseburger - Fast Food Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

This is the only Five Guy's location I've been to, and I hate to say it's not too mind blowing. It's simply a take on "quality fast-food", and though the fries may be some of the best in the franchise game, the burgers are not. The traditional burger meal is always extremely messy and greasy, and for the expensive price, it doesn't meet the standard. The cajun fries also take away from the original fries, doing too much with something supposed to be simple. However, if you get the grilled cheese and add a patty, it's a must. The shakes are also great, but I wouldn't go too far from the traditional vanilla, chocolate, and cookies&cream; as the other flavors are very inconsistent. This place is good, but not worth the expensive tag. read more

Customer service was good. It's a fast food restaurant you can go to and sit down with your kids or friends and have a burger your way. The burger was good hit the spot. read more

Five Guys - Strawberry Shake taste so good - Fast Food Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

See all

Can you guys get your shit together? Every time I get food from here theres a problem. First time I waited 30 minutes for literally one burger and some fries, I was the only person in the restaurant. Second time the fries tasted like literal dirt, third time I ordered through Doordash, paid, and waited an hour only for the dasher to come and tell me that they could not fulfill the order, even though it was conformed on my end. read more

Well you really can't go wrong with Five Guys in my opinion. As long as the burgers are not over cooked (which was the case this time but I've had many a juicy burger here before), it's a solid burger, second to Shake Shake and tied with Smash Burger. Get the Cajun fries if you like a bit of heat. Seasoned perfectly. Ingredients are always fresh and no extra cost for the toppings. Always good service and this location. For some reason, tonight this location was like an icebox. You couldn't really enjoy your meal and I had a hat! I've been to this location when it was cold outside and it wasn't this cold. Not sure why it was so cold tonight. Still giving Five Guys Bayshore 4 stars. read more

Pleasantly surprised I found this fast food burger palace of the gods at the South Shore Mall in Bay Shore. What's not to like about made to order never frozen burgers with fresh chopped toppings to add to a toasted bun. And the fries, omg the best fries, regular or spicy of any of chains bar none. And since when did they add shakes? Yep, got that too, a salted caramel straw sucking sweetness. Oh, you want to do something while they cook your food to order, munch on some salted shelled peanuts, yeah. Ah, simple idea, expertly executed, burgers, fries and shakes are back! read more

Five Guys - a hamburger, fries and ketchup - Fast Food Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

See all

Friendly staff that were super accommodating. They even give out personal bags of peanuts to adjust to COVID precautions!

NEW and I hope it stays like this... Very clean and very friendly staff of youngsters. Burgers and fries were fresh and the Oreo milkshake was OMG! Also... As of today they are still hiring! read more

Five Guys - Oreo milkshake... Amazing! - Fast Food Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

For tasty burgers and possibly a coronary, this multi location chain will satisfy. Went to the Bay Shore location outside the Sunrise Mall. I made a mistake ordering: you can get a large (two thick patties) or a small burger (one patty). I ordered the large thinking it was just a "regular size" but got two thick patties. My bad... It was still tasty and in spite of its huge size, I really enjoyed it. The fries are just okay and they give you a lot. Counter service was fine and prices are quite low making it a bargain for what you get. Worth coming back and recommended. read more

See all

I thought these were single burgers so I ordered 3 because my wife eats one and when I am really hungry I can eat 2. I also ordered 2 orders of large fries, and 2 large milk shakes. With the tip it was close to $70.00!!!! I guess you are supposed to order and wait by the back for your order but no one said anything so we just stood there waiting. A lot of people that came in after us were getting served so I went to the back and told them to cancel it, but just then the lady came over with our order. When we got home we found that the burgers were doubles with 2 patties on each, and it was like a bushel bag of fries. If I had known that I would have only ordered 2 burgers and 1 order of fries. In contrast, the shakes were in small cups. After we started eating my wife got a piece of bone in her burger and almost broke her tooth so all of the rest of the burgers went into the garbage. Why the hell can't any of the restaurants keep the bone fragments out of the ground meat?? This happens to us all the time with burgers and sausages. For $70.00 these should have been the best F#*king burgers we ever ate!!! Never again. I generously gave them 2 stars because the fries were good and the dixie cup of vanilla shake was tasty. We will not be returning to this establishment. read more

Not safe!!!Very disappointed on how they are handling COVID situation. There was too many people in store not social distancing, tables, vending machines for drinks and doors not wiped down. Pickup area no markings for social distancing with customers waiting around for orders. Spoke to manager and not happy with how he spoke to me very condescending and defensive. Will not be going back. read more

Staff gives their effort and are friendly. I don't think the burgers need to be so expensive, but they are good. I prefer the single patty myself. Today I got the double, even though I ordered the single. Now I'm not sure which they charged me for. read more

Food good but makes NO SENSE how I ordered food 2 days in a row. Went there 25-30 mins after I ordered and my order wasn't done. Both times they dropped the fries when I got there. What Is the point of ordering ahead? The asshole kid who always has an attitude for some reason made someone else's fries and then mine separate ? Not sure why you wouldn't do it Together. That kid is obnoxious and rude and I have an issue everything he is there. He's on of the cooks. black long hair and black glasses read more

I love the burgers and fries at five guys but this location was far the best. Service was great, the cook/chef was very nice and cooked the burger to perfection. This is how a business should be ran. Perfect perfect! read more

Good food But seriously clean this place. We are the first customers and the tables are sticky and the floor is disgusting

The food is always fantastic and the employees are always very understanding and friendly. 5/5 my favorite burger joint.

Customer service is so important and positive experiences aren't shared enough! My mom placed our order over the phone and George was a gem! I walk in to pick up the order and I'm welcomed by a lovely gentleman who couldn't have provided better service. Thanks for making our nights, we will be back soon! read more

Nice looking, love that they kept this interior true looking to most other 5 guys, great burgers as always, made very well and cooked thoroughly, constantly kept clean and my order came out fairly on time as expected of 5 guys. Complaints- no real notice of it being opened ever came up even though it was said to be opened months ago read more

Five Guys - Fast Food Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

Aside from the fact that every time I call ahead they get my name wrong, everything is always great! Order is always right. Staff is friendly. I kinda like seeing what name they thought I said each time lol read more

Cannot complain with Five Guys. Food is great, love their burgers and fries. Staff is friendly and the service was timely. Love coming here whenever possible. read more

I really dont see what the big deal is with this place. Average burger place. Overflowing portion of fries yay!

Great burgers and fries. It's nice and clean here and the staff is so friendly. I'm happy there's a Five Guys close to me now, but my waist isn't. read more

Got the usual, food was good service was good and almost shit my pants in the grocery store right after. #5guys

I've eaten here at least five times and every time I've eaten here I've had a long week on top of over paying for my food. If you're looking for an overpriced burger joint this is your place. read more

Great Fry's made from fresh potatoes. Fresh beef makes a great burger. Peanuts, Highly recommend for a tasty lunch.

Just got a regular cheeseburger, fries and a shake here tonight. Though I haven't eaten at a Five Guys for quite a few years, I found nothing to complain about. Everything was excellent, the same as I remember many years ago. The burger was one of the best fast-food burgers you can get (despite a couple of extremely small pieces of gristle). The fries were also very good (though a bit undercooked). And the shake was also great (though a bit too small and too thick, it needs more milk to really be thirst quenching). One minor quibble: they really need to specify that a "Little Hamburger" is not little at all. It's simply the same size as the regular burger but with only one patty instead of two. On the plus side, when you order two small fries you get enough fries to make up three small fries from any other fast-food restaurant. All in all, Five Guys burgers are easily the equal of the burgers you'd get at Long Island's other top fast-food restaurant, Shake Shack, and for a couple of bucks less, too. read more

Me and girlfriend come here every other weekend. Cant get enough of these burgers, dogs, fries, and shakes. We even triple stack our burgers. 5 guys never fails read more