Good burger, but a little expensive, 2 burgers and 2 drinks and one small fry came up to $34

Decent place for burgers in the Toms River area. If you've been to a 5 guys before, you've been to this one too. The restaurant was clean with lots of seating. Close to the movie theater so great if you want to catch a movie. Service was about average. Decent spot for food, but there are definitely other/ cheaper options in the area if you have the choice. read more

Five Guys - Fast Food Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

See all

Over-priced mediocre burgers. There's plenty of other local places to get a better one. Just another chain trying to sell you on a false premise of quality. read more

They won't take $100 bills, which is illegal in itself, when my order was over $80. I could see if I spent less than $20 but it was $80 for 4 people and the cashier would not take my money. Obviously it's not her policy. read more

It's a FIVE!!! Like all the time it's gonna be a FIVE! You can't beat a good meaty burger and this place has it. Then you can get every topping imaginable thrown in for free. The fries are crunchy, pillowy soft in the middle - YES! I'm writing this wanting Five Guys NOW!!! Okay so there is a bit of a wait at times and it's clean up after yourself and some people are slobs and have no respect for others and leave their crap behind - don't be that person! So you may have to clean a table off or wipe ketchup off a seat but that's a given in here. You gotta know what you are dealing with. Regardless, it's a great burger place. They even have comp peanuts in the shell to munch on while you wait or take a food boat home with ya. Either way it's good food and it's gooooood! Enjoy! read more

Five Guys - A lot of happy eaters - Fast Food Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

Delicious!!! I am not a big meat eater, I rarely actually eat meat at all. However, when I am in the mood for a hamburger, it's definitely Five Guys. This place has the best cheese burgers hands down I've ever had. Their French Fries are delicious. My son loves this place. When I let him pick where we go out to eat it's always here. The staff all works together and are extremely friendly. Everything is made to order, but it's never a long wait. But while you do wait there are large bags of peanuts for you to help yourself to. They have the new machines which gives you tons of drink options. I had have nothing but good experiences here and I really enjoy this location. read more

See all

Ur hers were always made fresh and the fries are hot!!!! Awesome peanuts to take home as well!

Unfortunately the last time I will come to this location. We purchased burgers with bacon, when the burgers arrived there was no bacon. After going back up to say there was no bacon I was handed a small tray of over cooked and burnt bacon. Unbelievable. read more

Five Guys - Burnt bacon - Fast Food Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

See all

Love five guys close to homemade burgers and fries. I get a single with cheese and love to change up the many options for toppings. Hotdogs are good also. read more

I was here last night around 6:30 pm. The staff was tremendous. The sever Joe took my order and was very kind. The two grill boys were a little slow and not just in the food game. Jack made my milkshake and made it extra special . Joe was the best staff member I have seen at this location, it's safe to say the others didn't go far in the education system, hence why they took so long for everything else. BUT Joe, wow what an employee. The burger I also ordered was handmade by him and was extra meaty juicy and delicious. I would definitely go again and see Joe. read more

I will confess that 5 Guys was my go to place for a burger in the past. However, the last few times I was unimpressed. I decided to try it one more time. Again, I was not impressed. There were a few people inside, the store was clean, and there were 4 people behind the counter. My order was taken, and they did not get the order right. Ketchup, Lettuce, grilled onions and pickles on one, ketchup, lettuce and raw onion on the other. They missed the pickles on one, and forgot the lettuce on the other. The fries shrank. There was no way we finish the serving of fries before. 2 doubles, 1 fries, and 1 soda, $31.00. Ouch!! I'm not coming back anytime soon. read more

Let me start off by saying I love five guys burgers and fries. Their food is very consistent. However, my complaint would be about the online ordering service. Twice we have ordered online and both times when I told them I'm here to pick up my food, they tell me it's not ready and I wait an additional 10 minutes. They need a better system. Why even order online if I drive 10 minutes to get there and have to wait an additional 10 minutes anyway for my food?? Makes no sense. I'm not going to order online anymore. read more

Better than your fast food burgers. I've had much better burgers. Tasted better burger in diner's.

We stopped at Five Guys on the way to Six Flags. This place doesn't disappoint, I love their fries. The challenge is, I'm a vegetarian and while they have the veggie sandwich often times I'm underwhelming. It's just veggies between a bun, no veggie patty. I topped my sandwich with fries and it was good. 5 stars for great fries but 4 because I'd like to see a better option for vegetarians. read more

Expensive price for very little food. Burgers are greasy and fries are soggy. Better off going to Burger King.

Although prices are a bit expensive for a fast food joint. It is very well because burgers are always fresh and the fries are freshly cooked in peanut oil that always taste soooo amazing. 5/5 would recommended for a great burger,hotdog, fries and more read more

The best delicious burgers I ever had always cooked medium and not rare love it numerous choices of toppings the best French fries return to them always read more

Outstanding! I haven't had five guys in years and it was outstanding! I love the vibe in the restaurant. The red checkers and the newspaper's on the walls really sets a mood. Now you would never think that at a burger joint, the restaurant would be giving you free peanuts as a little snack before your food. It's such a unique and great way to prepare for your delicious meal. And the peanuts are fresh out of a giant bag, which means you crack them open and eat them. A little hard to break off, but worth it. I'm not a big peanut guy, but these peanuts were to die for. They were salted to perfection! After that little snack, the main event was calling my name. I ordered a bacon cheeseburger with lettuce, tomato, pickles, grilled onions, and BBQ sauce. This burger was so juicy and delicious! The burger was even falling apart a little to how mouthwatering it was. Perfectly cooked, the bacon added a nice crunch, tomatoes were juicy, and the BBQ sauce was sweet. As for the lettuce, one leaf is all you need and five guys satisfied me with that! The bun was awesome. It held the double patties and cheese together and was toasted. A great bun makes a great burger! My only downsides however were that it lacked A LOT of BBQ sauce and grilled onions. I could care less honestly about the grilled onions, but the BBQ sauce kind of let me down. I only got it on the first few bites. But overall, the burger was incredible and filling! Their french fires are the best fast food french fries I've ever had. So salty, crispy, and amazing! The best part is I ordered a regular and there was a huge pile at the bottom of the bag that made me even happier! Now after this meal, I had to try a milkshake...and it hit the spot! The Oreo creme milkshake was thick, creamy, and wonderful! It was a perfect balance between Oreo and vanilla and they used so much whipped cream on top. It was splendid! Now I have to ask this question...How did they get their name, "Five Guys Burgers and Fries"? read more

Five Guys - a hamburger with lettuce and cheese - Fast Food Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

Rude staff. They start closing the kitchen a good half hour before the designated closing time & will refuse to let you order anything. If you're going to close the kitchen early because you're in such a rush to get home then the restaurant hours should be changed accordingly. Stop making people drive to your establishment thinking that it's open only to turn them down. will not be returning. read more

This was our first time ordering and they didn't make any of the burgers with what we asked and they forgot an order of our fries. Service sucks there. When I called they told me they couldn't refund my credit card and that I had to come in person even when I said I'm home sick. We're in a PANDEMIC. lol won't be going back. read more

I've been to Five Guys in various states along my business travel. I am always happy and satisfied with the service I see and receive. However, this location has to be amongst the most friendliest and welcoming I've experienced. The employees wear genuine looking smiles, and everyone has outstanding mannerisms. I would consider this a model location for customer satisfaction! Please extend my appreciation to the staff of this Five Guys location! read more

The food here is PHENOMINAL!! The burgers are very tasty, the fries are so good, and the milkshakes.. they are the BOMB!!! My favorite has to be the strawberry milkshake. The shake itself is very rich and creamy, and then you have the little strawberry chunks that reinforce the pleasurable experience. I would HIGHLY recommend this place for a treat!! read more

unprofessional staff when my order was incorrect and had missing items. Won't be back at least to this location.

Five Guys Burgers And Fries, 1311 Route 37 West, Toms River. Five Guys Burgers And Fries score and grade was excellent. Food nutrition was excellent. Food taste was excellent. Menu prices was excellent. Service was excellent and out standing. When there was a problem the manager handled it very professionally. I highly recommend this place for lunch and dinner. read more

It might seem strange that I am giving a "fast food" restaurant 5 stars, but in its particular category, it's about as close to perfect as it gets. There isn't a whole lot of great choices for food in the Forked River/Toms River area. Oh, sure, there are nicer restaurants, but strangely I prefer Five Guys. I've eaten here maybe 20 times, but only at this particular location. I've seen other Five Guys, but usually they are in places where I have more variety in quality food, so I don't opt for it. Still, for what it is, it is the best. Decor: Not a whole lot to say. A bunch of tables and chairs in a semi-cafeteria style seating. There is also "bar" seating with stools by the exit glass wall. Service: Friendly. Helpful. Generally positive attitude. About as good as you can expect for this sort of establishment. Food: Your options are limited. You can get burgers or hot dogs and fries. I've never seen anyone go for the hot dogs, so it's basically a one pattie or two pattie burger with a huge selection of possible toppings (from cheese and bacon to jalapeño and mushrooms). And all the toppings are free, except for the cheese and bacon. Fries are normal or cajun-style. And everything is huge here! Still, what they lack in variety, they make up in quality--their burgers are some of the best burgers I've ever had. Even better than more expensive "sit down" restaurants like TGI Friday's. Certainly the best in the fast-food category (admittedly, I haven't tried In-And-Out Burger yet). Big, juicy, flavorful, they hit the spot! The fries are also pretty good, especially the cajun-style which has a hint of spice to it. Sodas are the standard fountain fare (self-serve refills), but they offer an endless supply of complimentary peanuts to snack on while you wait for your food. It's burger heaven! read more

Burger patty's are small for the price but good. The burgers are cooked done so if you are a med rare person you will not see any pink, but be assured the burgers are not dry. The Fresh cut fries are a treat. The burger add on's such as mushrooms, sauces are free. If you are hungry I suggest you get the big burger (double patty). Always busy so plan ahead on Friday and Saturday nights. Enjoy! read more

A wonderful little fast-food chain with some really great burgers! My husband and I had stopped in at this particular location for a meetup group we are participants in. My first impression was that for a Wednesday night, it seemed very busy. The place was very clean and the staff was helpful and friendly taking our order. Make sure you realize that if you are only wanting ONE burger on your bun, to ask for a small, because otherwise you get a ton of meat! I do love that I can customize my meal here, and just simply kill a burger craving in no time. I hear a lot from my friends in the West that there is no competition with In & Out Burger, but you know what, this is all I have and it's incredible food! read more

Five Guy's burgers are like eating a steak that has been conveniently chopped up for me and smothered in all kinds of goodness. Add to that a week's worth of greasy fries and I am a happy man. Now they also make hand made milk shakes which is just like having ice cream!!! If you have read any of my reviews, than you will know I love steak and ice cream, so for me this is a win win situation. The only downside is can think of is the food coma I go into and the meat sweats later on...but well worth it. Thanks Five Guys, keep up the good work. read more

I have to admit the only reason I've been to this Five Guys is because of a monthly geocaching event. That said, they do a good job with the hamburger, especially when I get it with everything, plus jalapenos, peppers, onions, and hot sauce for the extra kick! Of course, the endless peanuts are a plus too. Also, this is one of the few places with two Coke Freestyle machines so you don't have to wait for someone else to make up their mind picking a drink. read more

See all

You can never go wrong with Five Guys. Huge portions for both the burger patty and fries. I usually just order the Little Bacon Burger which is about the size of a normal McDonald's burger. Also, an order of fries can be good for 2-3 people already. And of course, the free peanuts are always a nice appetizer while waiting. read more

The burger here is way better than the big 3 fast food joints. One of the better in town. Tends to be overcooked for me, but I know that going in. Fries are very good but I wish they'd lighten up on the heavy handed Cajun seasoning. Better off getting plain fries and ask for a side of spice. Still one of my go to burger stops. The fry portions are huge.... bonus. read more

Always good, solid burger every, single time without fail. Fries always delicious, food made right in front of you, not much more you can ask for. Milkshakes top notch, only thing I haven't tried are their dogs. I'd take a burger here over a burger just about anywhere else, I've yet to find one that matches up consistently. read more

The. Best. Do yourself a favor and get small fries or share a medium and still have plenty left.

Giving 5 stars for the friendly and professional staff in Toms River location and the $4 milkshake. The flavors are great and you can add as many different flavors as you want in each shake. Chocolate/coffee is my favorite and my husband loves the peanut butter shake.The size of the shake is decent; it will definitely fill you up so don't have it too close to meal time. The French fries, hot dogs and burgers are nothing special and are EXTREMELY overpriced! Minus 2 stars. I would only recommend you go there for dessert. Get a milkshake; you won't be sorry ... unless you're lactose intolerant! read more

We went to 5 Guys today for lunch, my wife and myself. We have been long time customers here. When we walked in, we were greeted very well( just checking to see if there was indoor dining). I looked at the menu, and couldn't believe my eyes. Everything was just about double.all of a sudden a bacon cheeseburger was now $9.85...everything else seemed to double as well. The girl behind the counter said these are the after covid prices. smh..I know one family they lost as customers forever. They might of just priced themselves out of business. read more

Terrible service!!! Picked up dinner and came home and was missing FF, and toppings on my burger. I paid for it online and they would not refund. read more

We love this place! It's my first time in this one and won't be our last! Greg does an amazing job keeping it spotless! Love that! He is super friendly too. Debbie & Chris are super too! Chris always smiling & friendly and Debbie (manager) going around to all the patrons' tables asking how everything is!! Kudos to u all. Thx for a great 5 star experience!! read more

Five Guys - Love this burger place!! - Fast Food Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

See all

I've ordered from here many times but it just doesn't live up to the hype people pile onto it. The burger quality seems to vary depending on the day and doesn't seem worth the price. Fries are very overdone, or at least they were the last time I ordered. At least they give you a lot. Bonus points for good shakes, but I don't feel overall like they offer up anything better than what I can get for cheaper at another place. read more

the burgers def taste good.. Simple MUCH better than any other Fast Food spot. its simple and Quick.. not thrills no frills, no server , just pay, then take home or sit down.. it was my fav spot ( the one in brick) until i discovered a New Spot for a Bangin Burger which i would like to share with U ALL!!.. : CHEEBURGER CHEEBURGER WOW BROTHER WOW!! this place has 5 different size burgers including a 20 ounce monster for big boys like me... u can do take out or sit down.. servers are friendly and menu has some more options Like wraps, but the BOTTOM LiNE is the buger taste amazingly GOOD!.. but brother, if u get the 20 ounce, nicknamed the "famous pounder" make sure you have a plunger ready and up your fiber intake!!.. Eww i am serious bro! oops i 4got this was supposed to be about 5 guys, yea they are good too..! read more

This place is by far the best place for a burger, it's a very simple place you can get whatever you want on the burger and the fries are amazing, they even tell you where their potatoes came from that day. Plus you get free peanuts! Love this place! read more