Finding really good pizza in Tennessee can be a huge challenge. Now when I say really good pizza, I'm talking about the mom and pop Italian places in Chicago, New York and Miami that pizza lovers go out of their way to patronize. Well I'm happy to report 5 points pizza is very damn close to ringing that bell. Thin crust that isn't soggy or floppy but sturdy and foldable with semolina on the bottom. The sauce has an appropriate level of spice that compliments the pie not sweet or overpowering garlicky. That the toppings are spot on applied generously. Altogether these come into one to make a beautifully delicious pie. I normally get the plain cheese pizza because when you execute at the high level 5 points does, that's all you need! Highly recommend. read more

Five Points Pizza - Pepperoni and banana peppers - Italian Near Me - Nashville, Tennessee

See all

Quick bites while in East Nashville. Nothing too crazy & nothing too complex. If you need a good slice or an entire pie then surely this place is cool. In the heart of east Nashville- they move quick so that's a bonus. Can't say it was the best slice ever. It did the job. Pepperoni 8/10 Prosciutto and basil 8/10 read more

See all

Me and my son (forget all that 'My son and I bs--it reminds me of some tight-ass no-imagination English professor that wears a red bowtie and counts geese in all the parks in his county on his free time) went to a concert at The Basement East right down the road. It was close enough that we walked. If you're curious about who we saw at this 560-person venue, you will have to go to my IG. I got a few reels. IG is also the only place you can reach me now. FB, TT, X, website, and email are all out. I do have a secret email but it's most definitely not the one tied to this account--that one is inactive. I only mention how to contact me because the number of people reading these reviews exceeds the number of readers for my books. That's a lot of exposure. So, it's possible someone would say, "We want that mfer!" But therein lies the problem. I misbehave while being incredibly reliable. Anyway, about that pizza.... If you look carefully at the photo, you will see the slice of pepperoni in the background. My son told me it was the best slice of pizza he has ever eaten. And that's a lot of pizza. In fact, he has taken a photo of every slice of pizza he has ever consumed and posted all of them on his 'Pizza Wall.' His theory is that pizza always puts him in a good mood, so why not always be looking at pizza. Okay, none of that is true, except for the part that he said it was the best pizza he ever had. My slice was very good but I don't know about all that. It seems to be a common theme at Five Points East though. Therefore, go for it! Our server, Annie, was excellent. And very efficient at her job. As for atmosphere, pretty cool! Small but cool. And I actually like that they don't have Italian food and stick to their speciality. Also, there is a small bar in the back. Highly Recommended! read more

Five Points Pizza - Pizza 1 and Pizza 2 - Italian Near Me - Nashville, Tennessee

See all

Wow! Why can't we have this pizza joint at home? Visiting and this was nearby our hotel. Pizza was incredible and they have a great tap list and wine on tap. Service was friendly. We had the supreme and it was delicious. read more

Overall: This is a must after a night out. Well priced for a HUGE slice of pizza, and delicious. I wish I could've tried their garlic knots too. Service: Pizza came out right away and was hot and fresh! Ambience: A little window, tucked away - nice for a to go spot! read more

Five Points Pizza - Italian Near Me - Nashville, Tennessee

See all

This had to have been one of the best places in Nashville hands down. The pizza is so good! And the deals are actually insane. You can have a whole meal for like $7. They do slices of pizza which I think is a complete life hack. They have special slices every day. The vibe is chill and the service was good. We went back multiple times. read more

See all

My personal favorite pizza in Nashville so far. The perfect NY style pie, amazing under crust and not too floppy. I actually like the East location better, and honestly I prefer grabbing the bigger slices over ordering a full pie. The garlic knots are really good too. read more

Jenna N. treated us great. Made us feel welcome. I've never had bad service here. 10/10 read more

Five Points Pizza - Fat Bottom's Teddy Cerveza and a finished pepperoni slice. - Italian Near Me - Nashville, Tennessee

Wow, ok I have been to NY and the flavors on the garlic knots and Pizza was amazing delicious. Service hands done on point they take care of you and are all helping. Table was clean and such a chill pizza vibe place here. read more

Five Points Pizza - Garlic knots - Italian Near Me - Nashville, Tennessee

See all

I genuinely don't understand the hype around Five Points Pizza. The dough was one of the worst parts -- it looked and tasted like it had barely been proofed or allowed to rise at all. The crust came out dense, flat, and stiff like cardboard instead of having any real texture or chew you'd expect from a decent pizza place. What made it even more disappointing was how stingy they were with the toppings. For a place with such a strong reputation, the pizza looked bare and thrown together with the absolute minimum amount possible. The balance between crust, sauce, cheese, and toppings was completely off. For the prices they charge and the popularity they have, I expected something much better. This felt more like overpriced cafeteria pizza than one of Nashville's "must-try" spots. Learn how to proof dough! read more

See all

Dang that was a good vodka pie. Dare I say the best I've had. Knots were good too . arugula salad was amazing, not some super over salted pile of leaves you'll get at some pizza shops and he made it in 30 seconds flat - simple the way it should be. If you like a nicer pizza give this spot a try. read more

Easy to order online for pickup. I love that there's a separate area for pickup. The area is tiny, but they are efficient. The garlic knots are over the top garlicky and so so good! And we loved the pizza. We ordered one with pepperoni, the other cheese. The crust is thin, the sauce has a good balance of flavor, and the cheese is amazing. The pepperoni has just the right amount of flavor. Highly recommend giving this place a try! read more

Five Points Pizza - Cheese pizza and garlic knot - Italian Near Me - Nashville, Tennessee

Oh my gosh! I loved that pizza soooo much! I have a bookmark problem in the City of Nashville. I have way too many you see. I am not sure when I began hoarding BM here, but it's silly. This last trip I removed like 10 because they weren't there any longer. Ugh Anyway, I ended up here by total accident. I was hell bent on going to Joyland, just down the way, but it was completely empty. This place was packed so I took it as a sign from the universe. It was busy inside, but I found a seat pretty easily up by the front window. Oddly, there was a steady stream of people running by the place the entire time I was there. Like hundreds of people. Like for exercise, not running from Godzilla or anything. My server was some really skinny dude, he was cool though. He took great care of me and made some solid suggestions, one of which I ended up trying. He mentioned the Habanero Cream Pie and I was immediately intrigued. I like pizza, but I love strange, not normal type pizzas even more! This junt was right up my alley. I left off the onions on mine. Do what you like. It came out smokin hot in so many ways! I loved this pizza. The crust was great! The crust was great! The crust was great! The crust was great! THE CRUST WAS GREAT! The habanero cream sauce was so delicious. It was rich, creamy, and spicy to me, which is banging spicy to some. The toppings were fresh and well distributed, and it was cooked perfectly. I could go on and on about this pizza. Got damn! The leftovers would not fit in my mini fridge at the hotel so I ended up eating it all later that evening. FatAdam style!!! No regerts either! '25 - 84/111 read more

See all

First time visiting this Five Points location and I'm in LOVE! We walked in an hour before closing and we were seated right away. The staff were attentive and friendly. I love the vibe of this location. It's clean, comfortable, and inviting. We order a plain cheese pie and a house salad with vegan pepperoni. It was sublime! I just love their salads and their pizzas are some of the best in Nashville. We'll definitely be back to this location. 10/10 would recommend. read more

Five Points Pizza - Plain Cheese Pie - 18'' - Italian Near Me - Nashville, Tennessee

See all

Súper delicious food and great service. The garlic bread was my favorite! Would definitely recommend!

This review is for a catering order. I placed an order for a dozen pizzas for an event. Everything was fantastic- from the minute I placed the order to the moment it was delivered- excellent customer service. The pizza was so good! Everyone enjoyed the food and went back for seconds. The slice of Supreme I had was amazing. Five stars! read more

Five Points Pizza - Supreme pizza - Italian Near Me - Nashville, Tennessee

See all

I'm a fan! I initially tried Five Points pizza when they were giving away free slices, and eventually started coming for weekly family dinners. Pizza is amazing and my husband who has trouble processing flour can keep this down, huge win. It's not greasy or gross, just PERFECT!!!!!!!! Their service is great. I really like ordering their pizza for pickup, it makes it super easy! I also don't like red sauce pizza... but love this!!!! We usually order: cheese, pepperoni, old world, Bianca. Parking depending on time day can be tough, which is why I usually do pickup. Ambience: exactly what you could expect for a pizza place. read more

Dope vibe! Good pizza and service.Pizza came right out and everything was solid! Salad read more

Five Points Pizza - Italian Near Me - Nashville, Tennessee

I liked the crust on the pizza but the cheese wasn't great. It looks like they use a cheddar mix.Service was Amazing...

Pizza here is a must try, especially for out of towners. We live right around the corner and still eat here! If you're going to pay for something like Papa John's, pay just a little extra and get something great! Service has always been great! read more

After eating here a few times I felt that the quality was inconsistent, the first time was great and I enjoyed the cookie from Hifi. The second time, I felt that the waitress was unfriendly towards us but thankfully the host stepped in and the last time we ate with my dad and my sisters from out of town it was just okay. I agree with the few who call this over rated. I think depending on what you order/the type you get it can be great. Spending on the day and time it can be very crowded inside, parking can be difficult if you don't find residential free parking Great for a causal meal with friends, family or a first date. The vibes are casual! read more

Delicious New York style pizza. We ordered this one night and I'm so glad we got it. Easy online ordering process and it let us know what time to plan on picking it up. Easy peasy. We got cheese pizza with 2 sides of blue cheese everything was delicious. Always so nice that the pizza was still hot by the time we got home and it came as perfectly thin slices. read more

Five Points Pizza - Italian Near Me - Nashville, Tennessee

10/10 food - Absolutely AMAZING! We ordered the half portion (4) garlic knots and a 14" old world pizza and split across two people which was the perfect portion. Everything tasted better than words could describe. The garlic knots were soft but had some crisp on the outside. They are a decent size and paired well with the marinara sauce. The pizza was thin and crispy and so fresh. 8.5/10 service - Aside from our waiter smelling so strongly of cigarettes, service was good! Our food came out pretty quickly. 4/10 parking - There is a paid lot across the street and street parking is pretty limited (even on a Thursday night). We ended up finding some around 10 minutes away. read more

Five Points Pizza - Garlics Knots - Italian Near Me - Nashville, Tennessee

See all

Checked out 5 Points Pizza after a long day at work and it hit the spot. Had a cider and a huge slice of pizza for just $8 -- can't beat that. My travel buddy went to another local pizza place the night before and paid $35 just for the pizza plus $8 for a draft, so this was definitely the better deal. I got the meat pizza of the day and it was amazing -- satisfying, filling, and full of flavor. The place definitely has a hipster vibe, but in a good way. I'd absolutely come back again, especially for the happy hour drink + pizza deal. read more

Five Points Pizza - Italian Near Me - Nashville, Tennessee

See all

Pizza was excellent. Service was good. Lot's of table for dine in. Great price 2 slices with soda $11. Will definitely come back if in town! This is a New York style pizza. read more

Five Points Pizza - Slice of the day! Fresh Mozzarella, meatballs, onion, minced garlic and red sauce! - Italian Near Me - Nashville, Tennessee

Five points is hands down best NY pizza in nashville! I actually would say Frankie's is up there too but they taste different/ same caliber. I love five points because service is amazing, atmosphere is great , garlic knots are top notch and the sauce! My only critique would be to beef up the salads more and make the Greek salad better. Overall five starts for five points! read more

Pizza is huge but amazing the ambiance is nice because the walls look crappie but they add ascetic to the place and it just stands out in east Nashville making it even better read more

Yea, it's still the Best. And, this location is it too. Dine in, or take out, it's always worth the trip. read more

Five Points Pizza - Large please. - Italian Near Me - Nashville, Tennessee

See all

Great place for a perfect slice of pizza, a whole pizza pie, garlic knots and more! The slices are thin and extra large - it takes two plates to hold them. This is a great spot to share pizzas, or everyone in the party can get their own slice. Kids and adults will love it! When you walk in, there is an option to order at the counter and dine in, place to-go orders, or you can dine in. Service was quick and friendly. The restaurant is a great atmosphere, with bar seating, booth seating, tables by the window, and an outdoor patio. I will definitely be back soon! read more

Five Points Pizza - Meat Lovers of the Week, Cheese Pizza, Prosciutto & Basil - Italian Near Me - Nashville, Tennessee

I had the pepperoni and mushroom pizza and I added black olives. Positives, the crust was phenomenal and their ranch is to die for honestly I could've just eaten that and would've been happy. The cheese was good nice ratio of sauce. The only thing I didn't love was the pepperoni tasted kind of gross like the meat itself wasn't very good. & I think it just felt overrated to me because I heard it was the best in Nashville and it was medium OK. read more

Five Points Pizza - Italian Near Me - Nashville, Tennessee

Our favorite pizza joint! The quality is amazing. Their choices of slices per day - creative and so flavorful! The service could be better, but it's a pizza joint so my expectations aren't high. Ambiance is family-friendly. read more

Man this place was poppin! I found this site off of Dave's one bite pizza list. Wait time was about 20 mins. My sister and I got half pepperoni and half pesto with no mushrooms. I got 1 cheese slice as well. Her husband did a meatball type and something else. We also ordered garlic knots. Service was quick, and our waitress was very attentive. The garlic knots were good, my party enjoyed them greatly! The pizza was really tasty, not what my taste buds wanted but it was still good none the less. The crust was tough to eat, was pretty hard. I had the pizza cold the next day and it still was really good :) and reheating was still good as well. Would have been 5 stars if wasn't for the hard as a rock crust. Definitely recommend people try this place! read more

See all

Five Points Pizza is a great choice f9r pizza. We had lunch here today and the pizza was great. The crust was perfect and the cheese and sauce perfectly complimented that dough and crust. The staff was friendly and the place has a cool enough vibe and ambiance. Parking can be a bit of an issue. But it is what it is. I grew up in New Jersey and just took it for granted that great pizza was available on every corner. When I moved south back in 2001, I was both shocked and dismayed to find that great (or even good pizza) was not available on every corner and in fact, was hard to find. When great pizza is found, it is indeed a time to celebrate (and what better way to celebrate than with a slice of pizza in hand?). I would definitely recommend Five Points Pizza and I will give it five stars for an excellent pizza. read more

See all

Great pizza!!! Nice little vibe and great music! Service was good as well, came here with a friend and it was a perfect spot to get some lunch. read more

Five Points Pizza - South Brooklyn - 18'' - Italian Near Me - Nashville, Tennessee

See all

This place is the best place to get a slice. It's authentic New York Brooklyn style pizza. I do recommend this spot even though I'm from Chicago, and I don't like deep dish, but I really enjoyed this pizza place here in Nashville. So when you have a taste for a slice. This is the right spot.. read more

It was ready very quickly and the pie was delicious! Highly recommend this place! Would not hesitate to go here again.

The pizza's amazing! The single pizza slice deal is great. I like sampling and not necessarily commit to one whole pizza. Love the hipster vibe of this place as well! 1/2 order of garlic knots (4): These came out hot. There definitely was a lot of garlic, olive oil, and cheese. Loved it! The hubs said the marinara sauce had a slight wine taste that added a nice subtle touch. Veggie slice of the day: This was surprisingly really good! And I'm not one to like veggies. The pineapple and gorgonzola cheese were really unique and what helped provide the unique flavors. The sauce on the pizza really helped give it a nice flavor kick as well. Meat slice of the day: The meat ball slices were really tasty. The hub's comment was that this actually tastes like real meatballs. The cheese and red onion slivers added to the nice flavor profile. Prosciutto & basil slice: So good! The prosciutto and basil were chopped in little slivers so each bite was filled with yumminess. If you like prosciutto then do get this! Pepperoni slice: Just a typical pepperoni slice. There was a good amount of pepperoni to cover the whole slice. Nothing else too special to call out. Each slice is sizable like the New York style, but the crust is slightly different per the hubs. It's crunchier I suppose. We technically didn't do the lunch special since we were dehydrated and preferred water, but the waitress still gave us the discount. Much thanks! Five Points Pizza was amazing: food, service, vibe, price. I would highly recommend! Also the area was super cute so I'll try to come visit again. read more

See all

The pizza is really, really good. Big slices, NY style. The garlic knots are delicious and very big. Much bigger than other garlic knots I've seen. If you're in the area and want some good pizza and cold beer; can't go wrong with this place. read more

Five Points Pizza - 18" pepperoni - Italian Near Me - Nashville, Tennessee

I have not eaten pizza until now! It's the most fresh different tasting pizza ever! And by the slice it's more than you can handle. I had 2 slices and was stuffed! Mt wife had the spinach Gorgonzola salad and loved it. The staff was on point. I mentioned food allergy and they made sure to avoid and double check to keep me from having an issue. The place is an awesome home feeling atmosphere. The place is also well kept and clean. I'd drive over an hour just to come back! If there ever was a perfect pizza 5 points pizza is it! You can tell they love to make food! The check was $25.51. Cheap for the quality!! read more

Great pizza! We got the vegan pizza & truthfully I am very picky about vegan pizza and I loved it! Great service, great beer! I also loved the photos in the bathroom lol!!! read more