I came across this hidden gem a couple months ago while me and a friend was in the area and we wanted a late night snack. So we both got a slice of pizza. Not sure which one I got and we went to the speakeasy room to grab a cocktail and just enjoy more of the quieter atmosphere and a cool little hidden vibe. And also they had a pool table so we was able to play pool as well. And then I went back with a couple of friends since we was in the area and we went straight to the back room and they had an amazing band set up. I honestly didn't know what kind of vibe this band was going to be but omg they were amazing!!! They had this soul in them and the singer his voice was beautiful. I can't wait to see them play again. But I ordered the expresso martini and it was good and we also shared a pizza. I was a little inebriated so I was just enjoying the vibe and agree to whatever my table wanted for the pizza so I'm sorry I'm not sure which one we ordered but I know it was good lol. Definitely a cool place to check out. read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Gulch - Pizza Near Me - Nashville, Tennessee

Came across this after hitting up the game room next door. Greeted by a young lady who helped us through all of drunken transactions...she was patient and friendly. The pizza was amazing the crust all the way around perfectly crisp all the way around..hand the perfect crunch when you took a bite. My husband and I shared a huge bread stick the girl helping us was so kind to cut it into pieces and ready for us to munch on as we walked back to Broadway. If you're looking for scrumptious pizza come here you will be happy and they have it by the slice! Thank goodness...life saving for those on a drunken weekend! read more

Stopped in for lunch with a coworker. The man working the counter was incredibly nice and helpful with ordering! We both got the lunch special, a slice of pizza, side and drink. It was such a great deal for the size slice and overall value. I got a slice of margarita and it was nice and crisp. Overall, great lunch spot with plenty of seating and slow enough to ensure you can get in and out quickly! read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Gulch - Margarita pizza/lunch special - Pizza Near Me - Nashville, Tennessee

What a nice place to stop in for pizza and drinks. The back bar room was nice to hang out and listen to a band play. It was nice to step in and listen to some r&b soul type of music. The food here was good. The service was up to par. Definitely would come back and visit. Parking garage near Whole Foods was about 5min walk. Or parking lot gravel access across the street if it is open. read more

See all

Goodfellas is a hidden gem in The Gulch. Great prices, great service, and solid pizza. We spotted Goodfellas on the way into Puttshack and were curious about it. We decided to try it after our round. It was a great choice. The dining room has four tops, stools for solo diners, and a couple of larger tables for groups. The dining room was very clean and uncluttered. There is a mafia kind of theme to the dining room. The employee who helped us was so kind and helpful. He gave us a quick rundown of our options to make it simple. You can order pizza by the slice for a quick option or from the full menu. We went with pizza by the slice. There were five options in the case including cheese, pepperoni, and sausage. One of the pizzas was a half and half of different vegetable options. They also had breadsticks. The pizza is 4/5. My favorite pizza was the one with mushroom and green pepper. My kids loved the Cheese pizza. The breadstick was pretty good with a nice variety of dip options. It's also large enough to share. I love that they offer a green side salad for some vegetables too. The pricing here was so reasonable. The lunch special price is great. You can get a slice, side, and drink for $10. Our family of four ate for under $30 before tip. This is a great spot if you're in The Gulch looking for a quick and inexpensive food option. read more

See all

After spending a few hours playing games at Pins Mechanical, we were hungry. It was late afternoon and we just wanted a snack because we had dinner plans Goodfellas Pizzeria was the perfect solution. I was glad they offer individual slices of pizza. That day they had all types of pizza, and they said it chances daily. Some of their offerings included, cheese, pepperoni, bacon and onion, Hawaiian with Canadian bacon and pineapple, spinach, buffalo chicken and others. The slices were large, so my husband and I ordered two pieces and shared. I loved the decor. It was very nostalgic, and It reminded me of the pizza restaurants from my childhood with red booths and a black and white checkered floor. read more

See all

Hey now my YELPies!!! Another spot in Nashville I know you should visit. No... not Goodfellas Pizza however delicious it may be.. This YELPer took a stroll to the back and entered the WiseGuys Lounge Speakeasy! Yes YELPies.. take a moment to tap into your inner gangsta and have a drink in this dimly lit walk to the past, complete with gangsta memorabilia and photos and appropriately named drink specials. Chandeliers and booths and cigars! YELPies, the WiseGuys even have LIVE music entertainment. So YELPies, if you want a good drink and great service with that feeling of Italian gangsta boldness.. stop in to Goodfellas Pizzeria and find yourself way to the WiseGuys Lounge. read more

See all

This place has really yummy italian food. I love how they are open late and always greeting me with a smile when I walk in! I like ordering food and then going to sit in the lounge to eat. It is casual and cozy with diner vibes. read more

See all

Overall: What a "hidden" gem! It was so delicious here, I got a slice of the margarita pizza and we also got the pesto bread. The pizza was huge (I would like to try their lunch combo sometime). It was super yummy and the place itself is so neat - a casual sit down eatery with a really cool speakeasy bar in the back! We also got a cannoli, but I wouldn't say that was much of note. At the bar, I got the Audrey Hepburn martini + the peanut butter shot. The martini was nice and sweet, and it was a pleasantly surprising taste for the shot! Service: Staff was super nice and attentive, was checking on us and told us about the speakeasy as well. Ambience: Really trendy and cool vibe inside (New York styled?) and the speakeasy bar is a must-visit for the live music as well. read more

See all

Pizza was very doughy and not enough meat and cheese. Breadstick was doughy on top and burnt on the bottom. Lunch special is a great deal but it's just not good. The garlic butter needed more flavor- not very garlicky. read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Gulch - Lunch special - Pizza Near Me - Nashville, Tennessee

needed to eat something after playing at Pins. This pizzeria is next door. It was clean and well decorated. We were greeted by friendly helpful staff. They had pizzas you can make any way you want and pizzas by the slice. If you get pizza by the slice you have to get what's available at that time. We were not too hungry and wanted variety so we chose a slice of bacon and onion and plain pepperoni. We sat at a table. The table had all the condiments you might want, garlic powder, Italian seasoning, parmesan cheese, chopped peppers and of course salt and pepper. The pizza looked great. The flavour left a lot to be desired. The sauce was bland as was the cheese. I would have liked a little more pepperoni. The bacon topping was good. read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Gulch - The kitchen and order counter. - Pizza Near Me - Nashville, Tennessee

Delicious pizza. The place can get really busy, but the staff works hard to get food out. Girl working the front register was very nice and engaging. Awesome themed decor. Giant individual slices of pizza for an awesome price. It took like 30+ minutes to get our cheese bread. read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Gulch - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Nashville, Tennessee

This is the 4th goodfellas location I've been to. This exceeded expectations. Employees were great. Pizza and meatball sub were excellent. Giant portions. Tons of flavor. Classic NY slices with loads of toppings. Their small pizzas are still big. Priced perfectly - especially cocktails. If you read otherwise on these reviews, then it's probably a Karen from Southeast TN who doesn't get out enough. Cocktail menu is unbelievable. Prices shockingly cheap for Gulch/Nashville. However, my cocktail was just decent but my date's was fantastic. 100% will be coming back to try more cocktails, their hidden bar, hidden billiards room & infinite cocktail list. read more

I was pleasantly surprised by Goodfellas! We went here after going to Pins Mechanical right down the street. Super easy for a quick bite and honestly a perfect location for it. They were play upbeat lively music. Walk up and order the slice you want. They'll put it in the wood fired oven per order. read more

I had their one of their giant cheese pizza pies at an event, and it was delicious! The slices were as huge as my face! The cheese was gooey and the sauce had a great tang to it. Will definitely be checking out their brick and mortar location, and hoping that my events host Goodfellas more so I can continue eating their delicious pizza! read more

Classic pizza, good service, pretty bar. The cheese bread is the true star of the show.

This was very bad. And over $50 bucks for pizza and a side of Cheesebreadsticks. Huge regret

The pizza slices are Huge! I like that the bar is hidden in the back. The bar ladder is a beautiful classic touch. Service improving since they are new! read more

Had this pizza to-go, which never works out well for pizza, but this one really didn't last the 10 minutes back to the house. Family was disappointed after a $115 bill. read more

Good location that is in walking distance to midtown and the Gulch. Slices are huge and a decent selection for walk ins. You can also order whole pizzas as well. Staff is very friendly. Only slight criticism is some slices may lack cheese for my taste especially when they are busy and making pizzas during the lunch rush. read more

4.5 rating Food was 4 The Pizza was really good. We ordered a medium pepperoni and Italian sausage. The Italian sausage was made in-house, but I wish I would have gotten the other one. It was okay but not delicious.It didn't take like tastes like the italian sausage that I'm used to. Service was 5 Everyobe was nice and helpful. The bartender in back was super friendly and we sat and talked to her for about 30 minutes. Atmosphere 5. And this is where Goodfellas places itself above the rest. This places in the Gulch is retro old style. Certainly, living up to its nam. In back there's a bar. We went New Year's Eve and the bar didn't open until 4. We waited until they opened because they had $5 old fashioneds which is his favorite drink. The drink was delicious. I had a mojito, which was about 10 bucks. It was delicious as well and very reasonably priced. They also have live music on the weekends and are open until three a.m. They also have a pool table in the back area and a space that you can rent out. Overall I was very impressed and will definitely be returning. read more

See all

Probably the best pizza I have had in Nashville. Me and some friends came here for dinner this evening and it was honestly amazing, the vibes and staff were all so welcoming and friendly. They also had a speakeasy / bar area in the back with excellent cocktails i definitely will be back! Also their house bottled habanero sauce is so delicious! read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Gulch - Pizza Near Me - Nashville, Tennessee

First time eating here. My wife and I were friendly greeted as soon as we walked in. The guy that waited on us I believe could tell it was our first time, he was patient and very helpful. The pizza was delicious. I will be back. Some free parking but plenty of paid parking. Staff is friendly read more

We went in on a Tuesday night and they were short staffed. Ended up sitting in the speakeasy bar area and ordered food. Pesto bread was so good! We also got the Vinny with pepperoni. Took a while for our food to come out (only two cooks). Service was okay. Ambiance was a vibe. read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Gulch - Pesto bread - Pizza Near Me - Nashville, Tennessee

See all

The best escape from Broadway. Great pizza and 10/10 lounge in the back. I'd try to explain, but this is something you have to check out on your own. PLUS, they just launched their delivery. As if I needed more read more

We have eaten at the good fellows in Chattanooga and enjoyed it so when we saw this one in Nashville we wanted to give it a shot It's a road over from most of the madness of downtown Nashville so that's a plus. The restaurant itself looks to be fairly new with a really cool atmosphere. The only downside to this place is due to its location free parking is limited. I was capable to find a parallel spot in front of the building that was free but the only other option I saw was a pay lot behind the business that was $25. The pizza was great and on par with the location in Chattanooga. A thin crisp crust New York style. We paired it with a few breadsticks which were also very good. Overall good fellows has fast became one of my favorite pizza places and I always recommend it to my friends now. read more

If you're expecting the same Goodfellas Pizza you get at the Distillery District in Lexington, KY you will be disappointed. Looked good and cooked good but bland. Learn to salt your dough!!! read more

Now this is a pie. This is a cannoli. This is a pizza. And Alexa is a delightful server and very friendly and was such a pleasure to interact with. Her and the rest of the staff will keep me and friends, family coming back here until I die!!! read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Gulch - Me and the pizza man - Pizza Near Me - Nashville, Tennessee

Great spot. Very clean and open. The pizza is solid NY style. Though it comes across as a gimmick, the giant bread stick is awesome! The service was great, everyone was polite and attentive. Will definitely be back. Glad to find a NY slice shop worth a damn in Nashville. read more

Genuinely the best New York style pizza I've had outside of New York. Go with the classic pepperoni! Great crust with quality ingredients. Brilliance in the basics! The staff was incredibly nice and helpful. Place is super clean and has a super cool speakeasy called wise guy club. I for sure will be coming back to eat some pizza and have some whiskey in the lounge! Seriously can't say enough. Pizza was epic, place had an old feel with modern amenities. Get there! read more

Can't recommend this place more!! The pizza was undeniably great and was a real crowd pleaser but the stand out what the customer service. We last minute needed 9 22" pizzas for 30 people and Danny was more than accommodating. We got 3 pepperoni, 3 cheese, 2 Vinny's, and 1 veggie. All were just as delicious as the next. I've worked in the service business for almost a decade and know a great spot when I see it. Huge thank you to Danny and the team for taking such great care of us. If you haven't already, go check out this new spot and get a taste for yourself. read more

On the positive side, nothing actually tasted awful. This is edible pizza. On the negative side: - For starters this place is horribly overpriced for what you get. - They topped the pizza unevenly, with one half of the pizza having the vast majority of the cheese and toppings and the other being nearly bare. - The pesto bread is tiny - far smaller than the deceptive website pictures make it appear. - For a place that spends so much time playing up their supposed New York bonafides they completely missed the mark. The sauce lacks the subtle sweetness of a NY sauce and is far more akin to the herb-heavy flavor of a Chicago sauce, while the central crust is thin and soggy with no crispness on the bottom and no rise on the top. So would I return? I certainly won't be rushing back. If I'm ever at Pins Mechanical, I want something to eat, and whatever food truck they have on site isn't doing it for me, I might considering going next door to Goodfellas and grabbing a slice. But I definitely don't see myself going out of my way to go there, or spending the outrageous price for a whole pie again. read more

Meh. This feels like upgraded chain pizza. Crust is too thick to be NY style. the sauce is boring. The best thing about the food was the pesto bread with cheese. Most likely won't order again but would I be excited to eat this at 2am after drinking? Probably. read more

Friendly staff, great pizza. There's also a hidden gem of a speakeasy tucked away in the back.