Five Star Pizza

Great wings! Love the lumpia…read more Ice cold amber bock on tap. Service was excellent. Visited on a night that didn't have karaoke! (Not my thing)

Not sure how this meal went this wrong here. Showed up with a group of 10 for a friends birthday…read more While placing the drink order, I advised that I was going to need another pitcher to follow the first. The first pitcher was dry before the waitress asked if we needed another. The person whose birthday we were celebrating ordered their meal first and got their food last (by quite a bit, half of the party was done eating already). And when they brought his food out, it was the wrong order. He went up to let us know it was wrong (because our waitress was missing) . He could see his order in the counter, but was told that order was a mistake and he received the right thing. We had two orders at the same table with one very small difference (an ingredient missing on one) and the two were blatantly different. Between slow service, wrong orders, and no accountability this place seriously disappointed tonight. It's a shame, in my opinion they were one of the best wing spots in the area, but they have obviously let their quality control drop.

Bar area

Loaded tenders

Big Dawgs Family Sports Restaurant - Menu

See all

Noodles & Dumplings

4.5(24 reviews)

1.4 mi

Wow!! The food here is awesome!!…read more My wife and I had planned on going somewhere else, but it was closed and she remembered seeing the Noodles and Dumplings name when we drove by a week ago. This is a small place with two counters and about 6 barstool style chairs. There was an only one cook...the owner and he was super helpful. We ordered: - Spicy Ramen Noodle Soup picked rice noodles with chicken, shrimp and beef. - Fried Rice with chicken, shrimp and beef. - Spicy Zha Jiang Miam noodles with Pork Belly. Spicy , is about medium(3) to hot(4) on the Thai 1-5 scale. Nice heat with great flavor. All dishes tasted great and more than enough food for 5 people. No joke, these were very large to go containers. We will definitely be going back soon after we spend the next week eating all this.

Tried out Noodles and Dumplings on Blanding & Knight Boxx next to the Winn-Dixie. It was okay but…read morenot as great as I expected. The Zha Jiang Mian was kind of ketchupy tasting and while I ordered it extra super spicy, it was almost about spicy enough. It was full of ingredients though and the pork belly was tasty. The "homemade" noodles could very well have been regular linguine but were also good nonetheless. Fried Chinese pork buns were decent but I've had better. It's mostly a takeout place but there are a minimal amount of rudimentary folding chairs and tables in there if you choose to dine in. Everything is served in Styrofoam or plastic with disposable plastic utensils. All in all, I might go back to give them a second try.

Kitchen

Fried rice with chicken, shrimp and beef. Weighed about 3 lbs.

See all

Zha Jiang Mian

Wingstop

2.4(7 reviews)

3.3 mi

Awesome staff! Food is fast, fresh, and hot! Love going here after work or ordering for pickup the…read moretheir app.

Food is good but they can mess up orders. Ordered fries and didn't get them. It's not hard to…read morefollow an app order.

See all

Burnt soggy fries

Hurricane Grill & Wings

3.4(134 reviews)

4.7 mi

Average food but good attentive service For a chain the fish…read moretacos are good and apparently they are known for their burgers The large pretzel was good and prodigious amounts of fries

After a not so good experience at this location, Noel took wonderful care of us. She's fantastic…read moreas for her lol. The manager also made sure we were taken care of too. We will be back.

Mini arcade

Philly cheesesteak with no peppers or onions

See all

Ice cold Landshark on tap!

Mr Chubbys - Fleming Island

2.7(146 reviews)

5.6 mi

My family and I ordered for pickup, an assortment of wings and fries. They told us to come by in…read moreabout 30 minutes and they would be ready. When we got there, our wings and fries were sitting at the counter waiting, and apparently they had them done long before 30 minutes. The wings and the fries were a little on the soggy side . The wings were really expensive and really not that great. Maybe if they had been hot and still had some moisture they might have been ok. Inside is a sports bar atmosphere, a little dark and danky with tvs everywhere! If that's the atmosphere you're looking for then this is the place for you!

Awesome best burgers around great staff great wings can't go wrong for the atmosphere and food…read moredefinitely a go to place

Hometown vibes

Chubzilla Burger

See all

Table area and band stage

Callahan's Irish Bistro

4.3(92 reviews)

2.7 mi•Westside

The food is all good and reasonably priced. They treat you like family. We come here at least once…read morea week.

Fun focused menu made it easy for staff Leprechauns all over…read morethe place Live music Fun!

Restaurant inside

Fish n Chips

See all

Wingstop

2.9(63 reviews)

2.8 mi•Westside

Wingstop was really good and definitely worth it. The wings were flavorful, crispy, and cooked just…read moreright. The variety of sauces made it easy to find a favorite, and each one had a strong, tasty flavor. The fries were also well-seasoned and paired perfectly with the wings. Everything tasted fresh, and the portion sizes were filling. I'd definitely go back again because it was a satisfying meal overall

They say they're open until 1am but I came to pick up my order around 11:00pm and nobody was there,…read moredoors were locked. Thats money down the drain with no food. 4 other people tried to pick up orders as well but couldn't

See all

New York Pizza

4.0(105 reviews)

5.2 mi

As soon as me and my son walked in we got greeted and let us know where the menu was. There was a…read morefew slices they had sold per slice in the case but everything else is made to order. The wait wasn't long at all. The design of the restaurant my son likes. We order a 18" cheese pizza; came with 8 slices, cheese slice with house salad and drink combo, fried cheese and slice of BBQ chicken pizza. Everything was fresh and the bbq chicken pizza was my favorite. I got 2 bites and my youngest son took it cause it was so good. The fried cheese are triangle shape and way better than any I have had before.

Always, good, always hot!! Best Pizza on the Island! My only…read morewish is that there was a bigger place to sit down And eat.

Quick to go dinner

Excellent pizza!!!!!

See all

Antipasti salad

Charleys Cheesesteaks

2.8(8 reviews)

0.7 mi•Westside

They give plenty of meat and season the food better than most Charlie's. I will be back!read more

I've tried this place twice. Well attempted to. Both times they got my order wrong from the wrong…read morebread to adding ingredients I specified I did not want on. Not to mention the bread was burnt, not like toasty like black around the edges. NEVER AGAIN!

See all

Krispy Krunchy Chicken

3.7(9 reviews)

1.7 mi•Westside

1/5. I do not recommend. I ordered the Cajun chicken…read moresandwich meal with wedges & red beans and rice from the counter. I had to go to the front counter to pay. While paying I noticed a Krispy Krunchy hot lamp on the counter. I was seeing what was under the hot lamp when the person that took my order at the KKC counter grabbed a chicken sandwich and red beans and rice from under the main counter hot lamp instead of from the KKC side of the store. Instant red flag. I got my bag and left. I was parked under a tree and opened my meal. The wedges and red beans were good. The Cajun chicken sandwich on the other hand was not. It must've been under the heat lamp for a while. The top half of the bun was hard. One of the tenders (it wasn't a chicken breast) was dried out AND freezer burned. I took a bite of the soft side and immediately regretted it. I've had good gas station fried chicken meals. This was not reminiscent of past experiences.

I ordered their chicken stripe. They were as good as any chicken place around! I would order…read moreagain.Chicken was moist and tender.

Dried out hard bun equals a dried out hard chicken. Maybe it was freezer burn. Either way, it was horrible.

Boudin balls. 2 to an order

See all

Jambalaya. Could have filled it up a bit more.

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

17 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Adam R.

13 years ago

Recently tried Five Star Pizza for the first time. Went and ordered a pizza during their busy hours. I ordered a supreme pizza. I was shocked when they had it made and out to me in under 10 minutes. I found this to be a little strange. Once I got home 18 miles away come to find out the dough was not thoroughly cooked all the way through. I had to pop the pizza back in my oven to thoroughly cook it before I could eat it. The supreme toppings were fine. It was loaded up and those were good. Just would have been nice if the pizza had been cooked thoroughly so I could eat it right away. I wrote to the store online and it has been a week without a response back from them. Obviously they do not take customer complaints seriously since they do not want to hear about them or respond back to a complaint. read more

R.j. M.

10 years ago

Welp this is my first review ever. I tried to order online late night about 1ish. Very hype to find a spot that would deliver this time of night, I was kind of elated to tip the driver whenever he arrived. Only to find out that the online ordering system somehow doesn't click with the actual store. The website accepted me within the 5mile radius stated, only to receive a phone call saying "I'm sorry although it says we deliver to your address online, we actually don't". Not too happy about that because when i called back and offered a more than healthy tip for the trouble, even though the mixup was on their end i was told "I'm sorry sir we have a lot of orders in the area we cannot accommodate you". Garbage. read more

Joanne D.

8 years ago

Have had several opportunities to order Pizza from Five Star, Orange Park. No only have it been consistently scrumptious. Every combination we have sampled have satisfied our pizza pleasure. Our delivery person on three occasions has been, Erin Burke and I purposely asked her name so I could add her in our review. She was very pleasant and Answered our questions without hesitation. I asked her if she was apprehensive about delivering late at night and she replied that she was very intuitive and was aware of her surroundings. Thanks for our Pizza experience. Patricia Caputo. read more

Joshua H.

306

8 years ago

Absolutely love their pizza! We get the really huge size typically and it's so cheesy and the crust is the perfect consistency. Something that I love about this place is the quality control on the food and their amazing drivers! Our food got here pretty fast and we enjoyed one of the drivers by the name of Kelly; she had great energy and was super friendly! Definitely recommend requesting her as your driver. read more

Matt K.

12 years ago

They put up with me, the guy on the phone understood what I wanted on the pizza, he got everything I wanted and then kept a convo going. Hope they make this business amazing. Always there when you need food, best pizza. The piezilla is a product from god himself. Delivery guy will get a get tip for a 1:40am delivery. $20 to be exact. I LOVE FIVE STAR read more

george l.

16 years ago

We ordered pizza tonight and it arrived incredibly fast. The pizza was very good but the garlic rolls were gone in minutes! We had almost given up on getting good pizza in Orange Park but after eating Five Star Pizza we are now believers. Check Mint magazine for great coupon offers but even without a coupon you won't regret ordering this pizza. read more

Lindsay P.

2 years ago

The driver of your white delivery van is speeding in and out of traffic on Blanding and continued on Old Jennings. Almost clipped my front end. Your delivery drivers in your company vehicles are extensions of your business on the roads. It would serve you well to remember that. read more

Jennifer L.

6 years ago

Omg! I got an xl pizza with pepperoni. It was perfect! Hot, just the right amount of cheese and pepperoni. The flavor of the sauce was spot on. We usually do The big pizza companies, but we actually seemed to have more pizza with xl than 2 mediums and tasted way better. read more

Sally B.

14 years ago

I used to love Five Star when I lived in Gainesville. So I was happy when Five Star came to town. We love their pizza! Very friendly staff too. The only downside is it's not located at a traffic light. Oh well, at least they deliver! read more

Brian T.

5 months ago

Great Pizza and the service is always good too! They also deliver really late at night, and no other place delivers that late.

Caleb P.

11 years ago

3 stars for great pizza and the price, but not always friendly staff. Would be nice if they delivered to more areas!

Matthew T.

8 years ago

Great Pizza and awesome customer service. I highly recommend Five Star Pizza. The pizza rolls are awesome.

Jennifer M.

12 years ago

My fav. Pizza delivery so far. I cant describe how great this pizza is. You have to try it for yourself:)

Dan r.

15 years ago

Yum! That is all you need to know. A must try is the garlic rolls. read more

Lana D.

10 years ago

About 15 minutes after eating this i got the grossest farts

Megan C.

12 years ago

Really good pizza! Fairly cheap and FAST delivery!

Kat V.

152

11 years ago

Tasty pizza and friendly staff

Five Star Pizza - pizza - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Five Star Pizza also viewed

New York Pizza

4.0

(105 reviews)

Always, good, always hot!! Best Pizza on the Island! My only…read morewish is that there was a bigger place to sit down And eat.

Hungry Howie's Pizza & Subs

3.6

(23 reviews)

Finally got the opportunity to try the famous hungry howies! We tried yesterday (Friday night) but…read morethey were so busy they temporarily stopped taking orders! Haha they were still busy today but we were able to order a chicken and bacon pizza with a side of cheesy bread. The pizza was excellent and the perfect amount of cheesy. The crust on the pizza was just the right amount of crispy and the garlic butter taste was absolutely delicious. I'm not sure of the ambiance because my husband made the pizza run but just from flavor we will definitely be back to try other menu items.

Hungry l howies is a s staple. Always love the pizza and the people who work at this location are…read morealways friendly. Will return again!

Marco's Pizza

3.5

(40 reviews)

Marco's has wonderful pizza! We should try something else but we love their pizza and when they…read morehave "full moon" pizza... it's half price! Yum, yum!

Katy who works here is the BEST! This place ROCKS! The food…read moreis amazing and Katy who works there remembers my order and what my lady didn't like on her pizza. She makes every visit feel like I'm the center of the universe, go see them! And the food is amazin

Wise Guys Pizza Cafe

3.5

(61 reviews)

I order here frequently. Food is good the owners are chill. Strawberry lemonade is not too shabby…read moreas well. The lighting and menus inside are intrinsic.

Never ordered from here before but wanted pizza and Was in…read morethe area..... DO NOT ORDER! I spent $30 on a large half meat half pepperoni, onion, peppers and an order of garlic knots. Pizza dough tasted like card board and toppings were very far and few between. Garlic knots are hard and chewy. I should have went to Pizza Hut and would have been happier. Same yourself from the disappointment, not everyone can make pizza!

Stoner's Pizza Joint - Southside

3.0

(58 reviews)

Forget Crumbl their peanut butter cookies are the best I've ever had. The last two times I've…read moreordered them they have been the big sized cookies and not as doughy as the smaller ones but still amazing and perfect blend of sweet and salty peanut butter. I want my last meal to be these cookies!!

Maybe the cookers were too high cause this taste like a science experiment. Honestly would feel…read moreguilty giving this to a starving person on the street. What do you guys make your pizza sauce with?

Jet's Pizza

4.6

(51 reviews)

Love this Detroit-style pizza. The chicken bacon ranch and the mighty meaty rock! The staff is…read morefriendly and the service is fast. The perfect game day watch party pick!

My neighbors ordered pizza last week and offered me a slice. The first bite had my tastebuds…read morerocking! I asked the where they'd gotten the pizza from and they said Jet's pizza. I went there tonight and order a single pepperoni slice of pizza. It was so cheesy, gooey, hot and crunchy at the same time!! Jet's pizza reminded me of my favorite childhood pizza joint in the Illinois. Simple ridiculously great pizza. Made fresh and served pulling hot with a side of outstanding customer service. I cannot wait to try the rest of the menu items. They have some great looking desserts. Jet's Boat looks yummy. I will return very soon for a Deli Boat! Samson rang my order tonight and he was an absolutely kind, professional and welcoming. The service alone made me decide to patronize this specific location for all future pizza orders. The food sealed the deal. Ambiance is a typical small pizza joint. It's a To Go pizza restaurant. Thank you, Samson!

Tony Pepperoni

3.7

(140 reviews)

I pass this place multiple times a week and finally stopped for a slice of pepperoni pie. It was…read moreplaced in the oven to be warmed and came out relatively quickly. The slice was hot and delicious. I want to come back and try more options because their menu was huge and had tons of yummy looking food.

I will never return here…read more The first time we came, the whole experience felt off. We practically had to beg someone to take our order, the staff was weird and rude, and the music was so loud we couldn't even hear each other. We decided to give them a second chance what a waste. We ordered ONE pizza and were told it would be ready in 30 minutes. We showed up after 30 minutes and then had to wait ANOTHER 30 minutes for it. And once again, the staff was rude. Two chances, two bad experiences. There definitely won't be a third.

Renna's Pizza

3.6

(133 reviews)

A perfect trip just me and my grandson eating pizza and me drinking beer. Of coruse, my grand had…read moreapple juice. We dropped Grandma to Panails to get her nails done. It was a 30 minute wait. We had to eat and run but the pizza taste just like the NY NJ metro area. The smell and bite of it all! Im writing this review and have been back already been back to taste a slice of heaven. Customer service was exceptional. I asked the counterperson to warm the pizza for my grandson since he does

Pizza is on the salty side, but this is the only pizza place the entire family agrees on!…read more We always call in our orders because it's a busy place. Reminds me of an old school pizza place. Always busy yet chill. Family oriented.

Krave Pizza and Wings

4.4

(8 reviews)

Loved the munch special. Pizzas was amazing! I'd highly recommend this pizza spot. The worker was…read morevery kind and quick

Near Walmart on San Jose near I-295…read more I read some reviews and was tired of the pizza spots in the area, so I thought, "What the heck, why not give it a try". I was intrigued by the menu and settled on the Farmers Market Pie, which ended up being amazing. Really well thought out and delicious. We did try another pizza, but everyone devoured the farmers market. Plenty of parking, easy to get to an easy ordering. No room inside to really sit and eat, but for takeout it is set up just right..

Vitos Pizzeria

3.9

(125 reviews)