We went here for our first time a couple days ago and the pizza was amazing. It was actual New York style pizza. Service was good. Will definitely be coming back. read more

Went for the first time today. my friend I grew up with in New Jersey said it was just like the pizza we grew up on! she was right! The lady at the counter was super friendly too! read more

A perfect trip just me and my grandson eating pizza and me drinking beer. Of coruse, my grand had apple juice. We dropped Grandma to Panails to get her nails done. It was a 30 minute wait. We had to eat and run but the pizza taste just like the NY NJ metro area. The smell and bite of it all! Im writing this review and have been back already been back to taste a slice of heaven. Customer service was exceptional. I asked the counterperson to warm the pizza for my grandson since he does read more

Renna's Pizza - Me and my grandson - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

Pizza is on the salty side, but this is the only pizza place the entire family agrees on! We always call in our orders because it's a busy place. Reminds me of an old school pizza place. Always busy yet chill. Family oriented. read more

Great little pizza spot. Love that you can grab pizza by the slice. They also have a nice little selection of beers. Nice break from the shipping :) read more

Renna's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

We love Renna's pizza! We ordered pizza from their website and by the time we got there the pizza was ready to go! They lady at the counter took my name and came right back with my food and gave me plates and a bunch of condiments to go with the pizza. Definitely recommend Rennas for some affordable food tasting pizza. read more

I have been to this pizza spot because I love their slices of pizza meal but every time I come in here, there is always an associate or a staff member that has an attitude but today I had experience superb accommodating, friendly service from Latesha who works there that I thought was an owner. But if only everyone was trying to be just like her, this place would be a hit. read more

Pizza is a little salty, but it's the only place the whole family agrees on. Busy spot, so we usually call ahead. Feels like an old-school pizza joint always bustling, casual, family-oriented. read more

Service was great but the pizza was not great Been coming here for over a decade This visit was dissatisfying the taste was Not up to par. Recipe was not the same Sauce was not the same won't return read more

I watch all of David Portnoy's pizza reviews on YouTube and have tried many of the popular local pizza spots in town. I have to say, for plain cheese, fresh out of the oven, this particular Renna's location makes the best in town 100% and is a must try, dine in. Get the entire pie! Great tasting sauce, perfect balance of sauce and cheese! Thin crispy crust read more

Renna's Pizza - Plain cheese 14" - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

See all

Consistently good pizza , decent price, convenient location in mandarin. Made my staff happy today- esp with the garlic knots read more

See all

We have been coming to Renna's on and off for +20 years! Tonight we ordered two Caesar salads, a large pizza with two topping and a pitcher of beer, with tip $50 to eat in. The salad came out and to be honest...very disappointing, very yellow lettuce but crunchy croutons; maybe no body orders salads?!? The pizza came out and it was 8 slices; the crust was good but the toppings were sparse and on one maybe not at all?!? Regardless there were people coming and picking up orders and others eating in but it appeared to be slices not whole pies?!? read more

See all

Amazing pizza!! The owner was very very kind and the employees were helpful with ordering. Got my pizza in 5 minutes!! They have roomy seating so you aren't squished up against anyone which is a plus. read more

Renna's Pizza - Pizza Cheese - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

Amazing tasting New York Style pizza located in the heart of Mandarin. Conveniently located in a large and busy shopping plaza near the highway. Plenty of parking nearby. Also lots of seating space in the clean and comfy dining area. Kind and professional staff. Ordered a 12" vegetable pizza on my visit. Easily can be shared but luckily I did not for this solo visit. :) Nice fresh portions of vegetables, extra cheese and delicious buttery crust. Pizza was baked perfectly! See y'all soon for another tasty pie that I may not plan on sharing! read more

See all

This used to be my favorite pizza place, not anymore! I ordered one slice of pizza with 3 topping for $3.49. The cashier charged me over $5.50. I asked her why she charged me so much. The menu clearly states "one slice of cheese pizza....add up to 3 toppings to make it your perfect slice". She gave a bogus answer that didn't make sense! What a shame. I ordered sausage, green pepper and onion. The green pepper was completely raw and the pizza was barely warm. I ordered the pizza while I was there and waited for it, so hadn't been sitting around. I brought it home and had to actually bake the one slice of pizza. read more

Renna's Pizza - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

See all

Even though I've been in the neighborhood for a while now and in this plaza multiple times over the years, I had never tried the pizza from Renna's. The pizza was delicious and I was able to order half pepperoni and half specialty, which was great. I'm not a New Yorker but this is a very good pizza and it was delicious. I think I found my go-to neighborhood favorite pizza joint. The place is simple and feels like a hole-in-the-wall establishment, which is totally cool and charming. The staff is friendly and welcoming. Overall I had a great experience at Renna's. read more

Renna's Pizza - Half pepperoni and half Renna's special - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

I have NEVER had bad food here, until now! The pizza was delivered 40 minutes late. The restaurant called me looking for the delivery driver, because I didn't get the order he picked up. When the pizza got there, it was ice cold, hardly any cheese, it was a small, and I paid for a large!! read more

Pretty good pizza here, everyone was happy with it as well as the garlic rolls. Unfortunately I forgot to snap a pic of the pizza because it took longer than usual to come out, and everyone was hungry! But it was pretty good. I guess I will keep coming back until I find my perfect pizza spot in Jax. read more

Renna's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

See all

Good New York style pizza l like the Italian subs ,fast order filling ,good price will recommend

I have been eating at Renna's, all the locations, for over 30 years. But I got a calzone tonight that was perfection. Look at it??!! Have you ever seen such a beautiful calzone? And it tasted just as wonderful as it looked. Calzone has always been good there - my favorite- but this one was just pretty too! I no longer live in Jax, but am so glad I stopped on my trip up tonight. Great service as well. read more

Renna's Pizza - Perfect calzone - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

It wasn't great, but it was pretty tasty. Pizza was a little soft on the bottom for me, but overall I liked it.

Lit. Cheap beer, great pizza, great service, comfy seats. Affordable and fast service. read more

Renna's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

If i could give 10 stars i would!! jack was a delight to speak with on the phone, very very friendly!!!

It is with great sadness that I write this review, especially since I've given glowing reviews (on multiple local food review sites) previously. Everything has changed and it went completely downhill. Can only give 1 star because less is not an option. Pizza was always our family's favorite around town, but no longer. I know there are multiple locations around town - so hopefully the others haven't changed their pizza as well - but all other locations are even further away. Hope they turn it around at some point, but will absolutely be going elsewhere. read more

Food is always good no matter what you choose! Service is great and ambiance is a pizza joint period.

I guess i always pass by Renna's but never tried it until today, it didn't disappoint! I saw a lot of people comes in and out for pick u orders. Daily's special include 2pizza slices (huge) and a drink for $8.50! Staff are friendly, clean restaurant and ambiance is a regular pizza shop (booths and tables) read more

Renna's Pizza - Cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

Ate here 2 days in a row. It is so good. Had a cosmo sandwich which has lettuce, tomato, ham, mozzarella, oil and vinegar on it. This bread was so fresh! I also had a 10" pizza with beef, banana peppers, and fresh garlic. This pizza had just the right amount of sauce. The crust is thin but still filling. You won't regret coming to this place. read more

Renna's Pizza - Beef, banana pepper pizza - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

See all

Still great as I remember from 10 years ago. We came and ordered in and our pizzas were great. A bit of a wait but a nice quiet chill atmosphere. I got a white pizza which has crush garlic on top that you could actually taste. Yum! My friend got a half cheese and half pepperoni which looked good just not as good as mine. Ha. The crust was really flavorful too. Will def be back. read more

We grabbed a couple of pizzas tonight and Renna's never disappoints. We always get a cheese and our second pizza chosen was their meat lovers. They don't skimp on toppings and this particular pie also comes with extra cheese. Nice NY crust and flavorful sauce. If there was one critique it's that the ample toppings made the pizza a little on the salty side. Would we get this pizza again, definitely yes, but we may leave the bacon or ham off just to reduce some of the sodium. This location has been here almost 30 years and their pizza is always consistent. I like being able to also grab a slice or two when in a time pinch. I believe there are four total locations - all in the family - between the Westside and beaches. #supportlocal read more

See all

I was craving pizza after donating blood and decided to check out this cute spot. I got the two slice and drink special. The food came out fast and was not overly greasy or too big to eat by myself. I think the sauce could use a little more seasoning but other than that it was good. I want to try some of the other menu options next time I am here The restaurant and bathroom are extremely clean. Great place to get a quick bite. The lady who was helping me was very kind. There is additional outside seating when the weather is good. read more

See all

Been going to Renna's for YEARS at both OP and Mandarin location. The pizza has always been amazing. Just how I like it. It's my go to pizza place. read more

Renna's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

The large pizza is now a medium pizza. Not big enough to feed a family of 4. Shrink flation should tell you this. Picasso's has a better pizza for the price read more

We love Renna's!!! The best dough, sauce, service, and the cutest vibe. It's a bit of a drive for us, but so worth it.

The food is really good. And the service is always great! I've only had pizza here which is really good. But I've heard the sandwiches are awesome. Looking forward to coming back read more

We always forget Renna's is tucked behind Chipotle & Chili's, but we remembered today! We had a nice pie with pepperoni, mushroom, sausage and garlic. The sausage was very mild to the point of not really tasting it. There wasn't really enough sauce under the cheese, and yet it was a very satisfying pizza. read more

Renna's Pizza - Pepperoni sausage mushroom pizza - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

This is the second renna's pizza that I went to, with the same punishment that I get. Whenever you order pepperoni and a regular slice, the pep slice is smaller than the cheese slice. Also why do they ring you up get your sodas give you everything before they even start to warm up the pizza? They should be warming up the pizza first. Then assisting you with ringing you up and everything so you don't have to wait. Very unefficient, this is another management issue. read more

Renna's Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

I took a Keto break after kayaking 4 miles. I needed...wanted to carb up. We were craving NY style pizza. We usually go for Napoli style from V. So this was to mix it up. We aren't native to JAX, so we didn't believe there was good NY style pizza. We were pleasantly surprised! I got a 16 inch cheese and 16 inch deluxe pizza. It was SOOO good!!!!!!! Oh my gosh, delicious! I do recommend this place. It has the nice thin slice with a crusty crust. It is our new go to! read more

Went to Renna's for the first time today after hearing it was the best in Jax. I do think the pizza was good but I didn't think it was anything to write home about. The pizza was really greasy and limp. We had a meaty and a pepperoni. The garlic cheese bread was good but could have used more cheese. read more

Renna's Pizza - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

See all

The wait time is ridiculous. Especially for a small, dry, overcooked, overpriced skimpy pizza. We ordered a medium sausage pizza. We received a small hardly any sausage pizza. We waited over 45 mins after placing the order to get it. I doubt we will go back and definitely NOT recomme . Plenty of other, much better pizza places in Mandarin. read more

One step above a frozen dinner. Started with a brown lettuce salad with watered down Thousand Island. (Asked for extra dressing at order and request ignored.) Followed by the Manicotti entre with square possessed Mozzarella cheese melted on top of undercooked noodles. On a bright note the beer was cold. In watching the locals carry out it appears you might do better ordering a pizza. read more

Renna's Pizza - As close to a Banquet frozen dinner as trademark laws allow. - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida