Pros: staff was super friendly and helpful even when really busy, ice cream was good, meet expectations. Nothing earth shattering. Cons: they didn't have all of their flavors available, shop is really small can get extremely cramped, due to the warm temperature in the shop ice cream was extremely soft and melted very fast Overall, it was a good experience, but nothing amazing either read more

Shakes in any ice cream flavor and decent selection. Store is cold so good break from the heat, but no seating inside so out in the heat to eat it.. Employees were very nice and service was fast. read more

The ice cream is made on site. I had a scoop of key lime and a scoop of coconut. It was the best tasting ice cream ever! I see why there can be long lines out the door. read more

Flamingo Crossing - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Key West, Florida

Came here for dessert based on a recommendation from our dinner server and we were so disappointed. The selection of ice cream is good and the flavors were fine but the man behind the counter was so incredibly rude that it ruined our experience. He rushed us to make a flavor selection and made us feel like we were bothering him by trying to buy some ice cream. Also a warning, my husband's ice cream was so soft that it turned to soup outside before he could get halfway through his cone. Would not go back since there are plenty of other shops with much friendlier folks and just as good ice cream. read more

We stopped in on a hot Saturday evening and despite a big crowd were quickly served. We tried vanilla, English custard and guava and loved them all. The texture and flavors were great and the selections were unique with options like passion fruit and Mamey to go along with the usual favorites. Outdoor seating and brightly colored picnic tables were available but we chose to eat as we continued back to our resort. The stop was the perfect ending to a fun day in Key West. read more

French chocolate in a waffle cone - yep! Coconut - great Clean bathroom! Spot can be busy but the line moves pretty well. Great ice cream spot on Duval. read more

The line moved quickly and we all really loved our selections. Two very nice employees behind the counter.

Love this place. They make their own ice cream and it's so delicious we were here every day of our stay while in Key West. A good selection of flavors. It gets packed at night so be patient, service is friendly and good when it's your turn. read more

Ate a scoop a couple times while moving around town. Blueberries and cream, key lime, coconut. All tasty. A line once in a while. Very friendly! read more

Fun little shop tucked right on a corner with lots of street parking for easy access! The shop is relatively small, but there is some outdoor seating and the bright colors make it very inviting. They probably have 20-25 different flavors to choose from and today I tried the Amaretto and the English Custard. The chocolate was out-of-this-world good (and rich!) and the English Custard was really nice and creamy and tasted a bit like horchata to me (which definitely isn't a problem)! The man working behind the counter was patient as we tried a couple samples in advance, and was quick and efficient and filling out order. Gem of a place that I would definitely come back to! read more

Flamingo Crossing - English Custard & Amaretto - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Key West, Florida

There were three of us. The chocolate cookies and cream and Cuban coffee were our picks and we would ll get the same thing. Great variety and the best we have had on the island. Matthew behind the counter was gracious and outstanding and was the "icing" on the ice cream. Makes for a delightful evening! read more

Blonde lady server on 12/22/25 was incredibly rude to us. We did not do anything to provoke her. Just immediately came off rude. She later tried to give us a sample when we told her no thank you she asked me if "i would be brave for my boyfriend" and then proceeded to try to put a random sample on top of my ice cream. Just a very very odd and off putting interaction. Ice cream was good but not as good as being served by someone nice and respectful. read more

I didn't even want ice cream. We needed the restroom and while I was waiting for my wife I decided the coffee option looked good. Then I thought it would be good to try a couple different flavors and the lavender won out. The gelato was really good and I don't doubt someone else's review that this is the best ice cream in Key West. It sure was creamy and full of flavor and didn't taste artificial. read more

Great spot for homemade ice cream and you get to sit down on picnic bench's to enjoy your treat. The selection of ice cream is pretty good too. There's plenty of fruit flavors and some chocolate as well Irish cream or pina colada with rum. I decided to try the pina colada with rum because I got the pineapple taste with rum. It's a good substitute for alcohol when it's hot outside. My mom tried the butter pecan and enjoyed it well. Definitely a good spot for ice cream and to relax. read more

See all

Such delicious ice cream!! So creamy and they had so many different flavors! Definitely gave such a nice homemade feel and would recommend on a hot day! read more

Flamingo Crossing - Mamey and Sour sop double scoop cup - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Key West, Florida

THIS IS THE BEST ICE CREAM IN THE KEYS!!!!! Ordered the chocolate ice cream and added Oreos for an extra $1. The ice cream itself was soooo creamy and delicious and probably the best chocolate ice cream I've ever tasted. The Oreos were a nice touch, but honestly the chocolate flavor was so good they weren't even needed! The outside seating area was cute, and a great place to people watch + hang with the infamous Key West Roosters. Great little spot. read more

Flamingo Crossing - Chocolate ice cream with Oreo topping - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Key West, Florida

A lot of different flavors! Lavender flavor is very good! Big scoops! Friendly staff! Very clean! Must try!!! read more

Flamingo Crossing - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Key West, Florida

Service was great! Nice bright n cool inside. Ice cream was excellent. One of the best ice creams I've tried in a long time. Apple pie ice cream and pumpkin ice cream were so good. I should have tried more flavors. read more

Great ice cream a must try. I had the cookies and cream it was delicious. Service was fast. A simple nice ice cream store nothing fancy just great ice cream. read more

Flamingo Crossing - Store sign. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Key West, Florida

Ice cream was delicious and creamy! We had chocolate, key lime, cuban coffee, and mamey. Every flavor was perfected. Our server was very friendly, he mentioned his been there 20 years. We enjoyed the ice cream outside in some colorful seating. Coming back here whenever we are in key west. read more

This place has great flavors and the quality of the ice cream is great, try the guava and mamey.

I had the key lime gelato style ice cream. So yummy . It was the perfect balance of sweet and tart. Had mine on a plain cone. The guys who owns it is no fuss, be ready to order when it's your turn. No frills place plenty of outdoor picnic table to sit. read more

Great ice cream with a lot of fun flavors. Went there a couple times and it was always good. It is in a cute building too.

*Cash only* Do not miss out giving Flamingo Crossing a try because you forgot cash! They do have an ATM inside just in case. Hubby grew up getting ice cream from Flamingo Crossing every trip to Key West. Thank goodness he introduced me to the guava ice cream. It's the only ice cream I've ever ordered from here because it's so good! This last time I got mine in a cup and he got the cone. If you like guava even just a like bit, you must order it! Very creamy and true to taste. Not one bit artificial. There is usually a line! Please don't let that stop you, it's totally worth the wait. read more

See all

Flamingo Crossing is a fun little ice cream shop. They have a lot of options to choose from - some seasonal and some regulars. Bring cash, that's all they take. But that's no big deal. Go check them out! read more

Flamingo Crossing - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Key West, Florida

Flamingo Crossing is in a great area with lots of shopping. The ice cream is stellar- would highly recommend the cookies & cream. Service made it a quick trip in & out. A must! read more

Great ice cream with amazing unique flavors. Super helpful gal server, extremely sweet too. read more

Flamingo Crossing - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Key West, Florida

We stopped by for some ice cream. They had some unusual tropical flavors but I went with the butter pecan. I thought it was bland and not creamy enough. They only accept cash. They were friendly and it's a cute place. read more

See all

I really wanted ice cream but didn't want to go all the way down to Kilwin's. This place was near our hotel so we decided to try it out. First off, it's cash only. There is an ATM inside the store. There was one guy working and he had a steady stream of business and was friendly. I wanted 2 flavors but really didn't want 2 scoops so I opted for Coconut with hot fudge. My boyfriend got Butter Pecan. The hot fudge was very good. Both flavors had ice crystals in them which is a turnoff for me when it comes to ice cream. The Coconut was also a little bland. Ultimately I was not a fan of this shop. read more

See all

This place is cash only. So bring plenty of cash. Many flavors to pick from. They have an atm machine but It seems not to work properly. read more

Flamingo Crossing - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Key West, Florida

Fantastic flavors, so many options, fruity and creamy choices... there is something for everyone! When we got there the line was 5 people deep and the employees got through the line quickly and with a smile! The shop itself is small (think: hidden gem) but there are lots of seating options right outside, so cute! It was on the pricey-er side but worth the cost! read more

Flamingo Crossing - We had the Cuban coffee in a cone and a double scoop- mango & guava - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Key West, Florida

Amazing ice cream and so many flavors to choose from, not sure how this place doesn't have at least 4.5 stars compared to other ice cream shops around the area this by far is this best. So delicious will be coming back again. read more

Flamingo Crossing - Passion fruit gelato + raspberry sorbet - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Key West, Florida

Whenever I can find a place that makes homemade ice cream onsite, I'm all over it. Loved their Papaya and Cuban coffee flavors. Got both in a waffle cone - so flavorful and creamy. My husband got the key lime, but said it tasted more like cheesecake. Don't forget to bring cash 'cause that's all they take! read more

Flamingo Crossing - I know these don't make sense together, but I live them: papaya and Cuban coffee - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Key West, Florida

The key lime ice cream is the absolute best! And every flavor I tased was really good.

OMG! They had so many tropical flavors, including passion fruit, guanábana, mango and of course key lime. I got mine in a cone and we sat on a picnic table in the shade watching a hen with eight baby chicks. read more

This is one of the best ice cream place since ever been to. Actually came here twice while I was on vacation, and both times were great with trying three different flavors. The flavors they make are tropical and related to the island with Mamey, Guava, Soursop, and Passionfruit. The first time I had Mamey and Guava and it was great! Very creamy and filling while tasting light and refreshing like a fruit. The second time I had the Guava and Passionfruit and it was just as good as the last time. And surprisingly I had the ice cream the second time in a waffle cone and no dripping! I was shocked because I was taking my time eating me and the durability of the cone was really good! Just overall quality ingredients and worth the visit while down in Key West! read more

See all

Great little ice cream shop. They were a little pushy about moving the line, but they were busy so I give them a pass. The ice cream was good and it is a fun place. read more

Flamingo Crossing - Great little ice cream shop - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Key West, Florida

Ice Cream... Gelatos..oh my..All home made and they supply to the restaurants on the island. No wonder. I think it's some of the best ice cream I've ever had with massive servings. Thankfully we bought the small. They have, I'd say about twenty different flavors with some having liquor infused flavorings. It's a hip little indoor outdoor joint with a Kitschy vibe. Cash only here and if you buy ice cream you have free access the bathrooms. Otherwise a dollar for the experience!! You can choose to sit in or out. The day we were here, inside was the only option, but note it's very small here. They offer coffee also which I did not have, but did indulge in the Cuban coffee flavor cream. Oh my... just loved it. Worth all the calories involved!! So again if you are in Key West do not miss this little hidden gem. read more

Flamingo Crossing - Ice cream counter - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Key West, Florida

Service was absolutely atrocious! My three daughters (sub 21) visited to get, what more than ice cream, when one of them inquired what Kahlua was, the server rudely said "You can figure it out when you're 21." Heaven forbid someone under the age of 21 ask an innocent question to get such a rude response. Needless to say they found ice cream elsewhere. read more

We were looking for local ice cream places to try while we were in Key West. Their description of homemade ice cream and great Yelp reviews brought us to this place. And it was such a disappointment. I was excited to see tropical fruit flavors, but after I tried peach cream, and a couple others, I didn't want to have any ice cream. The peach cream was icy and not creamy, and it didn't taste like peach. My husband got chocolate, and we didn't like it either. The server was also surly, from the time we entered, he didn't seem to want to serve us, he acted like he was doing us a favor even talking to us. The place is also cash only. read more