We stopped in to get some key lime pie to take back to our place. The service was great. Our key lime pie was so tasty and the crust was delicious. Highly recommend for a quick to go dessert. read more

Kermit's Key Lime Shop - Key lime pie - Desserts Near Me - Key West, Florida

Read this shop was a must stop in key west. After walking around in the heat, we popped in for something cool. We took ours to go, but there was some seating available. I got the strawberry white chocolate frozen key lime pie. There were lots of different flavors and options. It wasn't the best pie I had on the trip but still hit the spot. read more

Kermit's Key Lime Shop - Desserts Near Me - Key West, Florida

I got a strawberry limeade with the strawberry key lime pie and it was delicious! The cashier was nice and made the suggestion that I try the strawberry key lime pie instead of the original! Happy to know one of these locations are opening closer towards me so I can stop by and try all the other amazing flavors! read more

Kermit's Key Lime Shop - Strawberry Key Lime Pie - Desserts Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

The key lime pie was fantastic. Had an original piece frozen dipped in chocolate and also one regular. It was counter service. That particular day was very quiet and we had time to try the cookie samples also. read more

See all

Kermit's came up as a place I should stop for key lime pie in Key West. I loved the ability to sample many of their cookies, crackers and candies before making a purchase. They have so many unique key lime featured items including chapstick. I kept it simple and went with a slice but really enjoyed eating it in their bright patio area! read more

I have been to Key West before as a teen and always loved when my dad would buy us slices of key lime pies for my siblings and I to indulge in. My parents are both very health conscious so this was a rare treat for us. After about 15 years since I last visited Key West, we stopped at the island as part of our cruises itinerary and my friends and I immediately knew we had to get authentic key lime pie! Thank goodness we found this location near our cruise port. Kermit's had great slices of tart and fresh key lime pie ($6 a slice), as well as whole pies for sale, ice cream, cookies, and a few other lime-y treats. The pie was so good!!! It was refreshing and indulgent and wonderful. This location is in a tourist-y area of Key West by Mallory Square and this is one of the smaller Kermit's Key Lime Pie Shops. It was decorated pretty cute as well. They also had samples out for customers to try. I might have helped myself to a few too many free samples! ... (I have problems with saying no to sweets).... I wish there was more seating inside and that the calories were listed for the pie slice, but otherwise, my friends and I loved our delicious dessert of pie on Pi Day 2026! read more

See all

If you love key lime, you need to go here. You can sample the cookies, crackers, and nuts. They have key lime pies in a whole or I slice. They also have frozen chocolate covered key lime pie on a stick Friendly staff. read more

See all

Our first introduction to Key Lime Pie in the Keys. Went to this small shop on the first day and also the last to pick up goodies to bring home. On night one, we bought the basic pie and a chocolate dipped freezer pie. Fantastic flavor. Shop clerk didn't expect me to have cash, because no one has cash anymore. Good food, good service, one of the easiest and best places in town. read more

Dined: 5/27/26 This was our 1st trip to Key West and we arrived via Celebrity Reflection Cruise Ship. We love Key Like Pie and was trying to find the best in Key West. If you like a more tart filling than Kermit's is for you! However, if you like a less tart filling and an awesome crust, then Mattheessen's is for you. read more

See all

Very creative, I can't imagine key lime pie can make a good cookies. They're very generous on the cookies sample. I'm glad I tried them all, they were all so delicious. I almost wanted to buy all types of cookies I tried, but I have to hold back due to not enough luggage space. Overall, this is a great place for souvenir shopping, i like their key lime cookies. by the way, the shop itself is cute, love the decor and the wallpaper. read more

See all

Kermit's Key Lime Shop in Key West is a vibrant, sun-soaked icon at 200 Elizabeth Street, its cheerful yellow-and-green exterior welcoming visitors just steps from the historic seaport. Founded over 30 years ago by Kermit Carpenter who started with smoothies outside Papa's Restaurant before turning to his grandma's recipe and even lobbying in Tallahassee to make key lime pie Florida's official state dessert the shop has earned raves from Food Network and National Geographic for its authentic, tart perfection. No trip to Key West is complete without their legendary key lime pie: grab a slice or that famous chocolate-dipped bar on a stick, settle into the cute garden seating, and take a bite. The graham cracker crust crumbles perfectly, releasing a burst of bright, zesty lime custard that's creamy, tangy, and refreshingly balanced pure tropical heaven that melts on your tongue. Friendly service and the prime location make it even better. Bloody brilliant one forkful and you'll declare it the best in paradise ! read more

See all

Cute shop. Lots of free cookie tastings. Outdoor space was lovely and shaded. Service was friendly and prompt. Key Lime pie was tangy and tasty. Loved the lime ade. read more

Kermit's Key Lime Shop - Key lime pie - Desserts Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

While on our recent cruise with Virgin Voyages, we docked at our first stop in Key West. We had the chance to explore the quaint little town and all it had to offer. One of the biggest spots my family wanted to visit was the Key Lime Store. Now, let me tell you--there are a number of key lime shops in Key West, and it really comes down to which one you choose. After doing some research online, we agreed on the location on Duval Street. It wasn't too far from the Conch Shack, which I'll review in another post. This location was busy--it was a Tuesday afternoon, and people were ready to get some key lime pie, including us! Kermit's seems to be popular, and it's easy to see why. It's such a cute, quaint spot. I loved the coastal decor, with the colors and interior giving a really fun vibe. They have a variety of treats to choose from, from drinks and pies to even cakes. We grabbed a slice of key lime pie to go, and the packaging was adorable! The staff was friendly and answered all of our questions. If you're in the area--whether docking from a cruise or just visiting the neighborhood--I definitely recommend this location! You will not be disappointed. It tastes even better than the key lime pies sold in stores, so come get yours read more

See all

Can't come to the Florida Keys and not try a slice of key lime pie! I stopped by Kermit's, because why not, and was happy that I did. The fine folks behind the counter really went far and beyond to make sure I enjoyed my pie-xperience. The flavor was sweet, tart and delicate. The crust was pretty good for a precut and stored slice. Though I was told this was "fresh." Whatever the case I enjoyed it sitting out on the back patio. Like most other pie spots they have a bunch of lime inspired goodies. Be sure to stop by. read more

See all

Key Lime Pie lived up to the hype I heard about it! It was delicious! Tart and sweet perfection.

The best key lime pie in Key West. So good we stopped by three times and it did not disappoint. Delish crust with some crispiness to it , Creamy filling with the perfect amount of Zesty lime and not too sugary sweet and a great crust to filling ratio. Service was efficient and it made the perfect dessert to complement our dinners out while on vacation. read more

See all

The pie was ok. Literally it tastes like it came from the freezer section. Not fresh small portion. It You can Skip it. In my opinion Gk to the key lime bakery read more

Kermit's Key Lime Shop - This is the place I recommend this location lies are made fresh on site. - Desserts Near Me - Key West, Florida

One of our least favorite key lime pies in the area. I know they are legit on every trees corner but they were so sweet as not tart enough to be called key lime pie. I couldn't finish past the first three bites before I was too sugared up to continue. They were highly recommended in travel key west sites, locals, and our taxi drivers, but they did not do it for us. Sorry Kermit's! read more

Amazing store full of all things key lime... cookies, taffy, ice cream, candies ... all with ample free samples. A fun store to browse... and yes they have pie! Fresh, frozen, etc. your choice! Recommend you stop by at the end of Duval! read more

See all

This is THE place to get your key lime! They have pies, ice cream, cookies, the works. We got the famous key lime pie slice on a stick and I shares it with a friend. So good but very rich. read more

See all

Still my favorite key lime pie slice after all of these years. Stop in for a slice to go, or sit outside and devour your slice. Additional Key Lime flavored items available in the store. read more

Im not some sort of key lime connoisseur, but this pie was well balanced, smooth, flavorful, and extremely refreshing. It warranted a return visit before I left. I believe there are 3 locations (maybe 4). While going to Kermit's may seem cliche, it certainly was well worth the visit. ENJOY!!! read more

Kermit's Key Lime Shop - Desserts Near Me - Key West, Florida

Got a slice of key lime pie dipped in white chocolate from Kermit's Key Lime Shop and it was so delicious. I've been trying to watch my figure and be calorie deficit but this places key lime sweets kicks discipline out the door. Friendly service and a wonderful ambiance. If ever in the keys get some key lime pie. Never knew key lime pie got its origin in the keys either! read more

Kermit's Key Lime Shop - Desserts Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

We went to a tiny shop, but I had heard of Kermit's so it was the convenient location for us. The standard pie itself was good. There was a lady in there that was kind of rude. I was surprised by the rudeness of multiple people on this island. If ya'll can't appreciate money-spending customers, then get out of the service business. Like seriously. read more

I finally had Key lime pie for the first time at Kermit's, and I think I just met my soulmate (and it's citrus-flavored). Perfectly tart, creamy, and balanced. not too sweet, not too sour, just pure sunshine in dessert form! read more

See all

What an adorable place! The decor is stunning. There are 3 locations. We went to the one on Duval St. they have everything you need. Samples. Seating inside and out. Stuff for dogs. Decor for you home. Candies. Bakery items. And of course key lime pie. Everything is key lime pie flavor. There was only 1 person helping which was suffice and he was nice and answered all questions. read more

See all

Oh I love anything key lime and this stores the best! The cookies, the key lime pie on sticks and all other products they make are sooo good! Must go in and try something because everything's amazing! The young lady working there was so welcoming and helpful.. told us about best sellers and had to pick up bag of key lime coolers .. cookies with a key lime soft powdered sugar coating! Cute shop covered in key lime themes.. great stop right on duval street read more

Kermit's Key Lime Shop - Desserts Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

Service was great! Place was clean! Great options in key lime pies and other cracker snacks and cookies. Bought the strawberry key lime pie and it was super yummy! read more

Kermit's Key Lime Shop - Desserts Near Me - Key West, Florida

Wanted some frozen key lime pie remembering back over 13 years ago when we were last in Key West. I selected the frozen strawberry key lime pie and it was not frozen at all and had little to no key lime flavor. The staff was nice and offered another one from their back freezer but we declined since we had already purchased a slice of coconut key lime pie which was good. I think I was looking for the tart key lime flavor but the slice was a little subtle imo. Overall not bad but when you're in Key West you need to get a slice of key lime pie! read more

The best key lime pie in key west! Bring home the best souvenir - you can buy a frozen pie that is packaged to keep it fresh for 15 hours. $10 additional for the packaging and it counts as a carry on if you're taking it on a plane read more

I am very happy with Kermit's customer service! I had a bad experience in store and they made it right by sending me 3 packs of cookies that was so sweet! Thank you so so much! read more

Make sure to add this stop to your foodie itinerary! My husband LOVES key lime pie and orders it often. I can take it or leave it. Kermit's, I'll take it! Honestly, I really didn't think there could be that much of a difference. But...we visited the Blond Giraffe in Marathon Key. While it was good, of course, what's not to like about limes and sugar, I'd say save your money and taste buds for 2 slices of Kermit's instead. I don't know how they do it better but they did. So creamy, smooth and tart. It will not disappoint AND grab a bag of their coco-lime cookies to take home. They offer samples. After tasting, we didn't buy just one to "try". We were able to try and bought 6 bags to take home to the grandkids. This key lime pie made a lover out of me! read more

We stopped her just to take a look around and was pleasantly surprised, loved the decor and had a slice of key lime pie. A great place to visit! read more