I have taken the 3 hour trip from upstate Schenectady NY to Sheepshead Bay many times. This is by…read morefar my favorite charter! I have brought my wife, children, in-laws, & friends on multiple occasions with absolute confidence everyone will have a great time. The captain makes sure everyone has the best chance to find fish while the deckhands seem to enjoy some unspoken battle amongst themselves to see who can be the most helpful! You will never go without bait. Rods & reels provided for the whole family. Even if you bring your own gear, they have it so dialed in from the rod size to the reel capacity to the line diameter to the oz & hook sizes! Respectfully leave your gear home. It's worth the $5-$10 to let them do it. Then after you fill your cooler, they gladly clean your catch to your liking (dressed or filleted)

Very helpful crew and knowledgable captain. I had my own tackle, so I cannot comment on the quality…read moreof the boat's gear. All in all, a very fun day on the water.

This place is a hidden gem in Brooklyn! Although I don't live in the area, I know a handful of…read morepeople that do. Came here recently with my boyfriend for about an hour. There's parking available upon arrival. There's seating alongside the body of water. There's various activities available to do here including walking, taking a seat to overlook the water or people-watch, picnic, BBQ or grill, fishing, and running or jogging. The area is definitely kept clean. There's plenty of trash cans available here as well. I'm looking forward to returning here for some more relaxation.

Very relaxing walking destination one half mile from my house. Lots of regular folk fishing,…read moresitting around, talking and just enjoying the day. Plenty of benches and shade. Nice place to hang out. Bathrooms available.

The boat Marilyn Jean IV is kept well. When we arrived the deck was being hosed down and mopped up…read more The crew is attentive and will help you get on the fish. The water was very choppy and the captain had to constantly move us back to our spot to get on the fish. The crew was patient and cool people to fish with. The morning and night crowd are typically the more experienced fisherman. The 2-6 pm time is more family oriented. Either way it was a great experience and will go fishing again next time in town.

Huge shout out to the owner Tony! I called in to ask some questions about fishing and he was just…read moresuper awesome, helpful, and kind. I'm excited for the upcoming fishing trip with you all!

Never Enuff has done it again!! Captain Brandon and Mike gave us a experience we could never…read moreexpect...very professional kept boat clean and was very helpful. Me and my brother will definitely come back those guys were great. Respect

Booked a private charter with 10 friends and we were absolutely blessed to get Captain Mike and his…read moreson who is also a captain! They were friendly, patient, knowledgeable and efficient. We started catching fish on our first drop and ended up catching our limit! They took pictures, answered ALL of our questions, filleted & cleaned fish and gave us ice at the end to transport our catch! Can't wait for our next trip! It was well worth the money and an experience we will never forget!

Went striped bass fishing yesterday with my brother and cousins on Whatta Catch Sport Fishing…read more Charters . We had a great day. This is a first class operation. Beautiful boat, top notch gear, and captain and crew who know how to find and boat the fish. If you are looking for a great day on the water of fishing this is the spot to book your charter.

I booked a reservation for a bachelor party with Rob. Unfortunately the weather forecast on the day…read moreof included wind and thunderstorms, so we didn't end up going. What I was so impressed by was how Rob handled the cancellation. No arm twisting or anything. No problem getting the deposit back. They run an honest shop, and I appreciate that immensely.

My original fishing expedition got cancelled because there weren't enough people so they directed…read moreme to Brooklyn VI. It was a stormy cloudy day with rain on the horizon and really choppy waves. I was told that it was not a good day for fishing. The captain tried very hard to find us fish and it was one of the best fishing trips ever. I went with my brother and father for my father's birthday. We got 2 buckets full of porgies on a "bad fishing day"!!!! I can only imagine what a good day would look like with those experienced fishermen. Thank you!!!

Okay, so I just came on here to read the reviews out of curiosity & send the yelp link to my cousin…read morewho I want to bring fishing. I personally have been fishing with Brooklyn VI for years with a large group of friends. I have never sought out another boat because of the following: - They have a cool and helpful staff. - If nothing is biting, they ALWAYS tell us to stop and drive out deeper to find a better location. - I literally always have to STOP fishing because I catch too many Blues (don't have the freezer room). The first time I fished with them I caught 9 big blues. I always catch a bunch and then chill the rest of the trip and talk to friends who are pooped. On one trip, my son was about 9 at the time - he caught 3 or 4 by himself and the staff of course pulled the fish in for him. -They clean the fish for you which saves me so much trouble. I don't want to call anyone a liar but I will say, after what, 7 years of fishing with Brooklyn VI, I've NEVER seen the shore when we start fishing, never! I WILL say that I've only fished the weekend 7pm trips so I can only comment on that.

Guests: Check your receipt and make sure they don't over charge you. The Kid working this last…read moreweekend at the counter is completely clueless and from what I experienced over charged me on purpose in an attempt to pull cash later. Just wonder how many times the customer didn't realize this....... After I called him out on an over charge of 10 bucks on a 40$ sale I said why did you charge me 10 more he said "oh that's tax, and I said "nope that doesn't add up" he looked at me in a whisper and said "if I just give you the cash difference would that make it batter" to the Owner of this place and to other guests check your sales and make sure you aren't being overcharged or scamming your customers, Big fail.

Walked in and all the employees was about 7 of them had no masks on they also seemed more annoyed…read morecustomer came in

Fishing Trip! We had a great time aboard the Sea Queen!…read moreCaught lots of fish, and the crew was super helpful and attentive. Captain Steve really knows where to find them and made nice conversation. It was excellent family fun, and I highly recommend it for a trip with the kids.

I'm writing this review to let other potential customers know that there aren't any regulations…read moreabout smoking or drinking on the boat. Other than this despite not catching anything (seemed slow all around) the trip would have been fine. We had a 5 hour ride I assume trying to find fish but a group of friends in front of us kept smoking cigarettes like clock work. It was disgusting to keep inhaling smoke for those 5 hours. I wish people were more mindful of others (also, my niece who is a child was to my left inhaling all that crap). My sister took a trip before and said that wasn't as bad on her trip. Maybe it was just my unlucky trip, but I just can't recommend it knowing I would pay $70 to be in what felt like the club and not fishing. To the captain: You do have a big boat! I would have moved if there was enough space as you saw there was quite a bit of people last night. I also came with my family and it was a group of us. Again, I wrote this to let others know. My sister still enjoyed and will be back. Best, Diana

Captain Paris and crew make your fishing trip very enjoyable . the crew are very knowledgeable in…read moreseamanship duties

Was fishing on the 6pm to 11pm trip on the Capt.Dave...Got to say the fishing was good ,took home…read morea dozen jumbo porgies,mates were very helpful,and Dave put us on some big porgies....recommend this boat.