We got take out from here last night for the super bowl. The pizza is delicious! The crust is thin which a slightly doughy crust. The sauce is slightly sweet and the cheese is generous. It kind of reminds me of Bridge Street Pizza in Dublin with a slightly thicker crust. We also got garlic cheese bread, macaroni and cheese bites, and mozzarella sticks. The macaroni and cheese bites were good as well as the GCB although a tiny bit cold. However considering we got take out on a snowy Super Bowl Sunday they were pretty good. I think the mozzarella sticks might have either been taken too quick out of the fryer or not at all. Fortunately after putting them in the oven they weren't bad. We will definitely try Sparano's again because the pizza was amazing but will pick a time when things will hopefully be more calm. read more

See all

Same great food but new location. They have moved to 3947 W.Broad,directly across the street from Drive Time auto sales. Inside is clean and service is friendly and fast. Try the Heavy Meat pizza,it will put you to sleep! read more

Sparano's Pizza - Menu as of January 2023 - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

I guess no one stays on top forever and that's the reason I'm writing this review. A few years ago I found this pizza shop on the fly. They quickly became a favorite of mine and would order a few times a month. The staff was always pleasant and worked to make the food right the first time. Unfortunately my top pizza place has fallen. If I could date the change in taste and quality it would be around Covid-19. There seemed to be a change in staff and food. After receiving my order this week I've decided this would no longer a good pizza spot for me. Sorry but taste is everything for me. Best wishes read more

Sparano's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Soggy pizza got delivery. It was cold. Not worth it take your money somewhere else. Do not recommend

Sparano's is no longer at this address. They have the same phone number as the Sparano's. Just picked up a pizza from there for lunch. This is obviously not the same pizza I've been eating for the last 4 years. So I called them and asked if they were under New management or something because this is not the pizza I expected. They said yes they are the new owners. They are Kathy's Pizza now. Even though you can search Saparono's on Google and end up here. How frustrating. read more

Amazing pizza. We got the usual-- "heavy duty", It was a bit thinner and crispier this time which was the best pizza I've ordered soo far from SPARANOS!!!! The veggies are really fresh and crispy, not soggy. Absolutely delicious!! read more

Edited to add a photo of the Heavy Duty -- this is a medium. Look at those toppings! Added a star because this pizza deserves it. Not greasy, great toppings, tasty crust. They do use canned mushrooms, but that's actually my preference. Funny thing to note: I hate banana peppers but I really like them from Sparanos. read more

Sparano's Pizza - Heavy Duty Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

This is a very solid choice for a Columbus style, party cut, or whatever the hell you want to call it pie. Mine was extra cheesy so I really liked that, and they don't skimp on the ingredients here. I think my favorite part overall was the crust. It's super thin, and super crispy but not burnt. It really provides a nice crunch when you're digging in to this pizza and was probably the highlight for me. I don't have a whole lot to say about this place other than I wish I had tried it sooner. It's definitely a good option for people in the Grandview/Quarry/Riverside area and just a straight up good Columbus pizza. read more

This pizza place is a hidden gem. It doesn't look like much on the outside, but it's what's in the box that truly matters. Do not judge this book by its cover. This place makes incredible pizza. I have been searching for an amazing local pizza place, and this is it!! Trust me, this is the kind of pizza that you need to wear designated eating pants for - once you bite into a slice, you will immediately understand what I mean by this lol. This is the kind of pizza that you take home and smash the entire pie in one sitting. I like to order a pepperoni pizza and ask for it "well done" so the pepperonis get all crispy and delicious. The pizza is very reasonably priced, too. Do yourself a favor and order this pizza ASAP! read more

Sparano's Pizza - Pepperoni pizza - "well done" will make the pepperonis crispy - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Easy online ordering through the Slice app. When I arrived they had a lot of to-go orders. I had to wait about 10 minutes longer than the estimated time. I got the garlic Parmesan chicken wings and a pizza. The wings were a bit dry. The pizza was really good and unique from many other pizza places. It was more of a pie but not deep dish. It was filled with toppings. Personally there were too many banana peppers, but easily something that I can specify on a special request next time. read more

This place is a gem! The pizza is delicious Columbus style. Love their sausage pizza. Nice emoloyees. Ordered from here for my son's 1st birthday party and everyone loved these pies! read more

Sparano's Pizza - a table full of pizzas - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

we ordered cheesy bacon fries and a large pizza. The pizza was delivered in a timely manner however, the fries where completely burned and the pizza was doughy. very disappointing. read more

I think I discovered the next place for a reality TV show. Pizza with a side of drama is all I can say while picking up from here. The employees were obviously going through something with one another. Moral was very low. I ended up waiting for my pizza for an extra 15 minutes. Left and came home to the wrong pizza. MTV- where you at? I found your next best hit read more

Call me old-school, but sometimes a girl just gotta get her hands on a pizza sub. Who knew that they weren't as common as back in the day. Lucky for me in my search for "pizza subs near me" Sparano's menu popped up, so I thought I would give it a try & I was glad I did. I ordered the small, not knowing if it would be as good as I had remembered as a kiddo. I would definitely order again, but I would request for it to be served open-face style just for old time's sake. There is a 5% discount for ordering online, which I found to be quite easy. read more

My son brought home some leftovers from a friend's game-watching gathering, so I heated it up in a skillet, and was quite pleasantly surprised. Liked it a lot, and I'm quite critical of most pizzas I've tried. Definitely want to give it another try, especially the one with sausage, feta and pepperoncini. read more

The pizza taste good but the crust on bottom seems undercooked and is limp. I did request pie slice, however I got party sliced. Since you can't order directly from the business, the $5 delivery charge on top of tip and "local" fee makes this pizza way too expensive. This will be my last time ordering. read more

Long time customer. Finally see it tanking. Sad. Got a salad and pasta plate the other night - salad was half the size of the large we've gotten in the past 17 years - hardly any greens and no dressing was provided. Pasta plate was considerably smaller than normal. And no meatballs available. Will review again IF and when I try a pie. Will probably check out other local pizzza places first since our "go to" place has taken a downturn. I feel bad but who isn't struggling after 24 months of not normal. The MAJORITY of your customers are repeat life long customers - let's not take advantage of a good relationship. read more

I sat to the immediate left of the owner of this place while playing poker in Cincinnati a couple of months ago. During our conversations, he told me of this place and proudly proclaimed how good of a pizza his place made. I told him that in the near future, I'd give it a try when in the Columbus area. A few nights ago I ordered a large, half pepperoni, half sausage. Very delicious and high quality in all ways from the flavorful crust with a nice crunch, tasty sauce, better than average pepperoni, and a very good sausage that blows away the poor excuse of what passes for sausage most chain shops and many local places have as well. Staff was friendly, attentive, and hard working. If I was younger and didn't have a bad back, I'd approach the owner about him opening a location or three in the Dayton area and offer to manage one so that my fellow Daytonians could get an upgrade from their usual pizza offerings! p.s.-4 stars only because it takes complete perfection for me to give 5 stars and that almost doesn't exist! read more

Have ordered Sparano's likely close to a hundred times since moving to the area five years ago. I've always liked the quality of the pizza however will no longer be ordering after tonight. I arrived home and after eating two pieces of my pizza discovered a five inch brown hair in the pizza (pic attached). I immediately called and the manager offered to make a new pizza. I arrived back at Sparano's, hair-pizza in hand, but when told none of the bill would be reimbursed I politely declined the pizza. Due to ordering through a third party app the manager explained there was simply nothing he could do. I disagree. Recommend addressing customer service, hair nets, sanitation etc. read more

Sparano's Pizza - Hair in bottom right corner of box (has small amount of cheese attached) - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Best pizza in columbus, perfect amount of everything everytime.

I ordered food from here probably once a week sometimes twice a week sometimes three times a week. I have been ordering food from this location for the last 15 years. I called and I ordered my food at 7:35 PM it showed up at 8:49 PM not only was it an almost an hour and a half late when they showed up they said I only have half of your food. So I rejected it and I called the pizza place hoping they would at least offer an apology, and I got no offer. It is absolutely the principle of it I will never order food from this location or this company again. read more

I really enjoyed this pizza. The crust was cooked to perfection and the sauce had a good flavor. I also would recommend the breadsticks. Even though the place isn't in the best part of town, it's still worth the trip out there. read more

Sparano's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

LOVE this place. Honestly this place is about 10 minutes from my home, but it is worth driving a little farther to pick up some good pizza. I havent eaten at this place for several years. I figured to skip out on making dinner tonight and suggested Sparano's to the hubby. We called ahead and picked up the pizza 30 minutes later. GOOOD!!! The owners are always friendly and the pizza is one of the best in the area. We will definitely be back again for pizza!! I didnt realize this until this evening, but they have two other locations too -- Northwest Blvd. in Grandview and also Hubbard Rd. in Galloway. :) read more

This was a mixed bag for us. I found the pizza to be pretty spicy (in a good way) and would likely order it again. My husband didn't enjoy it and said it was bland. The flavor was reminiscent of Donatos flavoring but not the same or a copy cat at all. It's a hand tossed crust but a little crispy. We also ordered breadsticks. These were something I would not order again. They were bland, and unseasoned. I'm not gonna act like we're casual about our pizza and tend to be a bit picky. Second day pizza this is not either. I would likely order this for myself again but not for us as a dinner. We ordered during an OSU game and were told the order would take an hour. We were fine with that and had ordered early with this in mind. Sure enough they arrived at an hour on the dot and the driver was very nice. I appreciated that. read more

See all

I really surprised when i went in. Only half the staff had on masks. Very unorganized. No one wearing gloves while handling the food.

Went here after a golf outing at Raymond. Pizza was really good. Ordered through Door Dash a few weeks later and added a sub to my order. Subs are great as well. If you haven't had this pizza, I would suggest to try it at least once. It rivaled Tommy's for me. Will be ordering again soon as my girlfriend liked it better than Tommy's which was her favorite until now. read more

Phenomenal pizza. Busy on this particular night but really good service. Really old school vibe and down to earth. read more

I've had the Italian Sub (very good-nice dressing and toasted bread) and a small 10" Heavy Duty pizza. The toppings were impressive--very chunky. The mushrooms were from a can, which I'm not a fan of, but all in all it was pretty good. Crust a medium thickness and slightly chewy; sauce was nice and mild. If it says anything they have multiple Slice of Columbus award banners hanging on the walls. Speaking of the inside, it leaves a lot to be desired. Not a lot of tables and not very, um, cheery. Order to-go or delivery and you'll be fine. They have a small case of canned drinks and 2 liters. Check out their menu for they have appetizers, subs and pizza. A little pricey but worth a try if you like a lot of toppings. Go Heavy Duty. read more

Sparano's Pizza - 10" Heavy Duty straight out of the oven. - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Best pizza in Columbus. Also best Italian sub (the Michaelangelo) & meatball sub. I get the pepperoni and mushroom pizza, and it's always delicious. You can also take your pizza to the pub next door to enjoy it with a bucket of beer. read more

We love their pizza and Greek salad! Great service and awesome food! Do yourself a favor and check next time you are in a "pizza" mood order from Sparano's! read more

Very good pizza. The sausage was large chunks as opposed to small rabbit dropping sized. Sauce had a little sweetness and crust had a little crunch. Overall a good pizza...definitely will order again... highly recommend over large chains. read more

I am in total love with this pizza. I just moved here from Athens, GA and the owner of Kinetic told me about this place. Can not wait to get back after I get settled in and learn my around my new home. read more

Love their pizza. actually my favorite!! Never have I ordered or attempted to order during prime time for carry out and was told we aren't talking my orders. REALLY?? Not taking orders at 6:00pm at night. Yes I will order again. But REALLY??? read more

I had a bad experience ordering from Sparano's using The Slice app. I work at a busy and large office building so I left detailed instructions to ask for me by department. The driver arrived and told the front desk my name not department. The front desk asked the driver for more information that they did not provide. Because of this the food sat for 30 minutes before I was able to pick it up. In that time I contacted Slice who informed me the pizza was delivered but not to where. When I complained later Sparano's said the front desk person seemed confused -- she takes deliveries all day long, she definitely wasn't confused. The pizza seemed like it would have been good, though when I tried it it wasn't fresh any longer so about 3 slices were eaten in total before it had to be tossed (I HATE throwing away food but at an office party it just sorta sat there as the other food had already been eaten by the time it arrived) I would love to try them again, but will definitely be picking my order up or eating in next time! read more

They make a mean pie. Good flavor, good crust, and they are consistent. I have brought a lot of my friends to try this pizza, and everyone loves it. Definitely well worth trying. read more

Top shelf pizza Great taste Fast delivery Friendly people A must for lunch and dinner. read more

Great pepperoni pizza. Of the 8 or so Pizza places that deliver to my house this place is the best. Great sauce and perfect crispy, greasy pepperonis. read more

Sparano's pizza has a perfect crust. Not too thin or thick. Ours was party cut square slices. Generous toppings. We ordered sausage and it was almost sausage balls on top. Delicious! Nice and greasy pizza. read more

This is my favorite place for pizza. But time after time I've been let down, every chance I give this place, it always seems to burn me. I was ready to order 13-16 large pizza for my guest for my party on New Years. I called and of course Sparano's was closed "due to being out of dough and other supplies" keep in mind this was around 6:45pm New Years Eve, the only pizza shop on New Years who decides to screw over customers, and not take Our money. I think I'm finished here forever. :( It's too bad , this pizza is the best in Columbus. read more

Although the pizza is amazing, the employees working were not wearing masks except when ringing up the bill.