I've enjoyed their pizza several times and this is my first review. Just wanted to share how much we've enjoyed it every time! They have been consistently excellent! Want to mention how much we've loved the Cajun pasta with chicken ...the veggie with added pepperoni is my go to for pizza. All the veggies are fresh and crisp and they never scrimp on the toppings. The dough is above average and I wish the owner would tell me how he makes the sauce! Tastes fresh and homemade and not from a can! The service is great, the food is always hot and fresh even when we've had it delivered. And thanks for being available at 330am for those late weekend nights!! Prices are very reasonable for the quality, service and delicious food. Oh and don't forget to order some Dessert!! The Oreo pie and cheesecake are sooo good and you can't beat their prices!! I've included a pic of my fave veggie pizza with pepperoni which prompted my current review. If you've never tried them please give them a try! I've had others that charge a lot more and get more word of mouth that have been a disappointment...but Pizza Fresca deserves your business! Thanks for a great pizza guys! read more

Pizza Fresca - Veggie with added pepperoni - Italian Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

We ordered food here after a concert last night. The pizzas were out of this world delicious. The Chicago style pizza has a ton of cheese in it!! Their menu is very extensive. The food was fast and steamy hot. Definitely going to keep this place on our list. read more

Food was amazin!!! The service was top tier and it was delicious. I ordered a large order and it came hot, ready and fresh in no time. I will come again! read more

I have trouble believing some of these reviews are not competitors or something. This is the best place I've ever dealt with in my life. There are great pizza places in Ohio this one the food is most definitely exceptional, but the big thing for me and the big reason for my rating is the absolute amazing service, they read any notes you put in orders they accommodate any special requests they are amazing. The service at this place is the best I've ever dealt with. read more

delicious!! look at as all this cheese!!! smells great too!! I don't give fives very easily but this real darn close read more

Pizza Fresca - Italian Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

very good pizza I love it delicious plus the wings very good well done my kids love, pappron Rowl, Rowl

Breading on the Tenders taste like biting into a leather shoe that was stored in a cheese barrel for 11 years. But they are open at absurd hours. Don't get the fries. Can't speak on the pizza, haven't had it. read more

The place is small in a busy strip mall area. It is a carry out only location. The service is friendly and attentive. I ordered their stuffed Chicago style pizza. It was delicious! Nice job guys!!! Having lived in the Chicago land area, I know stuffed pizza. This was good. I would order again. The cheese was delicious and the sauce is on the sweeter side, which is good to me. I heard another customer mention the pizza isn't heavy on the sauce here. I understand. The crust on my stuffed pizza was well done and the layers were perfect. read more

Pizza Fresca - Stuff pizza slice - Italian Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

when you order a pizza, sometimes you want a PIZZA. A cheesy, greasy, hot slice of pie that makes your tummy feel full. This is that pizza. but this is my to go for when I'm craving pizza. This is the epitome of pizza. read more

Pizza Fresca - Hand-Tossed Cheese Pizza - Italian Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Solid pizza! Everything I ordered was correct. They make it super cheesy and delicious. Would definitely order again! read more

Pizza Fresca - Chicken Bacon Alfredo Pizza - Italian Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

I ordered it on grub hub not in person the pizza was the worst pizza I have ever had . Had to force feed it to myself. The cheese just doesn't seem to be melted right I question if it's real cheese tasted low quality or vegan but I hope it's not vegan . I had a cheese pizza with pepperoni I believe. read more

Good food Great service and friendly customer service/environment Highly recommended read more

Oh lawwwd How is a supreme pizza gonna have ALL THE INGREDIENTS AND STILL TASTE LIKE ABSOLUTELY NOTHING?! WHAT KIND OF DARK MAGIC IS THIS?! But let me tell you that it sure doesn't feel like nothing coming out the next day. It feeling like death. I thought I had food poisoning.. we ordered the fried mushrooms the Cajun pepperoni rolls and the 16" supreme fresca pizza. Worst $44 I EVER spent. I would have been better off spending that money on an enema. That picture I posted, that's all we ate. That is what is in my refrigerator right now.. it was getting late and my fiance was talking about he didn't want to grill out because it was getting chilly outside.. I told him he either grills out or he has to eat that pizza. He immediately went and got the bag of charcoal. IT'S THAT SERIOUS. It literally has all the ingredients. It has pizza sauce. It has all the cheese. IT HAS ZERO FLAVOR. We cannot understand how this is possible. We cannot understand. And if the aftermath wasn't so bad I would be happy to fix it, but my butt says no. My gut says HELL NO. You know when you've been eating kind of healthy and then you eat something really unhealthy and you feel sluggish and gross and your body tells you you shouldn't have eaten that. That's how eating this feels x10. This is what happens when you mess around and wait till the last minute to order dinner on Uber eats. Order before 9:00 p.m. people. On the side note the pepperoni rolls weren't terrible... But just don't do it.. I'm just really grateful that my birthday was last week and my fiance bought me a bidet with a really powerful jet blaster. Really saved me and him both a lot of pain and suffering today. I highly recommend biobidet if you're in the market. It has a seat warmer and it'll blow dry your booty. So there's that. I just really wanted to end this review on a good note and that's all I could think of. Ok byeeeeee! read more

Pizza Fresca - a pizza in a box - Italian Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

At first you'll think the cheese bread is cheese pizza. But they got ya there. Yum yum read more

Pizza Fresca - Cheese Cheesy Pizza Bread or Hand-Tossed Cheese Pizza - Italian Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Good place that always comes through. Good for a late night order. Pizza is good and so are the entrees.

This was my first time trying this pizza place. It was the only one open late enough so I ordered a large cheese pizza. Pizza was good and reasonably priced. read more

Pizza Fresca - Large cheese pizza - Italian Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

I've ordered from so much lol. Portions are good, food is amazing even door dashing it its still good when it arrives. Always accurate. And they remember to put the sauces I asked for. Cuz what I'd pizza with out ranch dressing read more

Worst customer service ever. Would highly not reccomend this place. I ordered a pizza through uber eats and uber said I should call them to adjust the order when I called I got pushback and was told that they couldn't do half pepperoni and half chicken... I tried to order that through uber but they would only let me add the pepperoni, I told the guy Id pay the difference on the phone, he gave me so much pushback I just said its fine. I tried to contact uber to cancel it becuase thats not what I wanted, and uber told me I had to call them to cancel so I called them and they told me that if they cancel they wont be paid for the pizza. so they forcefully made the pizza and sent it out with a driver, the driver got in an accident on their way to me and I ended up being refunded. Then later on, I wrote a google review for the company, and they responded back in a lie. I would not reccomend this place... I had covid and hadnt eaten the whole day so was really looking forward to trying this new place out because donatos was closed and it was 1am already. Now I am reading the reviews and glad that I didnt get the pizza because a lot of people are saying their pizza is horrible. I tried Kings Pizza instead because of the whole issue and they gave me such amazing service. I would highly reccomend Kings Pizza. :) read more

They work hard slinging out pizzas and delicious bread. Saw how focused they were on the job and I respect it. Pizza is great, a little on the greasy side, but it's a good guilty pleasure. Bread quality is a good 4/5. I've bought before, I bought today, and I'll buy more in the future read more

The cheese on this pizza is SO thick, it's impossible to enjoy. Buffalo cheese fries were just a clump of crappy fries with hard cheese and tasted like maybe some buffalo sauce had been sitting next to it at some point--very blah. definitely won't order from here again :/ read more

The pizza here is way better than it has any business being. The sauce is great. We are in the delivery range for 2 of the best pizza places in Columbus, Adrioticos and Hound Dog's, but half the time we opt for Pizza Fresca instead. read more

Im not a columbus local so i dont know about how this place does regularly. I will say that my visit a couple weeks ago on a late saturday night was excellent. i didnt expect much from a local strip mall pizza joint at 2am but was pleasantly surprise. the pizza we ordered was delicious as were the calzones. so all of the negative reviews ive seen, im not sure what to make of them since my food was excellent. read more

their pizzas rolls and Buffalo chicken salad are to die for!!!! soooo freaking delicious!!!! I'm not sure what type of ranch they use but omg also delicious and makes the food that much better! best part is they are open pretty late 2am or 3am I think!!! so if you have late night munchies please try them out!!! read more

Not really that good. My friend drives for postmates and said that when she delivered it once that it smelled so good. And it ends there. That's the highlight. How can buttery garlic not smell good? Soooo, we tried a few things. Stuffed pizza bread sticks, cheesy garlic bread, and jalapeño poppers which were very overpriced. The food was ok at best. Lacked flavor and taste. If the best part about a food establishment is their sauces, that's not worth revisiting. read more

See all

Open late, fast delivery. The crust is phenomenal and fresh. Heavy on the cheese, but the cheese is high quality. Sauce tastes great. Toppings are fresh. I normally do not enjoy plain cheese pizza, but this stuff slaps! But lots and lots if cheese. Good luck if you are lactose intolerant. read more

Delivery dude offered no change back, keeping a ridiculous tip. Was too dumbfounded when he walked away after I handed it to him to even say anything. Then I opened the box. No ranch that I ordered (even though they nickle-&-dime the hell out of customers... $1? Are you for real?) so I drove to the shop. Explained they forgot my cups. And the owner actually tries to make me prove that I ordered sauce. I was a very frequent customer until this. Screw this place. I'll wait until it picks up a new owner again. read more

changing my review this place used to be great however I got a Philly steak the tasted like dog meat out of nowhere I was very upset I called N and they offered to waive the delivery fee and the manager said no ! I'm not helping you you have to pay this place doesn't take care of their food when it's bad you have to walk up there drop the food on the counter and let them know it is wrong the fact is is the chicken fingers get old and chewy to me gets old and chewy I don't know how to explain the fact that you can order from there 10×9 times it's great 10th Time it's awful The place next-door offers a Baci steak and shrimp for $10 it's awesome however that's gone bad they've made it right but this place I have to go and return my food for someone that spent over $200 there in the last six months I can't sing anymore one star read more

the mozzarella sticks were delicious , had a great crunchy crisp & were very cheesy . but i wish they were seasoned , i had a strambolli also it was decent but very greasy & had slim flavor , & the cheese tasted different , but overall i'll give it a 6.5 thanks read more

I ordered through a delivery service. I have never had a more disgusting pizza in my life. I also ordered their "buffalo chicken fries," which were absolutely awful and did not have a hint of buffalo. It was more like a KFC bowl, which tastes much better. I wish didn't even have to give a one star rating. read more

CHEEZY BREAD PIZZA DIPPED IN RANCH IS AN EXPLOSION OF FLAVOR IN YOUR MOUTH!!! a life changing experience perhaps. The regular pizza is not worth getting but definitely indulge in the cheezy bread read more

The most horrible calzone I've ever had. It was so flat and no flavor. I threw it out. That and the staff was not friendly

$6 for 4 mozzarella sticks is a crime. Food isn't very good and very overpriced. Do not recommend Pizza Fresca.

Great concept build while maintaining old quality I was a fan of this place many owners ago back when it was Gumby's. The pizza was pretty good and dirt cheap, and the pokey stix were on point. (I ate it far too often during undergrad.) When it reopened as the Pizza Joint is was roughly similar, with a slight name change from "pokey stix" to "pogo sticks," but the new Pizza Fresca has moved the focus from pizza to Italian. My first order was a veggie calzone and "Cheesy Pizza Bread" (pokey stix). The calzone wasn't too great, mainly filled with green peppers and olives, but the cheesy bread is pretty much exactly what it used to be. The next time we ordered I made my own calzone and really enjoyed it. They use mozzarella and ricotta cheese (yum!) and offer marinara and garlic sauce. Miles above most campus pizza offerings. The menu is enormous, including pizza, wings, salads, subs, stromboli, calzones, gyros, pasta and Italian entrees. Hopefully this iteration will stay a while! read more

I've only tried their cheesy bread (a round pizza without sauce, cut into squares), but it was definitely good enough to make me want to try more. read more

Tastes like cigarettes and smells like BO. If truck stop bathroom pizza is your thing, then this is your place. Excuse me while I vomit into a urinal. read more

Ok, I'm updating my review to a STRONG PRO-PIZZA FRESCA STANCE. I should have tried them more than once. They've got some good stuff on that menu for late-night snackin'. The delivery is always fast and the food is hot. Their pizza bread is good. Their pepperoni rolls are DANK. They are SO good. I mean, they're full of butter, but they're that goooooood ish. Chicken tenders are ok, nothing exceptional but they'll do. Jalapeño poppers have that cream cheese (DREAM cheese) filling and it hurts so good. Fried pickles are nice and crunchy. Also--have gotten their pasta delivered a few times. It's durn good!! Reliable service for munchie standards! read more

I may stand corrected. I decided to go back and try the pepperoni rolls and it was a completely different experience. I don't know if the first time was a fluke with a new guy, or this time they did something different but this time around was probably the best of pepperoni rolls I've ever had. Consistency is very important for me with restaurants so i'm holding off on a five star just to see if the next experience replicates this experience. But man, those were some great pep rolls! read more

do NOT order food from here. Delivery took forever. food was cold and awful. Manager was extremely rude and wouldn't offer any money back. Do NOT ORDER. read more

So I just ordered the chicken Alfredo from this place, I'm very disappointed, there is no taste at all and I should have looked at the reviews before I ordered. read more

Good pizza, bad customer service. I ordered the brisket pizza and some pepperoni sticks through the yelp app. Both were pretty good as I have not had either before. Strongly recommend the food but service...eh. The customer service left a lot to be desired and all they had to do was being my order to me. When the driver called me he said for me to meet him in the lobby to get my food. I mentioned to him that is something I have never done before and was completely new for me to hear. He assured me that is "what they do there" and I should meet him in the lobby to grab my order. At this point I was too hungry to continue to question his job and got my shoes on and went to get my food. Honestly, it would have not been that big of a deal to grab my shoes and stop what I am doing if I hadn't paid and tipped already. Certainly will wait to tip in person if they deserve it in the future. 3 stars now, could have been 5 if they did what is expected of a delivery service. read more