The pizza was so very good as well as the fried ravioli. It was fun reading about the history of this place. I would eat there again if I ever make it back to Greeley. read more

Fonta's Pizza - The house pizza - Pizza Near Me - Greeley, Colorado

See all

Absolutely love this place! One of the best pizzas you will get in Greeley. It's a little pricey, but then isn't everything nowadays.

Amazing sausage and crispy thin crust on a medium! Highly recommend!! We usually order extra sausage; it's that good!

Five stars. I've been coming to this place since I was a kid. The pizza and Greek salads are so good! Some people might be thrown off by the square pieces but for some reason Fontas just tastes better that way and Fonta himself said that's the way to do it. This place has been around for decades and hopefully will be around for many more! Keep up the amazing work Troy! read more

My family has been coming to Fonta's for 40 years. The Greek salad is so good and the Roman is on point every time - best sausage around and the cheese is slices of mozzarella. Even my husband, who is a NY pizza snob, says it's some of the best pizza around. read more

Fonta's Pizza - The Roman - Sausage and Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Greeley, Colorado

On an out of state trip and pizza sounded good. Just picked one out of a list that looked like it got pretty good reviews. We were seated right away but there was no line. Drinks brought out quickly and also ordering was fast. We did have to wait a bit longer for the pizza to come out but it was really good. My husband likes softer crust but I loved this thinner crust with a crunch to the edge. I would definitely go back to try some other variations. read more

Fonta's Pizza - a whole pizza with various toppings - Pizza Near Me - Greeley, Colorado

Always great and unique pizza. Service for take out always great. Deliveries for me have always been on time. It's great the next day, but keep it covered as thin crust meds more TLC! Love it! read more

Hands down best pizza ever! Always made as requested. Large Roman with extra sauce. Only down side is the hours. Needs to be open all the time. We absolutely love Fontas Pizza read more

I should have taken a photo of our medium Roman ( pepperoni and sausage) pizza. It has been an age since I got Pizza anywhere and it Was prepared with an adequate amount of pepperoni and attractively arranged. On this very busy Friday night in August, the packed restaurant had barely a seat available. There are a couple of televisions, thankfully with no sound on. There is also no piped in music- just the sound of people dining and mostly taking to Each other. ( except those who are writing yelp reviews) Our blonde, efficient server was great! But I didn't catch her name. This restaurant is a long standing GREELEY tradition, stop by and give them a shot. read more

Sure the pizza is way too greasy and the prices are probably too high, but, this place is amazing and has the best slice in town. Pair the Roman special with a Greek salad, and you're in heaven. read more

Love me some Fontas Pizza!!! We go there every chance we get. Tasty pizza ordered to taste.

I reviewed this place two weeks ago and for some reason was not posted, maybe because I stated it was one of the worst pizzas I have ever had, that's pretty bad since I typically love pizza and haven't had many bad ones, this was bad. Horrible meat type sauce that was mushy in the mouth and made the bottom crust inedible. I ordered on line and it was ready in time, this was the one high spots. When paying it was about $15 more than what the on line menu stated, cashier just said "yea, that's wrong on line". What a joke. Horrible over priced pizza --beware. Interior did not look welcoming, but it was take out so not sure read more

We had take out and got 3 pizzas. Probably the best pizza we've had in awhile. Not greasy, good amount of toppings and cooked perfectly!

Amazing food and service. The crust is chewy and crispy on the bottom. Ask for fresh mushrooms at no extra cost.

Been coming here since I was a kid. Greek salad is amazing. Pizza exactly how you want it: Super cheesy, greasy, and with delicious crust. Perfection. Staff is always so nice too. Cute vibes and nice comfy booths. read more

Whoever gave this place 4 stars must like truck stop food. You dont go for ambiance or mediocre service, you go for pizza. And the pizza is great...if you also like licking a salt lick. Wow, was it salty. We had 2 pizzas and had a tough time finishing them. The people were nice, so that was a plus, and its certainly not pricey. However, for 10-20% more there are plenty of places in Greeley that are much better values. read more

The pizza is amazing. The wind blew the pizza off my hands and into the floor, when I went inside and explained what happened they put on a new pizza for me ASAP! Awesome team and great customer service! Thank you from a long time customer! read more

I have been coming to this place for years and it has always been delicious and amazing! Staff is friendly and attentive, food is fresh and amazing, and atmosphere is casual. Great place to bring your kids and family for sure. read more

See all

Always love Fonta's! It is so much better than a chain pizza place. Our favorites are the American and the Roman. The salads are a bit pricey now but worth it. Try the Greek! Location is clean and staff is friendly! read more

waiting 40 minutes for the floppiest and wateriest pizza ever. they barely even sliced the pizza and the slices were very uneven. the pizza was quite sad read more

Fonta's Pizza - a person eating a slice of pizza - Pizza Near Me - Greeley, Colorado

My family and I went on a Sunday night and at first it was fairly dead. However in about 20 minutes the restaurant filled up to a wait list. No complaints and this generally a good sign, however, they only had 2 waiters in staff we got all of our food at once. Our waitress was very apologetic. We ordered a Greek salad, the American pizza and wings. The Greek salad was great, the pizza was good but a little on greasy side (pools of grease) and wings were decent. Even though all our food arrived at once, it was still and enjoyable experience. I recommend this establishment. Cheers! read more

Hands down our favorite pizza in town. The thin crust is great, the toppings are fresh. The Bear is our favorite, the pizza rolls are great too. read more

I have become addicted to Fontas after living here a year. I have always preferred to make my own pizza because everyone always fell short. It has been literally a decade since I actually LIKED restaurant pizza. The ingredients are fresh and top of the line. I always have a positive service experience here. The specials every day are great values. Today I took advantage of the Thursday special - BOGO HALF OFF. All you hear at my table is "mmmmmmm". If you don't do anything else in Greeley, make a point of eating at Fontas at least once. I love the Greek selection here too. read more

Can't believe we have never eaten at this place before. It's a little pricey but is really good Italian food they even make their own sauces. Desserts are even homemade. Family owned and the owners are on site. read more

Simply the best Greek salad, pizza, and service. Get the Bears Pizza. This place is a gem in Greeley

We used Yelp! to track down good eats in Greeley and Fonta was on the list...and they did not disappoint! Before I get to the food, the service was exceptional! Those who greeted us as we entered were genuine and friendly. Our server was energetic, friendly, focused and thorough. The food was exceptional! We had a larger party and ordered their homemade mozzarella sticks, some pizza rolls, calzones, spaghetti and meatballs, a few pizzas and some of the kiddos had burgers and fries. Everyone was beyond pleased with the meals they ordered and talked about it that evening and again the next morning. BTW, leftover pizza rolls heat up nicely and taste just as good the next day. We don't visit Greeley much, but have said we may now do so just to go back to Fonta's! read more

Short version - Gordon Ramsey needs to get his hands on this place! Fonta's does have good pizza, but if you go, stick with that and stay away from the Greek side of the menu. I love spanikopita and ordered that. It was obviously frozen at LEAST once and re-heated til barely warm in the microwave. I know that because I got it less than 5 minutes after I ordered. The crust was soggy and strangely tough and the filling was only ok. Then they charged an extra dollar for a couple tablespoons of tzaziki sauce. I will NEVER get spanikopita there again, especially not for $8. I also ordered pizza rolls, 4 for $6, which is a good deal. These were much better, even though they took awhile to get out. They were topped with a ton of oregano and parmesan, which I brushed off, but the dough was good (slightly yeasty), gooey cheese and full of pepperoni. The sauce they come with...well...that was terrible. It took me forever to figure out what was wrong with it, other than being too sweet. Finally it hit me that it tastes just like the sauce in Chef Boyardee ravioli cans. There's NO reason for a pizza joint to have bad sauce, but it must be a combination of their tomato brand and having sat cooking too long. I would smuggle in my own, next time (or just order to go). The restaurant itself is one big room with a bunch of outdated seating and decor. It can get loud if it's a busy time. The wait staff is pleasant, if not very fast. I had to ask for drink refills repeatedly and about the timing of my food. I wasn't checked on after it was delivered, either. My waitress only had 5 tables with 2-3 people at them. Next time: Stay on the pizza side of the menu, get the cheesesticks, which are AMAZING, and order to-go. read more

Fonta's Pizza - Pepperoni pizza rolls @ Fontas. Way too much oregano on top and the sauce was definitely gross. The rolls were great, though! - Pizza Near Me - Greeley, Colorado

I ordered spaghetti and added sausage and mushrooms. The base price is the spaghetti is really low but the added ingredients brought the price up. Still the meal was lower priced than had I home to some place like Perkin's. One drawback is that they could use a larger parking lot but it wasn't crowded when I went. read more

Not good at all. Pizza had a heavy meat sauce instead of marinara (menu said marinara), the dough was not cooked all the way, and everything tasted like salt, and my digestive system also expressed negative feedback. Would not recommend to anyone. read more

Came to Greeley to visit my sister and family. Haven't had much luck with restaurants in Greeley but really loved the pizza. The place was packed which is always a good sign about a restaurant. Definitely coming back! read more

Joke service, terrible food oh wait I wouldn't know because it never showed. Then when they for getting about you they are rude bitches. How about this maybe spend some time on the people in your restaurant and stop using to go orders as an excuse for your sorry pitiful customer service. Never again. read more

Best pizza in Northern Colorado. I've eaten here so many times and have never been disappointed. Love it!!!

Very Dirty, Unfriendly & Extremely Slow. Spent $130.00 and will never return. Staff was too busy socializing instead of taking care of customers. Didn't offer a drink while waiting. If I was back in management I would go chef Ramsey on this place! read more

This is a family owned restaurant. It's nothing fancy as far as decor or atmosphere but the pizza is pretty good and we've always had good, friendly service. read more

Pulling into the packed parking lot for a Saturday night dinner, we thought we might have to wait to be seated. Not the case; plenty of tables to accommodate large diners.. we were seated in minutes. Our plain 16" cheese pizza was delicious. Plenty of toppings available; can also order specialty pizzas from the menu. Service was excellent; our drinks were filled promptly by our waitress. Another staff member came by and asked us if our pizza was to our liking. Men's restroom was clean and attended to. We be back to dine here again.. plenty of other dishes on the menu to try out! read more

Well, my first stop in Greeley, Colorado for food was Fonta's. My bf's family lives in Greeley & boasted that this pizza is fantastic: they were oh so right! Fonta's is a small cozy restaurant with an old time pizzeria feel. On this particular Thursday evening, the restaurant was packed with children celebrating a sports victory. They were extremely loud & running all over the restaurant, but even that didn't phase us, as we were with family & the food was so great. Fonta's menu was much more than just pizza: fried zucchini, spanakopitas, wings, burgers, sandwiches, & chicken fingers. The pizza menu was extensive with a variety of specialties. We had the spanakopitas, fried zucchini (amazing!!), the house specialty pizza: beef, ham, sausage, green peppers, onions, & black & green olives & another pizza with pepperoni, sausage, & Canadian bacon. The pizza crust is thin, but a full thin: NY style. & Fonta's doesn't skimp on the toppings: each piece was slathered with every ingredient. & the sauce was wonderful with large tomatoes & a great flavor. The beer selection was smaller than I am used to, but for a small restaurant, pretty good with bud products, & sunshine. Our server was wonderful: checked on is multiple times & made sure everything was great. read more

Fonta's Pizza - Pizza boxes assembled & stacked near the entrance of Fonta's - Pizza Near Me - Greeley, Colorado

This was a good find for an easy night out. We had the Greek pizza, and a gyro. I didn't get any beer, but there appeared to be decent specials on a limited selection. There seems to be an overwhelming trend for smaller pizza joints in northern colorado...thin cracker-like crust for pizza. There was an option to get thick crust, but we opted to have the original to test it out. I'm not a fan of this type of crust, but it was ok. The sauce was decent and the cheese was nice an salty. The gyro was average, but still good. The tzatziki sauce tasted like 90% cucumber, but this is just because I prefer a more garlic and Mediterranean spiced tzatziki. The huge disappointment was the bathroom. I will go back to this place, but I refuse to use the bathroom again. $1500 would go a long way for this place to update their restrooms. My wife said there was a curtain to slide for privacy in the women's room, which would be difficult to wash regularly...so I'm assuming they don't. We really enjoyed this restaurant. The staff was friendly, the food was good, but we will make sure to stop at 7-11 to use their slightly cleaner bathrooms before we eat here again. read more

You can't go wrong with Fontas. Delicious pizza, spaghetti and garlic bread. This is what a pizza joint should be. Great customer service and excellent food. read more

Fonta's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Greeley, Colorado

See all

absolutely shitty service and the owners could care less they just yell at us saying "it's a shit show" first off, thats extremely embarrassing to even admit as a business owner but second, we arrived at 5:00pm and didn't eat until 7:45. waitress blamed her poor work on "fighting with her husband" like why would you even tell us that, don't bring your personal life to work babe. to add, i ordered a pizza and didn't even get a pizza they didn't offer to take it back they just made me eat it. if i could i would give 0 starts but i can't. read more

I went here for the first time for lunch and liked it a lot. Family owned and busy (meaning it's good) but there was not a long wait or slow service. Lunch special was a nice size pie (4 toppings) and a drink for 7.50. Great food quickly with full service and a pride point at or even lower than a fast casual. I dig it. You will too. read more