Fuego Pizza

We were in Fort Collins for vacation and were looking for pizza for dinner one night. Decide to…read moregive Totally 80s Pizza and Museum a try on a whim, and it was legit the best pizza I've ever had. I ordered the Rad Chicken Bacon and Garlic. They offer personal pizzas, so it's easy for everyone to get what they want and the personal pizzas were decent size. The toppings were fresh, the crust was crisp, and it was not soggy or greasy. They also serve Pepsi products which is something we look for when we go out to eat. I wish there was a Totally 80s Pizza where I'm from as we would be regulars if we were.

Food was great! Vibe was great! Will make a habit of driving from SE metro Denver to come here…read more Yeah, that good.

Wall Decor

Totally 80's Supreme Pizza

See all

Arcade/Store

The Corner Slice

4.5(42 reviews)

2.7 mi

We last minute wanted something before heading home. We had a little one and at 9:30pm a lot of…read moreplaces stopped serving food to accommodate the night life but again we had a little one. This place smelled so good from the side walk. They had great deals and a good variety. We want to go back and try more of the pizzas but the service was great and so was the atmosphere. I told my husband, it made want to go back to college and come chill there!

Really good pizza. Dough is crispy and thin but not too thin. Service was fast, and everyone was…read morefriendly. Pizza was cheap too!

A nice place. Where is everyone?

A slice of meatlovers (I like to always add some garlic powder and parm to my pizza).

See all

Peach blonde ale

Slyce Pizza

4.2(245 reviews)

2.6 mi

Josh is really awesome and we had the best afternoon and if we go over here because you could see…read moreoutside, you could see outside the window

Overall: 8/10 Pizza: 8/10…read moreAtmosphere: 8/10 Service: 8/10 Value: 8/10 Their NY Style pizza is about as good as it gets in Colorado. We just got cheese slices and they were great! Rated the pizza 8.1 on the OneBite app which is VERY good.

Pepperoni and sausage Burnt 12in pizza

See all

Postcard Pizza

4.7(27 reviews)

2.5 mi

Gluten free pizza was delicious, crust is great. Loved the pie with potatoes, the pie with fresh…read morebasil was a little too light on fresh green toppings for my taste, but my partner liked both pizzas. Be forewarned, the wait time was a little ridiculous when we went. They're popular as it is and I don't hold it against them. But be aware that 30+ minute wait may stretch closer to an hour if they're packed for a live show etc. still worth it and great vibe, but may not be the place if you just want a fast dash n go. They do not take phone orders so use the website if you want to place to-go orders ahead of time.

Are the photos not convincing enough?! The pizza is as delicious, no catfish here! The crust is…read moreamazing, the cheese and pepperoni used are incredible, and the garnish, the honey drizzle and the cheese are the cherry on top!

Buffalo chicken with hot honey.

See all

Menu

PizzaVino NoCo Italiano

4.4(222 reviews)

7.7 mi

Cute little Italian restaurant hidden away in a neighborhood. Party of 4, we walked in and were…read moreseating right away. We started with the Herbed Burrata, 1/2 Wedge Salad, and the Brussel Sprouts. The Burrata is a MUST order, for all future visits!!! For our entrees we ordered the Spicy Mushroom pizza, the Sausage & Mushroom pasta, and the Vodka Cream Fettuccine with Salmon. Sooo delicious! And our sweet waitress kept our drinks full the whole time.

Good food, good service, good place. Hot honey pizza was to die for! It was ssssooooo good…read more Combination of meat and hot honey drizzle was just a perfect pairing. Fettuccine alfredo is another to die for. Worth every garlic breath after meal. Canolli top off the night perfectly. Our server Kylie F was awesome, thank you Kylie. Come visit the place, you wont be dissapointed.

The kitchen

Ceasalad and bread.

See all

Cute entrance

JJ's Wood Fired Pizza

4.2(144 reviews)

3.3 mi

We've known about JJ's for years, finally stopped in and tried the pizza and wings - both were…read moregreat. JJ's nice casual place with quick service. We'll be back.

JJs pizza was very good! We had the Diavolo pizza and a pepperoni and black olive…read more The atmosphere inside is laid back and great. Tons of beer on tap. Plenty of TVs to watch sports games. Their caesar salad could use some work, but that's my only complaint. The food came fast and the pizza guys are very hard workers! JJ's is definitely worth the hype!

Modern and comfortable

Margherita with pepperoni

See all

The Margs!

Krazy Karl's Pizza

3.6(374 reviews)

2.5 mi

Chicken Bacon Ranch pizza was good but the deluxe pizza was atrocious and had no flavor. I would…read morecome again for the chicken bacon ranch but would never touch the deluxe again. Typical bar/pizza interior and service.

My sister raves about this joint, so when I was visiting, I suggested Krazy Karl's…read more The service was super slow, especially at an off time with little people in the place. The waitress seemed to not want to be there but was nice enough. North of the Border. A well cooked pizza with great ingredients. I was looking for it to be more spicy with the green chilies, but overall was really tasty and good.

New Beirhaus!

See all

The expansion came out great!

Beau Jo's - Fort Collins

3.3(346 reviews)

2.8 mi

The mountain pie was very good and our server was a friendly young woman. There is indoor and…read moreoutdoor seating but was too hot the day we went.

Good place for pizza but parking can be a challange. We got the sky hawk pizza and it has a kick…read more The crust is amazingly fluffy and topping were overflowed. Really good and tasty pizza. Green chile mac n cheese is one of a kind, some kick throughout, and strong cheese. Overall, a good place to visit. It was just a very llllooonngg wait.

See all

Pizza Casbah

3.6(270 reviews)

2.1 mi

4 stars for Colorado, but if I were back East, this would probably be a 3-star pizza spot…read more Pizza Casbah is solid and definitely scratches the itch, especially compared to a lot of the pizza around here. The slices are big, the crust has a decent chew, and overall it's satisfying--but coming from the East Coast, my pizza standards are unfortunately obnoxiously high. The sauce/crust/cheese ratio just doesn't quite hit that classic NY/NJ pizza level for me, and I wouldn't call it amazing pizza if I were rating it back home. But for Fort Collins? It's one of the better options I've found. So: Colorado rating. East Coast rating.

Simply the best slice in FOCO and pretty cheap. Just walk in and try it out, you will not be…read moredisappointed.

The Mobster: Meat lover's pie. Pepperoni, sausage, bacon, meatballs.

The Lunch Box Special: Giant slice of cheese with your choice of topping, 22 oz drink, and your choice of one side.

See all

Our twist on the Margarita Pie. Fire roasted tomato base, mozzarella, onion, freshly chopped basil

PizzaVino NoCo Italiano

4.6(41 reviews)

1.4 mi

Amazing pizza and salads!…read more I had the Pepperoni and added Hazel Dell Mushrooms! Incredible My wife had their Roasted Beet Salad and it was the best she has ever had. Our server, Ashley, provided us service that matched the incredible food. We will be back soon and be asking for Ashley.

Solid local Italian spot, would go back. No reservations, but you hop on the waitlist through the…read moreToast app, which gave us a real wait estimate and worked out perfectly. Seated quickly when we got there. The place was packed and the staff still managed to be attentive and friendly without rushing us. We ordered the Brussels sprouts for the table (good portion) and three of the 15" pizzas: Pepperoni, The Jimbo, and The Pesto. Plenty of food, went home with leftovers. The Pepperoni was the standout for me, rich flavor, the kind you keep going back for. Drinks were a strong point too: good wine and cocktail list, and while there's no full beer list, they had a decent IPA on hand. Vibe surprised me. For how busy it was, we never had to raise our voices to talk across the table. Indoor and outdoor seating, full bar, ample parking. Works for couples or a group dinner. Get the Pepperoni, grab a spot on the waitlist before you head over, and sit on the patio if the weather cooperates.

Things to do in Fort Collins

Bar interior with diners and TVs: Packed bar area, hockey on the screens

Brussell sprouts with fig and feta. Must get appetizer.

See all

Patio at dusk: String lights, heaters, plenty of outdoor seating

Fuego Pizza - pizza - Updated September 2026

Best of Fort Collins

People found Fuego Pizza by searching for…

People who viewed Fuego Pizza also viewed

Arte Pizzeria

4.5

(311 reviews)

We were in town visiting our adult kids and had the younger two with us, and my rule when traveling…read moreis simple: no chains. We wanted a good locally owned pizza place, and Arte Pizzeria fit the bill ... so well, in fact, that we went back a second night. The pizzas are handmade and really good, and the prices are fair. Everything came out fast both nights, which matters when you've got a 13-year-old and a 9-year-old at the table. But the thing my wife and I kept talking about afterward was the staff. It's mostly young people working there, and they were friendly, upbeat, and clearly invested in making the place feel welcoming. That kind of energy doesn't happen by accident ... somebody's running this place well. Great pizza, quick service, easy location, family-friendly. If you're in Loveland and want pizza from people who care about what they're making, this is the spot.

Amazing pizza, good prices, and friendly staff. Can't complain…read more Annoying for a pizza place where I am just picking up a pizza their default and lowest tip % is 15%, but a small gripe I suppose.

Slyce Pizza

4.2

(245 reviews)

Josh is really awesome and we had the best afternoon and if we go over here because you could see…read moreoutside, you could see outside the window

Overall: 8/10 Pizza: 8/10…read moreAtmosphere: 8/10 Service: 8/10 Value: 8/10 Their NY Style pizza is about as good as it gets in Colorado. We just got cheese slices and they were great! Rated the pizza 8.1 on the OneBite app which is VERY good.

Postcard Pizza

4.7

(27 reviews)

Gluten free pizza was delicious, crust is great. Loved the pie with potatoes, the pie with fresh…read morebasil was a little too light on fresh green toppings for my taste, but my partner liked both pizzas. Be forewarned, the wait time was a little ridiculous when we went. They're popular as it is and I don't hold it against them. But be aware that 30+ minute wait may stretch closer to an hour if they're packed for a live show etc. still worth it and great vibe, but may not be the place if you just want a fast dash n go. They do not take phone orders so use the website if you want to place to-go orders ahead of time.

Are the photos not convincing enough?! The pizza is as delicious, no catfish here! The crust is…read moreamazing, the cheese and pepperoni used are incredible, and the garnish, the honey drizzle and the cheese are the cherry on top!

Laporte Pizza

4.4

(57 reviews)

This place is genuinely a work of art, walked in got complimented, the aroma in there is just great…read morein general, saw a kid in a army hat slinging pizza dough, workers where super carful and washed hands after everything, workers where friendly and all hard working, gave us free burgs on the house, for teens making food this was amazing you can expect me back with friends.

I ordered a pizza and chicken tenders by phone, and they told me it would be ready in 20-30…read moreminutes. I arrived after 30 minutes, but then had to wait another 30 minutes! What a joke. To make matters worse, I saw an employee handling the chicken tenders without gloves. When I asked her to put on gloves, she said, "I washed my hands." That's completely unacceptable when handling ready-to-eat food. I asked for a full refund and left. Absolutely disgusted. I won't be back!

Justine's Pizza

4.4

(114 reviews)

Food- excellent pizza...qualifies as 'parlor' style pizza…read moreService - don't be surprised if if the owner stops by to greet you; very good Ambiance - comfortable and quieter than large dining rooms Try it out!

The pizza here has always been good until our last two visits (both within the past month)…read more There has been a change in the cheese and IMO not for the better. It had nice stretch but now it's more chewy. Harder to get a slice and it doesn't taste as good. The staff is always friendly but this doesn't make up for what I consider to be cheaper ingredients. It will be hard for us to give them another try.

Cozzola's Pizza

3.6

(52 reviews)

Love Cozzola's!! Best pizza in town! My go-to for years! Great thin crust and delicious topping.read more

In the late 1970's, I delivered pizza for Panhandler's mini-outlet on Mason Street and then, with…read moreoriginal recipes and iron skillets, it was the Best. Arrgh! New owners came and messed with the formula. I left for better pastures and heard some of the old staff wanted the magic back and made their own place in Ft Fun old town on Linden Street. They did the old shop some better!! Sauce, crust and cheese options. The 1st gourmet pizza in the area. I was happy. But after years on Linden, the building was sold to the 4+1 crowd. Had to move to digs away from my usual sphere and I missed them very much. Had a chance to drop in the spot off Harmony Rd and the magic is still there. Hope the old guys I knew are still involved.

Mama Roni's

3.5

(71 reviews)

The location off timberline and harmony was honestly a let down. It was my first experience and the…read moreentire lobby was packed full of kids and they were friends of most workers just hanging out and getting food. I noticed during 3 other guys the kids were being helped the most. Bro like how does a pizza take 30 minutes to make. It was my lunch break and it just sucks that it was wasted and also some kid working hanging out with others was saying "i dont care for this job" so he definitely was just hooking them up with all tons of food. Like i get it you mess up on orders but if your distracted by your friends and it takes 30 minutes and more to make 1 pizza and it was a medium. Im a manager at cinemark and i wont be coming back. Just wierd seeing teens cussing along with employees. Really sucks being the first time.. wish i could give 0 stars..

The food is great Delivery fee + Service fee + taxes and…read moretips = Way too expensive! I am 74 and occasionally like my order delivered.

Slice N' Roll

3.5

(53 reviews)

Me and my honey were out on a little date day and decided to stop into this pizza place when we got…read morehungry. The inside had a cool, divey vibe that we actually really liked, and the service was great from start to finish. I ordered the supreme pizza with green peppers, red peppers, sausage, pepperoni, olives, onions, and all the good stuff. They also had pepperoni and cheese slices already ready to go. The pizza itself was just okay for me -- I'd probably rate it around a 4/10. I think it would've been a lot better fresh out of the oven, so next time I'd definitely order it made fresh instead of ready-made slices. What really surprised me was the side salad with ranch. The vegetables were super fresh, the ranch was delicious, and honestly it ended up being my favorite part of the meal. Overall, even though the pizza wasn't my favorite, the atmosphere and service were good enough that I'd still come back and give it another try.

I do love a bar with a good taplist, full bar and pizza by the slice…read more This is a great place to grab a quick drink and pizza between activities in Downtown Loveland. We found it especially handy for a quick meal between shows during the Laugh Out Loveland Comedy Festival. They have classic slices like cheese, pepperoni and combo. They also have a creative slice of the day and customizable personal and full size pizzas. This is the kind of place that makes the pizzas and keeps the slices warm. They don't make a unique slice for each order (like Fat Sully's does). So, if you are picky about your toppings, be prepared to buy an entire pie.

Panhandler's Pizza

3.5

(68 reviews)

I can only speak for a GoldBelly order. The pizza arrived on time and instructions were easy to…read morefollow. I ordered the sampler which included: deluxe, begger, and pepperoni. The deluxe is the first pizza I baked and it was VERY GOOD. I loved the large sausage pieces and the crust was pretty good too. I will say if I am ever in the area I would definitely visit the restaurant. I figure if you can ship a pizza and it taste good, the in store version has to be just as good or better. I did place the other 2 in the freezer, so I will see how that goes once I decide to bake them.

This pizza was disappointing. Sausage was good but the dough was wet and yeasty. No cheese that I…read moresaw and the sauce was store bought vibes. Prices are fair 4.99 slice but nah.

Brick Oven Pizza

4.1

(65 reviews)