I have been going to Eaton Pizza for many years. It is a classic small town everyone in town eats here and everyone knows each other restaurant! I went there for lunch this week and enjoyed a great pizza with a good friend! If you don't live in Eaton it's worth the drive to enjoy a small town experience with fantastic food! read more

Every time I come up to Eaton, I always order a pizza Been here several times it's always been great. Highly recommended.

on March 6th, four of us women went Eaton Pizza to celebrate one of our birthdays. None of us had ever been there. It was one of the best experiences ever. The owner and his wife were fun and very personable. The food was great! The service was exceptional and we were treated to a sample of their homemade ice cream! If you haven't had it , It's a must try! our original choice of restaurant was closed and we found this place by chance. So glad the other place was closed! We laughed and had such a great time , even the owner joined in! If you want a very all around wonderful experience, please give it a try! Starr J. read more

Awesome pizza every time. Kids love the cinnamon sticks/bread for dessert. Always consistently good with generous toppings.

I ordered 4 large pizzas and a sandwich. The pizzas were amazing so much cheese the toppings were hidden. They fed 16 construction workers for lunch and there were no complaints. Then about 4 hours later because I had placed such a large order the owner called to make sure I was happy. My crew and I will be back!! read more

*Update* The owner called me and is buying our next meal from them. He apologized for how the kids who work for him handled it, they're in high school. I'm very impressed with the way the owner's handling it! Ordered online from their website. Selected the BBQ chicken sub and they gave us a small BBQ chicken pizza. Called them and they refused to do a refund or give us the item we paid for and ordered. Now my husband has to eat a small pizza for dinner that wouldn't even fill my child up. read more

Ordered a BBQ chicken sub...got a dinky small pizza instead. After contacting and telling about the mess up....no go. I still got the wrong food and just a small pizza. My hubby is hungry and has to suffer. ‍‍ read more

Just got home with a pizza from here. Most definately not a meat deluxe. No Canadian bacon or hamburger whatsoever. 20 dollars for a $10.50 cheese pizza with 50 cents worth of pepperoni and sausage. I was the only customer when I arrived, so they were not overwhelmed. It was also slightly undercooked. I've been here many times and have not had this experience until tonight. I hope the owners read this so the teens running the place pay more attention to the customers order. This place typically has good pizza. read more

Had problems in the past with orders arriving late, cold, or i had items missing. Decided to try them again after about 3 years and still the same problems. This time it was all of the above at the same time. The salad I ordered was missing and the wings were cold. Plus they tasted that bad that my dog wouldn't eat them. The pizza was still warm which is what confused me. I guess the wings must have been made the night before and left out overnight. It was also delivered about 40 minutes after the delivery time. Not worth money and obviously not worth the wait. read more

Worse pizza ever. Ordered two pies with different crust. Crust was the same. Two inches of crest before the cheese started. Took 2 hours to get from time of order. Pies were cold when delivered. Two stars because I got a refund and a lousy supper. read more

This locally owned business is awesome. They're friendly and provide great pizzas. Love ordering lunch from them.

New owners changed recipe on pizza and wings. No longer the best pizza around. Pizza sauce is sweet and the crust is not good.

The pizza is good. Crust is good. Sauce is good but both times we ordered there was so much cheese it was not good. My advice would be train your employees a lil better. You're probably losing money putting that much cheese on. read more

I ordered a turkey sub. Asked to have it heated and it came cold. Looked nothing like the picture on the ad. Pizza was greasy and had very little meat for the price. Was hoping it was better as we like supporting local businesses. read more

Good pizza, great for takeout/delivery. I wish CO had more basic pizza places like this!

They have the best pizza in town our go to favorite for sure, we have tried their wings, pizzas and bread sticks it's always good and always on time I would recommend it to anyone read more

Impressive , we had a cheese pizza ,great sauce, good cheese ,dough was perfect...AND A REAL PIZZA OVEN..not made on a conveyor belt oven (dominoes..papa johns ect..) There should be more pizza joints like this one in the world. read more

What Eaton Pizza lacks in ambiance it more than makes up for in great service and even better food. As a pizza lover, I look for a pie that is not greasy or doughy or crispy with just the right amount of sauce and this is just that. A lesser known fact is that you can save money by ordering and baking at home. read more

The pizza was ok I guess. Took twice as long as they said it would, so we had to wait over 20 minutes once we got there to pick it up, and it was pretty soggy. They have wings on the menu, but don't mention that they are BBQ wings when you order. Most people assume hot wings, but the employee said they don't even have hot wing sauce. Probably won't order again. read more

We have been relocated from South Carolina and we found this pizza place from the hotel we stayed in and the Pizza is amazing and the staff is very friendly! The price is great! I definitely recommend to everyone I know!! read more

We ordered tonight after a chicken disaster at home. Pizza was pretty good but really greasy. Kids liked it.

A hole in the wall. The two kids working don't understand proper hand washing. And the girl was wearing flip flops. Pretty sure those two things are frowned upon in the food industry. An ice bucked was used for for the ice in the ice water we asked for and filled in the disgusting sink that the girl even said stunk. First time there and I'll never go back! read more

They have amazing gluten free pizza. We can't get enough!!!!

2 Large Pizzas 15$. Wow incredible. Simple yet amazing at the same time. Always consistent and topping are always fresh. This place is really a hidden gem in Noco. If I lived closer this would be my go to spot for pies. Go Reds! read more

The pizza is really good, but it depends on who is cooking....sometimes it's not worth the price....

This isn't the best pizza you'll ever have, but I like it better than a pizza chain. They're always fast to deliver, and the delivery boys are nice and respectful. Would recommend. read more

First off I want to say that I greatly appreciate your staff and the convenience of your location. We normally order pizza and wings on game day but I recently ordered a side salad and an Italian Sub. Let me tell you something, receiving a fresh made salad instead of one that's pre-made and stuffed into a fridge to me says a lot about how they take care of their customers, and the Italian Sub is something I will order more often. And the staff, you can't get any friendlier than small town USA, and as we all know how the staff treats us will depend on if we go back. So i'll leave you with this, no matter what time of day you go in, they are always happy to see you and you get great quality food for a great price! read more

New to town and was happy to find pizza delivery. The young man who answered the phone was extremely courteous as was the delivery boy. Good customer service is hard to come by these days. Pizza was good. Someone said this place is a "hole in the wall" which, in my opinion always has the best food. Pricing is fair. We will order often. read more