JJs pizza was very good! We had the Diavolo pizza and a pepperoni and black olive. The atmosphere inside is laid back and great. Tons of beer on tap. Plenty of TVs to watch sports games. Their caesar salad could use some work, but that's my only complaint. The food came fast and the pizza guys are very hard workers! JJ's is definitely worth the hype! read more

JJ's Wood Fired Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

You wouldn't think it, but Fort Collins' best pizza is in a gas station. Ok, that's only partially true. JJ's is a gas station and a liquor store and a car wash but the pizza restaurant is its own animal. While it is in the same building and shares a name, the interior is modern and nice and not at all reminiscent of a gas station. They offer a variety of Italian items, some salads and a bunch of beer. I get the traditional Margherita pizza and add pepperoni each time I go. It never disappoints. Crust is good with some flop but not too much. The sauce is mildly sweet and tangy. The cheese is excellent. Overall, on the scale of great pizza, this is a 7 which is definitely near the top for Colorado. On a scale of Colorado restaurant, it is a 9/10. I love this pizza and will continue to return. They are always friendly and fast. I will be back. read more

JJ's Wood Fired Pizza - Modern and comfortable - Pizza Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

See all

I love this pizza. What I don't love are the teenage girls coming in with their butts hanging out of their bathing suits. I am so tired of thongs. I wish jj's would have some sort of a dress code. What happened to no shirt no service? It should read no shorts no service. I don't need their asses in my face the whole time. Young children are in there with their families. Come on girls have some respect for yourselves. read more

We've known about JJ's for years, finally stopped in and tried the pizza and wings - both were great. JJ's nice casual place with quick service. We'll be back. read more

For about $16 I got a pizza that weighed a pound at most. The slices were tiny, the cheese and toppings almost non-existent. A "large" feeds about half a hungry teenager. The flavor was adequate, but hard to discern amid the nothingness. The JJs convenience store offers a half gallon of milk marked $6.39 in the case...but I was charged $7.79 at the register. I pointed it out and was told that the difference was tax. (Colorado does not tax food for home consumption and Fort Collins charges only 2.5%). And the gasoline costs $2.79 per gallon while most other stations cost $2.19. All true facts. read more

Bro if you're looking for the city's best pizza and live in Southern FoCi and Northern Loveland, COME TO JJ'S! Best pizza in NoCo

Note that this is in a gas station area, so don't be surprised. Also, you walk in, and you order at the counter. They give you a buzzer for your pizza. They actually brought it out to us, which I assume is because it wasn't as busy or why the buzzer. I got a gluten-free lasagna as the meatballs are 100% beef. My hubby got Marco's pizza. Mine was ever cooked for my liking. His looked great. It was recommended by a local, and I'm glad we tried it. The gluten-free crust was good. read more

JJ's Wood Fired Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

See all

The pizza was great! Thin, crisp ( but not cracker like) and had that charred flavor that only comes from a wood fired oven. We ordered the meatballs and salad as an appetizer- both were really good. The service was good. The person taking the order was helpful and very friendly. The only place that falls down a bit here is the ambiance. This is at a convenience store/ gas station. It's a "order at the counter" type place, then go find your silverware and a place to sit. It's PACKED at 5pm on a Saturday, so everyone knows the food is good. The pizza quality and that massive oven from Naples DESERVE to be in a place where you can sit and order, have a bottle of wine, and really savor. If I was local I'd pick up pizza to go often. read more

Came here after a hike and it was pretty damn good. I hadn't had much water or food so the one beer I had there made have made me inebriated enough to enjoy a fried turd but the wood fired pizza was amazing. Pretty good priced, nice place with good service and alcohol (obliviously lol) and It isn't full service so I don't feel obligated to tip a bunch so thats a plus too read more

Pizza is good. But be forewarned...they do not secure Door Dash orders. So easily opened and toppings for the taking. Someone told me long ago that during college that's how they ate. Toppings off of pizza deliveries. How much can a security sticker cost? Ugh read more

I was in the area for a couple of days, and just yelped local places! And oh I'm so happy I did! If you read the past reviews you will hear to not be skeptical of the location, I 100% validate that! Do not miss on this place based on location! chicken BBQ pizza was great. The crust just tasted Fresh and ingredients tasted fresh! Prices were very fair and reasonable. Customer service was 5*, the employees were kind, friendly and attentive. This is a very casual place, not fancy at all, the environment is super relaxed! Be sure to try the margarita's!! read more

JJ's Wood Fired Pizza - The Margs! - Pizza Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

We've lived in Fort Collins for nearly 8 years. How did we never hear about JJ's Wood Fired Pizza. Perhaps because it is tucked away in the middle of nowhere SW Fort Collins at Taft and Harmony in a gas station truck stop. Really I have to thank Fort Collins' first Yelp CM Becki K for the recommendation/glowing review she wrote. I was 3 minutes late coming down for dinner...and the picture says it all. Not only does the camera not get to eat first, but clearly neither does the Yelper. I managed to fight for a few morsels and WOW! Super good. We ordered 3 types of wings (good but pricey at $1/wing). Not sure what all the flavors were but all were great. Comes with a generous tub of ranch. We also ordered a pint of 4 large meatballs with tomato sauce. Really excellent. We also had a small order of focaccia bread, which must have been good because I didn't get any. And then we got 2 12" pizzas (only one size option), a margherita and a meat lover. The family thinks this is their favorite pizza in town now. Total $35+tip. We would likely order the same items again. Not a bad value for a family of 4 including 2 hungry teenage boys. read more

JJ's Wood Fired Pizza - Yelp Big Night In - Pizza Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

As you drive down Taft Hill, you have the silhouette of Horsetooth Mountain towering over the town, and a little gas station packed with RVs that's hiding a secret. As much as I'd like to keep this secret, the world needs to know - JJ's Wood Fired Pizza is the best wood fired pizza I have ever consumed in my life! We waltzed in one day on a whim and sat at the bar. They have an extensive, and very fairly priced (especially at happy hour) tap list, wine offerings, frozen margaritas and sangria. The bartender quickly got us some cold Odell IPAs in gigantic icy mugs to sip on as we perused the menu. While it took us forever to decide, we finally settled on splitting two - the Hawaiian and Adamo's (named after the owners' son). We waited for only five minutes and were presented with perfectly cooked pizzas. The crust was thin and crispy throughout, the toppings piping hot... Then we dove in. Adamo's is topped with fresh ricotta, Italian sausage and pepperoni and has a nice kick to it. The Hawaiian was balanced with sweetness from the pineapple and salty bite from the mozzarella. We devoured each within minutes while chatting with the wonderful staff and neighbors at the bar. Keep in mind, they don't do floor service, so if you feel the need to be waited on the bar is the place to be, and the service there is incredible! We've been back many, many times and don't plan to stop this streak anytime soon - especially since they're still offering takeout during this time of craziness the world is going through. read more

JJ's Wood Fired Pizza - Hawaiian pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

See all

We picked JJ's based on the reviews and drove up from Loveland where we were staying. We almost didn't stop because it looked like a restaurant in a gas station - but luckily we pulled in anyway. The restaurant was nice, and had a very inviting patio. The staff was welcoming and accommodating. We ordered a pepperoni pizza and garlic bread. The pizza was cooked to perfection and the seasoning on the garlic bread was amazing. This was certainly worth the drive! read more

Totally didn't know what to expect...between a gas station and liquor store... looked pretty sketchy! But was I wrong...great beer, really good think crust pizza...and love the crust! Ordered a pitcher of a hazy IPA and two pizza - bbq and spicy pepperoni (forget what they called it) - we should have split because it was way too much for the both of us. Highly recommend read more

Super efficient systems in place here. I love the limited service approach. The restaurant was very well set up and also very clean. You scan the menu on your phone and order at the counter. We got a salad that you can grab from a case. We are our salad while we waited for the food. It was very fast! Ordered the Caesar salad, homemade meatballs, and the Adamo pizza. The salad was delicious although it's hard to mess up Caesar salad. The homemade meatballs came with a bunch of sauce and focaccia. The sauce was super flavorful and so was the focaccia. The meatballs were tasty but nothing to rave about. The adamo pizza was very tasty! I loved the crust, it was so flavorful and very well cooked. Great little pockets of cheese and then pepperoni and sausage. The staff here were very polite and they were BUSY. Wonderful experience and will definitely be back! read more

See all

Surprised by the menu offerings and the quality of the food. Fast casual atmosphere and friendly service. Food was prepared quickly and delicious. We will be back. read more

Jj's wood fire pizza, good pizza - but not too memorable it was just pizza at the end of the day. Still on the hunt for some true New York style east coast pizza, thin crust, sweet sauce! The journey continues Fort Collins! Another great local business to support, prices might be inflated due to proximity to Horsetooth reservoir. Pizza is a hard review everyone likes it different this one just not my cup of tea! If the pic looks good, go for it! Crust was to die for! Me lady didn't like the crust tho... read more

JJ's Wood Fired Pizza - Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

Stopped in today for lunch and we're glad we did! Simple, casual vibe and atmosphere. Friendly staff, pizza was really good, good selection of beer and drinks. I would recommend! read more

Perfect for yourself, a date, or the family and friends !! Convenient to Horsetooth Reservoir or the perfect destination to enjoy their amazing wood fired pizza and other fantastic offerings. read more

Wow, no wonder fellow locals rave about this little joint! Delicious, wood fired pizzas and salads and deserts and apps and drinks... great service and suggestions, delicious mixed up margaritas slushees... highly recommended! read more

Gas station pizza... that's what I always thought. Boy was I wrong JJs is now our preferred pizza joint. It's all about the crust and fresh toppings. They nail it everytime. My only wish is they did fresh salads instead of pre prepped in a tin. Maybe one day read more

JJ's Wood Fired Pizza is located in the JJ Plaza. Don't know who JJ is but they've covered all their bases from a gas station to a liquor store to this pizza place. Given the vibe from the outside you'd think the pizza place might be a little rough, but, once you enter, it does have the surprising feel of a clean, well-maintained neighborhood pizza place. There are many pizza options on their menu or you can create your own with toppings as I did. A pizza with choice of cheese, sauce, and two toppings ends up being $10.99. Pizzas are all the same size and probably could be comparable to medium pizzas at the average pizza restaurant. The pizza was enjoyable. I appreciated the wide variety of vegetable options in toppings including capers which are growing as a new favorite pizza topping for me. Ultimately, if in the mood again, I'd come back to JJ's and certainly if around that area and looking for pizza. read more

Don't let the location fool you. I honestly thought this was a typical gas station pizza, until my husband paid them a visit. So good, nothing like camping and eat a wood fired pizza outdoors. Must try! They are also the local's favorite pizza joint. read more

JJ's Wood Fired Pizza - Mmmm so good! - Pizza Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

See all

Best pizza!!! Great menu if you're in the mood for wood fired oven pizza (which is hard to find out here vs out East). I like the lively atmosphere as well, they have a bar area with decent beer on tap and wine. Nothing super fancy but good for a date night if everyone's in the mood for some good quality pizza. read more

Pizza and hospitality was amazing, our order was ready within 5 minutes and they were pretty busy. Tables were nice and clean and I really like the ambience of the building. Margarita pizza was a solid 8.5/10. Thanks for having us !!!! Off to Los Angeles. Highly recommend. read more

JJ's Wood Fired Pizza - Margarita Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

See all

For being part of the entire JJ's Corner empire, between a liquor store and a gas station you wouldn't expect much, but the pizza is fantastic! Salads are great too! We haven't eaten inside, we always grab it to go on our way to Horsetooth. It's our go to when we don't feel like grilling on our pontoon boat! read more

Super busy on a Friday night and the staff did really well keeping up with getting everyone served and tables cleared. Really good job on that. But pizza sauce was flavorless and not impressive. It literally just tasted like cheese and dough. Dough was chewy and delicious but everything else was disappointing read more

Excellent wood-fired pizza. Our vote for best in Fort Collins. Dine in or take out, this place is the bomb. The hard part is deciding what to choose. read more

We moved to FC from San Francisco not long ago and one of the foods I have missed most is the popular Napoli-style pizza served at places like Pizzeria Delfina. I'd given up hope finding it and settled for thicker crusts and too many chili flakes, until we stumbled across JJ's! Their I'd rank their Dimatteo pizza with the best of San Francisco - thin, perfectly cooked crust and fresh toppings with just the right amount of sauce. Thanks, JJ's for making me feel a little more at home in Fort Collins! read more

I come here after Stand-Up-Paddleboarding the Horsetooth Reservoir everytime! You would never expect the quality they offer from a random pizza place next to a gas station. They actually have a classic wood fired pizza oven from Napoli! This place is legit! The DiMatteo is my favorite and is always super fresh. read more

Hands down the best pizza I have ever had. Lived all over the country and you can't beat it. The bar is awesome as well. Go here once a week at minimum. read more

Hands-down the best pizza in Fort Collins. This place is kind of small and it's a hole in the wall, stuffed somewhere in between the surrounding gas station/liquor store/corner store. My go-to order is a large pie with a mozzarella sticks app. It picks me up so quick if I'm in a bad mood. Also available here: beer growlers, a bar, beer on tap, multiple televisions, indoor and outdoor seating, an ENORMOUS wood-fire pizza oven that makes the place smell amazing. Staff is always very friendly, and everything is always very clean. read more

Cant review the food as no one acknowledged our presence so we could ordered. But as far as service-CRAPpy

This place used to be great when there was table service. Now we have to keep getting up through the meal for drinks, to clean the table, get to go boxes, etc. It's no longer the relaxing place it used to be. We went twice after they stopped table service and haven't gone back since. It's sad because we used to frequent before. read more

Such a great little hidden gem with an authentic Italian wood fire pizza stove. After a day on the lake or shredding dirt bikes, I love coming here to wash my boat or dirt bike with the wash next door and then have a delicious pizzas with friends. Everything is good! read more

The southwest side of Fort Collins this. The outside needs a little work to look inviting - like flowers but it SNOWED yesterday. Too early. However the inside is beautiful and welcoming! Cute and modern with the pizza oven adding color and function. I am a bit of a pizza snob and these guys hit it on the mark. Crisp, delicious toppings. Really very good. Thanks Madi for the outstanding service. Will be back! Well, we are so very happy you reopened! We missed you guys. The pizza is still excellent and we are happy you are open for lunch more. But the fast casual, serve yourself is just sad. We LOVED the excellent service and atmosphere before. It felt like a great, community restaurant which we sorely need on the west side. But with the 'walk up and order, you have taken a huge step backwards. Please reconsider. We love to patronize this business, but you've made it hard now. read more

Don't let the outside fool you, this place is great! We ordered 3 pizzas and all of them were great, will be back again.

Best pizza in Fort Collins. Eat it there--it doesn't hold up to take out. Which is fine, that's just how wood fired pizza is meant to be enjoyed. read more

Went there twice and never disappoints. Ordered online and each time the order was ready. The staff is great. No matter how busy they are, they take the time to help you out. read more