I read a review on here that said domino's or round table or some other chain was far better. I sort of laughed, but after trying this place out, I totally get their comment now. For the price they charge, it's a joke. Outrageous pricing for C+ food. Lacked flavor. Ordered pick up. Guy is just standing there talking on the phone then after a solid minute, decides to help me while he's still on the phone in a very "first gear, care free" speed. Employees seemed stoked to be there I noticed. Finding my order was a chore for Mr. 1st Gear although the place was dead. Now I know why. Pass on this one. There are other options for C+ and above pizza that cost less. This location is trying to prey on Serrano area money. read more

We were getting tired of paying a lot for pizza on door dash so decided to try this place right around the corner from us. It's really easy to order on the app and they have a lot of customization options for toppings. We got a large pepperoni and a small mushroom and onion, I was able to get extra pepperoni and mushrooms and it was perfect. I ordered for pickup in advance and it was ready when my husband came in. The pizza was good and we enjoyed it for lunch. Sauce was tasty. I would say it was a little undercooked, it actually was much better for me the second day when I popped it in the air fryer. But it was convenient and easy to order and we will be back. read more

Formaggio Pizza Express - Large Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - El Dorado Hills, California

See all

I finally had time to check out the pizza at Formaggio on Bass Lake. OMGOSH! What a pleasant surprise and experience!! I chose the calzone. The dough is amazing! The ingredients are amazing! The service is excellent! I even told the owner (whose name escapes me right now) that this pizza sauce is better than mine.... It was delicious through the last bite! I'm looking forward to the next time ‼ read more

Really really good employees. The store is nice and cool and it's very clean. The pizza is also so damn good. I definitely recommend it's the best place read more

Formaggio Pizza Express - Pizza Near Me - El Dorado Hills, California

I LOVE the Armenian Pizza! I think I can eat it everyday. I know this place is a franchise so speaking for only the place in El Dorado Hills, the pizza is fantastic and the people are super friendly. read more

My husband and I love to come here for the lunch special! The food, service and atmosphere is truly a treat. The main guy even gave me a drink. We will continue to recommend this spot. read more

Formaggio Pizza Express - Lunch special: one topping - Pizza Near Me - El Dorado Hills, California

If you love Formaggio Pizza Express as much as I do, you will love their new second location on Bass Lake Road in El Dorado Hills. Formaggio has become my favorite pizza place because the sauce is so delicious, the toppings are fresh, and the seasonings are just right. And it is all homemade... nothing out of a can or jar. Ever! I actually know a couple of the secret seasonings used. But if I told you I would have to kill you :-). The owners of Formaggio Pizza Express are stand-up guys who want to provide the best experience with their food offerings and wonderful, friendly, personal customer service. Some of the best customer service I have ever received. Yesterday was the opening of the new location. Can you say lights, camera, action! There were plenty of Italian "eats" coming out of the ovens and many people enjoying it all. And believe me, there are even more food items available in addition to the signature pizzas. And even some reflecting their Armenian heritage. Can you say yum! It is definitely worth a trip to check out their new endeavor and bigger space for Formaggio Pizza Express. We die-hard fans of Formaggio know how fantastic it is. The best in El Dorado Hills and beyond! Yelp friends Joe Y. and Lillian W.,....... you are going to love this new Formaggio Pizza Express location! Congratulations, Steve, Jack, and George! I know all your food is made with love. read more

Formaggio Pizza Express - Pizza Near Me - El Dorado Hills, California

I ordered one of their Margerita Pizzas on line and requested a specific time for the delivery. They actually showed up 3 minutes early and their pizza, in my opinion, was one of the best pizzas I've ever had. read more

Excellent customer service, friendly smiling staff, and excellent food! The place is small and mainly for takeout, but they do have some seating. I think it may be seats about a dozen give or take. The sauce choices are excellent, they have vegan cheese options, the dough is vegan, and even fries. I enjoy going there for dining as they don't play loud music if any music at all so it's very nice and quiet. and a nice location, but close to the freeway. Oh, the very best part is they have calzones done right! (Soft dough , not overdone, large enough if you're hungry or want left overs, braided edge and wrapped in foil if to-go to stay warm) read more

Formaggio Pizza Express - Vegan Calzone - Pizza Near Me - El Dorado Hills, California

Best pizza in El Dorado Hills. Fresh ingredients and always tasty! Service is always so fantastic! I highly recommend!

Fortunately this place opened very close to our home. The pizza is outstanding and the service is also excellent. We have only ordered pizza for delivery, but it always arrives on time and hot. Our favorite pizza is the Armenian Combo, which is very spicy and unusual. Every pizza we have ordered was cooked perfectly and was exactly as described on their menu. I highly recommend this place. read more

The best. If you want a pizza place the best hole family loves and is quick. Come here!

First time take out customers. Ordered 1/2 & 1/2 pizza... it was all good pizza as well as the honey garlic chicken wings - wife loved them! Everything was at a perfect level of doneness, not overcooked nor undercooked! PS: George - thanks for taking my order! GOOD JOB! read more

The food was amazing and delicious and the owner was friendly. Great service. I will be back for more!

The tastiest pizza around!!! Thank you Steve and family for another perfectly cooked thin crust pizza. read more

Formaggio Pizza Express - Large Thin Crust Half Cheese, Half Cheese with Suasage - Pizza Near Me - El Dorado Hills, California

First time ordering at Formaggio's. The few places available in the town I live are pretty mid. Was looking for something great that I hadn't tried before. Ordered a delivery order of 2 Large pizzas. The Bianaca that had a white sauce, and the Formaggio Combo which has red sauce. Delivery arrived in under 20mins of placing the order. The pizzas were fully loaded with meat and toppings. Everything tasted fresh and delicious. The crust was very delightful as well. The pizzas was perfectly cooked, and flavors on point! Next time we will try the Margherita and the Armenian Combo. Thank you Formaggio for exceptional service and food! -Jen read more

Ordered from here for the first time. Pizza was basic at best. Not a lot of flavor & a lil dry. Also got an upset stomach after eating it. Won't be back. Hope to find a wood fired pizza place. read more

Great pizza and great wings! New location great and friendly service. Prices worth the buy. Custom orders are welcomed!

I had a vegetarian pizza with cauliflower crust..The Pizza was excellent.. they made it special for me..the service was amazing and they are helpful and pleasant. We'll go there again for sure read more

Very average pizza and well above average price. There was very little sauce on the pizza and it wasn't anything special. They barely Compare to the better pizza places like Pizza Factory, Round Table, Pizza Guys, etc. For what they charge we were disappointed and won't be back. read more

I picked the order to go here Great service great food and lots of toppings but the dough is little chewy cut down a better job on that. All experience is great and the staff is very friendly thank you. read more

Super Good!!! We ordered a little of EveryThing and it was also good! Great Service from the moment we walked in the door and a small outdoor dining area where our super good pizza (1/2 chicken club, 1/2 Armenian Special) which was perfect. The calzone was soo good with a perfect crust. Not too thick or heavy. Seasoned to perfection. The Mediterranean Salad will a good size for us to share! I will definitely be back! read more

ive eaten here a lot and its consistently delicious. Cooks are really nice, good service.

Was looking forward to trying their lunch slice pizza since they took the time to mail me an ad/coupon; however, when I got there no slices available, was told "no slices today" :( read more

we recently moved to the area and so delighted to have such a treasure in our neighborhood . The Formaggio pizza express located on Bass Lake road offers the BEST pizza in town .The place is clean , modern inviting extremely friendly and professional.Five stars is not enough I am giving them all the stars from the sky. Thank you for the best and fast service , great food no wonder customers are driving from far away to enjoy their food. read more

Loved it... had their classic veggie specialty pizza and it was great. We'll be back. Welcome to the neighborhood! read more

We ordered two pizzas for pickup. The Formaggio Combo and a pepperoni Both were delicious, fresh and the combo was loaded with toppings. We will definitely make this our regular place to order. Do you ever put out coupons or have a rewards system for returning customers? read more

Love the customer service and quality. Last night I ordered plain pizza dough to make pizza at home. The staff was friendly, helpful, and even gave me cooking tips. Love our local independent shops. read more

First off let me start by saying this pizzeria is one of the best I have been to for several reasons. Usually I would start a review talking about the food however the first thing that struck me was the extreme high level of hospitality. The owner was very involved with all the customers that were coming there for orders. This place is a tradition based pizza with family recipes that will pleasantly surprise you with the delicious savory food they offer here. It is very clean and has outside sitting to eat there. They even have homemade ranch!!! Be sure to check out both locations read more

Formaggio Pizza Express - Pepperoni pizza (best I've ever had) - Pizza Near Me - El Dorado Hills, California

See all

Fresh flavor, friendly folk! I drove 35 minutes to pick up a vegan pizza for my son today, his 29th Birthday. He is a selective eater, and he said it tastes good... He likes it! Yeah!! I am glad to have found a pizza take-out place that has quality ingredients and includes an option with vegan cheese; pizza with no cheese is quite dry and not much fun... So, I am super happy with this location, quality, and online ordering platform. Awesomeness! read more

Food was excellant. Fresh and hot. Great service too. Helpful and gave excellent recommendations. Would definitely eat here again. Got the poppers, Italian combo and Californian pizzas. read more

Best pizza around!! Good price and friendly staff. Always on time and great quality. Fresh ingredients good sauce!!

Great pizza and service. This place hits the spot every time, that's why it's our go to pizza spot when the family needs a quick dinner fix.

We love this place! We discovered the location in El Dorado Hills first - but it was a little far to drive. We were thrilled when they opened a location a few miles from our house. Best pizza in town - hands down. The staff is always friendly and helpful. read more

05/17/2024// We love this business. The pizza is delicious. The owners are super personable and professional. The store is clean and the service is excellent. Highly recommend. read more

Pizza is terrible. All preprocessed. I got the Formaggio combo, yuk! $24.66 for medium size, A lot of money to waste on bad pizza.

The pizza was good and close to home very convenient for take out. I loved the sauce they use

First time here/ for takeout. Wanted to weigh in that the gluten free crust was very good. I've had a gluten sensitivity for 10+ years, so have tried a lot of gf crusts and this one stands out well. Not too chewy, not too crisp. That said, pricing seemed a little high, $24ish for gluten free Margherita pizza. Was able to order online easily and pick up time estimated was pretty spot on, just had to wait couple mins at the store for the order. read more

The pizza is amazing Ive ordered veggie( all kinds of veggies no skimping here) n meat lovers ( the sausage n pepperoni n salami are outstanding in taste n flavour) n like I mentioned before only quality ingredients. Their pizza is way better then the more expensive ones Ive bought elsewhere ( not mentioning any names)! The service is always upbeat n friendly n the ambiance of pizza cooking delights my Yes it's that damn good better than homemade. You are missing out if you have t tried this place trust me you will be back read more

Pizza was good. Grabbed 2 slices during lunch. Super helpful that it was fast. I was able to eat the pizza easily in the car. Crust wasn't floppy and the toppings stayed on with each bite. I'll try again read more