Four days before Easter and yes, the line was long. Everyone getting candy for their family and…read morechildren's Easter baskets. I walked around and didn't notice any plant based, allergy free options but that doesn't mean there aren't any, I just didn't see any as I made my walk through. What I did notice is that chocolate is ridiculously expensive and with all that I've learned about chocolate, I can't help but wonder if it's even chocolate. I didn't ask either... all I know for sure is that everyone says this place has the best chocolate in town so I'm here buying a few basket stuffers. Before coming here, I stopped at Fowler Chocolates around the corner and no one was there so this place must be the place to buy chocolate. I watched the ladies at the registers ask everyone before me if they were rewards members and when they said no, they asked if they'd like to be. They forgot to ask me though. I overheard someone say it was 10 percent off today, must've been for members only, I didn't get a discount. I will be enjoying my dark chocolate tonight though, thank you Wahl's.

Stopped in here for the famous Loganberry Sponge Candy, a Buffalo favorite. The staff were very…read morenice and friendly on this visit. I even got to try a sample of the peanut butter sponge clusters before purchasing which was great. The loganberry sponge is good but it tastes more like a raspberry to me than the traditional loganberry. It was still good and their sponge candy is some of the best I've ever had. It's perfectly sliced and covered on every corner so there are no dry spots. Very good production on the candy pieces.

Such a cute hidden gem ! I absolutely loved the ambiance . It felt like going back to my childhood…read moreat an ice cream parlor. The walls are covered with stuffed animals you can purchase which is also very cute . The chocolate is good and well priced ! The service was also friendly and helpful !

Best hot fudge sundae hands down! Homemade ice cream, unbelievable homemade whipped cream and the…read morebest homemade hot fudge there is! Great candy shop atmosphere. Great people providing great service and fair prices. Tons of parking too!

Came in town for business but was not leaving without some delicious Watson's Sponge Candy. Shannon…read morewas the best!! So glad we stopped and met her at this location.

Well first off, the good stuff... I went into this store and I have to say that the selection is…read moreincredible, the store was super clean and everything was laid out beautifully in the display cases and around the store itself. The lady behind the counter was super polite and very helpful with my selections. I typically do my chocolate shopping at one of the competitors stores however I thought I would try Watson's chocolate and my first impression was very high. One of the items I purchased was orange sponge candy and she had a little concern that maybe some of it wasn't up to the high standards that they try to abide by so she asked if you check the box first. She explained that during the summer time sometimes sponge candy doesn't survive the trip for too long so no problem I said she gloved up and checked all of them, found a couple that weren't passing her quality control standards so she replaced them. I took that box and a couple of other selections, paid and left. One of the other items I tried was fudge meltaway which I had never actually had before. Personally my wife and I didn't care for it however that is probably just our personal palate coming into play as I'm quite certain it wasn't prepared improperly or anything. The coconut patties were very good and the orange sponge candy honestly some of it was kind of chewy. The fact that she had some concern over the quality of this and felt the need to check it kind of threw up a little bit of a red flag for me and after getting it home and having some I'd have to say I'm a little disappointed. I'm not by any means a connoisseur of sponge candy or anything however if what she said was true about it staying fresh during the summer months and obviously she had some concern that it may not have been, why wouldn't you just pull all of it off the shelf and make more? I mean I used to manage a restaurant and it's the same idea in my opinion, if you're not happy with the food going out, don't send it. I would rather have purchased just milk chocolate sponge candy and been reassured that they didn't have orange because it failed their quality check. So I took one star off what would have been a five star review for that reason, the other one I took off because I couldn't find the building. If you approach this location from the side that I did, the side that faces a little strip mall with a good sized parking lot, there is no signage of any kind anywhere that says hey this is a store that sells chocolate. It just looks like a house sitting on a separate property off to the side. My GPS said I was there, I'm driving around the parking lot for 5 minutes looking at all of the store fronts trying to find Watson's chocolate, and it doesn't exist. I finally put my GPS on walking directions and found myself approaching like I said what looked like somebody's big old house... And I didn't even feel comfortable doing that until I got about 6 ft from the door where there's a sheet of paper sized sign that says Watson's chocolate and has the hours posted. I mean seriously something that could be seen from the road would have been nice, something that could have been seen from the parking lot would have been even better. Apparently if you approached this from the other direction there's a great big sign so I would have had to have driven past it not realizing it and did a u-turn and then I would have said oh there it is. The lady working inside like I said was very super polite and I suggested that to her and she kind of looked at me and said the owners are aware of it but they haven't done anything about it yet. I'm guessing nobody local has a problem because yeah they probably know where this place is however I live over 3 hours away and didn't have a clue. So yeah I'm kind of mixed as far as my opinion of the actual chocolate, I might go back and try a couple other selections and see how they taste. If I do I will try a different sponge candy, maybe one that sells more often so the stock is rotated more often.

I have not been to the physical store location. It's too far from New York City for me to go. I did…read morehowever receive a gift in the mail that was purchased by my boyfriend and everything was so great. Their chocolate is decadent and the peanut brittle is quite amazing.

My wife was craving some sweets, and this popped right up on a search, it was close to where we…read morewere, so easy decision. When you enter, if you take a left you end up in the Candy Shop, and if you take a right you end up at the Ice Cream Shop. We did a quick pass through of the Candy shop, they have quite the selection, and the lady who was working at the time was incredibly friendly. The candy itself seemed to be a bit on the pricy side for what it was. On to the Ice Cream shop! They had quite a decent selection of flavors, and the day happened to be buy 1 get 1 free Pie slice day, so that is what we did. We went for once slice of the Apple Pie, and one Slice of the Peanut Butter Pie, to share. While the price was good for the pies, considering one slice was free, both slices seemed stale, and the apple pie seemed well underbaked. It was very clean inside, and we had the place to ourselves. I love tipping for good service, when I paid, I tipped 20% even through the employee seemed less than thrilled we were there. Not certain what the tip was for as we ended up having to go grab our own desserts, as well as bus our own table.

Good nice food and recommend it. Very delicious. Very delicious. Very delicious. Very nice. Very…read morenice. Very nice. Nice roll ups.

From the owner: Here at Roll-ups we specialize in making Rolled ice cream and your day :)read more

Cool little chocolate shop! The owner was super friendly, and you can tell they put real passion…read moreinto their work. The chocolates here are more of a niche, artisan style than your typical candy shop -- true works of art. They had everything from footballs to skulls, and the flavors were complex and creative. Personally, I prefer the more traditional treats like chocolate-covered marshmallows and sponge candy, but if you're into fancy, upscale chocolates, this is definitely your spot.

Always beautiful and delicious artisanal chocolate and excellent service…read more It's like going into an art gallery shopping at Blue Table. Every piece of chocolate is more beautiful than the next. This trip I got not your average Easter Chicken and some beautiful eggs as well. Along with some yummy side treats. The Chicken and the eggs are filled with different selections of chocolate depending on what you pick. But they are all delicious and just lovely! They have a large selection of vegan chocolate along with dark and milk chocolate in so many shapes and sizes. With a window to watch the chocolatiers create their masterpieces, you can't go wrong at Blue Table.

Shop local!! If you are a candy maker, looking for candy for the holidays and for gifts, or just…read morelove candy this is the place to go! They are local and their suppliers are local so sometimes they may not have all of your options but they have so many I am sure you can make your treats with everything they have here. Also the staff is so pleasant and helpful we just told them what we were trying to create and they pointed us in the right direction! They are a part of Niagara Candy so you can even find their candy bars too! The types of candy to choose from is endless and their prices are very good' this is our go to for all of our candy making supplies!

The address is wrong on Yelp. It is 3528 Genesee St. The phone number is correct…read more Now, My mother started going here in the 80's. I guess there was a fire in a store close to them, then they moved. They are actually on Genesee and not on Union. As soon as I found that they were still in business, I ran there as fast as I could. I am in the process of building my mold collection. All four walls (and a little alcove) are lined with molds (of which I'm sure, some change for the season/holiday). There is even a section with a couple of boxes of molds that are on sale. Molds range from $1-up. With most being around $2.50. They carry Merkin chocolate at VERY good prices. Along with almost anything else you would need for candy making. Their oils are wonderfully priced, as are their boxes and wrap, and foils. It really is a one stop shop. A MUST if you are a candy maker! Best chocolate and nut prices I've seen! Can't wait to go back for more molds and other accessories.

They make the absolute best peanut butter sponge candy I've ever had in my life! The very large…read morepieces were nearly twice the size of competitors sponge candy, and everything else - the taste, quality, texture were superior as well. I came with a friend and will be a customer for life now!

My wife, who lived in nearby Amherst for 9 years, tells me that Yia Yia's Goodies makes a very good…read moreversion of Sponge Candy. I'd argue that there's no such thing, but I love my wife more than I hate sponge candy, and so, at her behest, I say, visit Yia Yia's and buy as much of the stuff as you can tolerate.

a must when in town, for your sweet tooth or for a gift …read more oldest building in town, nice people working there; good ice cream!

To the Point:…read more Ordered $150 plus worth of product that was acknowledged but I never received. (Previously shopped at Watson's Chocolates, East Amherst,, Never had issues.....) Sadly disappointed at the customer service. I contacted the store for delivery specifics and I submitted an order online on the afternoon,12/16/25. I was informed by the (young sounding, likely high school age) employee that the orders usually ship 1-3 business days (according to the website US priority mail) but with the holiday may be up to 5 business days.....ok that will still work. I received an email shortly after I ordered online that the order was accepted and being processed. Card was charged on 12/17/25. Order was to have the items during the Christmas holiday. 12/27/25 No order arrived. I sent an email to address listed on website, inquiring about my order. STRIKE 1 12/30/25- NO response from mgt. STRIKE 2 12/30/25 called the store requesting to speak with a manager, request refused. Employee instructed me to send email to the address listed. I stated that had already had been done, had not received a reply, and requested again to speak with a manager, Denied. Employee stated and attempted to check store data base regarding order. Was told that they didn't have the access level to check deeper, Thus the reason to speak with a manager... No information, tracking regarding my order was accessed STRIKE 3 Was told it would be looked into and I would be notified via phone. I understand holiday is busy mail season, US Priority states 1-3 business days, 9 Business days later, no order arrived. Poor service and no confidence in any further order deliveries, based on my experience.