You should be warned that if you have a golf cart, parking will be scarce. This review, however, is not based on that. Also note that this is a review of the pizza serving side of this establishment, not the bar. The cups are maybe 6oz, but I believe there are free refills (if not then I'm in trouble). The soft drinks are more limited than usual places. They do not have rootbeer. Our 7in pizzas were served on 7in cardboard circles. In other words, our pizzas drooped off the edge. This place seems pretty average in terms of the environment and service. read more

Great for breakfast. Slower service, but worth the wait. Upset due to a bartender throwing my change at me because I said to keep it. If you pay $4.75 for a can of beer and say keep the change, it is not acceptable behavior For a bartender to throw the quarter back at the customer. Don't expect, just respect read more

Service was great! Basic breakfast options. I was surprised that there were no omelette choices on the menu but we had a good breakfast. The pancakes were huge. Brought a large pot of coffee for the table which was nice. Right on the Main Street in PIB. read more

Just had the pizza and it's about on par with frozen pizza. They have a nice restaurant and patio area. They're breakfast is really good but forget the pizza. read more

Frosty Bar - Pizza Near Me - Put In Bay, Ohio

Frosty's is my favorite stop whenever I visit PIB. Cheap pitchers of beer, frosted mugs, great pizza. I've always had great service here and the atmosphere is so fun! Whether your stopping in for lunch or there to party, you're bound to have a good time and drink a lot of beer! read more

Good bar to come and grab a cold beer or a drink. Good music friendly staff. Not sure about the rest of the food but if you like Red Baron frozen pizza from the freezer isle at the grocery store you will love their pizza! read more

We had breakfast there, and the country Benedict was delicious. The service was brisk, attentive and pleasant. The entire staff was friendly and personable. read more

the servers were nice- but awful food. sucked. my pizza was undercook and had way too much cheese. it just tasted horrible

There is no spot on planet earth more glorious than this beautiful establishment. I've never felt more alive than at Frosty's. Great cold brew coffee!!! read more

came in at 9:30pm. worker was taking condiments off of each table. we asked what time they closed and they said 1am.. pizza came out with barely any sauce, and we asked for more sauce and they gave us ice cold pizza sauce that came out of a jar sitting on the counter. asked for them to heat it up & it took another ten minutes and by that time the pizza was cold. asked for a parmigiana shaker bc the worker took it off the table and they refused. will not be back read more

This pst weekend was my second and third trips coming here. I tried breakfast and lunch this time around. We waited about an hour for a table for six of us, while other groups (the same size) were sat before us when they arrived after. That was frustrating, BUT our waitress and the food beyond made up for it. For lunch, I had one of their burritos (PHENOMENAL). For breakfast, it's better if you get there early-there's hardly a wait. Also, the blueberry pancakes are amazing. Get them, I'm telling you. read more

We had a group of seven individuals and ate on the pizza side of the restaurant. We did not experience the bar. This was a typical pizza place, not much to write home about. Pizza was OK, nothing special. read more

Today while on vacation me and some friends decided to eat at Big Man's Burrito. So I ordered a wet & cheesy which is a enchilada.well the customer service wasn't too bad but the wait on my food was like the equivalent of waiting on a snail to run a mile.But the worst part was when our food came my was the first person to get his food I Watched him take a bite of his taco and he immediately spit it up into a napkin.Also we found that a lot of our food was undercooked such ass rice and beans and some meat In conclusion it was trash read more

I'm sorry, but Big Man's burritos suck. And I had the unfortunate experience of going here twice (once for a snack, another time because almost all other restaurants stop serving around 9:30 and I was forced again to return. So I had the understuffed, underwhelming burrito the first time, and cold, unheated, ridiculously nasty nachos the second time. Who serves nachos and doesn't melt the cheese on top? Or the meat lukewarm? I have never been drunk enough to call this palatable, nevermind the possible code violations on this under heated food. Shame on you! read more

No one is wearing a mask or gloves while serving my food. Many other places in the area are doing The same. Also the pizza is salty and has too much cheese. read more

Frosty Bar is a multi-faced beast. Part one is the pizza parlor. Frosty pizza, while a classic, is pretty terrible. The cheese and sauce are decent but the crust is cardboard. Part two is the Burrito stand. Big man burrito stand is excellent! The burritos are delicious and are one of the best food to cost ratios on the island. They also serve great breakfast burritos! Part three is the morning bar/breakfast scene. Weekdays are nice and quiet with good service and no wait. Weekends are a hell hole. If you manage a table within an hour your doing well. Service is slow and the place is so over crowded its tough to move. Part four is the day time bar scene. Weekdays and weekends this bar during the day is great! Prices are average and service is friendly. Whether lounging outside on the awesome patio or shooting pool inside its a good time. Lastly part five, the nighttime bar. I used to frequent Frosty at night and have a great time. Back then we called it Frosty. Now we call is CLUB FROSTY. Laser light shows blasting music with a rather unsavory attendance makes Frosty now a place we avoid at night. In conclusion, weekday breakfast, burritos, and day time bar scene make frosty not a complete loss. read more

Great place, sort of divey, but in a good way! Breakfast at Frosty is amazing -- pancakes for days! The new(er) outdoor bar is a great place to hang out when it's nice out. Pizza, subs, and burritos are on the menu; no table service, you just order and they buzz you to come pick up your food. Glasses are frosted (thus the namesake), and they have the best Bloody Mary's on the island! read more

The overnight oats are actually amazing!! Honestly did not have a bad experience until it was time to pay. First of all, when we were seated we were given both water and coffee without anyone asking us if we wanted the coffee. We assumed perhaps it was I clouded with out meals, just like when you are served bread at some restaurants but you're never charged for the bread; it's just a part of their service. When it was time to check out, we were all charged for coffee even tho we never asked or order it. When we questioned it the owner was very rude to us. We all work in the service of the food and beverage industry, it is never okay to be disrespectful to guests. And most importantly, it is just common sense to ASK your table if they want something before simply putting it on the table then charging them for it. Had the coffee not been sat on the table, none of us would have ordered it. Food was decent except the hash browns. read more

We ate breakfast on the restaurant side of Frosty's but didn't have enough time during our stay on the island to check out the bar. Looked fun and was always crowded but I can't say for sure. There is now an outdoor bar in the back and a burrito stand that smelled amazing when I walked out back to check it out but it was raining so we didn't get to try that out either! On to the breakfast.. french toast is my favorite food group but I wasn't all that impressed with the cinnamon french toast. It was a bit boring and the syrup was runny. I like thick and fatty syrup personally. The french toast does not come with any side items but you can add a meat side if that's something you are interested in. They have a large breakfast platter that has eggs, toast, hash browns, and meat side and my parents both really liked that. It was a lot of food for a decent price. I also sampled a blueberry pancake. It was just so-so. Tasted very pancake-mixy to me. Kind of like Bisquick, which is fine, but not really the pancake density I was craving at the time. I like how they leave a pot of coffee at your table so you on't have to keep flagging the waiter down for a refill. They also keep just about everything you need at the table, like a giant bowl of coffee creamers, huge container of syrup, napkin dispenser, and a carafe of water. I would have liked to have had a pizza and some brews but I will have to come back again another time! read more

Cool place! Just had drinks, but my husband got a glass to bring home! Fun place that is on the main boulevard and kind of overlooks the water. Great bar! read more

I ordered the chicken bacon ranch pizza there was no sauce, and zero flavor! way over priced will not be returning

Pizza tasted like a pizza you bought at the store. Pepperoni goes under the cheese and the cheese is hard. Wouldn't pay $17 for a single topping store bought pizza. If you like a store bought, has a lot of excessive cheese, very thin crust and pepperoni under the cheese this is your pizza. Would not eat again. read more

After a hot day of watching women cavort topless on the flybridge of their old man's boat out in the harbor, head on into Frosty for a chilled mug full of uncomplicated, ice cold beer. Also get the pizza. Actually, this is sort of a must here in Put-in-Bay on South Bass Island, in the middle of Lake Erie. I think they check your breath for Frosty beer esthers and your shirt for pizza sauce stains before they let you back on the ferry to the mainland. read more

Not the best coffee on the island but it is a bottomless cup. It's lively place at night with lots of young people dancing. But I'm usually there in the morning, great service. Love that's it's been handed down for three generations. read more

Had breakfast here, not bad at all. We were in a hurry so this was on the way and glad we stopped. Small menu but I wanted to try a plate that sounded like something my wife makes in her restaurant. It was a B & G with potatoes and an egg on top. Not as good as the wife's but not bad. I'd go back. read more

One star. Worst pizza in Ohio. This place must be the islands cardboard recycling center because that's what they're using for crust. If you're drunk and need to purge this spot will get things moving. The overpriced T-shirts are some of the nicest on the island. And what happened to the Big Buck Hunter? Good place also for stale salads and cold nachos. read more

Good ol' frostys!! PIB's main pizza place with everything! The pizza's are pretty good here for island food. You can easily split between 2-3 people. If you want to have a drink after the bar/dance floor is right next door. They are know for their large frosty beer mugs. They pretty much have all the basics on draft. We always change our pizza up at this place.....they can handle just about anything. Great service and the wait is minimal. If you are in PIB you will defiantly be a frostys-at least once! PS huge patio out back! read more

Just speaking to the pizza, it was very mediocre. Tasted like a Giant Eagle brand frozen pizza. Would not get again. Others in the group said the sammys were 3/5. Can't speak to the bar. read more

Fabulous breakfast spot! Sit at the bar and the staff will have you laughing in no time! Nice outside bar in the back.

I forgot this place. Pizza is decent, atmosphere and service are great! The dough is a bit mediocre, but the abundance of sauce and cheese makes up for it. read more

Nice atmosphere but I didn't care for the pizza. Others at the table liked it but it reminded me of a cross between Tombstone and Red Baron. Not my style of pizza. read more

On the plus side, cold drink mugs, a large number of beers on tap and live music. On the bad side, this is probably the worst pizza I've ever had, and it's pricey. read more

If we come back we'll try the beer and pizza for sure. This time we ordered Itailian subs and they were just ok. Nothing special. The side salad that came with it was good. read more

Used to be my favorite place to go on the island. The pizza has gone downhill however. That being said it is a great place to go for fun times and to meet great people. read more

I visited Frosty's bar and pizza for the first time ever and enjoyed a great cup of coffee in fact the best cup of coffee on the island by far! I was fortunate enough to meet most of the staff today and what a great bunch they are. I suggest you go there to enjoy their endless coffee as well as meet their wonderful staff.... enjoy! read more

Frosty Bar can be summed up by 3 high points~ historic atmosphere, nice selection of craft beer on tap, & good service. Pizza isn't what everyone raves about, it's okay but when your drinking on the island it becomes great. A must go to bar/restaurant on PiB. read more

I grew up on the island. Every weekend...all summer for 15y. I go back now once or twice a year for 3 things. Chicken Patio....Bisque from Boardwalk...and a Frosty's Pizza. This year, the last one REALLY disappointed me. I'm not sure what changed this last year, but the pizza was NOT good. It's not "I remember it so much better" or "when I was a kid" type thing. This year it was definitely different. The crust wasn't the same. The cheese wasn't the same. The sauce wasn't the same. It was all different. I've had HUNDREDS of Frosty's pizzas in my life and this was the very first time I've had one like this. Last year: Fine. Year before: Great. This year: Meh. read more

Came in around 6 on a Saturday. Very crowded. Not enough seating for dinner rush. The menu is very limited. Wished there were bigger pizza sizes for larger groups. The largest they have is a 12" The food was very delicious though. read more

The biscuits and gravy were incredible! The hash browns and eggs were cooked perfectly!

My favorite place (other than Heineman's wine garden) at PIB! Yes, it gets loud, big deal, it's a bar. I love it for the atmosphere, the yummy pizza, the cheap (for the island) pitchers of PBR, and the friendly barmaids. read more